High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5608/2019dismissed

Vikas Gour And Another v. Naval Kishore And Others

2020-09-02Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih12 pages

#$% &'

(%)*+*&,- ! !

!!! / .

!" # #

$ %!"

&' ( $ " #

* $ + &'

( $ ,

%-" # #

." # !" /" + 0 ! 12 ** 31*& $# " " " # ." # $ "

) 4 -.4" * *$

# $ " &156" ) 7377 3* +! # 8 ** 1* *9':

(" $ $ "

$ 6") 7377 3* +! * *; ""$ $# # # + " ! ." 1:

31*9 < "

" # $ # !" #$$ "

$ 8 8 6

" 8 ;"

-. 4" "

* * )4 ** 1* *9':$ 8$"#=" 8$# ;"

# " 3'

3112 " " " =" $ # 2' < > # " 8 3'

3112 "

; $ 8 #" "#=" 8 $ # ;"

-. 4" $ " $" " < # "#

# " $ # 8 3112 $ $ 8$ # %$ "# $ $ -.4" " %$ ;"

"#=" 8 3112 " %!" #$ * *$

" 4" #"

# /0 ;"

8 3'

3112 " %8# #" "" " $#"

$ #$$

" "#=" 8 3'

3112 8 ** 1* *9': ;"

" * * #"

$" "#=" 8 % !" #$ # $ ." # #$ #$ < " " " ." !" 1*,2#3# *,21 #+*4 .#53 $13&521 /+ .#3#67*$ .#53 #,( &$1%3+8 31*& /70 ? &'9

&2*,(%3 #9 1#36# #,( &$1%3+ *,&( .56#3 1#36# #,( &$1%3+ 3119/*10-!-/!0:&353(*$$# #9

%#( $13&521 /+ %%3

1#,831*7/&0-!-/!037&#34#,+ *,21 #,( &$1%3+ %36#, *,21

%#( $13&521 1*+ /+ #,( &$1%3+31**/&0-!-/!0@99 .#36* :(;&

#* 1#,( *$#9 #,( #,&$1%331*&/30-!-/!027 :

< "# # " $ " ." $ #"

# & % $ "

6" ) 7377 3* +! # ! 6 *972"

$$ $ # ? $ 3

*9:3 # ? 3 ! A $ $"

*9:2 %$ A# ! $ -.4"$ " %! " ? 3

) 3$ $" + B" .B"

) *

) 3

! 19 *1 *9@' # $

-.4" " ? -.4" ? " ? ! %?

) 3 " $ " ! $ "

% " $ # "# " < ! ! ." 1& *9'1/>;

+'0 %." $ #

-.4"# $$# "# "$ $." 1& *9'*/>;

*C>;

+90 < ""

? # " ! "

% 6") 7377 3* +! " "

$ ? /" 0 $

-.4"/ $ ! 0 % "

-.4" "

$;"

8 3112/>;

0 #=" "

" < # 8 " # )4

*$$" "

D % !

%" $ # ) *

" ?

-.4"# "

8=" "

)4 ** 1* *9':/>;

+@0 6"

# #"

$ "

@ E # $# #

#$ " 8 />;

0# ;"

""" " $ # # "

8 % #$ # " " $ "#=" 8 3112# " % "# 8 ** 1* *9':$ 8 " # # * % # $ # #$ '

% # "

$ " #" "#="

8" $" #" # 8" "" $ """ % ." $ # # " #" " $!" " $ "

" 8$$" $ $

< # < # 8 #

#" ;"

$ $ " # < " " !" $ $ " $ 8 " "" " ;"

8 < """ "" 8 # # " $ 8# " % # $ " %!" #$ " "" " ;"

8 3112/>;

0 ** 1* *9':/>;

+@0 " "" " "" ;"

"#=" 8 3112#

%!" #$ " # !" /#=14*3 *,21 *,(%3 *,21 *99&/*0!!" !21:/F60." " !" #6 *#3* 1#2:#,$ #,( &$1%3+*991!!" ! 7@1/!0 % " $ $ " $ " 8 3112/>;

0$# " # # ""

*& ." # ?$ !"

G*&

* " 8 ** * *9': # "

# "

-.4" " %" $ " $$"" "

" $ 8 3112/>;

0 "# " # < $ " " 8 3'

3112" # "

$ ? / 30 ?

-.4" > ED%! 3& 311@ />;

+*0 &15 #

-.4" " #

-.4" % >;

+3 # 6$ *

+ B" @ 311@# > E 3&5#

-.4" " # " 8 311@ " "8 6

"8# ; ) *$"

-.4" /0 %

-. 4" $

? #" ! $

? /

) 30" #

$ " $ $ ." & *9'1 # ."

-.4" $ % ##

-. 4" $

? #" $ $"#=" "

" 8 /0

" " # $ / 30 #

;

" # " " /0

* /8*0 $#

8 < $#

8 ;"

-. 4" $ " # "

"8;"

# " *# 8$" /0

$ 8 3'

3112 4"

# 3& 311@>;

+7$ $" # 3# > E

-.4"

# 8 3112$ ; $ 4"

$ 8

-.4" /0

$ 8 3'

3112 $

$ ; # ) * >;

+87 " - .

4"/+870) + !" ! $# $

$ 8 $ =" -+"

B" / 0

-.4" 8 -+"

$ #"

8 " /0

8$"

# $ #" "

";"

-. 4" $ " $ ; "

"" #"

% "" # " ; " $ 8 "" # """ $=" ;"

8"# " < ," 3119/*0- !

- /!0'32 6 H#;!" $ 8 " " # # $ " #

!" H " 8

""" 8$" ;"

# $ ; """ " 8" # < "

" 8

" 6 """ I *1 %?$ !" " *2 " $# #

* )4$ !" #" $ ** %." # #$# $ $ # !"

< # " # #$ # =" $$ =" !" *7 < $ # #

%>$%64%3 8

J) 8 - # J)