← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5545/2005allowed

Sunil And Another v. Manjit Singh And Others

2019-12-19Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

 

     





! " 

# 

! "

 

# $ $&'(  (       ) '

*



+

,-./ 0&

1 2-

 ,3      5 

  % .%

 

  % .%



! "/ 5& 0   -

, %3 / %& &

! " , #-/

 0"

 8

 $ &  .

" &-

 

& 



& &/ (99 %

%

&

"

0 +

, 2

&3 : 0" ,/ $ & #;

5

<2< & 2

)0

: #;

&

  1 2- :

 

.

"  =#,( %

%

%%"

0& &-"

  ; && %% -

0&

&&/ 5& ;

&  > &&

 "" %%"

0&

0   >/ "



.

""

#;

5 0"

 $ &  = = - &3& .

"  =#,?

 - &3& 5&

.



 ?

- &3& ."

0 %  

 - 

?

. ' @&&;

5 - &3&

& 

0" ,3 

/  %%"

0& ."

0

 "" -

"

 A"A"

-

&- #;

?

0

%%"

0& 3

 .

; - &3& 

"

&&?

%%  "

0 &"

& ?

)<1 / #;

% 5 ?

%

- 0

53

?

)<1  #;/

% 

<" #- = / $/ 5

- -

>  > ( >?

-&3  ?

&0 - 0     ""

- - %"

&-



&& "

&-/

 - /9/7 -&/ /   &

= .&-

-3 .

=  , ) B

3"

*"

&& %% &&/ % & 



1# >   >

%%& 

& ( >> 1)2

" "

"

3 &-

 && 

 ""

&/ 





# / /  , % !  - & 0 "

  &-

 &"

&/



1# &&

& ."

. % % - %  &-?

0"

=#,( & &&?

50

 (  ( >

#%"

-"

 / 5

3

- &-



1   - .- .%

3/ ;

.!&

"

0 %%&0 && - " &&?

-

%& 



& 

 ""

?

&  3 && & %"

%& % - "0

?

-

%& C "

-

 & %  3 "

& ?

- &3&

 "" -

&;

- &3& 

"

&&?

&-

 %  

-0 D & -

1 /

3

- &-



1 - 5 -

 5 %% C

  0&

%

 "-/ &  %0

"

"

;

& 

 ""

5

3"

=#,( &

1  & "

 " //7   F

-  %"

&-

 

A  & %0

"

 ,

1 & "

&&

+-

5 0"

&& 0 " 

 >/

D 

1  & %0

"

 %"

&-

 -.

 %"

 /



&& 2- ./  %

%

5 &-



3 & "

 ,

 //7 "

  F

-  %"

   &

A 5

3.

 ,

!3 0 3

% ""

0 5 & && "

- - 5 5

 "3 D 

G 

 % 

 .-"

&-

 "3 &&  3 

5 !%&/ 5  D "

*&

 5 

=50 3



  " &

:

/ 

 .%



0 "  "

&

-0 >(211 (   

 

 #  2)2 ;"

-   0& .3 & %& 0 5& >F

- .

% 

&   0 && ?

% 3



&

  >?

" .3 

& ,

& .3 & %& 0&/ 5& & && && "3

*5 .3 & %&    9  %

-   3

-   3

& % .3 & %&/ 5&  (  >

1 %%& && & %&    9 %%

  -   3

 

5"

&  & %& 5 -

"

&&;

.&;

"

  / 5& &

& / -

%

%"



+-



 "" %%"

"

&"

&& / %"

  &

 % &

G &-"

 &&/  &  &

0&

0

! "/ 5 " 5 -

)G .-"

%%0 BD )G7  "

&& & "0 &-



%& 1# >   >

%%& 

& ( >> 1)2

" "

+-

)&   #;

BD )   &  %& +-

 5.D &

.  0 

 -

%& C 3"

; ;& -



- &3& "% -

 

"

5&

&0

%

  0& 5  1# &&

&

%"

 %% -

*5 &-"

%"

 / 0 5& - //7 5 / % 5 5



&& "

)G $

=

"/ 5

0 .3 & %& BD )/ -& , D-

(  > %"



"

-.

%% % ; .3 9F

5 - 9/7

5

- .3

% - 5 C

D 2  

            

  

  !"#$"#% &'() "0

-

5 "

&

- .3/ " &  !"-

 &

- .3 && 5 - .3 C  .3 . 0 

 & .3 9F ."

5  , ) B

5 .

 "-

3& &03 ;  - - ."



3  && .3 %%

 -

 - /7

F .3

H"

3 &;

0/ "

9 - -

&. 5/ & 5 ;  />/7

2  %& .3

5 -&  &- &&

 % -

 3"

- 

=

 &



-"

%

5

 "

 -



5 - /7 3 



 %%

 0 5  - &



 && -& -/ & -& .

&

BD )9 BD )/ - />9/7 5

G "

"

-. - 5 -& -/  05 %& -3 -/

0  -



& -& - ./

& / & -- &

;

- " - &

  - 5 5 % -& D 

8/ 

 &

!"

- 5 5  & "

+ 05

  A  5 0 "  

%5

- / -



5 - && 

- 3/  - 5 5

& 

(

%%  

& 

 3

&0

5 -







0"

%% 

C 

 

  A  ""

 

%5

-

-



  && "3 5

7&- &

&& %% - 5 . 5;/





- >/7 & 

"

5 - &&  -  D & %

8  - &-  //7

%"

  -% && "3

*5 &-"



" "

-

 ,

.

-

 +-

0"

" 0 && -

,  % 5 

/ #G #! +- 2 ;/ $8 %%&/ I .

" --

"

 -

&& +-

5    0

>  / & && ."

BD # &

5

"

."

BD #

= "0 -.



5 #8/ #;

>> #87(

 &

&  >

5



5

#G =

) "/ 2 ;/ $8 %%&/ #;

.

" --



"

 >> (( "

  >> (( && #! +-

#- :

5 $8/ #;/ 5& 0  >  

1 & D-/  &

&"A " BD #> & 5- 

= 

" 5 -3

" 5& 5 .;

3 --.

5 

"

 &

= %

 5 -3

"



%%& 5& 3 -

  #G =

) " %%&

0 && &&

 +-

" -

& 3 5 #G #! +-

 & D- &&

5 %

0 %&

$8 %%&

5"

&&

 0 %3 "

%%& 5

&& C  %%&

&&

5 -&& -

& 3 %

&-"

&& +-

0"

&& 0 " 3

1 *  

   

     

+ !!'$ %,,$  % -.

D 2 5  5 "

&-

 5 && 0

0& % %;/ . 0 .

& & & 5

0& - . 0

" 

3 &-

1 2- &

&0

5

3 %

0

 0& ;5"3 3  0

0

"

0 && 0 0& % &&  0

- 0 %& / 5

D & -;

0"

C %  03 5

0"

;5"  5 .

& &

&3 &  .

8         &/ & 

 !!#01"5  5 C/ 5



0 5

0 "3 ""& % D &

. & -

%%"

&

&3

" "

0& 3 & 0

 5 C% 0

0 -/ %% -0/ . 0 - .&/ %;

0 &&

C%& 0

0"/ -0 %& 0.

1 2  ,                

 !"'$#%,,$  % -'/ . 0 5 & 0 5

 %; &&/ .

5

0&

 

/   &

" & &&

 0

% %;/ .C

5 5 -; 0 5

% D  5 &

 & - &  &&

 0

0/  - &

&3 0&  0

0

5 0 .0"

.

%

   &

/ ""

 " !"-

%

  &



"

/ % !% "

"

&0

"



0"

 5

"

0 && -

,  & & 0&

 5

0& ;5"3 3  0

0&

"

0 && 0 0& -"

&&



%& - 0 5

& 0 &

" "

- &

5 - - 0  %%& &"

 3

& .

&  - &

&3

0"

#

 "

&0

"

1 .

+-

"

0 %%&0 && - &&/

& 0  - &

&3 ;

&/

"

."

> .0

%

/ /  

"

!3 0 3 .

-

2C3/ %"



0  & "

%"

   &

 % &

8/ 30+455#54 !!5 % .% 0

5

 5

3

5 - //7

1 53/  - &- />/(7 //  //

5  "    F

-  %"

  &

A  - />/(7/

3.

/ /  !3 0 3

G -%&/ 30+4" "-4 !!)% .% &-7

! " 5

3

& -

 5 5

3/ -&

&/ % 3/    && "3

(  (

#$ , !

 %&'(&'))'*+,'- .'*/0,1  ' + %&'(&'))'.+)(*23'

' +