← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13485/2020disposed of

Karanbir Singh v. Deputy Commissioner Cum Chairman Appellate Tribubnal Sirsa And Others

2023-09-15Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl5 pages



   

  

 



 !  "

#"

'!() """!% *% + ,+- .. !% +.)%.!

!!!

/,,00 1%&+!02 '% 

)%

"""3 ,!

!

      % ! %"

34!

5! 02 6 

,!%"

%"

/.!

, 7 )2 /82 %-!

% ,!

! 9 "

 "

%.0 9!2 6 

% ,!

! 9""

::::

   "

1)

60 % !

0

+!

% /% 0

;

<

! +!

=!

 +!

>%2 %

!

 , 00- !+%

%%%

?+ )!( %



"

"

/!!@+% 

  , 

% ,!

! "

3 ,!

! 9"7 &% '!()

0

,!

+!

% ' !

!!!

0 %

'!% A!

2

<

0.

.!!!

>00

!( %( %

%!

%



"

# @ +

% ,!

! 9"7 &% '!()

6+%

'!()

,!% +!

% &0

%0!

%( %

 

'+&3( %%2 '% "

1) '2 >)0 @%  !( ,>%

1%&+!02 %



00>

,!

00

%!

%



"

#

% %!

,!%

%.

!% %!( >!% ),

,  !

0!

+%)%



%6!+

&

%% 

6+%

% ,!

! 9""

/!

,,0

0

(!  . '!()

,!% )%! >

 . 

/,,00 1%&+!0 %



"

"

"

+%!( ,!

!

-

,% ! >% ,!2 0%!

+! 0

,!% >00

+! 0

% ,!

! 9" )6 4!0- +&.

.% &!

0

&!

,%,%

>) ) &!

+0- (!

,!%

% ,!

! 9 "



)%

!

%!

,% ! "

= &!

4!0- ,%-

,% !

  &

 , 

%.

.,%. "

"

1) &6 

B!

!

.%B

C/!!@+% DE 0!( >) .,"

1) %.

% %,% +

)%!&0>  

   

            



             !" !" 

 # $% $ &!'(%  )   

            !"% * + $  &  ) # $$,$- " .  !- %



 /       0      & ) # $$,$- " .  !- % 1   $  & ) # $$,$- " .  !- %!" 

 # *%

 

 2 

  ,  3 ( 4 

# * # * 14 $5( $'4 '$5,3$0 $54 # 0($# 3(. # $'5

# 5,*

('6 $1  **'* 14    

         !        % $              2   

  2 2 

 

72  7          2   

    89 %                 2        &  )  :        &     +/ /  2                  

     %        

      " ;  "7  % 7<-  #   $130   *(*(      2  7

   97 /





  = (0$(*(* % ./  #   0'   *(*$      2



+  = $3$(*(*   2     

    2& %      6 

                   

      /

  

       6           2

 >    

 2    2      

&    2   2% :-      6  

  2 2 2 

  

   2%     6  



 

    

           2  

   2%          2     

       

 =    

               

             

  

     

,9 ,9$& *+ /  1/  ?

,%+ 0

. >+0

)> '!() ,!% >)

%  ,%-

%+%!

,%,%-

 

?+ !

&  !

,%-

!

,%- 0% - B!

,  !

0!

!  %- !% )6 &!



%6!+ 5) ,% )6 +&.

&!

!%

>)+ !-

% !

,% +%

&) ,% >+0

& &+!

%.

!

!

.,%. "

"

$,!( 6> &6 

4! ,%-% . 0%!

+! 0

,% 2 ,% ! 60 % !

 , 

%.

.,%. "

/00 ,!

!( .

00!+ ,,0 ! 2

!-2 )00 !

 , 

6>

&6 

%"

!"#

 -   $%&'%&()*&+,-./0(&+)1.&23 &)01 $%&'%&((&*1('+45&3 &)01