High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3784/2015dismissed

Maninder @ Mandeep @ Moni v. State Of Haryana

2015-10-07Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain5 pages

! "#$#%&"' (

! "#$#%&"' ( )

)

* %#%! (+* %! ,+*%# ##% ( - ($.$ / (0

$,%! % *& *& *& *& 12*/// 12*/// 12*/// 12*/// ( $ %& ( $ %& ( $ %& ( $ %& *(3#45 ()!7"

(5 , ##% ( /) /) /) /) ##% (5 #8 !5#$, ##%"5 88 %9#%95 (! (!

!: ;

)<5 ( '0, ##% (< $(! ( ! ' $.33% !

" 5 (# "".$ !%

,,8#"

#%37 !'05 ,($ ".#% (.%! (/ "#%;

! (#3#% 8(" !.( );=1(1 ($5(> (% !".%$ 8 (5 , ##% (5 $$.'3# !

5 , ##% (< .%!#%%" %!.(#%9#%7 $#9 #% 3,8 #% % 5 ! 3 ! 3 8 #3,(7 3 %$ #% 5#$ 3 %<5#8 (#%9#%<#% $$?'@ / "#%; (( !$ $.%! (&?

A< ( ,(" ! #%$ 5 ( , ($%$ < ( ,(" ! #%$ 5 ( , ($%$ < ( ,(" ! #%$ 5 ( , ($%$ < ( ,(" ! #%$ 5 ( , ($%$

(#%9' 9.#80

%" &?

=> B5 ( )#%5 ".($ %0#%C.#(0#%)( 8 ) %

%" ) # ($ (3 5 7#! %" 5 %0 , ($% % ' #%9 5

"".$ ! 5 $ "33# ! %0

%" <5#"5$."5, ($%".8!' (# !9 5 ( <#55 "".$ !)5 .(3 0,(" !

#%$$."5, ($% (5

%" <5#"5

5 ($5 7 "33# ! = > B5 ( $."5 , ($% #$ % %!#%9 5 .()5 3 0' (( $ !($.33% !) 5 "#(".3$ %" $ 5 "

$ 3 0( C.#( )

(5 ,.(,$

( $ #! => %0 , ($% %!#%9 5 .( 85.95 %.%! ( (( $(.,% $.33%$)3 ' !

#% !'0$."5.( (5 ,.(,$ 5 #%C.#(0#%)((# 8 )5

<5#"55 ($5 7 "33# ! = > B5 ( 5 .( ,(" !$ #%$ %0 , ($%.%! ($.'?$ "#%=>)5 %?

= > 5 ,(" !#%9$ #% ( $, " $."5 , ($% $5 88 ' "33 %" !

( $5) <#% $$ $( ?5 (! ='> $.'D "5 ,(7#$#%$ "8 .$ = >) 5 "

$ 3 0,(" ! $# $."5, ($%5 ' % % "".$ ! , ($% <5 % 5 .( 6"9%#E %" 5

%" .,%<5#"5 5 #%C.#(0((# 8< $"33 %" !F 5.$) $, (5 '7 ,(7#$#%)5 .(5

3,8 ,< ($.33% %0, ($%

" 5 (# 8 <#55 "".$ ! 8( !0

"#%9 (# 8)#

5 ( #$ %.953 8%( "(!,(" ! #%$5 #!, ($% %1'8 , @.(#% (! ,/#%957 ($.$/

(! ,/#%957 ($.$/

.%D ' %!5 ($ .%D ' %!5 ($ .%D ' %!5 ($ .%D ' %!5 ($

=>=(#3#% 8>:

)5 $5 8!

$.%! (&? AG. $#%$H G. $#%$H G. $#%$H G. $#%$H G B5 #$ 5 $ 9 <5#"5 ,< ( .%! ( / "#%;("

%' @ ("#$ !I GB5 5 (5 <(!J 7#! %" J.$ !#%/ "#% ;=>(5 $' %.$ !#% "3,( 5 %$#7 $ %$ %!#%"8.! $5 7#! %" "88 " !!.(#%9 #%(5 <(!J 7#! %" J#$8#3# ! 5 7#! %" ( "(! !!.(#%9(# 8I % 3 81$"

$ )5 %$#.#% %"5 8( !05 8!5

("33# 8)"9%#E %

%" "

%' 6 % #%$ , ($%% 3 ! "".$ !'. #%$<533 8$

( #8 '8 (35 , , ($ #8 !'05 ,8#"

( "3,8 #% #% /."5 "9%#E %" "

% ' 6 % .%! ( / "#% ; ( %!5 / $$#%$.!9 % !%< ##88 1 7#! %" 1 .%! ( / "#% ; ( ' "3 $

#8 '8 ($.33%#%9 "".$ !I / "#% ; () $#9%# #"

%80) .$ $ < @,( $$#%$5 5 7 ' 6 %% # => %C.#(0 = > (# 8 $ (# 8 "33 %" $

3#%9 "5 (9 ) % #%C.#(0 "

% %80 '

.%! ($! ' ,( ?(# 8 #%C.#(0 %C.#(# $ .%! (/ "#%$

)

(K %!.%! ( / "#% ; ( ( $, "# $ 5 #%C.#(0 "% 3,8 ! '0 / "#% ; ( * 8$ "3#%9 '

( 5 .( #% ".($ $."5 %C.#(# $ "

% ' .$ ! ( "(('( #% 5 7#! %" ( "(! ! #% 5 ".(

( 5 (# "33 %" $) ( 5 @ ("#$ ,< ( .%! ( / "#%;() %! 8$ !! <5$ % 3 5 $' %$5<%#%8.3% 5 "5 (9 ?$5 %7# < 5 '7 ,$##%5 <(!1 7#! %" 1#%/ "#%;(5 $'

'( !80 .%! ($! %! % 8# ( 880 # 7#! %" '(.95!.(#%9 (# 8 GB5 5 (5 <(!J 7#! %" J.$ !#%/ "#% ;=>(".8!%803 % 7#! %" $ !

'0 "($$? @ 3#% #%( 5 ".("

% @ ("#$ 5 ,< (.%! (5 $ #!,(7#$#% 7 %%5 '

$#$ 5 $ 3 %3 ! #%5 @ 3#% #%?

#%?"5# 5 <#% $$"%" (% !I %$#! (#%95

" 5 .%! ( / "#%;

( , ($% #%$ <53 3 8 #$ !#$"8$ !#$%80$.33% !

" 5 (# #%$."5 % 7 %.%! (/ "#%;= >(5 ,(" !#%9 #%$$."5, ($%#$"33 %"

(35 $ 9 6#%9 "9%#E %" )5 .( % ! % < # ( 5 7#! %" #%$ 5

"".$ !,(,$ !' $.33% !' $ !

'0"($$? @ 3#% #% G - B5 #$ 5 % .( 5 $ #$

"#% ( C.#( !#%76 5 ,< (.%! (/ "#%; ( (( #9% "".$ !IB5 5 (5 ,< ( .%! (/ "#%;=>("

%' @ ("#$ !

%80 # 5 ".( #$ $ #$ # ! 5 5 $.33% !<#88#% 888#6 8#5!' "%7#" !I 5.95 .%! ( / "#% ;= >='> ( 5

"".$ !$.'$ C. %80#3,8 ! !#$' (

$ # 5 5 ! ' % "".$ !<5 % 5 .( #%## 880 6 "9%#E %" 5

%" ) 5 ! 9( $ #$

"#% 5 <#88 ' ( C.#( !

$.33%#%9 , ($%.%! (/ "#%;( <.8!' 5 $ 3 (I 3#%9 "5 (9 5 !#

( %" #% 5 ! 9( $ #$

"#% $.33%#%9 5 (#9#% 8 "".$ ! %!

$.'$ C. % "".$ !#$% "".% 5

5 (# 83 05 7 8( !0"33 %" ! #%$ 5 (#9#% "".$ ! %!##$#%5 ".($ $."5 8 5 3 8$ ( !#$"8$ ! #%$ 5 % <80$.33% ! "".$ !( $5$.33%#%9

% "".$ ! <#88 ( $.8 #% ! 8 0 5 (# 8 ?

5 ( ( 5 ! 9( $ #$

"#% $.33%#%9

=(#9#%

$.'$ C. %>5 $' !#

( % G. $#%- G. $#%- G. $#%- G. $#%- G- $ 5 ,< ( .%! ( / "#% ; ( @ %!, ($%$%% 3 !#%5 (% 3 !

#%5 '.%"5 (9 ?$5 !(<55 ' %!#$"5 (9 !I , ($%%% 3 !#%5 ( , ($% 5.95% 3 !#%5 '.5 $%' %"5 (9 ?

$5 !( , ($%<55 $' %!#$"5 (9 !"

' $.33% !.%! (/ "#%;(,(7#! !

(35 7#! %" # ($5 $."5, ($%"

' (# ! 8%9<#5 5 "".$ ! 8( !0

"#%9 8< 7 ()#%$

( "".$ !<55 ' % !#$"5 (9 ! #$ "%" (% ! 5 ( C.#( 3 % I/ "#%$

%! ; ( 5 $ '

"3,8# ! <#5 '

( 5 "

% ' $.33% !

( $5 5 3 ($ ' ,8 " ! '

( 5

,,(,(# %"5 ( #% 8!#$,$ 8#% ""(!

<#58 < @,8 #% !5 ( #% '7 F ($ ".#%$(0#%'(# #$5 % ;

) "3,8 #% %)5#$.%"8 3, %!".$#%'(5 ( ( $5 < (

"6 !'0, ##% (* %#%! (+* %! ,+*%#) /.%#8)#8 6 %! , 65 "".$ !< ( (3 !<#5(% (!$ %! 5 ! #% 8#" ! #%D.(# $ % 5 , ($% 3, 8 3, 8 $ < 88 $ ( $5 %! 5 "3,8 #% % $.

( !

#%D.(# $3, 8)5< 7 ()$."".3' !5#$#%D.(# $ 85.95) , ##% ( < $ .%! #%%" % !.(#%9 #%)'.!.(#%9(# 8)"3,8 #% %$ !5 5

, ##% ( 5 ! #% 8#" ! #(% (! '8<$ % 5 , ($%

3, 8 5.$) 5 ( < $ %.95 3 8 #8 '8 % ( "(! $.33% 5 , ##% (

" 5 (# 8 $

"".$ ! 9(.%! (#% ( ( %" '05#$.()#$3 .

#$3#$$ ! =/> =/> =/> =/> "' ( )

"' ( )

7#(