← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14951/2011dismissed

Piari v. Financial Commissioner, Appeal-I And ORS.

2015-02-12Mr. Justice S.C. Datta7 pages



   

  !"#$#%&'&()  

  

     

  

 

 )*+,, !

  #



 %

& '(

& )!

 %





*% & 

+ , -.%  

, 0 1

-  , 

2  

3 ,  $ 



4  4  

  -





(

 

  

   "

  %  

  %

/

, 

4$



/ 5

(

 %

/

, 

 '









%

 

,  5 











    5 

  (







 %

 

"



  "  

% # 

1

 #



 "  

  $ 

"



  ''47''8

 



"  

  "

 9 %  

 ' ''::4

8

#

)   .$

 ';:8'::; 

 ;  

# 

 

'  

2

 */

2

 

:3:3':

 3

#

   

    <  ""



""

 

3 "



 "

"

   % ='

1  8 

$

 "/% <  (



* <.% 

    - 

.$  "









"

#1 %  "#  

1



$

  

':#  

1   "$     

/ $ 



#

 



"  %

 #"

 

" 

$

#

    - 

"  $ 

   >  

  $

 

   

  #     - 



 /

' :''::3

?%  

 

   $ $ 

 $ 

    - 

$  



 "

# %



/

)::)'::4

3    "  

 

#  

             - 

  /

 '4:8'::4 

 4

 

#

""







" ""$1



 % 

'4:8'::4

4

3"

 

   $ $ 

 $% 

    - 

$  

""



 #



" 

 #" 

 3 '::' /

%

 ' ''::4

8%  

"

 

 

2

 */

 2

 $ $ 

/

%

';:8'::;

; %  

"

/

  

   $ $ 

/

%

:3:3': 

 36

$ 



  

 "  

 

 

3    

  

"

$ 



$

/

 

 

 $  

 3 '::'  

"   

%

"

" @

" 

> 

 

"  



 

 

$

  $



$"

$ 



3  /



"

  



"

/

#



$ 

':#   1

 

 

  / .

$  

  



#$# " 

0



 

%   

  ?  

   

 '$ 

 

  

   

      

 

    "

 

4     4   /

#  

 

 

"

 

#

 

 

"

#   =='=)

 :

 ==8=;

 

  $

 

 1   

$  

"/   /  

#"

 



/



 

 

.



""



$

  "

$  /

    

  

   

 /

" 

 

$  % /

0

" 



" 

 "   

    %  

 

 



 :

 



0

" 

  /

%/



 

  

4 A



$

3 / %  % " 

"

3

 

 









""





3

%/







 /



 /

"

"

  

$

 /  

  " 

3 "

"

#   =='=)

 :

 ==8=;

    "

 /

  

/ 

 

 (



3 

 

 : 

  "  1   



    "



   1 "

4

 



=)3

  

/





 

 "1   

% 1 

 

 #   %  

/

" %



 , # 

 

9



(

 

 '$ 



 #

 



#  

"



 



$

%/



  

 )

$ 

 %

 %



 #

#



%  









"   



!

    



 "

5

    " 

 )1    

4 / % "

 

 $

  

 

   / %  B    

3 / % 7?  

 

3  

 %   

 

 

% 

"

"

$ 

 #/ 

9# "

 

 # / 

"

" 

 C/ #

#

%/



 

 

 )!



  



9#

 % / $

  

 

"" %



 # 



"

5

  / $ "

%



"

%

 *

.