Harbhajan Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab
!
"
"
#
$%
& '()
$
&
' (*' "
$*"
+ "$ '()
---- ("
. ,/*
0
"1 . !
0&#/' ,,
& 2%34
566
6' '
' ' 4' 4' 7% '
.
,
'*" #".
/( , 8"
*" #"'.
) " &
4 9"
& 7 ,/
'
# # /
*" "
2 "
" &&" /'
),,
.
8
'
&
2 &+
)7
,
),,
/
3
':
, *" #"
"&
&#,
566
"#
, #"
&
" + , $ , "
),,
8
' .
", )
# ;
.
"
',
,
&+
)7
/
3
;
# .
&
" 5 + , 4 $ ,
) 1
3 < 5566;
&#,
)
,
&# /
"
7 , , .$ $ ,
#
,
/
)
.
,# & ;
566' ,
#
)
/
'* '
&# (
.
,#& ;
7 ,
'",
,#
&
) #;
#
,
),,
.
,,
/
& &
1 "
;
), #"
# '.
"
66
# )" / ( 8" #"(2%.
=&#,
)
' # "
6'
.
% .
" 9"
,/ "
7' ' 4' 4 % .
, &#, *"
, #)
&#,
'*
' ) 7 ,
6' ' ' 6% >
' #
(
7 ,
),,
8
!
65'&#, ," .
#,
,, =#
,,
" ( , 8"
#"# "& , "#
,, .
"##,
#) "
>
( , 8" , $
' *" #"
"
6
.
% .
,
'
' .
'
/#,
", / , & ,:
?
)
# : & ",
'
#
?
& & / ) . ' ,/'( %
+"& @'
"# @' @'*".
1 @
$ $ @5 :
'
# ) , /"
.
"
'.
,,
&
"&
&.
#"
&"
/
,,
", )
;
/
, ,/),)
("
) >
, $
&",
,,. #
&
AB @
566
&#, .
#
&
" + , $ , ," ," +
3 <
),,
AB@
"
&&
#
, C AB@
,/ &)
#
A)B," (
"& ',
9"
&
#/
" & #,
, '
,
,'.
# /,
(
8" A( B'2 : 1 " #") " &
) % .
,,
,
, " ,#
'
&
&
/
& , @
"
#"
,,
&&
/
' ,#
AB
,,.
5
'
&
/#)
:
" " , ?# #.
"
## ,/ &
#
.", ## 1
," .
, " ,#
,/
)
"#
#& &&
/
& ( ,/'
#
) /, ,
/
5'
,"
#
&
.
.&
&
# #/
' # ",
,
, " : ," ' , .
#/
'
"
,,
& :
, /
,"
##
" /.
/,
)#
' .
"
# D
#"
"
" ,:
,
"
" , %
,
" ,
%
)#
& # /,
( ,
8" A( B'2 : 1" #"
4 "
, >
" ,
)#
"
#
" ' /' ", &
"
"
(
8" A( B' 2 : 1 " ' *" #" /
)
& ,
'
1
'.
" ,,
.&/
4 '.
/ #"
!" #
$
%
&
%
$ & %
'"( $ &
%
) "
"
&
* +& $
&
&
, &
"
' .
E, (# ? " .
,
, .
#
)
.
) &&
E(E "
)
)
&&
E7E.
"
# '
.,, #
" ", ," '"
.,, #" ,"
.
"
"
/
! "#'.
E, (# ?"
)
"
,,
& ,/
"
.
) ",
#
" >
" ,
"
$ %
&
'% ( ) #*"*' .
.
)
)
,,
) ,,/
"
& ", /&&
'",
"
&
,"
,' 9"
' ,"
(
" ,
"
'%
#
, ) '
# . .
?
&
,
'
.
'
.
) ## " /
,
)
"& '
9"
,
:
, &
/ ) && #
" ,"
&, ,/'
#
,/ & "#.
" #,
3 #
" .
# /&
:
") .
#)
4
/ ,
" ,
) #
) ' & "
:
&#" # /(
8" A( B'2 : 1" #"
7"
,, /
& '
9"
,/'
) #
,,.
& :
",
,
,/#, '# ,/.
. &
&
# #/
:
," 4 7
!"#$ %&"'
!()$* "&#
'# !+,
"&#