← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2041/2007allowed

Hans Raj v. Mahender Singh And Others

2025-01-29Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages



     

    

!"

#$%$!&'

 &( )* +  &%  , -------.. // & 0%-

1 &2 ) 3$&41

&2 !1 )% ------ %.!&2 &%  '

56

3- 3 3  3  



  

      

   

        !"#

$  %& '

""""

3  3 

-

6 (  

  )    *

   +,-

  &   $    (--   .  (/001 2 34)'     %&

)$ 5 1 6  )$ 64   & &

  *   & 7   $ 5 ((7" *            +8     

$&    $      9$ $    )'     7&   . $ $  (,    

$   &    

     :$ $&&

  )'    )$    

      $  

        ) '



3 333   6

363   3 !    $

 & "      &$ 

)'    )$       ; $      < )$  *   ' &$ 5 07" '

 &  =5 +7" $  )'  &$  *   & 



   *     

     ; $   

4   )$    * &

  *       ) &  )   > +8     9 '"

'?     *

'

  >&   $&   %

) @  &    4   )$   ' &$  '

 & $ * &

  4  &$  *   $$    &*     

&         '

 

  )   &

 )        ,          $

         "#

$  %& '    & '*$   

    

 &$ &

  

)'    )$  *'

) *  ; '

 &

    #    $

    $      -  $     &  (0'  *    ?$  $      & 

  * '

  >&   &   

 & '

  >&    1A>B"7C4$     $   &

 )'1A>B",74  > +8     & $       '"

'?     %$$     *  

    * '$ **  &  &  

  &  &  5 !!7" &     & &$&*  ) *'

     ;'  4  $  $    < )$ 

*      & *   &$     &

        $  * 

      *   &$  *   &*    $$     

&          :$       %$ 36

68   3 + ; 3) $ & %$    * **  &

     )'   >%$     , 9(:

) 0%- , * 9(:

)

&2 &!1 )

  3(.) :

!()  % % 77    $              

     

    ! "#$"        "! %#"& ! !'" &       !

#$ !(!

( (! "!  "    (  !        &     !          # !'" # 

"#"      !

(#$& !%"! !  &"  & "(  $"     "! #& ! '"  #  &#  !  & $"&#"    "!  "" $"&



   #  !  #& ! "



  #&$&      "!

$&!#" $" !  #&   "  "! "!  !

)* + )"#  ,&

+" " - ,./0)" *"1/2.

4  ( ! *,! 5!

  )**

 !

6  7"( #&/0*82/

   !  "!          !!    $"&    (9         :%   (         ;   !   " (! !  "%!"  5 ( ! (    $"! "!

 ! ! #$"! (9  5 (!"( !  < #  5    ""   (    "      ! #&  ="" ! % ->" &!

(?  (  3 ( "( ! "

  '"  $"  5  !@  (

 5%  ( (&

," $"&    # !!

&"!  !    !

,&"  $"&   ! !# ( !       #( !"! &   ! #    !  (""  (    "       ! #&  ""  !  %  !@  (

!%  %%% %%% %%% %%%    

   

 !  $" ! # ( $" ! " (  & 

 ( ! #&  

#!&  # "

!#  (  (  & "!&  (  (  &     (  ! #&%      #"  #  !"!  ( (  &     ( ! #&



!  ! $"!>   % !

 "#'"&  %  ! #&    (  !  &    ( !     %      ! #&

 (  &  (    # !#&  #"    ! & 

        ! #&  &  "    !  (         (    &    !  

;

!!("  "" $# ( !"  !   "#$ 

 %

%%  

& 

%  

%  '

 ()(9

$"!     (!10&  !

 (. 1000@>      !  3   !        ! #&        #    '"       $"&    20A  !     '"   ! #&  '" ! 10A

  (  &   !#&  #"    # !# "   "! & #"  ( ! * "    #  9 "  #  !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "

 A  "  9 . 800@>  "  #   (9/ !

5"" (9 800%/ 9 . 00@> '

 (*(9

$"!  ! (!10&  ( . 1000@> 

4 ! " ! !   ! #& ! 20A 4   ! $# 

  "!    (  !  4       ((  &    &  #  ! ( &$#   &  &#  

 #"   !  "" (  & / * "     #  9

"    !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "

/ A  "  9. B/000@>  "  #   (9/ !

5"" (9B/000%/ 9. 8 000@> '

 (+( 9

$"! B &  !  &  :(("!  "  !  

    (  !  " ! !  !

 ! #   ! /0A  $"!    !""    !  '"!      "( "   "" (  &   ! /0A

 "     #  9

  "    "!

( !# &!   :( 9. 20000@> # 5"" ( "

/0A %! "  9. 8B000@>  "  #B &   9 !

5"" (98B000% 9. / 2000@> C-  9 

  ("  !!    "     !  6  

&  

("," *   # ! "    !!+"

  "

<

0 ; 3)  $ &  %$          ,   '  +- .



/0 =   < 3 < >   $   

(--(-!" (-0  .  (/00   *  

14

$      * >

  &

&$ = 1C4    &$    * *    = 1%4 *     ) ' *&$ = 5   ) *$        & '



 



$& $  >

  = 1A4 ?$$           *      

       *

 &

9)= " &' >  '       9$*&   $  $  

   &%  #"

,  "   #("   ! &             "  !  "  %  "! # .  000 . 80000 ! .  000 & 

(  !  !   # 6"  "!# >   '" "

>   7         "!  # !(   "   '" ! "!#  ! (# & &  !    "!#   0A    &  7 !! !# "  #( &   ! / ; 3) $ & %$   1  .

  1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34   $   F/

      '"!#% !#& "9 

  %  %(5( 

%(6(<

  !  ""(  #  (      B1 & &(   $"!(   -  ," *  &5 !   &)  !G  B0/  *H  B/00  )*

 ,     82        !  $"!(    *"6 &  !  "  !# "!  !  #  )   ) 

!G  3   *  ! B00*H B)* ,  ((" >B &   "  #   (   ( %! #&

  ! &!"!#& ! " !) *  ! "   "   "# !     #   ! /

-

%  

%





   %78 ,          !            !

    !# !" H (!   IG B0*H0)*  !) ! + "$  "3 !I B0/*H/)*

7%  #  " H (! "   9 J  ,  (          & #     !

!## !

 "        &  ! #&   !  #&   !    !       !      

!        "    (       ( 9 

   "(  !   "

 "(     !< 

5 "!("" < 

   #&            !       (    < 

! %"!(    & #'"!"! ""< ! 

5%  J C "!D

  !  # ;!   $"!(   ) !+ "$  " (    "  ! ( &"! !( &   # !'" &    "!    ! #&"!  ! ,  " "   %  ! #&     !

@  ;    ""

#! &K&  "(" B0H " &B01

 "$" !#"  "!9 J, % 9 

 "! "  " 

 "# #  

 "! "# #(   

 "1!8 I     (  ! 

"#  "(  " 

 "  " 

 "# #(  7  "!  (   %!        (     "   &           "(  !#& !" !) *      !  " 6   &      !  "$"   % ="  #!  1 ) !  + "$     "       &(  

"  !"" !   !   # !  7  ""'" &    

     !   !

   ( !  ""  "   # !      (   ! #& 1 A

'"     #  $"!( -  ," * 5!

  "   &  2 !(  (     "!# 0A  "   &    $ 





 

  

     "8 ,   !     !

!   !"( "  (A        $"!   "   "!(     H (! L "

G   (   "!" !#&  !" !    !A     !#& *"

+0,+-9'0, 

"   ! &( !

  "   #&    "    & "! # !!  9 :

)  5     (    . 828%B%1 @00 . /@> =""     0    !!

. 80@> ! %"!(    ( "



. 8228@> 5   

    .

00000@> 5         

 !   (& .  0000@>   !"( . B00000@>

  . 821@>

   "! "#!    . 821@>   ! (       A "

  !    !   & 

+

6 ( #    )' ; 3) $ & %$  )    9$*&   

       +,-  &  *'    "&   

  &

    $

&   "$   3)- !-  2% !:. &% $!& ?

)2 2 (

 '# & !!7"

 ?$$    ,8 (!7"1,8!!4 ! 

$# & ,,7"1,->(4 , <

$$   *+8 !007"1+8,,7"4 

$  (0 - <

$$   * -/0,7"1!00>(04 +

 >

!(7"

0    $  * 7"

/ 

 *

(7"

(   %*

(7"

(( <

&   -7"

(    (7"

(!

*   

(7"

(, !

/ !:. &% $!& %-7@@ <A ( :!(& ?

)2 2 B*

)$B(& / ((7"

(- &1 &# 2

:!(& %-@+@ ;A

7@@ <@ ((                            )'  ; 3) $ & %$  

; *.

  

. +  7 <   <. 0

 .$ ,  $ 

+ 

 ;

3(.) :

!()  % %  @    "& 



*      E/8 

$&     &$ &    *&      F  (      "#

$   %& '              

  &$ &

  *     )$ 

 &  &'   )$  $    )$

    &$ &

  *     $  & 7      & 7            $     )

$     )$  (!  #

$  %& '   )'   )$  $ 

 $          '

&     ' 9$*&       (0+,

 ?G (-0+)' %$ (,

  *' (  *

 '     

3  3  

 

 &( )* +@ ;

  B     *7    *   *   B   )    7