High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5683/2005allowed

Mamta v. Karnail Singh And ORS.

2016-06-02Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih9 pages

"#"

$% &'%

!"# $%&'( #&% (# )%*'

( # " )&*'+ ,'

""-)&*'+ ,'

% "#% .)&*'+ ,'

'/ '&% &% ")&*'+ ,'

0 &+,-,)+./$ %" " ,"& 12 +" 3 $"

- & && /454/446 & 12 ''

++"& " ) 1 -% 12 % ""'

#+"'

577 ', % ''

%"+ + ."

+' ,'

" ,, &12% ''

++"& -"%+ 1 $" ' 39:345:9 ; " < ; ,

& ' =%',, $*%"+><)-&""& / " &+ "1& % "

+"& "

/9 ', % ""'

,''-(3

! " # $!

% & '( #()* *)

# + ! ," - ! + ," .

+- ! -

/0& )

1 #%0 /0& ,+1

! ! #()* *) - - ! - - #()* *) ! - - 2 0

' / '- ', % ',, $ *%"+ & "& % &+'

& &+'

'* &%* &"

%""'

'-* )%&&%%',, $*%"+-"

&-"% "

+' 2?&" '0) +%)"1""2)", 2)"',

+' 2'2%+' '5"& ', %',, $*%"+&"& ' '+'

%""'

+ ' 2 ?& "

" - " ' & "& % ++"& & 1& % '

2 3,'

% 12 +" +'

+'+&'

-$&%%++"& -+ &12 ' "& ","& *%"+ & ', ) % &"$ % *%"+ - &+ "1& -$' &&'

4945/4401' 4756)

""+"

$ % ',, $ *%"+ % * $ $ ++"& '

& "

- '"*& & , %' $%) 3,'

% "

"* + -"% ' 5 & / -"% &"$ ' $ % +' -, % &&%%*%"+"

*'*&"

$& -1"

$& 12 -"%' %'&"

$ ,,+"* &*"& & "*"

$ "+ + & % - *"'"'

', & +'

&""'

', %

+'"+2%'% * ',+" - '+'

&) '* & && "& 6

$', "&', "

$',%" ,''-(3 ;"< @%% %++"& "

A "'

''.+& ' % $"$ & "*"

$',+ 1 $" ' 3 9:345:9 12 !

" #"

$% ' 5 + "

"'+" B

;""< , " ' 5 " '*& "

% ,,"

"*) -%% +" " "& ' +' ,'

% "

" "

%++"& ,')'-%'

&, ' -%'B

;"""< @%%

++' 2" '"1,'

2 ', +' *"-',% ""

2'18+"'

. %- " B

30 9

", 7 % '1 *& % % ',, $ *%"+ - ,2 *'*&"

%"+"-"

&-"% '0 &&"+ && %',+" %++"& -+ &12%',, $*%"+ &""&%""'

C ?

& +'

% % $ & % +" 1'

$'''

', '+"2 & - -'

$ % * "

"& * , %++"& )%-%",&'%'"12

'5 &% , )% -2, '%'% &',%'" -"%%'"+- " &#%%& ' "2-"%& '- ',%',, $*%"+'',2""+%%'"+" *"$"'

', % + $" & *"& ' C && 4945/440 %& ,'

' 53!

" #"

$% $ "2 & & % +% $"

%""'*"& %%*%"+"

A "'

-. ' '"'

12%'"+ &$'+% "+2D"

//45/440 - ,'

& "

&$& +'

&""'

1 - + +.) , "& %&"$% &"

&"+'

- 1 '. ), "

$-'1 '. % -& '

"-%"+%%'-%%"*%"+%&-"% ++"& &"" '-% %+', %%"*%"+%&-"%' '% ++"& %

+' 2%&'"

& *"$'

+&%" '

;D <'

,"-% "

*"$'

% '

&% '- ',%',, $*%"++'

&%++"& 1 &%& !

" #"

$% , %" 8'1 %" %'- % * ', % ++"& $"* 12 +" " +'

+ & % % - $2 &"+ && % : ?

&+'

'0% $ &%+" %+'3,'

- &-"%%* %%"',++"& % '% 3- - ' % & %& ++' "& +" ' "*" '") 1"21 "

% &',%'" &%"',% &"+ D"

)"" "'

&%"

&- +"' &1 ' $%12 ' .

'- %&"+% $"" &12 )% &"$ %)"" "'

2',%+%" -%", '1%"

&12) -%"+% %'- % % ++"& %& ' . + -"% % ',, *%"+-'

4945/440% ;D <- $" &-% "

%',, $*%"+-"

*'*&,'

%,"

"%"%'-%% ',, $*%"+- &"

'$+' %"

*"$'

&12%

+' 2+$'

"+2&%%',, *%"+1 $' 39:345:9%1 &"

%"+ '

" '1 &-%' '"

E % *" A "'

-%"+% " ,'

"& " ' -%% %',, $*%"+-"

*'*&"

%++"& B 54 " %& D"

& & *") % '% 3"

3-)

@35)-%'%&%%',, $*%"++, '1%"

& &%" % +" % & % , '& % + & ''. % & % & $% 3"

3-'"*"'"" - +"' &%- .& ' 1 $ &"+"

% -%") ' 5 ,& -2 , '%'"D&2)+" -%",&' )% &"$ %-'

4945/440% - $" &12%'"+" % , & @3/ &&%%-%"12+ , '1%"

&-% %-$'"

, '1"2'% %' 55

* &'+ '

& " "

*"$"'

<) '& +&12

+' 2-% "

*"$'

&12 "%&%-% %*""& &"'1"

&$ % &'- ',% ',, $*%"+)%"

&%!

"#"

$%3 '5%, %" *"+1 +'

&%++"& -"

',% '

% % "& ' "

&"+ -"%' 2 1" % % ',, $ *%"+ % 1 &% '

%'-%'- ',%',, $*%"+%+'

+&& 1,'

*"$'

%%++"& %&. +%",+", %

'1'

&12+% "+ '

;D <',%',, $*%"+% '"+ %& . % ',, $ *%"+ "

' '"'

& % $' " +% "+2D"

//45/440 &,'

&1 ),"&%&"$%

&"+'

), "

$1 '. && '

%1'

" '-% % + ', ' / & 0 % % *%"+ - "

*'*& "

2 '% ++"& %+'

&""'

',*%"+,'

% '

',+% "+ ;D < + 2 "

&"+ % " %& -"% ++"& % %"

+ +' '

%+'

',+" "% '5 & ',%',, $*%"+% "% &-" ,"& 2 - " ' 1 %* ',+" 5/ &"&2)"

% '

&"*"'")1)" " "'

&%%"

&-1 ' $%12' .

'- ',%"

&- ' "'

&%- +"' %&"+% $ "-%"$"*"

$%1 ", 2)"" "'

&%%"

&-%" , ' 1%"

& 12 % % ,+ "

$$ % % ',, $*%"+%1 &"

%"+%*"& + '& +&12 +" ' '* % ++"& " ' ' 1 & & + "

"F& "

""+ "

"F&"

+ ""

+"+',+" %%- . '%'"12 '5%","

%"+ " 1'

$' ''

','+"2 &%'"1""2%-&'% % %+)+

'1 &' *"-',%+"

+ +%%*+' &)""2 '*&%%',, $*%"+-"

*'*&"

% & '- ', % ',, $ *%"+ &"& % %" & -

'53!

"#"

$% 50 *"-',1'*)% %+'"&$ *

-%" &"""

$ %+" ""'

-"% %'1 *"'

% % ++"& " ' '*&'%*1 + &12%',, $*%"+ &%"*%"+- & $%,"

$', '%",,+""& ,"

" '5 * & &&$"

'5 &/ &"

,*'

',+"

(&&%#& 59 % % ' && 2,"

" '/ &0 -"%%'1 *"'

%%" %*1+' & & 1 *"'

',% +'

2'$ ''""'

* , +%"

$% + "'

-%"&+"&"

$ " '5%%',, $ *%"+%1 ,2""+&"

%"+)% - A "

&' &,"

$ " '/ &0'-* )."

*"-%,+%%"55 2 '&)"

&', $%+'

%"%'

$ &)%*. " + ',

& +'

" -"% $ & ' A ', +' ' -%"+% +" " "& & "1""2 ',

+ ' 2'2'

',+' 56

' % &"+% $ 2 ;D 30<) " " *"& % +" "

& &"& "

) % &"$ % , ' 4945/440 ' 4E4//440

'%%-&"&"

"*"'")1%" %'-%% "

&&"&"

%'",'

94&2 57 ?

& +'

% % $ & % 1" ', /9)/94G3 '

) &"+"

) %* 1 +& '

& %' $%) % " ' + ","+ ', &"1""2 ,, & 12 +" 1 % &"+ '

;D 3/< %'- % +" - +"' , % - , + "

"',%"$% &'% ',1'&2@%" &"+% $"

$, '%'")%-&*"&'.&"+"

&'+' ,'

*"-',% "@%" $ @3/)+" %&% % % ' , 2 +'* & , ' &"1""2 ,, & 12 % & , &",,"+ 2"

-."

$#'"%,-%"-."

$#%-&'"+ '

$ /644G3 '

% 1 , % ++"& % % 1+' +1 ', &'"

$ 2 -'

. @35 '% 3"

3- ', +" % ' &%% '

%- ")-%'"% 1 &',+" )"=%"+.%&&>

& &' '

2%"

$ " - &'"

$ %' %'& -'

. "

%' & & '

/644G3 '

% % 1 & %& &2 D"

& &% " '1 %,"2'

5C ?

&+'

% $ &% +" % +& '

& 1" ', &"+"

+%& 12 % % " ' '% *"& +'

$ $ % D '

'2 ', &"+' $D"

',+" ;D 3/<)&"+% $ &,''- + &;D

30<) + 2 ;D 36C< %'- % +" %& ,, & * "' , + "

"',%"$% &'% ',1'&2%"',% &"+% $) %-"'

1& &% "- &+ "1&$ "*' %' $%) % " '&"1""2+ ","+1 "+ 1- ''&%"

+', , + ',%"$%)".% ','

%,'

',1'

&* , ',1'

'& ", &%"" "+ 2"

%+',+" )-%'-"& * &-'

%%' ', ''

% "*"%''&# +% 2."&",,"+ '"'

,''

&&'%28'1" %' ,, &'',$'

2)"

,, $ & " "& ,'

+' '

% +'

* "'

%& ". & +% $) ""' &") '

) , &"+ D ) '',"

+'+ 5: % 1""'

& +'

%* 1 + & '

& 12 *"& + '

& -%"+% "

1 & !"

*"-1'*,+ &*"& +'

,")%'

',+' '-%"+%+" " "&)"++ &,''-(3

;"< &"+D /9/94 &&',, '/9644 ;""< ?'',"

+','

% '

%H /644G3 '

% C644

;"""< '

+% $ 54444 ;"*< ' '- &"

,, 04444 ;*< ' '- & & +% $ 54444 ;*"< ' ,'

, &"+ D 56444 ;*"" ' ,'

""' G+"&" 54444 54C444 5E % ',, $ *%"+ - "

& -"% ' 03

+' 2?& &% " '%"

,"'%'-%

'/3'- ',%',, $*%"+%+'"& 21 +% ', &+'

&""'

',"

+'"+2%' $%)% " 2"1""2' 2'

',+' "', '5 &/1

' 03

+ ' 2 1"

$ "

', % ',, $ *%"+ -" & ",2 ' /3'- ', *%"+ 12 ."

$ 2 ', +' '

/4 A ', 2 1'* &"+ "'

) % " ++& - & & 12 % " "& & " '-& +' ', 5)4C)444G3 ,'

" ,, & 12 % "

*%"+ -"%',, $*%"+" "' "&'"

HC6I

- &&'

',+' , '%&',,""

$', +"""'

"+ "F"'

'03

+' 2 -"&'"%+' '

1 .++'

',+" '

2% % ' $%& && ,'

,"&6444G3 $+ / &% (# )%*' 8. $%)#