Parminder Singh v. State Of Punjab




   
      ! "# $

&' ()*

+- ./ 0  1+2 - 34 5  

&' ()* ./ 0  1+2 - 34 5   )

 89)  -
:

9
-


+  ;

)+ ) 5:2/<=0=++0  4//  ) ) <7= 34 )+  3/1+,=0=+,57  >//+/ 5++77 ?55+,@477? /32., A "

4+++/ 5+++  >//+/32., /274+5+ /.A ; ;

; ;

:

9
-
  /++?775

&=7

./1+2- 34

&=7 73 ./1+2- 34=+ .2/,32.,  /  5+2  =  ?//    4    /  ,    7? +:2+=?2+,- ./=/ % " "##&=7? ,5   4@  /+  /24   2+,  - ./  ?  . .    /+  7 2+,- ./55//5 /7 7? +:2+?  77/ 
?42B

B ) >/ 7? +:2++/ +/

;"; ,+ 73 ./  '2*=  73 + - ./ '2* 42 7? +:2+  >/ 7? +:2+++ /,+, .= ./? //2 +/,+ 4+2./?+  .047??+/+ >/  ++0/+7=7? +/+7/ =/?+//7/ /2,47? ',57 *  ./ 7? ./=?/ 5/? ./=.0 . 47? /7+,7?

+</:2+=?7? ./=.0<<47? /4,  7? +:2+  +:2+? ./.047?

/ /    ,57    7? + :2+  ',57 *  +  7+,= ?//+-2/- ./=+ 177.- )3+=?/, /5 +2/,57  7? /2++ 2+,- ./+,0 7? +:2+0757=:2+7  / ,0+/+,?//?73 .//. /+ 5+ 7/2 73 +- ./225//, /? ?  5      4@  /  ,57    /++=  /@  <  / ,57  

 +0 .?+7 , +,  7- :2+7 42,  32+7? +:2+ 0757=:2+7=-
4- ./ 7- )277 52+=00757=:2+7=  ++/,  32+'C > (* , +, 

#B) B " "##&/+,/)9 = .

D47 , 2+ /++=/? 4</57  ++

'C * "

B B " "##& -  / 32+?2 4 .+02 2+=/++=  ## %?+.+ "# " "##& +- "B
+?/- %
 7- :2+7

;;

. 77/2+2 +/ 0. =/77 ?5+  /2+  / +72+/+./77/2+22 + - "B="%="
+?/- %
24 /+=,57 7? +:2+/+7 55+ >  C, /+/24 2+,- ./'

>"* ? /@? = ,7@=-2/- ./'

>*  ./'

>%*?+ 7C, =?/2+ /7 + ) </?C,  >!

 / 0. .+ +,7?   >/ C, 2 +- +  =257 //@+

  /@/0 ,, @  /04

77@,57 / /2 7 @   /7+  7/27).+= .+= 0  32.,      0     $

"# B=   0  77  /  2+ 2= ,7@=73 ./=  ./=  +</:2+   + :2+2 +- "B="
+?/- %
    /,=0++  $

"# B=2 + ;

, 0

( - 

./ "B
2 +.
+5+ @+ 5@   B##(; 
27 5@,  2+/+2 +.

+ B@

73 ./ "B+ ?   2 +.
+5+ @+ "  +</:2+ %
/ 5@   B##(;/   275@,  2+/+ +.
+ B@/

+</:2+ "
 2 +.
+5+C "  , //

73 ./ "+ ?  2 +.
+5+C "  ./ %
, // 77/  ?+++2  2++ 7@  77/+ 05+++5574+/- 

;%;

2+= .+=?/=032.,  " $ "# &=25/7/32.,   0 /+72+ -+/  5+/32.,   + =/7+ - 2.= .+=+7 +</:2+  +:2+ 5+4

+/2+=73 ./  .//0 5+++  5+  +0 =  ?//  ?77  4  5    4@  /   .7 32., 
/0/+/7+ 2 7++0 =/7+  -2 7=/7+ 2 7+,57  /07+277@ . /+2.//7 /7?+2+87?77 >/755+ . /2+=7? +:2+/++/+ , ,4+/57 >/75 .=//?/ /+ /24 2+,- .//55/5 //. 77/= ./+42 ./+ >/ /++ /,+, .

=/<2?++,//2 .0?+47?=?//7  /+7/ /2,4  ./.0 ( .47? 7 +, -/7+5/+7+42 +</:2+  -+ >-2/- ./'@? *   + =/ 2+ /7  255+/5+2   /+@?   ./'

>%*72+ /7 ?7/, @2+, - ./=/24 ,57 =?/?,  /5= //?/2++ +,//5 ,. +7,  //??4 254@77/2+2?/2577@ +42 ./ 0+@ 32+@=4@/? 2+ ./+ C,  =///+0+?//,-++@= 34= 7@,/, ,// .+7 /

;B;

,57 73 ./'2* 2+/+,/:2+7          B  <7,+  +,  /  /2=  ?/+  )277 52+ 0+ ,   /57  '.    5 +@*             % <7,++,//2  
 6<7,+ 
7 +@ 2,+/ 32+ 4@/ +=?//++5+22 + ;

E
32+ +07 +7+ 55CB,C# B,< 5 / ++7/ /2,4+/47 .5+  "

( 5  /7++, 2?77 .55C 6 #,C  %, 5++7++, 0 F;

@C, ( 5 7?+4,  32+@,+<(?77 .

% ( 5  /4<+.  32+@,+<( ?77 .

 5+/)9 =/  32+/++0/ /57

% " "##&& B# )=?/+/2++ /0< 57 +2 B

B ) /, + ) </'

>!*7,+7 32+@ /7 ++, +7.7C,  ?2 4 +2+-/ =0+5+ $ " "##&'C >!(* = /++=.+02 2+  /+ 32+  %?+2 4 ,57 2+ 5+/)9 'C >!(*=/< ?5 2?  /+/547@ 32+@  = % 4 .

2?/+ 7@/ 

4+272  ?=/, 7? +:2+/?/73 + - .//0.0 /47??+=?//7  /+7 / /2,4 ?0+=/++5  . 32+@+07 +7+

;&;

55+C B,C# B,< 5 
32+@  /04

2?/472 ?5  
   ?2   /++=/ , ,57 /?2?/?+(<+5 47?

++4+4@,70    //2+47?7 55+//+7+4273 +- ./ 255+4@ ,70 :5 .    0?  /  4<.+2   /    /  ,    +- ./=?7+@. . ?/2+,- ./=/24  ,57 =/547@7,57 73 ./

 4+2725+27+7@?/ /+7+42/, 255+4@ ,70   /++=/+0 73 ./747 5  ?=, ./2 ./=, 2//77./0.0  .( 47? /7+, ,57 =?//++5  32+@ "=?//?2 4 +2+=0+5+ $ " "##&'C >!(* -2/ 32+@

4 72+  /++=/+7+42 ./27@ 255+4@,70   / 7+ 2 7++0 /+.2//+?  + 7@ ++ ./
,/0?//2++ 77./0<

57  +2  B

B )  +/ 2++ =/,57 ? ,,7@+,0/57  B<7,+  :2+7 0757 ++0/+& B# ) ?,,7@C,  4@/+ +, ?7++4@/57 / C ,+ .++0 . , +,//57 /++=/7@=

;$;

 @= +/ .//57 /5+57   /5+ /,57   4  4.0 2 ./

/2  /+, .?2= ,7@= +</:2+  + :2+/07+@4 +7 5+4 /@/0 7 @ +0 /++=/2+?77++ 7+,2 ./++7 /2++   /,+/?/@? = ,7@= -2/- ./'

>*  ./'

>%*/2+ /7= .+2    470  /  5+2     .   2  +  - ./= 5+27+7@?/ / 32+@ +42/, 72+ + 2?/+ 7@/  /+? ,@4? /5+=?// 27@5+0  +27/+. .2 =
,/0?/ / 32+@+4273 ./'+0 * 255+4@ ,70  /++=73 ./.0 4 24  /   H2//+.+,. /,  /++=+0

'

&*=74@73 ./77? 
   @,+ /+0 =74@ ./ + .7@=+0

H2 ./'

&* ,    '

+ - ./* 4  +;++     ,,    37    2 +.  / +, .5+  ':

9
-
*  

 ! "# $ 3< >//+5< .(+   >//+ 5+47