High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3399/2015dismissed

Sabban v. State Of Haryana

2017-10-07Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul7 pages

!""# $#%&%

" '

#( %)"

***** !#%" # + ,#%+ -,. "

#"+)""# # %+/ 0-,1-'

#( 2+)""#+ 0"+)#%"#.%)"" %""+ ## "

) %% ( 0 # !#) 0 "- 4&.0 4&%"/ #-1&#3 -5+#("+)""#36&.0 0"5"+ 5 5 % ## " 7)" 0 '8- ,8 # "+# ( #% # 88%%

&# " 9! + 003+ 0%0 ""+6&38" " : ;

) %%(0 #," %%%4&3-1&#3 -.5++"+ ))

0("+)""# %""+

#% ## "

) %%( 0 # "-5 %%8%%5"+8 ""+## %" /# 0(%"

"-<9 "

&# "%;- - : 9! 5 % #3%"# %" "+ )""# "+#

&% " !0 "

" <#=)&# 4+#7 - %"#" 1&#3 - 5+# "+

)""# 035"+"+# &%5 %+03&0"(&# " 9!

5 % %" " &#3 8)#%8" # 0 ( 0 # ,"

%%% 4&3- 1&#3 . 6&38" ## " :

2+ )""# 0 )) %" "+ % 6&38" ## # "+% &#" .## "

) %%("+%&#"-"+." "+)""#5 %8 "

-&""+%") %%(0 #,"

%%% 4&3- 1&#3 5 % %" % ( +03 "+ " "+ )""# 5 6&.0 " "+ "8 88%%

- "+# #- + &0 " + .)&%+("+"# 0&#" ,#30(-"+ %5 %#8

7""+4&.04&%"/ #-1&#3 #) %%3 ))#)# "## )&%+8"&#"+4&.04&%" !#"" +0# ,"- 98)0 "+

#% ## "

) %%( "+% &#"- 0 # !#) 0 "- 4&.0 4&%" / #- 1&#3 - .## "

+ ##"+ ""+)""#%+ 007)"

0'8-,8 # )# "+#( #% #88%%

&# " 9!-+5.#-"+)# &%"( 8"+% (% 0# (&#3(+85 %##"%"

,33#. %" "+

#% ## "

- "+ )""#)# ## )) 0 #"+&#" %%-&""+% 85 %8%% ( 0 # ," %%% 4&3- 1&#3 . 6&38" " : ;

-+5.#-5"+8 ""+## %""+ ""+

))00 "%+ 00 )) # #"+/ #5"+"+#"( (% %+ 00 &#%+ 3 + .# # )# "5 ( #% " "+ % "%

" "+

/ # +%&"5008"#("+!# "

# 9"5 0% ##"+ ""+)""#%+ 00%"" %) 0+8#8 (7)"

" %""&" %&+ 8 # % "+ "

" 1.#8" 8 ( 8 "

))#)# "" 0+8"%#."+#8 #)# +%%" 9"5

0%##"+ " %"+ ))00 "5 ))#>8 "0(

( #% 3-+%+ 00 "7)"5"+6&.0%-5+ #%#.3"+%""#8% " "+,"#&# &0"%-5++ .6&%" ""

8 6#"(

"00 33#.- "+ )""# + 0 "+ )#%" #.% )"" ? # &%0 # "+ )""# + % " "+ " "+ 8)&3 ##% ) %% ( 0 # " "+ ))00 " &#" "# #("0 5

"% , "#"+ 3 ( #%- &%-6&.0 0"5"+0 5- "%"" 0'8 0("+6&.0%-5+

#05 ( #% 3# #;( #% 3- %"" '8 '+ &#"+#""+ ""+)#%" %-"+)#.%% "+ 4&.04&%","- ;: ))0 0 ? # &%0 # "+ )""# + % )# ( "+ " % "+ )""#% &" ( #% 3 + %&#3%&%"

" 0) #" +% %"-"5&0")#)#"7)+8"+%) 0+8 +8 ( #0 % 9 %&))#" +% ""- + + % )0 #0 &)

" #$ % & '( '#! )*+*")& " '%&,,--5+#"+ &%5 %6&.0 ""+"8 88%% #8-&"+ ""

"+ 3 ( #% 0# (&#3%" ( #%8"+% (% 2+,)>&#"+0"+ " ""+%%"

3-"5

"&.""+.#8""+%) 0+8 ""+"#%" "+# 6&.0% +&% "+ %) 0 +8 " # # +8 " "+ / # # ) %%3##% #%3"+ ))00 ""%) 0+8# #7)3+8 " %8"+#)0 %

"( #"+#8 3)# 0%%"+ 3+"8"+% "+8 >8&8)# #5+++ 57)""+# "+"5 )0 % 0 + 0%)0 &)!

'. !!

#$ )*+/"-&" '%&0)5+#)0 6&.0"(5 %# % # '@0 &)#8&#" "5 %+0("+,)>&#""+ ""+#% A&%" %3 "+ &% " %#.

" +8 # )%%0 # #8 " "+"+#+ -0 # "

"&%0+ #3&"+ "8#0( &% "+ )""# + ""

"+ 3 &" ( #% &#3 "+ "#.3)#%3#&"#0 %+8"+ % 9%&))#" +% ""- + + % #0 &) "+ 6&38" '@0 &)#8 &#" % % '

#'#$'( '('#! )*+-"-&" '%&,12

"+## " ( - ) %%("+%&#" '%

#' #,2+#$)*+2""0 % 4 !!

#$5' 9+ .+ #0 #&%0 #"+) #"% 2+ )0 0 # &%0 # "+ )""# "+ " % "+ )""#%#A&#" 0"5"+ %)#"+)#.%% 4&.04&%" ,"- ;: " )" %.## "

-"+%&#"+

0# ( ## # ) %%3 ))#)# " )&%+8" "+ )""#

# 5"+"+)#.%% "+4&.04&%" !#"" +0#,"-

2+# " 0'8+ %"%)&"("+# "+) #"% 2+# #-"+)0 0 #&%0 #"+)""#"+ ""+ )""#% &" ( #% 3 "%""%) 0+8 " )".5 "+6&38") %%("+,)>&#"% %

6 " 7&5+#"+ %+0"+ ". "+)""#+ ""

"+ 3 ;( #%-+5&0%"00+ ."&#3"+8)%%" "+#( #%5++&0%)00("+)#5++ ""

8 6#"( 2+#0.

") #" "+% 6&38"%#)#& %&#

" # " $ %&&& ' %&&

(

%% $

%&&

) *

' ' ( )

(

( '

( +

( '

) #

, (

' (

' * .

% / ('

%%&0%&&

) * ' ' ( ) #

, (

' (

' * .

* ( ' ( ( '

( ' ( (B 2+&%-+ .3#3 #""+0 50 5("+,)>&#" % %

6 " 7& "

73"%# ""+6&38") %% ("+%&#" 4 !!

#$5' 6 " 7&-"+%&#"

%"+ ""+#%003 0"(###3&0 #"("+8)&3##%) %% ("+&#"%05 C. "+#5%- "+ %) #.% 0 6&#%" % .%" 5"+08")5#% "+% 8%+&0>#%0( %5+#"+ &#"% 05 + . 88"" 8 %" ### 0 5 # )#&# #+ .#07 3##0.

" 8 "# 0. 9"+)#%" %-

"+)""#+ 0%" 0")#."+ "5+ "8 #-8)&3 ##% ) %% ( "+ &#"% 05 %&

# #8 003 0"(- ##3&0 #"( # )#.#%"( 5++ 8 ( 5 ## " "# # "+% &#" ( .73 "% #.% 06&#%" ,#30(- "+ 8)&3 ## "

) %% ( 0 #!#) 0 "-4&.04&%"/ #-1&#3 %500 %"+ 8)&36&38" " : ;

) %%(0 #," %%% 4&3-1&#3

#8 "+)#%"#.%)""-3.

(8#"-%%8%%

!"# 3&"" E+"+#%) 73F# % D% E+"+#)#"