High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3401/2015dismissed

Kuldeep Singh v. Ajmer Singh

2015-09-11Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain5 pages

"#$ $%&'&()*$+#$,-$.

0123$$+*&(45 $#&#&($.

6$.'1'

7,$.*&(45 $'+(3$(# )89* **

)89* **

.$'$(#

.$'$(#) ."(701,"./ 3:%"#$

.#5$+$#&#&($. ;;;;

;;;;

* / * / * / * /

$#&#&($.5"3 "%$3#.&"2&("%,+2"&(# &2$3-< #5$ .$'+(3$(# 1(3$. *$%#&( = #5$ $4#&"-2$ ('#.1,$(#' %#/ == 8 %#8 . '5.# >1" 3&'5(.

%5$>1$&(#5$'1, ?/ / @ .&"21.#:&3$.3$.'3"#$3

.3$.$3 #5$ %(:&%#&( "(3 '$(#$(%$ #5$ +$#&#&($. >1"

%,,&''&(

$(%$+1(&'5"-2$1(3$.*$%#&( = #5$

%# 5$ %(:&%#&( "(3 '$(#$(%$ #5$ +$#&#&($./ "'

.3$.$3-<#5$#.&"21.#/A"'1+5$23-<#5$ ++$22"#$1.# :&3$.3$.3"#$3 =

$(%$/#5$+.$'$(#+$#&#&(-< #5$+$#&#&($. "'$ #5$%,+2"&("(#/&(-.&$ /A"'#5"#5$5"3 .$#&.$3 .,'$.:&%$( =

$5"3.$%$&:$3"22

5&'.$#&."2-$($ &#'(%#-$./

/+$#&#&($."++."%5$3 #5$%,+2"&("(# ."3:"(%$,$(# " .&$(32<2"(##5$

#1($ ?/ / @ ( .3$. # .$+"< #5$ '"&3 2"(/ +$#&#&($. &''1$3 %5$>1$ &( >1$'#&( &( ":1. #5$ %,+2"&("(#A$:$./A5$(#5$%5$>1$A"'+.$'$(#$3 .

$(%"'5,$(#&(#5$"(B/&#A"'3&'5(.$3-<#5$"(BA&#5 #5$.$,".B'C&('1

&%&$(# 1(3'D,+2"&("(#'$.:$3"2$4"2 (#&%$3"#$3

(#5$+$#&#&($.-1#3$'+&#$#5$ '"&3(#&%$/+$#&#&($.5"3 "&2$3#+"<#5$%5$>1$",1(# &(>1$'#&(##5$%,+2"&("(# $(%$/#5$%,+2"&(#&( >1$'#&(A"' &2$3 9$".($3%1('$2 .#5$+$#&#&($.5"''1-,&##$3 #5"##5$%,+2"&("(#5"3 "&2$3#+.:$5&'%"'$( "%#/ #5$-3< #5$%5$>1$&(>1$'#&(5"3-$$( &22$3-<#5$ %,+2"&("(# $'+(3$(# 5"3 "3,&##$3 &( 5&' %.'' $E",&("#&( #5"# 5$ 5"3 (# '$.:$3 "(< (#&%$ ( #5$ +$#&#&($.-$ .$#5$ &2&(4 #5$%,+2"&(#('1++.# 5&'

".41,$(#'/2$".($3%1('$25"'+2"%$3.$2&"(%$( 5(0

5(0

-."5",:$.'1'*&,( -."5","(3"(#5$.

-."5",:$.'1'*&,( -."5","(3"(#5$./

9FF 9G=G/A5$.$&(/&#A"'5$23"'1(3$.) CH5$( A$ $E",&($ #5$ %"'$ #5$ .$'+(3$(#%,+2"&("(# "' +.7$%#$3 -$ .$ #5$ 2$".($35&$ 13&%&"2"4&'#."#$"(3#5$,"#$.&"2 $:&3$(%$ +2"%$3 -$ .$ #5$ #.&"2 1.#/ A$ &(3 #5"##5$#.&"21.#5"3(#$3%$.#"&(:&#"23$ $%#'

&(#5$%"'$ #5$.$'+(3$(#%,+2"&("(#*1%5 3$ $%#' (#$3 -< #5$ 2$".($3 5&$ 13&%&"2 "4&'#."#$A$.$"'1(3$.) " 5145 #5$ .$'+(3$(# "' H

3$+'$3 #5"# #5$ "%%1'$3 .$%$&:$3 #5$ ,($<"#5&'51'$"2''#"#$3#5"#5$3&3 (#.$,$,-$.#5$3"#$A5$(#5$'"&3'1,

' / / @A"'+"&3#5&, - '.$4".3'#5$'1.%$ ."3:"(%&(4 #5$ '1, ' / / @/ #5$ .$'+(3$(# %2"&,$3#5"##5$'",$A"' .,"(31#

#5$ '"2$ %('&3$."#&( 5&' '5".$ &( #5$

",&2< +.+$.#</ "+".# ., " '1,

' / @/A5&%55$":"&2$3-<A"< 2"(

.,#5$%+$."#&:$'%&$#< #5$%22$4$ A5$.$ 5$ A"' $,+2<$3 5145 #5$ .$'+(3$(# '#"#$3 -$ .$ #5$ 1.# -$2A #5"#5$A123-$&("+'&#&(#+.31%$#5$ 3%1,$(#' &( '1++.# #5$ '"&3 '#"(3/ &# A"'(#$3#5"#( 3%1,$(#'A$.$+2"%$3 -$ .$#5$1.#-$2A %(#5$%1.'$ %.''$E",&("#&(/ #5$.$'+(3$(#'#"#$3#5"##5$%5$>1$A"'

'&4($3(#5$3"#$A5$(#5$+"<,$(#A"'

,"3$/ ($:$.#5$2$'' 5$ '#"#$3 #5"# 5$ A"' (#"A".$ #5$3"#$A5$(5$+"&3#5$'1, ' / / @ 3 %%.3&(4 # #5$ .$'+(3$(#/ #5$ %5$>1$A"'&(#5$5"(3A.&#&(4 #5$"%%1'$3 5&,'$2 "(3#5$:$.<($E#,,$(#5$,"3$"

%(#."3&%#.<'#"#$,$(##5"##5$%5$>1$A"'

(#&(#5$5"(3A.&#&(4 #5$"++$22"(#"(3 #5"#5$%,+2"&("(#A.#$#5$'",$ $5$.$'+(3$(#"2''#"#$3#5"##5$ ",1(#&(A.3'A"'A.&##$(-<5&, 5$#.&"21.#5"'"2'(#$3#5"#&# A"'(##5$%"'$ #5$.$'+(3$(##5"##5$

A.&#&(4 &( #5$ %5$>1$ "(3 &22&(4 1+ #5$

&41.$'A$.$A&#5#5$%('$(# #5$"%%1'$3 "++$22"(#D ,+2"&("(#/&(.3$.#+.:$5&'%"'$/"++$".$3 &(#5$A&#($''-E"'H "(33$+'$3"'+$.#5$%(#$(#'

5&'%,+2"&(#,+2"&("(#"2'$E",&($3H 5"."( *&(45"(3H "'+"2*&(45#%..-."#$5&'+2$"#5"##5$ %5$>1$+.$'$(#$3-<5&,A&#5#5$"(B .$(%"'5,$(#5"3 -$$(3&'5(.$3

$#&#&($. A5$( $E",&($3 1(3$. *$%#&(

3$ .&,&("2 .%$31.$/ IG#B#5$+2$"#5"#&( "%#/ 5$5"32'#5&'%5$>1$-B"(3#5$%5$>1$&(>1$'#&(5"3 -$$(,&'1'$3-<#5$.$'+(3$(# ('1++.# 5&'+2$"/ +$#&#&($. $E",&($3 H "'+"2 *&(45 "(3 H "27$$# *(45#5"#5$5"32'##5$%5$>1$&(>1$'#&( 51'/&(#5$+.$'$(#%"'$/%5$>1$&(>1$'#&(A"' "3,&##$32<'&4($3-<#5$+$#&#&($. +.$'1,+#&(".&'$'

#5"# #5$ %5$>1$ &( >1$'#&( 5"3 -$$( &''1$3 -< #5$ +$#&#&($.&(3&'%5".4$ 2$4"22&"-&2&#<5$+2$"#"B$(-< #5$+$#&#&($.#5"#5$5"32'##5$'&4($3%5$>1$-B/A"' .&45#2< 3&'-$2&$:$3 -< #5$ 1.#' -$2A "' &# %"((# -$ -$2&$:$3 #5"# #5$ +$#&#&($. A"' %"..<&(4 " -2"(B '&4($3 %5$>1$-B"#5$.+$#&#&($.-<234&(4%,+2"&(##5"#5$ 5"32'#"'&4($3%5$>1$-B( =

/#.&$3#%.$"#$ $:&3$(%$ &( 5&' ":1. ' #5"#/ &( %"'$/ #5$ %5$>1$ &( >1$'#&(&''1$3-<5&,(

/&'3&'5(.$3/#5$(

5$%"(":&3#5$%.&,&("2+.%$$3&(4'#5"' 1.#5$.-$$( (#&%$3 -< #5$ 1.#' -$2A #5"# "' +$. E5&-&# / +$#&#&($.5"3(2<?

/ =@&(5&'"%%1(#.'1%5,$"4.$ ",1(#/#5$.$A"'(%%"'&( .#5$+$#&#&($.#%"..<"

-2"(B '&4($3 %5$>1$ -B A&#5 5&, ,+2"&("(# 5"3 .$%$&:$35&'.$#&."231$'"

#$.5&'.$#&.$,$(#( =

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

$.$(# "%#' &',&''$3 * * * * *$+#$,-$.

*$+#$,-$.

,"5":&.