High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1779/2025dismissed

Neetu Kanwar @ Nitu Singh v. Bhim Singh And Others

2025-12-02Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal8 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()**

) +,

* -.

!" # 000 -.

/,1* $ ##% #

& "

'( () '('* +,- # .

"/ 01 # +,2 ## &"

)3 )) '()4 +,- # - !

6 + !

" # " # +, ## '

0 #"! " + #

$ ##5 6 #/

5# )6/

)7 )33(

$ # +,

5+ # /

6 + # # ,

!+ /

$ ## # " ##" "

)7 )33(+,- # +2/ ' - 01 !

"# )5

6 " + #

:'5#,"

6 !# $ + .

"01 5 # #

8 2!'3& 4($%6

! !

++ +,# +

# ## -; # # &" # )# # #

"# # ##!

< !

7( (9 '(() !

+ ## # '>7

)7 (:

'((?

.# ) + "! # + "

)7 )33( "

" ++ +,# < !

# )"" # # , "!+

! < !

## < !

! ," - # ,

< !

" A " " , ,

$ +, # ) <

" ,+&" < !

### "# + !

5# '6 B 5# 76 !

# < !

, +

C ,+&" + , "#" "

< !

# "

+ /

# "

- +

" "

)7 )33( "/

, ## "

; #! ## ) "" , +,- # - !

! 6 +

) # "

5 + # ##6 "

- !

- + " "

; < # '>7 ##

$ # # '>7# " ## # ' "

" $ ('

(7 '()*+,- #- !

/5/

! 6 +

< !

"" # +, ## !+ !," C

< " !

$#"# ## !,

+ " !,, #

# # # 5* /2! 2!6 2!74&( &##&'!( & 4!$#"6$!%46 &"( '768!$#"69

* /2! 2!6 2!74&( &##&'!( & 4!$#"67!6:(!( &(;3(% &"('768!$#"69

<* /2! 2!6 2! '3& "# 2! 74&( &## &' (" :&( &(=4!&(& '76!'!( #"6:9 >* /2! 2!6 2!74&( &##2'("%3'!"#% &"(($ 4"%3'' ($& "#&4! 2!76!'!( '3& 9 * /2! 2!6 2!74&( &##&'!' "77!$=82&'"?(% ($%"($3% #6":#&4&(@ 2!76!'!( '3& 9 A*

!4&!#*B

" !!

)(

- # +, ##!

)3 )) '()4 #

" +,- # .

" / 01 !

'( () '('* # #

))

<! "#

D " + + -

# +, ## #" ##++ !"

; + + +,#

* )7

<!" + +, "#

+# +! #

-", "

" )7 )33( +, ## ') (* '()?

# '?, # #"

! = ! # $- #

, +

" &"

+# " ## ,

<# /

# ! # ,+

B "

"" $ #

# " - " # $# " +,#

5* -!68 =6&!#481 2! # 2!6 "# 2! 77!44( ($ 6!'7"($!( '"* <(:!48&C6(&&(@2?'%" "?(!6 &( 7"''!''&"( "# 4($ '& 3 !$ &( D&44@! :6736* &C6(& &(@2 !E7&6!$ "( <*>* 4!D&(@=!2&($77!44( ($6!'7"($!( '"* <'

2&'4!@42!&6'* (!" 2!64!@42!&6237&($!6&(@2 2'46!$8!E7&6!$*2!@63$@!"# 2!77!44( &' 2 6!'7"($!( "*?& 2:4#&$!&( !( &"( "@6= 2!76"7!6 8"#&C6(&&(@22'"= &(!$$!%6!! "(<**7''!$&( 2!'3& & 4!$'2&:&(@2 D!6'3'&C6(&&(@2?2&%2&'6!'34 "##63$*2! 6&4"36 # !62!6&(@ 2!: !61$&':&''!$ 2!'3& "# 2!77!44( *2!77!44( 2'%244!(@!$ 2!'&$

&:73@(!$ ;3$@:!( ='&%448 "( 2! @6"3($ 2 =!#"6!7''&(@ 2!&:73@(!$;3$@:!( 1 2! 6&4%"36 ?'6!F3&6!$ "%"('&$!6 2!76"D&'&"("# !@&' 6 &"( % 1 :7% ($6('#!6"# 6"7!6 8% * 2'

=!!( #36 2!6 74!$!$ 2 6!'7"($!( "* 2' (" %"(%!6(?& 2 2!'3& 4($($("#:&48'! 4!:!( 2'!D!6 C!(74%!=! ?!!(6!'7"($!( "*($ $!%!'!$&C6(&&(@2*2!'&@( 36!'"#&C6(& &(@2 ?!6! "= &(!$ =8 6!'7"($!( "* "( 2! 76! !E "#:"D&(@'":!774&% &"( "%(43 2"6& 8 "(=4(C77!6'*!& 2!6&C6(&&(@2!(@@!$(8 %"3('!4 ("6 77!6!$ &( (8 "36 ("6 #&4!$ (8 ?6& !( ' !:!( * 36 2!61 2! 4($ &( F3!' &"( &'

;"&( 1(%!' 64($%"76%!(6876"7!6 8($=!&(@ %"76%!(!61 2!77!44( 2'76!!E&' &(@6&@2 &( 2! '3& 4($* ?'#36 2!6D!66!$ 2 2!77!44( ($6!'7"($!( '"* <6!&(7"''!''&"("# 2!'3& 4($($''3%21 2!77!4&'4&=4! "=!44"?!$=8 '! &(@'&$! 2!&:73@(!$;3$@:!( ' 2!#&($&(@'"# 2! 6&4 "36 "( 44 2! &''3!' #D"36&(@ 2! 6!'7"($!( "*6!!66"(!"3'($''3%26!(" '3' &(=4!* ( 2!" 2!62($1 2!6!'7"($!( "* :&(48%"( !' $ 2!77!4'?!44' 2!'3& &( 2! 6&4%"36 ?2&4!" 2!66!'7"($!( '"* <$:& !$ 2!'3& "# 2!77!44( 74&( &##&( 2! 6&4"36 & '!4#* "?1 2! 7!63'4 "# 2! ' ($ C!( =8 6!'7"($!( "* &' " 2! !##!% 2 "( 2! #&6' &(' (%! 2!'3& #&4!$=8 2!77!44( ?' &:!=66!$ ($ #36 2!

6 & &' 4'" '3##!6&(@ #6": $"% 6&(! "# 6!';3$&% ($ ?' (" :&( &(=4!* D!( 2! @6"3($"#4"%3'' ($&"# 2!77!44( "#&4! 2!'3& ?'4'"F3!' &"(!$*2!6!'7"($!( "*D!2!:!( 48 74!$!$ 2 2!77!44( %"(%!4!$ 2!: !

#6": 2! "36 * 2! # 2!6 "# 77!44( (:!48 &C6(& &(@21 2&: &(@2 6!'7"($!( "* ($ 'C6(&(@2?!6! 26!!=6" 2!6'*" 2&C6(& &(@2($'C6(&(@22D!$&!$*2!'3& 4($ %:! " 2! '26! "# 2&: &(@2 &( 2! #:&48 '! 4!:!( ($''3%21&C6(&&(@2'3##!6!$ 2! %"443'&D!$!%6!!&(2&'#D"36*'3& ?'4 !6"(#&4!$ =8'C6(&(@2 ="26%244!(@&(@ 2!$!%6!! $ !$ <** &( ?2&%2 &C6(& &(@2 ?' &:74!$!$'76 8=3 1 2!'&$'3& ?'$&':&''!$ =8 2! 2!($$& &"(4&D&43$@!!(&"6&D&'&"( ="26* @&(1 237&($!6 &(@2 !4$!6 =6" 2!6 "# 77!44( '&(%!$!%!'!$ #&4!$%&D&4'3& ="26 @&(' 2! 6!'7"($!( %244!(@&(@ 2! $!%6!! &( F3!' &"( ?2&%2 ?' 4'" $&':&''!$* 2!6!# !61 6!'7"($!( '"* <@&(#&4!$%&D&4'3& @&('

6!'7"($!( &( ?2&%2 77!44( ?' &:74!$!$ ' 6!'7"($!( "*%244!(@&(@ 2!$!%6!!&(F3!' &"( ($ 2!'&$'3& ?'@&($&':&''!$=8&D&43$@! 3(&"6&D&'&"( 1="26"(*<** 23'776!( 48 2!77!44( $&$(" 776"%2 2! 6&4"36 ?& 2%4!(2($'($%"(%!4!$ 2!D!68 : !6&4#% ':!( &"(!$="D!* 77!6' 2 (" "(48 77!44( =3 6!'7"($!( ' "* < 4'" 6!

:C&(@ 2! :"%C!68 "# 2! 3$&%&4 8' !: =8 =6&(@&(@ 2!'3& '%244!(@&(@ 2!$!%6!!&(F3!' &"( 7''!$8!6'@"@&(($@&(* 36 2!61(" 2&(@ 2' =!!( 76"D!$ "( 6!%"6$ 2 2! 76"7!6 8 &( F3!' &"(?'(%!' 64&(( 36!* 36 2!6("!E%!67 2' =!!( 76"$3%!$ "( 6!%"6$ " '2"? 2 2! 76"7!6 8&(F3!' &"(?'(%!' 64&(( 36!*" 2&(@ 2' =!!( 74%!$ "( 6!%"6$ " 76"D! (8 :&'6!76!'!( &"( $"(! =8 6!'7"($!( "* #"6

@! &(@ 2! $!%6!! &( F3!' &"(* 2! D4&$& 8 "# 2! $!%6!!&(F3!' &"(2'=!!(46!$8372!4$ D6&"3' &:!'=8D6&"3'"36 '*D!( 2!'3& #&4!$=8 2! 77!44( &( 2! 6&4 "36 ?' &:! =66!$1 (" :&( &(=4!($#36 2!6?& 2"3 2D&(@(84"%3' ' ($&"# 2!77!44( "#&4! 2!':!* "6!"D!61 2!

$!%6!!&(F3!' &"(&'(" !D!(4&=4! "=!'! '&$!"( 2!@6"3($' C!(=8 2!77!44( 2 2!76"D&'&"(' "# !@&' 6 &"( % 1 :7 % ($ 6('#!6 "#

6"7!6 8% ! %*12D!(" =!!(#"44"?!$*23'1 2! #&($&(@'"# 2! 6&4%"36 "(&''3!' "* "<6! %"66!% ($(!!$("&( !6#!6!(%!* 36 2!6 2!#&($&(@'

"# 2! 6&4%"36 "(&''3!'"*> $!%&$!$@&('

2! 77!44( 6! 4'" %"66!% ($ 6! '3' &(!$ %%"6$&(@48*B )?

D "# ++ , , # # , #!

"+, #-

# " "

$+ #++ ##

"" , )4

" 56 #, # -.

!%!:=!61 & F A

GA F +