Prince Kalra v. Heena Kalra & Others

 




 !"#$%$& $ '$$ $
$& $

 





 



 


  

 

 
 

 $ ( )%*  + #+
*+$ **  
!"

# 

  

$
# 

 
%


&#'


$

( 
#  

%

 
)
*** *+$ ** ,#

 +

 #



),



-.


 
$

/
0 -
1 -.


-.


%

2 3 4

-




1


 

 

 #
-.
 
 
/





0 
(


0 - # 


5,

 
$ 
)

  

6"
"
"
  
 
7
23 
"

  
 3
8


4
 9 
   

.

 
: 
 

 
%

8
1 

 
 

 
$ 

 ,



 
)

 
"
  
 

1 
#"


" 
1 "


1 

7;

0 - <
1 
  
" 
- "
-


 # 
 

 " 
 = 
%




"
 
 
" 





 .




+ 

1 
>

 







 
%

"
 
 
"   

.



1

-.
 
 

5; 

%
?
1




57
1#
 " 
- # 



 

%
 
)
1

1

 
%

+ 

1

-


1
1

2-

574 ) <


 
- # 





- "
1 

 
- 

1




%

1




 
 







#

" " .

1
"

 #





  

 ( # 

1
 

,?7
1 


%

 
 "


 
 "


-.
 
 


1   

.
 

 
# 

8
1 


1

"


#
 
 .



"
 
" 

 
((+
"
1




" "





8
1 
1
.
 


"
"



  




" 

1.

1




>

  
".
 
1






 
<""







 
1"
-.
 
1
 

<
1


 

,5
 
8
1 

 

 
"





2"
 
" 4
1#
1


 

" "


"
 
1
 
 '
+ 



 1
1



"
 
& '

 
1   




"

 
 
+ 
=
1 

 1
"

 #

# 


 
+
 #
-#

-
1
 
-.
 
8
1 

.


 =

4 





 
-"
 
 




%
7 @)
A
7 @77
%<+
0 -B

4 







 
  @ 


4 

"







 .


.

 



B
#4 "

 
$ 


A


 
"

  
 

" 
" 



" 




" 
 
.


#  
  @ 
 

 
 

  $ 


 
"
  
 B
2#4
 #
 





<  
 
#-  
:1.
 B
2# 4 



'

 1
" .
"




 '

B
2#

4  "
"" 
 .

-



B
 2#

4
  '


"

 


; <
1
#
 
1

-

"

1

#




"

"


;
'


"
1
 

"
+ 
1 

-
 
1 


#

 

0 -
 
!
1
 
 



$ 
)

 
"
  
 


"
 

1
 "#
-.
 
%

7 + 
 










"-

 "

.
-: 






.


" 
.


"
#  
1



<
1
#
 
 
8
1  1 .

 

--


.

 3
 
+ 1

"



-


 
1 '
1
#
'



"


-.

#
- 

 "
<
1
#
  
1
"

#
 
" " .
(

C .
 

 


.

#
.
 
"

1
' 
-
 
8
1  1 

 

 #
1 
+ 
 ".
  


 
$ 
)





 
 


75

 
1



,5
<
1



 
8
1 
"

 
" 
1
#

-.
 
 
 .


1
> 
<
1 
 
-"


 
8
1 
1 
 

 .
 

5 & 
 
(
1





1 
  $ 
)

 
"
  
 
- #
 


C


> 

#
.

 
 =

=1
 



- "





1#
1









 

# 

 "" 
 -.
1


 
8
1 


 .
 

-


%
()@;

 ." 0 -

<  

 
 .






 
  (
 
 

"


 #
-1 
8 

 
 "




<
1
- #
  



C
1
.

(
1 


8
1  


-
'
-
 


 
&   
(
1


- #


 
  
 


 

#

-

 "
 

 
8
1 
1



 


 
  
 
 .






"


  
 
8
1  1
-

 -.

"

1


#.
1'

$ .

 


7
"


 #


 

)@=

"
1

 

-
 

 

1 



"
"


1  ,  #
 "


1
 
-.
 
8

/ 
& 
 
$

/
0 -







 5,



-.
 
/





0 
(


0 - 
1


  

= 4 
 @ 

 

 
 



"
" "


"


 


C .
1
 
1


 


4 
 
%

1 
"" .

#
 .

"


1

".
D#:
A
$ :
  @ @1 
1
 -.

:

-  




4 
 @1 

 


 
@)

"


- 
1

"



77@=
-: 

1



 :.


 



 


" "




 
 
 

 '
 #. 
 
"


 B #4 


  

"#

 
((+ " 
 


"

 




" "





#  

 @ @1 

 
1



 #


"

 .
1 
 .

 B 2#4 
 

 

. 

"
#

" 

 #
 





"
  @ 


" "


B 2# 4

 



 C .

#
 
  
 
%



 
1 

 







 
 
%

1 
- -

.
 
" .
 

 
-"
-  ""

 @ @1 

" "



 


%<+
0 -B
 2#

4 


 @ @1 
1 
 #

#
 
 

"


1


 
1 

""


 .
  



 


  

-
 
-.
 
=
-






),



-.
 
 
 

$

/
0 -
? & 




 
 
-"


   
$

/
0 -

"


 
 


 # 
" 


),
<

-
1 .
- #
-.
  
 
$

/
0 -
 
#  "



1

-.
 
 
-.
 



 
 



 
8
1 
 


1



"
 
"

8
1 

 


  



 
- 


 
1


<

 



"

 
 
  $ 
)




 
 
1
 
-.
 
 


75
% 




1




 
8
1 

 ,5
<

 
 
 #

 .
 
 
 
 
8
1 
2-



 " 4
+ 
 
1 
C

 .
.

 8
1 





 
#


1 #
1
#
 


 

55
2

>
=4
+1

1
-


 
 
8
1 


57
$ 

 


 



57
1


-.
 
  

,?7
<
1  .
#


 
 

1
 
-.
1.
"

  
 " 
 
 
 "


-


 


 
1 

" 
 

- 

 
 

 
 
8
1 


1

" 
 

"

'

 
 


 
# 
1 
 1 .

 


 .


 

 #
-.
 "
<


 

1

 & 




 
 
 
 



1 
.
 
1 



.
 
 


 
 


'



# 1
 









.



 
"


 
 '



 
%

1 ' 

 



7),
 
,),

 
 
 
%





 


%

.
#






"
 
 
"  
1


1 
 
%
-: 
1
#



 
-.


<

 
 
 
8
1 
1#

 " "


"

2 - C .
 
"

4

,75
<

-"




'









 .



"




#
 

"
 .

 
8 

1

-


1






"

 #

-1 =

1 
 


 



 
#
 .
 
1 
1


 

 1

-

-.


<






 #


8
1 





 

-
 
1

.


#.
1
-
'

'




" 

<

-"


 
"

C
1
-





-.
 
8
1 

1 
 @- 
<

 
 
   
(





 -


.



 #


1

1
"


-.
 
8
1 
 <  

 
" "




-"




C
 
- 

 



-
"






.

-
 #


.

  "


"

' 


 
1


8
1  


 .



 


-


"




-.

"


8
1 

 


 

 








1

-

 3
 

%

 
) <

 -"


 

"


77@=
1

 
8 


"

> 

#
 
 :  
<


 

.



-
1
 


),



-.
 
   
$

/
0 -
-




 
 
 




 
%



 "

-#
<

 
 
 
%


-

-: 

""


.

 
"
#  

 

%

 
)
<

-"





1
#.
1
1

 
 
" 

 8
1 




 





 
 
"  1
.




57
1#

1 





"
1
 
 
 

.


1

 .

 
#

" 

<

-"





-

"

#


"

"

1
 
 


"

"

-
 .
 >
#




-



 
8
1 

 

 
 





 
1 
 
1
 #


 1



"

" 

<

# " .

 

" .
 
" 
-

".
 
 
1 
C

 





 <


1 


#  "

 
1 

-

 
8
1 


= - 
1

"


1 "

 "
 - 
  



7),
 ,),
1#

 
1 
>


1
".

 


 
<




 
 
%


 

 "


+
 
 .

-"





1






-.
 

,7,
 


-
.

"
 -


(

 



 

?7,
1# 
 
'


"

 
"
<

 
 
 1 
1

 .
 #


1

 

 ""
-
 '
<

 .

-"


 

 


"
 .

 



"

-


 
 


<


 
.



-
1
) <
#

 




 


  #  
  
 


 
 


# 


 
%



.


 "
 - 
 1 1


# 




7),



(


 =


%

.
 
-.





(
+ 


-

 #
1


 
 1 
1


 
"

1.
"


 

%

1#

-"


"


1

#
-
' 
-.
 


#.
-
& 




 
 -"




" -

'

 .
 
"

  .




-.
 
%

-: 




 - 

%


 


1


 
  @ 


1
 '




 
"

-.
,
"
.




 
 1


"


 
 




 

& 




 -"




-



1


1'
  < 
 #  "

 

"



 
 




>




 &



,),F <









: 
 
C


.



1



1
  

-
"



 
 >





# 


), G

,),
  = & 




 -"

- "

  
1 
1


 
%




%
55
0 
0
$ 
7=

0 -
#
-

' 
-.
 
+

 





-.
  




 
%
 & 




 
 
%
 

 
 
%



 #  
 
1 
1


"

 + 
   #








" "

 
 
1 
 


# 
 

  + 
 
%

1 



(

 
 
%

1
#


"


 
" 



1 

#.
 .
"


"



"
+ 
1
'

 
1



 


%



:



 
-#


"

"1

),

;
"
+ 
1
-
 

 "


%
55
0 0
$ 
7=

0 -F ; + 
 
 
 
%


;,
1

 


-


(
-"


 
- "
1
 #


  1 
1


<
1
 

 
 
%
 
"
#







#.
 .
"

"

 "


 
 

#






#.
+  .
"
7
" 

"

 7 + 
( =;?,?=,
1
"#
-.
 
%
 
 " 

 






 
 
 
 
 





 "

,7,
+ 
1

'



?7,







 

1#

 
"
1

'


+ 
 1


1



1 







 3 " 
 '



 
 "" 
5 
 
 
"#

( = ,=,
'



 

 


#

 




"
'
 

;,
( 


1






%



 



 
" .

 


,7,
 
 

:

" .
 

# 
# 
+



1 
1

-.

1 
,
+ 


1
"

"

-.
 #
 


 -1 "
+ 
"
1
 
-
 
 
(

( 



(
1#
"
-1 

 
 +

(

>".




 
 


 1



1
-
 
.

<





"
 .





 



".
-
 #

 
" 
1 

 
<

.

>"



-




 
" 

+ 
(


 
.



 
1
1
-




 





"


" 


 

? + 3-
$"
(

2

 34  56  %

+5 /0+

./




 


2*6895 "

$27,0-+

///4
 
> 
# 


1





  = E5
<
+76+:6;96  9<5 +:6  9<,$ // <./


(




C

 .



1

E
<



C

 .
 
1






" 


 
 
 
 




1

H


 I
 

"

 . + 










#
-
 1 
$ 
,



 


1
 C.
 -






 
1

 
"

 
$ 
7
+ 


 




H I
.
 

" 
 
" .
 " 
 

/

( "-
"

-.
 
" 
 


 
 


"
-.
 !


6
 


 

"





1


 
-

 

 
1

".
-
 




"

 




- 
 



 
1


"


 
 
 
 
  





 
1

 
1J

"
 '

-



 " 

 
 " 


1

.
<

.

>"
 
1 

" 
".


#


 



" 



$

" 
1 
1
#


 




" 

 
 
.








    

 
"

 
 
 
"
"
 -


 F ,
<
9:4  96  &878  5 9  +958 9 &878,1+

/..,


(

  E,
+ 




1



 
 .


"

 

-
1
 -


<

1

 
 .
"



"




-



 
 
 .

"
 




# 1

 
1


 



 <



1

"




"


 
(




- .



.

 
(





- 
1




 

 


I

 
<




C

 .


"


 
(

 -
 
-.
 
 .




 
1

 "

F  <
=+956 $7+9/1+

-1 3-
$"
(

- #
  = + !
 
  
 .



 
 
 





-
 #


@ 
" 
 

 



 





#

 
 
 '



 
1


 



 -


 "



:



 
 .



-.
 " 
$ 
524

!
 
 
 # 
 
 
 

-
 
 
.






-

 












 #
.

<
#

 
> 


"

.

 





 


 
 .


-
 #

 
" 
 




-1
 #
.


6
" "" .

 .


$ 


 
"
 .
 
#




 




!A6
 
 


C .


" 

 .




#

 
I






 #
. F <
1
 
- #
 - .

 
 

 .


# 

1 








-1
 #
. 
"



- 





 
<


 
 


 #


- .

 
" 
0 "
  
-


-
 



" 3 - .  < 
 
 
 








"  -1 
 
%

+ 
C


 




 
%

-.
 
  "






1
 


"


-
-1

.


 

8
1 

'

  
 # 

 





 .
1
 
 
"

"
-.

 .
1 

#
  
" 
 
1


1


 
-
- 

<

# 







 
 
"
  
 





 


:

-
 
-.
 
 
 
(

 
"
#


 
# 
 
".
-

-.
 

  
+
 #





 


8
1 
 

#


 







 
-

=  #

-1 
 @-


:  









 

>

.


 
 #


8
1 
1 
 @- 

 

 1






"
 
 
" 

 8
1 
 "

-: 


 
-


# 

-

-.


   #
 
+ 
"


 >
 
 
 

 #

1
 

 .
-
>"


-.
 
 
 
(
  "
 
 
# 
$ "

.
 
" 


#
- 
#


 
8
1  
 
" "


"
 

" .
 
" #
-
". 
'

 "



# 






"
 .
 
< "
 .



"

.
- 
 
 
(
%
-  
 

 

 

+




#.
 




C 
#
   
" 
<


1#
"



 
 .


 



 
  
-








"





-

 -.

"#
 

.

/  
+ 
   
 
 
$

/ 0 -

 

 
 .








1#

#


 
 

1'

#.
0 .
- 
 
(

( 
0 -
-1
)
"
 7
"
& -.



 


 .
"
#

"
 
.

 
1'.
#

 



8
1 


-
 


"


77@=
 "

"
"





-.
 
 
 
$

/
0 -
< "
>




 
.
5= ,
 



"

-

,;)5@=







1#  
-.
 
 
 
$

/
0 -

 
 



"
3" "


"@


3


:  


 
" >

 
 
<

- 


 

 
 


 
%





  "




%
55
0 
0
$ 
7
0 -


%



-
 

 





 
"

 +






.
.
 

 
"


 .

1#
 
 



 

"



"

"
 
 
 
(




)
1


  


" 


 ),



-.
 
 
 
$

/
0 -





 =

4 ( .




1

".
D#:
A
$ :


-


#
"" .
-.
 
 

 %


4 +


-
 

#


 


0 1'

#.
0 .
-
 
 
(

( 
0 -
-1
)
"

7
"

4+






"


77@=


"

"



 
%




 .

 

#4 
%



-
 





  "




%
55
0 
0
$ 
7=
 0 -
<
 
 
"

#
-
# 
-.



"


"


-
' 
 # 





 
%

1

 1'


#4 <
# 1

 
   "

 
 
   
(

  

 
 
 


"

"
 


  

  
.




; 
" 



),



-.


 
 
$

/
0 -






 











*    








#7<>6 

'

@ 
D @% 
- D @%