High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2295/2016disposed of

Hc Harpal Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab

2017-11-21Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

!"#"$%&%'() *+ ,-%'./ '#!/"*& "0%&%'%&!& 1"*&2& -! !" 2'3 4 "&+'#"'!

( 56

-7 6 -

*"&"'!(8

*7 * '0%*-%'./7/"/ *9#0$ !"9**"0%&%'%&!&

& '%: ,! 9 2'3 4 ;/"!/"*!/" "+*!"*&,$ ,'"<&+ +"*= >4" ,,<"#! &""!/"32#.="'!?

4"*""**"#!!/" "+*!"**'! @ ;/"!/"*!/"32#.="'!&/2,#4"*"+*!"#%'!/"#%."&!? 88 88 6 -

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

3 &!/ '%'$ &"+"*! %'%'.! A A9*".%&!"*"# 2'#"*-"$!%'!/" -$! ! ,%$"-! !%'/ < '%- 3&: !

88 ')9!/"$2&!#>& %# *' =-%'./< &/ '#"#0"*!+*"&"'! *"0%&%'%&!&9' =",>9 *+ ,-%'./9 *&/ '-%'./ '# .= %, -%'./9 * ! :%'. /%= ! -+"$% , 2*!9 '2= '. */

3 &!/ ' '

A)9!/">%'!%= !"#!/"-2+"*%'!"'#"'!9%&!*%$! %,9- '.*2*9!/ !2'#"* !*% , *' =-%'./"&$ +"#*=!/"%*$2&!#>'))*= %,< > -! !%'9 '2= '. */

3 &!/ ' --2:/$/ %'-%'./4"%'.!/"6%'" %$"*= #" &! !"="'!!- 2: '#-%'./9</%$/*=&!/"4 &%&

$$*#%'.!!/"+,%$"%'0"&!%. !%'9/" <"'!! %,< > ,%$"

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

*"0%&%'%&!&8 $$2&"#'".,%."'!,>&2"*"#2'#"*!*% , *' =-%'./!"&$ +" *=!/"%*$2&!#>%'!/" *" %!>- '.*2*9 '#+*"&"'! 9 # !"#)92'#"*-"$!%'&@9B < &*".%&!"*"# !"*!/"!*% ,9&! !"="'!&*"0%&%'%&!&8 $$2&"#2'#"*-"$!%' @@* <"*"*"$*#"#9%'</%$/!/">#"'%"#"0%#"'$","# . %'&!!/"= '##%#'!," # '>"0%#"'$"%'#""'$" /" ," *'"# 2#%$% , .%&!* !" &! , &&9 - '.*2*9 0%#"

%=+2.'"#*#"*9$'0%$!"# '#&"'!"'$"#!/"*"0%&%'%&!&9 & *"& %#

8@8 /"*#"*< &2+/",#%' ++" ,4>!/"," *'"###%!%' ,-"&&%'&2#."9 - '.*2* / 0"/" *#!/"," *'"#$2'&",**"0%&%'%&!&9!/"," *'"# -! !"$2'&", '#/ 0" ,&$ *"2,,>.'"!/*2./!/"%," '#,<"*2*! %," &<",,

%*&! ,,9%!%&!4"#"!"*=%'"#</"!/"**"0%&%'%&!&<"*" '".,%."'!9 & *"&2,!</%$/92'#"*!*% , *' =-%'./ $$2&"#"&$ +"# *=!/"%*$2&!#>? ! %& +*0"# *= !/" &! !"="'! 2*= %, -%'./

;9 ; ** '! %$"*9%&!*%$! %,9- '.*2*9!/ !')9$2&!#>& %# 2'#"*!*% , *' =-%'./&' .#%&/-%'./< &/ '#"#0"*!+*"&"'! *"0%&%'%&!&*+*#2$%'./%=%'-+"$% ,2*! ! '2= '. */

3 &!/ '

')),, $$2&"#$ ="4 $:'A) '#%'*="#!/ ! *' = -%'.// #"&$ +"#*=!/"%*$2&!#> ! '2= '. */ %,< >-! !%'

2: '#-%'./9</*"$*#"#!/"&! !"="'!--2:/$/ %'-%'./9&! !"# !/ !#2*%'.%'0"&!%. !%'9'%'$*%=%' !%'.$%*$2=&! '$"&&2* $"# . %'&! '> $$2&"#' $!9 2: '#-%'./#%#'!*"$*# '>$ &"#% *> '##%# '!$'#2$! '>%'0"&!%. !%' ' !/%& $ &"9 & '$!%' C -"'%* -2+"*%'!"'#"'!

,%$"9- '.*2*9< &! :"'4"*"+*"&"'!%'.$/ ,, '*2$% ,%'!/%&$ &"%& &! !"="'! - -2:/$/ %' -%'./9 </ / & = %'! %'"# !/ ! !"* /%& %'0"&!%. !%'9/"/ &$="!$'$,2&%'!/ ! *' =-%'./< &'!! :"' 4>42&** %,! '2= '. */ '#!/ ! *' =-%'.// #"&$ +"#*=!/" $2&!#>+*"&"'!*"0%&%'%&!&%'!/" *" %!>- '.*2*',>9 #2"! '".,%."'$"+*"&"'!*"0%&%'%&!& '$*&&"C =%' !%'9/"/ # #=%!!"# !/ !/"/ #.'"! '2= '. */ '# ,&$'! $!"#!/"- &

8B8 <",, & ,%$"-! !%' '2= '. */ /"& %#- &#%#'!= :" '> &! !"="'!%'<*%!%'.!/ !+*"&"'!*"0%&%'%&!&<"*D"*"+" !"#,>$/ '.%'.!/"%* &! '#9'*!/">. 0" '>!/%'.%'<*%!%'./">/ 0"="*",>"C+*"&&"#!/"%* &2&+%$%' " #=%!!"#!/ !%!%&+&&%4,"!/ !!/"& %#- &%'*#"*! "&$ +"!/"%**"&+'&%4%,%!>9=%./!/ 0"= #"&2$/&! !"="'!&<"0"*9%!%& +*0"#!/ !+*"&"'!*"0%&%'%&!&#%# ++* $/!/"- & ! '2= '. */9* = :%'.$=+, %'!!/ ! *' =-%'.// &"&$ +"#*=!/"%*$2&!#>! ."& ! &/< !/ ! ,, *"0%&%'%&!& / # %' $! .'" ! '2= '. */

3 &!/ '

". *#%'.!/"$'$,2&%'+,%$"!/ ! *' =-%'./"&$ +"# *=!/"$2&!#>+*"&"'!*"0%&%'%&!&%'!/" *" %!>- '.*2*',>9- -2:/$/ %'-%'.// &&! "#!/ !!/"*"%&'+*!/ ! *' =-%'.// # "&$ +"#*=!/"$2&!#>*"0%&%'%&!&%'!/" *" %!>- '.*2*" 2*!/"* #=%!!"##2*%'.$*&&"C =%' !%'!/ !/"< &%'*="#4>4!/!/" - & ! '2= '. */!/ !'*"$"%0%'.!/"%'*= !%'*". *#%'."&$ +" $$2&"#9!/">/ #.'"!!/" *" 42&&! '# '#/ # ,&$'#2$!"# ' : 4 '#% '#!/ !!/">/ # ,&$'#2$!"#&"$*"! '#+"'%'0"&!%. %'9%' </%$/ &="+"+,"<"*"& >%'.!/ !'"+"*&'/ #"&$ +"#*=!/" $2&!#>+,%$"942!4!/- &*"2&"#!.%0"%'<*%!%'./"*" !"*9/" $ ="4 $:*= '2= '. */"2*!/"* #=%!!"#!/ !/"/ #! :"' ,, *"0%&%'%&!&8 $$2&"#! '2= '. */ '#!/ !!

/">/ #%#"'!%%"#!/"+, $" *=</"*" *' =-%'.// #"&$ +"#*=!/"%*$2&!#>" #=%!!"#%! & $**"$!!/ !&="+"+,"+*"&"'!!/"*"<"*" ,&&! %'.*". *#%'."&$ +" *' =-%'./*=$2&!#>+,%$"942!'4#>< &<%,,%'.!.%0"%' <*%!%'./"*" !"*9/"$ ="4 $:*= '2= '. */!- '.*2*,, !/"&" $!&.!&/<!/ !& %# *' =-%'./"&$ +"#*=!/"$2&!

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

%'& <%!/ +24,%$ "*"9!/"*"< &'&2$/"0"'!2 ,%!>/"*"*"94!/!/"2*!

88 $**"$!,>/",#!/ !!/"*"< &''""#!."!& '$!%'%&!*%$! .%&!* !" /" $!*"= %'&!/ !$2&!#>& %# *' =-%'./< &/ '#"# 0"*!+*"&"'!*"0%&%'%&!& '#%!< &*!/"=!"C+, %' &!/< $$2&"# "&$ +"#*=!/"%*$2&!#>"C+, ' !%'%&$=%'.*!/9'* $$2&"# ,"# '>"0%#"'$"%'#""'$",,!/"$%*$2=&! '$"&"&$ +"2'#"*!*% , *' =-%'./*=!/"$2&!#>*"0%&%'%&!&<"*"<%!/%'!/"%*&+"$% , =" '&:'<,"#." '#%!< &*!/"=!"C+, %'!/"$%*$2=&! '$"& </%$/!/">/ 0"'!#'"&&2$/9#'!%'# '>%,,". ,%!>*%'%*=%!> %'!/"32#.="'!&4!/!/"2*!&

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

%& %! $ &"</"*"*"0%&%'%&!&&/2,#4".%0"' $/ '$"!%=+*0"!/"%*$'#2$! /"*"*"9$'&%#"*%'.!/""'!%*"!>$%*$2=&! '$"& '#!/"&"*0%$"*"$*# *"0%&%'%&!&9</%,"= %'! %'%'.!/"$'0%$!%'+*"&"'!*"0%&%'%&!& 2'#"*-"$!%'@ 9!/"&"'!"'$"+ &&"#2+'!/"=%&/"*"4>&"! &%#" '#!/"> *"*#"*"#!4"*"," &"#'+*4 !%'2'#"*-"$!%' !

8)8

*4 !%' "'#"*&$!9A9'!/"%*"C"$2!%'.+*4 !%'4'#&%'!/" &2= & 9 8" $/<%!/'"&2*"!>" $/!/",%:" =2'!9* +"*%#'">" *9!!/"& !%& $!%'!/"/%"2#%$% , .%&!* !"

2!>

.%&!* !"9- '.*2*9<%!/ '2'#"*! :%'.'!!*"+" !&2$/$'#2$! %' 2!2*" '#%'$ &"9!/">#&9!/"&"'!"'$"+ &&"#2+'!/"=&/ ,,*"0%0" '#!/"><%,,&2**"'#"*4"*"!/"2*!!2'#"*.!/"*"= %'%'.+ *! &"'!"'$" !%&2*!/"*#%*"$!"#!/ ! &+"*-"$!%'!/" *4 !%' "'#"*&$!9A9& %#$'0%$!%'&/ ,,'!4"!*" !"# &#%&E2 ,%%$ !%' * '>+2*+&" $$*#%'.,>9*"0%&%'%& ,,<"#+ *!,>

6 - ) &3:& ;/"!/"*&+" :%'. *" &'"# ( "& ;/"!/"* "+*! 4,"

( "&