Principal Commissioner Of Income Tax Faridabad v. M/S Piyush Buildwell India Ltd.

  

    
 

  

  
 !"# 



 $ %&'()*( +


, -    !

"#
 $
!

"#
%#
 &'(')*  &+,')-'&.(/01#')0&+)'23)('240*/ &%05&+6 +2013)0&+)'23)('2 &*/'+77'22+)*  .//0121
3!2 /'&'8')3'0(0)+77'+23)-'&#'9*0)

 */'
)96'+:

9*1 ;

&(/&*1!*/'9*!<+=+0)(**/'&-'&-+*'- >

>7+(('-?@ */'
)96'+:77'22+*'&0?3)+21'4 '2/0;

&(/&*1!*/'&0?3)+2!< 92+060)= 2240)=(3?(*+)*0+2A3'(*0)( 2+4 B;0<)*/' +9*(+)-0)*/'90&936(*+)9'( */'9+('*/'"-
/+('&&'-) +9*(+)-0)2+4?@37/2-0)=*/'

-'90(0) "-
;<+)-0)-'2'*0)=*/'7')+2*@ (

1 1

CD2'80'-?@*/'(('((0)=

09'&3C( E;< ;9< */'9*?@/2-0)=*/+**/'0673=)'-7')+2*@0(7&'D 6+*3&'+)-/')9'3)+?2'*(3(*+0)*/'(+6'F ;00<)*/' +9*(+)-0)*/'90&936(*+)9'( */'9+('*/'"-
/+('&&'-) +9*(+)-0)2+4?@37/2-0)=*/'

-'90(0) "-
;<+)-0)-'2'*0)=*/'7')+2*@2'80'-

 ?@/2-0)=*/+**/'(('((0)=

09'&/+('&&'-0)2'8@0)= 7')+2*@  )  ')*0&'  +63)*    -0(+224+)9'  +(  4+( &0=0)+22@-0(+224'-?@(('((0)=

09'&4/')*/'"- 
;<  /+-  /'2-  */+*  +(('((''  4+(  '20=0?2'  & 7&7&*0)+*'-'-39*0)'(7'90+22@4/'))A3+)*36

7&7&*0)+*'-'-39*0)4'&'A3+)*0 0'-4/02'-'90-0)= */'+77'+2 ;000<)*/' +9*(+)-0)*/'90&936(*+)9'( */'9+('*/'"-
/+('&&'-0)-'2'*0)=*/'7')+2*@4/')0*0(+6+**'& 92+06 ':'67*0)&-'-39*0)3)-'&*/'9*1+/'+8@ )3(  0(  72+9'-  )  +(('((''  @  92+060)=  0)+993&+*'

-'-39*0)  *  &'-39'  */'  *+:  20+?020*@  *+)*+63)*(  *

3&)0(/0)=0)+993&+*'7+&*0932+&( 0)96' ;08<)*/' +9*(+)-0)*/'90&936(*+)9'( */'9+('"-
/+('&&'-) +9*(+)-0)2+40)-'2'*0)=*/'7')+2*@ '(7'90+22@40*/3*=0)=0)**/':72+)+*0)G;00<* #'9*0) */'9*FH /'&'2'8+)* +9*(+&'*/+**/'+(('((6')*@'+&0)828'-0(

>D ('+&9/+)-('0I3&'4+(9)-39*'-+**/'+-60)0(*&+*08'

09'

0@3(/&37 67+)0'(+)-*/'&'(0-')*0+27&'60('( 0&'9*& 4'&'+2(('+&9/'-) 

>
)7&9''-0)=(3)-'&#'9*0)G 9*180-'&-'&-+*'- 

+--0*0) 
>1

1>G1> CD4+(6+-'?@ -0(+2240)=*/'92+06 */'+(('((''6+-'3)-'&#'9*0)>
*/'9* 3&*/'&1+)+--0*0)  
1> 1 1>G CD4+(6+-'?@-0(+2240)=*/'& ':7')('(
)*/'+77'+2 02'-1*/'(* 77'22+*'3*/&0*@&'6+)-'-*/'

 6+**'&  ?+95  /2-0)=  */+*  */'  +(('((''  4+(  '20=0?2'  &  7&7&*0)+*'

-'-39*0)3)-'&#'9*0)>
*/'9**+50)=0)*9)(0-'&+*0)*/'

&'(0-')*0+23)0* /+80)=+&'+2'((*/+)

(A3+&' ''*/'(('((0)= 

09'&4+(*8'&0 @*/' +9*3+27(0*0)1/4'8'&-3'*))D8'&0 09+*0)1 */'  +--0*0)  4+(  (3(*+0)'-  ?@  */'  (('((0)=  

09'&  ')+2*@  

1 1

CD  3)-'&  #'9*0)  E;<;9<    */'  9*  4+(  067('-  )  

&*/'+63)* -'-39*0)(-0(+224'-
)*/'+77'+21*/'(* 77'22+*'3*/&0*@-'2'*'-*/'7')+2*@)

G/'+77'+2 &'8')3'4+(-0(60(('-?@*/'&0?3)+21/')9'*/'7&'(')*+77'+2 "'+&)'-93)('2 &*/'&'8')3'+&=3'-*/+**/'(*77'22+*'

3*/&0*@'&&'-0)('**0)=+(0-'*/'7')+2*@+(*/'7+&*0+2+--0*0)4+( (3(*+0)'-+)-/')9'*/'7')+2*@A3+*/'(+6'4+(2'80+?2' /'9)*')*0)&+0('-2+95(6'&0*/'92+06 */'+(('((''

3)-'&#'9*0)>
*/'9*4+(&','9*'-?@/2-0)=*/+**/' 2+*(4'&'

(0*3+*'-40*/0) G5026'*'&( &663)0907+22060*( '2/0+)-*/'?302* 37+&'+4+(6&'*/+)

(A3+&' ''*/'(+0-&-'&4+(('*+(0-'+)- */'6+**'&4+(&'60**'-?+95 &+2240)=7&7&*0)+*'-'-39*0)80(D+D80( */'&'(0-')*0+23)0*/+80)=2'((*/+)

(A3+&' ''*+&'+
*4+()2@+(+ &'(32* ))D8'&0 09+*0) +9*3+2+(7'9**/+*+--0*0)4+(+=+0)6+-' /'+(('((''/+--0(92('-*/'7+&*0932+&(+)-*/'-'-39*0)4+(92+06'-0) */'  &'*3&) 
*  0(  +2(  )*   -0(73*'-  */+*  */'&'  4'&'  -'*+02(  ?' &'  */'

(('((0)=

09'&*7&8'*/+**/'+(('((''/+-9)(*&39*'-*4?'-&6 3)0*(
)80'4 0)-0)=(&'9&-'-?@*/'+3*/&0*0'(1*/'-0(73*' ?02'--4)*/+**/'+(('((''4+(')*0*2'-*7&7&*0)+*'-'-39*0)3)-'& #'9*0)>
*/'9*14/'&'+(/'/+-92+06'- 322-'-39*0)8')

  */3=/  32*06+*'2@  -3'  *  ))D8'&0 09+*0)    */'  +9*3+2  +(7'9*  */'

7&7&*0)+*'&'20'

932-)*?'=08')?@*/'(('((0)=

09'& /'7&'(')*9+('-'()* +2240*/0)*/'+6?0* #'9*0) E ;<;9< */'9*/'92+060)= -'-39*0)4/09/ 32*06+*'2@4+()* (3(*+0)+?2'4022)*0*('2 +63)** 3&)0(/0)= 0)+993&+*'7+&*0932+&( /'  #37&'6'  3&*  0)  
  )#  $  -   (!

4

5
-67-'+2*40*/#'9*0) */'9* +)-/'2-+(3)-'&  BE=2+)9'+**/0(7&80(0)432-(3=='(**/+*0)&-'& *?'98'&'-1*/'&'/+(*?'9)9'+26')* */'7+&*0932+&( */'0)96' */'+(('((''#'9)-2@1*/'+(('((''63(* /+8' 3&)0(/'-0)+993&+*'7+&*0932+&( /0(0)96'&'(')*0( )**/'9+(' 9)9'+26')* */'0)96'/+*0()**/'

9+(' */''8')3''0*/'&4'8'&1*/'"'+&)'-3)('2 & '8')3'(3=='(*'-*/+*?@6+50)=0)9&&'9*92+06 &*/'

':7')-0*3&')0)*'&'(*1*/'+(('((''/+( 3&)0(/'-0)+993&+*'

7+&*0932+&( */'0)96'(7'&"+4"':09)1*/'6'+)0)= */'4&-J7+&*0932+&J0(+-'*+02&-'*+02(;0)723&+2(')('<K */'-'*+02( +92+061&*/'('7+&+*'0*'6( +)+993)* /'&'

&'1  */'  4&-  J7+&*0932+&(J  3('-  0)  */'  #'9*0)

E;<;9<432-'6?&+9'*/'6'+)0)= */'-'*+02( 92+066+-'
*0(+)+-60**'-7(0*0)0)*/'7&'(')*9+('*/+* )0) &6+*0)=08')0)*/''*3&)4+( 3)-*?'0)9&&'9* &0)+993&+*'
*0()*+(0 +)@(*+*'6')*6+-'&+)@-'*+02 (37720'-4+( 3)-*?' +9*3+22@0)9&&'9*')9'1+*2'+(*1 7&06+ +90'1*/'+(('((''9+))*?'/'2-=302*@ 3&)0(/0)=

G 0)+993&+*'  7+&*0932+&(  /'  "'+&)'-  3)('2  +&=3'-  */+* J(3?60**0)=+)0)9&&'9*92+060)2+4 &*/'':7')-0*3&') 0)*'&'(*432-+63)**=080)=0)+993&+*'7+&*0932+&( (39/ 0)96'J$'-)**/0)5*/+*(39/9+)?'*/'0)*'&7&'*+*0) */'9)9'&)'-4&-(/'4&-(+&'2+0)+)-(0672'
) &-'&*':7('*/'+(('((''**/'7')+2*@3)2'((*/'9+('0( (*&09*2@98'&'-?@*/'7&80(0)1*/'7')+2*@7&80(0)9+))* ?'  0)85'-  @  +)@  (*&'*9/    06+=0)+*0)1  6+50)=  +) 0)9&&'9*  92+06  0)  2+4  9+))*  *+)*+63)*  *  3&)0(/0)= 0)+993&+*'  7+&*0932+&( 
) 
 

      

 ! "

#$%14/'&'*/0( 3&*  4+(  9)(0-'&0)=  */'  (+6'  7&80(0)1  */'  3&* ?('&8'-*/+**/'(('((0)=

09'&/+(*?'(+*0( 0'-*/+*+ 7'&()  /+(  9)9'+2'-  */'  7+&*0932+&(    /0(  0)96'  &

3&)0(/'-0)+993&+*'7+&*0932+&( (39/0)96'/0(3&* &'

'&&'-*+)*/'&-'90(0) */0(3&*0)& 

    ' 

$ ()! "

)*%1 +(+2(1*/'-'90(0)0)& 

 +, "-. / 01. 

 ()! "

22$% +)-&'0*'&+*'-0)7+&+ */+* D J
*='(40*/3*(+@0)=*/+* &+77209+?020*@

#'9*0) E;<;9<9)-0*0)((*+*'-*/'&'0)63(*':0(*J :::::: $'+&')*9)9'&)'-0)*/'7&'(')*9+('40*/*/'6')(&'+ 4'8'&14'/+8'*)2@(''+(*4/'*/'&0)*/0(9+('1+(+ 6+**'& +9*1*/'+(('((''/+(=08')0)+993&+*'7+&*0932+&(
)

 $'?(*'&!( 09*0)+&@1*/'4&-J0)+993&+*'J/+(?'')-'

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

@0*('2 14022)* +63)*  *  3&)0(/0)=  0)+993&+*'  7+&*0932+&(  &'=+&-0)=  */' 0)96' */'+(('((''#39/92+066+-'0)*/''*3&)9+))* +63)***/'0)+993&+*'7+&*0932+&(H
)80'4 +9*( */'9+('+)-9)(0-'&0)=*/'-'90(0) 90*'-+?8'1)0)*'& '&')9'0(4+&&+)*'-0)-'2'*0) 7')+2*@ /'+77'+20(-0(60(('- 4.

$/'*/'&(7'+50)=C&'+()'-

'(C $/'*/'&&'7&*+?2'

'(C