← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3541/2014dismissed

Bhim Singh v. Pawan Kumar

2018-12-14Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul11 pages



    

"#$!  

          



     

%& "#$!         



       

    # $ % &'"% !    $ " ' (&'"%   )))))     * " (("

   (% !  

  + ,-. # 



   "+ ,-/.#     

 

    *    0  % !  

 "!  "

!

  (1 %&0% 2&  0 3 + ,-. # 

    #!(   ("!   (% !    !

  4 "  "" /  !

" 02 ( " '""   (

5 "&6  & 02  (!!( ("02  #

" 

  4 "    %    ""   - ""  ""/  -!

"025 "  ($ 7 +(

&6  & (( "   (2 "&  !   #!(  "  ("  !(  

   #

"

"   -   , 0(7

  '&   &8'9 %  

 !

  ( (( "0  ,:/ $ & ;& ; & ; "    %

    ((   & * ( "  6  <  (4   &   

& (( 6  & * (  "    6   !!"  & 

   "   !

  ( " 

  . =  2"

 '"

(2&   "0  !   #!( (4 ( (

"    <    

&   

  ;. (3  "  0 ! " 02   #

"   !   #!(  '"

(2&  !   #!(  > "   " 6 (    ' 2 "" - 

 %   (4    "     "&    (( ( > "02!   #!( %   (4   *  #

"

"3  " 

"  !      (( !2 ;. (3     

"  =  ,.;:/ "" - 

 "

   <  (  3  +    $ ( %  $ " &  .& 6    

 



;&.&?#  %    !     "

  ( 

"   1 %& !     "=    &   " 3 8!2 !!"9<  !  " "  &  !   

0 "  ((   "" ;



    & 0

  

 =    ! "   !   & ("!( =    @ " $     0    

"   % " & ("     (2   

"   -'% "4 " ""  -  "  

" 

 !  ! " >  % " ! """/  -'



  (3 ( ""0 ! "!   #!( 02 # % 

"  -.;- ++         "   " 4 " &  ( 

 & ""

"  !( !     ' %" 

  4 "    %    ""   - ""  ""/  -&  (" !!( 0  +   

&    (( " 02  ( " '""   ( 

 5 "& 6   % " 4 "  "" / & =         (%((" 

   

( (2&  "  %   ""  -!

"02( "$ 

 " !!(  7       &! % !    0  ("02!   #!( 

4 " = ( "" / !

"02( "'""   (

5 "&6  

  @ " 

(   !       "  ( " '""   (

5 "&6    " (( "4 "   %    ""   -  " "    "" /  - !

"02 (+ *(  "=   + 0(      #

" "

"  =  =   &   "

(20 !%" "7  "

"=  =   "

(((2 0("0 1 %&   !         0 3&    "   3  8!2 !!"9  !  %  0  %   

"  -'& #

" (" 3!2 = 

 ."2 "     "  "      -   ' %  0  ( (("&  ""%0  "* 

(( > "0  !    (4  - 

  "!

   * 

" =  =     ! "

 

   &  %&    "

 " * 0 %    ( " (  '!!((+ ( = "02       !      =      &

     0(  "  =  ! "&( ""

0 = "*  2  "

"

=

  ( " "!

02   (%  "

( !   

"  - '   "1 "4 "   

  !"#!$%&%'# ()!#*+ ,- ..

  /..$ -  , .$

!)#  !$%&%'# 0) !#  " '.1  &&.2.$',,.3%'&+.4.'

&., $ $,%  ,-5$

!6#  !$%&%'#   !2.$' #    "  !(

"  -'   0(% 

    

"= "

( 0 ( 2 !   <     "& ( " 

(     

!!"  4 "   = ( !

" 02 ( " (  '!!(( +  1    "   !"

 "

 =

    (

("2 !

    

"   ":@ '=

   '& / " ("2 0

" "

  (    "   7%"( "

(!   "!

" "  * "

!

 ""- 

" 0    !   #!(   "  (4    *  #

" (2 " 

 "& % 

0! "& = "0! "02 (4 *  "

"= ,.;:/""- 





;.&?# "

   <  (  3  +    $ ( %  $ " &  .& 6   %    !   # !(  " !     "= &    "  " 3 8!2 !!"9* ! % 2   0    !   #!(   "   #

" *&   = "  !2  2    !(    2 ( 0 ( 2  * +  0(  = "   



 (((20

"!2= 

&0  (+  ("

"  !*!   "> "  "!  2 - 

%  (4  

  !   #!( "  "        (( *     (2 "      

      ((  *

&   ! % 2    0    !     "     $%&        "

 2 0( = 

%

"%   (4 *(  = "02 6%   *    

"  

   " :   @ '=

  '  !!!2&  

04   ((& ("2!

0( "! " 

((""- 

*  "(  ((2= "02   &  !     %  !       2

  ( = " "!

"*!   

3

0      &  

2 

& "

"=     2 !   *(% "



( "( '!!((+   ( "(    "!!   "



" #     





                 

   

!    "

  # #

  $   "  "

!



  

  

  !

! 



  %  

 

 &   

   '   

 (

 ! 

     

   

"

 !) *+ ,,,-.



  

   

   &   /

!$  *, , 0, !

 !

  '   

 1 

 

 ! 

   

      

 

 

 &   



  '   "  (

!

 !"   " !



  

  

   " !

 '  ! 

 

"  ! *)!2  1   $       

     "  !



          $  "

 

     "

     "    "   "!" "

      !!   "   "

 !

"

1 "   

 

 1 !"

     ! 

  3      

   "

   

    "

   



4    5"   

    1 !

       *) ! $     "

 

 ! 

       "

  !     

  %   !!  "





   + ,-  ..  /..$*

!)#  !$%&%'#0)!#*%'7 $8 $.. , 4,

,- 9! #!$%&%'#0:!5 #*+.4.-.$ & ;

' 999 !

#   !$%&%'# 0 !'' /-#* &&'  <.-$ : ! #   !$%&%'# ":

 !-$#*

 !6#  !$%&%'#   1

  '.1 &&.  2.$' ,,. 3%'& +.4.'

&., $ $,%   ,-*

!6#  !$%&%'#   67  

 6 8               "   

   

     !  "   9 !   



!   ! "   !!     *) !  2  1  $    

     ! 1 !!   ! :   "  

      

    

 ! "  

  

"   !   ";   "      !  " "  *)! 2  1   $           !           

   " !

   

 

   

7      

   

 / $!

! '

  !

   !  ' !

 !

    

 "  

     

  !        '  3  



 



   

   "



  ' !

 1     ! "

          !    <  <0 !  1  9  $   "

    "    

    

  

.&              1  

    !

   

!"""!!   

  "

       !

 "        

 

 

7

   

 

  !"

 

  '

1



 &"



"

   "   ! '

 

 



"   "

"  

   !

=  (    !  "     

     "

     

         '   "

 





 

 !            "  

!  

     !  3   1      "      

    !

     ! <   ! >  $   $     "  ! ""  '    !



"  ",  !

 

   * , 0,      ?)? @ ??, " 

1

  A.

0    A.<      

  " !

 '  ! 

   "

    0, ,< 0,0  "

   3 

!! / 0, ,< 0,0  9

 !'

!  0,,.,09& A-*

    3!

 !   <@!> $  $   1! !



"   

"  

    &   

  '  

      ! 



    4%$  7. !=$#, .

!

  <45!> $  $   " 0?  ?+=  !  ""  " B ?+= 0$  ?+) A

       "   < $   ?+)  1      

 67  "&

 8     

   !  "

 ! !

    < 45  

         

 !!      

    %$%4..- %  %   ;=-%=-% .>, =//    0 !#* )"9* 67  "& 8        !

  !!

       "     "



 !

    ""    

  !     !  !!!   "

       

  ""  1!





   

      !



" 

  

 

! ! '  

 



 

 !      

 

  

 

   "  !  ""  '  !

   

!   !

 1

"

 

    

    

  

  !  

  

 

 -  *) ! 2  1   $   (

  !   ! 

    

 ! 7 ""

7                ! 

        

  

   "

   !  '



   

!       

      

      

!

  && && && && && && && && && && ?

6  

   3          "   !

   ' "

 !"

!    

        

     &"

  





"

!  !

      "    3

   "

 ! !  





"!  "   "           

!      

   !

  "     "  "

 " 2

 !  ' C '" "(2&!   "  ""%!

( =    %  (4 &   ("2

04=

  7   "(  = " "!

 ("20 3 026%   *!   

% 42"!

   (( *

& +  !   4

30  

   & 



= 02  *4 "  "   "

!

"&0    "  & !      ""%( "%  (4    "      *&  

 "       " = (!

"02( "( '!!((+   '"

(2&0% !  

02"



" ' !!2    " 0 !("     (   

"  '(! )#$!% *  +, -. /    A !3 ? "B C ?, A!0(B C ?,