Avneet Saini v. Punjab University And ANR.





    
       !"##$%&%'(  ) *'##"+!%'%  #"%"%'#, *&

!'-!. '%*#,&%"/!'0!'"1#,  #&2'0#'"&    34  +


  5  

 !"#$  %&  '#  "%' !"#$  &" (% )% !"#$  &" 

 6 ,!7 (  *%&& %+

,"  ,  - '$  .  %' /"/'"

$ &" 01+ 2 3

#+

 %&# $ 43""+3% & 5./ 5%)')%/
,,  
%"

% &"  *%& %&,""%%$ 6',3$#"+3 ( ',  %2 35
//  ( ',    & $',,3 '+
,'$"'+$,' 

 
,'% *%,#&  7$"% +,. 8  
' &# $ "

$$'

/"&/  '"
!
!"#$/$%/   # ' ',# $ .%% ,  ,  !   !$   6'

#,   2 3 
,,    ,  +     % $ 

$0&  ,      '$%    % 
9(  9
!( )() 25
9
( 9
:( 9
( );* $%',"+$'"



"

$$'

/"&/ '"
! $% !      !$           3 % /$,'%&"$ +"&!&&"

7999*+, 99&# ""% + $  *%$"

"  "

$$'

/%&&, "%'

% &&$%,,3 "    *%&# '&& /. ',$' 3 "'  "%$ ,##$$3 ,%3 "'   !" %$  /&3# $   / % 3 "' $+$'"&# ""%  

 7777 

 %  $'/+  .  ,$"    %  &/  &  $ ' %"%$/&3# $ .

%'3+-< 4 '$$ $,3 % $',+$- '" %%& .% , .- %$,, 0&" &&, " %& !    %)&/ ;

&%3 $ 1+2 3 
%"

% &" .% $%%"+"# " # ""# / 0 "" = !7'   % %%"+ .- !   $ ''& " 43.  > >' ,%" %

   >   5./

5%)')%/
,,  
%"

%

!

'"  %,$ &$ %& ."',3 ,$".% $%.,"',3&&#"+3%3"

$",+3%  1+2 3 ''% && /,""

> !7'>. '" *%&& /,$,,3 # "%%&& /. $,3'+1$25
5'

", "

 '%"+,.

4 89$3'/&,3" 3',6'

"+ , #

" /3'&/&,3 

, .% $%3'.

,,+ ,,."1 
<

9 $ &  %&& / %& %","3 '+/ "%

 # "%,"" > !7'( 04!$$& %

  %#3/"3&" 
,,  '"%, # ,0$

$!7'(4 .% $% +,. 8*%  $

3%!# %#"%   '  $'0!  %)&/ ;

 / $

/ > > >  %%, % 1+%. >  )' % & " %.-"$"'$%+ $3 9.

%%,,'$$ ,

 "0  $ &, 55))
,, 
%"

%<

!&%// " %&& /,!7' > % ", # $

$."',3'+/ "+3%&  &""&''% %1 "%#37"3

'$ %&& /, > 9 %  %%& %+&''

%$'

  +

 $ '

3 %&# $ .% $%   ', % %+

#% *%& %%'+/ "

& ""== !7'? ,,."+3% "">  !7'= /

 %  #$:.# %/.1$"# " /&'

""""4  !7'   #3$3& $"&- /  % ,,.

/



89/ /3'%%(

 ,- %$% $$""%6' $' &# $"" 55)) 
,,   $  4 
%"

%    %  6'     $#"'"25
( ',   < ? !&&  % +# &- " %&  $

'+/ ",+& ""   !7'  

# % +$- '" %,$ &$ ,,3  ( ',  25
( ',    + "*- "'$ @$ &" &, " # " ,""  4   !7'   - %&# "$

$ /%&# '/&,3 $,

.%%%%"&&, "%'

%%&&$%,*%/., &# ""+3%& :&# '/&,3 '",""

4> !7'4A'%&&, $ %'

%&&$%, %&# '/&,3" +,. 8

&&, $+,%' %&& /./&3 +', -,3$ '+ < = !&""

"&"  / +  &# ""  %  &   /"  %  &   ""      !7' B " /&'

""""   !7'  %. /"%%6'%"

+"$, "+3%B $
%$,, %%" %&&, "%'

%&&$%,% $ ''&# $&25
( ', :.# +  '

 %$

'+/ "& "">   !7'  $

# " /&'

""""    !7'> % 6'."$, "+3$3& $"&- "9"%% 6'    $'    &  # $  "  &3  &$   %"    +



$$&"  +3  %  (

     %  %"  %  &&, "  %'

%  && $%, %&# $ ,,'"%25
( ',   :$ %&. &   9%. / 

,"+3%$ &"  %/"  % /&'

"" %+-%'

%.

% , ,,+ 9 $' '%.% ,% /&'

"" &/ "% $%%%"&&, "%'

%&&$%, .%%/ %' %&,"



,"+ % 
' %% . ," %+

.

% $%%. &   "3+.%" %

  /%$,, "" 1 %# $ %2 3  (&" 0$,,  & /&3 

," &,3 #%'

%,  $, /"

 (&" &&% $, / %& % '" % $%%", &&$%"

%C"'$ * +', - &3/  &3$$' # "&3$,

"+325
%  %  +"

, && /  %$, / %&   %'&&"

&&"+3&" %%%$% $,&3%%. & /3+"

/ "   9%# %'

%%&,"

"%$"&&""

%"%#,%"% #,$  %,"$',  %&$ #&  4 *%  /&'

"  "  ""  4    !7'      !7' "    !7'>,3 &- "  $3& $+'   , +"   % $/&,,3.



&/ %%$ %&  $#"+3( ',  % 25
( ',     !&', ( ', ,#/ "'+% &# $ +$'", $"

"%&&, "%'

%% &&$%, #

% 0%&# '# $."%$/&3 +  ,%3"' " %$"

"%+ ,$"&/&.

%'3+- # $*%&" %#

,"%.%. .%"3 %'$% # " ( ', %& "6',

3 +

 $' %&# '# $  *% '/ %,"$', %&"% %& "

"1 .

%'3+- %,$  %. &  "3  "# " / *% " &  "3 #

'/"+ $',,3$$%'

%"

&'"+3&  $+ $'"8+- # $<D & " -+.1+ %% / .

$%#  8+-+.%# $<" 8+- # $<;- # $%+ /% , 

% .+- $ '# $"' %&# '# $.

%% / /&,30$,,   9  /  ,    &$ ',  /  .

%     ,  ;$% 1'"

/""+3% 
'  8,4!"%9!+1!,:!*1# !'-!.

'%*#,&%"/  !'0  "1#,&  + 
    ?

>      "$ ""   >=  .% $% , $%+&,$"+3,"$',

%& *% "1'"

/% $ "

, 3  !

.& "+3%2 3(,#&% &"'$"%

> +,.   

                            

  
    

         ! "

 # 

  $%     

   

        
&       

         



    '  
(   

 )"

  

    

  *   '      

 





       '         

+  ,-
$,
$../
( 

       0 

 1    +   ,-
$,
$../  2 

    

      0



 1     



         * *   

  3    
(     
45 6 

 #      
   

         

       
< > *%% '".% $%&"%'

% 1'

3%" , %+

 &3&$ "$6' ,+



%&# $ %%& %"&&, " %& !   2 3%'

%&&$%,*/3/ " % / .%,,3'+,9) -%/E$   ., +#"0%,"'"

?

(                0 

  

 0      

                 "

     3  

 * /
7
%    .

 

  ,-
$,
$../4 ' !)/

    



    



 *8    

 
    9"

       3   0 

  

 1
(       

    

 

        

   

 

       





     


( 

                  

          '     



   



  
(         








(   

      

 0     1    



    

    

    9"

     

         9"

  

               

           
 (   

  

 
1 9/ &$ ', /.

%%+#  "% # .-+3%
"

;$% % 
'*%/ ',,3 &&, $+,% , '$*% , '

%&,%

= &, &"- 1'

3 ', %& E$, / ? ; " %,#"# /!7'0   '"+3 &" .%3% ./"3%%$"

" ,"3 # $$',"&&,3 %"# "&,3%'

%% &# '/&,39 %$ %&"% .% ,&&,3

%"# "& %& %"$$,"% $ %+

,"3/&,3".

%&" 9 $%$$""&  %%&# '&& / %& .

%&" . /"  .

%  &&#,    &"    F'%  &"   2 3 '&&"+ &  %& G&&, $   %"# "& !   ;

&%3 $
' ',3 % /%+&"'$"+3&"9 +# '%.% , ,$ "&&  %&   ..

% %-.,"

 &"%%& .,"3 %# $ &"  9# . %   /'1'"'

%& &"   %#  "%& E&&, $ "$"

"' "%# ,$""&& "%%"# "& 1$% $, / %+

 &# $%$% $,&,%%&&, $ 

%"# "&'"&" .'+/ "%'

% &&$%, =  ,,  '%  %  &   %  &$

$,,3  #"    % &  0



            

           

   

   

               

!

   +
,        

  

            
1

 A'% #/ %,3&,3 &"  %  / $"% ,", .

%% &$ %$ &"% #"%0    

  

        

  

   

4!

  6

 
1 !"+# %,# &&, $ %+&"'$" 

#   $

% "-+3&"  9  # .  % +#  "

$'   9 /   % &   % &"2 3 1'

" 1$ %& G$, /

+

 &# $ &3&$  $ % '"%% &&, $     %  &    !        ;

&%3 $  .   '+/ "&"%'

%&&$%,!$$"

,3 % &, &" ,1$"  ! %+1$  &" /  + , 3 . &  $$" %/ ,' +, # . &

  %  1'"

/  &"  +3  %  C"'$   * +',  &'$"   ? ? .% $% "3 $ &"'$"% +,. ; & .

%% 1'"

/ "+& "'%

& 

,"+3&&,,.% $% &"

+ :G+,:

%
' %%&3" "

$ 1+2 3$'% &# $"" %$,,  .% %&$  # "&3$,# " /  %+ '

%+3%*%$' $  +%%$ "

< *%C"'$ * +', %

%,3& "+#"9

"

%%$

,"+ % 
'  ,3&$' $  "%,  '

%%   ,3"

 /%.% $%.

 '

% /%C"'$ * +', 4 9  %  $ $'/$  &     ,,."  "  "  ""

4             !7'      "  > &$ #,36'%" .

%"

$ &"

#% +

    & G  &  # $    5./  5%  )'   )%/
,,  
%"

%.

%,,$6' ,+

  $,'"

&3 &$   $/, &3" $/$.

% % /% /%" $ & $

"$&3 % "   

      )
 &- 0("

H0 (&+, H0