High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12872/2012allowed

Vidya Devi v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court , Ambala And ANR

2016-02-11Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain9 pages

!"!#$ %&'

&() * * * * +!( ,!

+ &"'"

& "!!#.

# &"

0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 120333 120333 120333 120333 & $ & $ & $ & $ 0& .& 43!#.-# &),

& 0&3

/- &5 6),

&& 77777 77777 77777 77777 3) 3) 3) 3)

-!"/

!#'# && ! 8 *

!# #!

9!#. 5&!

!# #

!& &! &:'

"-!#. &

; <## ='&

& - !"

# #'"

8 !"/'

%( &,!#. # #

<## ='& > ?

#.!#. - &

!# - //&/&!

, &#4

&& ! !"/'

& 6'!

!# #'"

)4%

&)!#%&!

"- 5&9!#. " #A ( 5!

- >3 -8 5 * B@ B'/ C

3 "

!# ,!8

!# /&,!"!#" #'"

!"/'

" )@B <1 1 &"-& ?

>3 -8!#!

"5&!

&4'

(5 ;

,!"

6!#- &'

(,!

.!"

)%'

6!#- &'

(-'")

& - &"

## 6% '&!#.

# !8!

!#/&

!#." 8")/

"9 6!#- ()%'

" # /8

!#." ") 885!#. !""'

%( $> D -

!# "

5&94 #!"8!

%8 %

!#.5&#.) !88 8)#'88 #,!

5&94 #!"

!# "

- '88 95 88

"!# 8'!#.

# !#'!

( E -

& 8 !4 "

!" #

!# %8 !# /& &4E0 ; -

5&94 #- "# '"

/& 8 !4"

E0 B 8!

F " 8 !& ,!

!# "'//& !& "/

!, /8

" ,!

;

8!#

"'.- %(

!#%(

&>5&94 #

&# '#"

8 &

& - " "'%4!

& - 5&9 & ; (

&" 5!

>3 -8 # - & "

" - %

4/8(!#.5!

&(/&,!"!#"

;

#%( >3 -8

## 6%"

8"!

& - &, # # #

("&

( #5!88!#. 6!#- &'

()%'

#/ &4!

6!#- &'

(%( > 3 -8

&# '#"

8 && )# #)- ""'%4!

## " #

)'&!#. # !8!

!#/&

!#.")/

"9 6!#- &'

()%'

"- /'

!# ; (

&" 5!

- >3 -8) %'

" - %

4/8(!#. 5!

&( /&,!"!#" / &'"

8 8 !4

<## ='& >;? &

& -

"/ 88(/8

"- 5&9 > 3 -8#& .'8 &% "!"5 * B@ B !88

!#) ! C

# -!" & &) >

!4"

"'# &$> G-

5&94 #A 8 !4 //!#

#A ( %( 4 # & .'8 & % "!"

5 *B@ B# 4# -8("

&( "

A>/ 4# -- 5&94 #A 8 !4 "%

#/ &4!#.

#A (

'88( #"!# 8( 5!

#( 4/8 !# &4 #( :'

& # #

'# &5&9 #"!# (- &( "!# &

" CA>5 &)'

-!.- /&!

")!

", &(!

! '8 & 5&94 # -

5 !4 "4

8 8" &-

4!8(4 4% &" &4

! 4

& "

&( 3) "- :'

!# &

& "

4!#!4'45 " - !# &

&( 5&94 #A 8 !4 " B CA>5

5-! -5 "/ !!# 4# - '.'"

)

# ""'& 5&94 #A 8 !4 &

#- # !#.- &('/ 4!#!4'45 "5!

##'

8 !# & " 5

) %'

#'8

&!&4 !,

5&94 #A 8 !4 5&#.8() !88 88(

/&!# !/8 " #

86'"

"5 88 "!#,!8

/&,!"!#" #'"

8!"/'

" 5 C

#5- ##

<0# (?!#

4&#!#. 5&94 #5 / &4- &'

("-

"# 885 #

" -8/& 4!"

( 6!#!#. #/ &4!#.- &'

5 C@

F /8(<## ='& >B? !/ .& /-&

"'# &$> G-

# 8 !4 "

5&#.) !88 8 # ,! 4 " !"

4/-

88( #!

&4!#. '

'88( # "!# 8()

&!# 4/8(5!

& 8 "5 88 "5&!

#!&

!#" & "'4

(% "!

", &!'"4 ""

"5 !# -!"

&) %'

!#"/!

88 %

& " %(

#"5 &!#.&

& !# 6!#

( 5!88 '88( 5!

#( !# !4

!# & !# &4

!#) ""' -- ## "

&5# !" #!

& 5

" !"

# @

& "'4 -!"A- &'

( #5 "# 885

" -8/& 4!"

" -

9 '/

&!,8'"

-'.- &( 4!"'"

/& "" 8 5) &5-! -

&!"# & #(& 8!

F -'") >3 -8 - # "/ 88(

& !# 5&!

- >3 -85

## "- !/8

>3 -8 "

#" % 8!

!44

!#)/

#'"

8!"/'

%("

&,!#. ##

<## ='& > ? #

&4 () >3 -8 "-'8 - 8 # !#:'!&( 5 &)!# /& )#!#:'!&(5 "- 8

& >3 -8- = 4!# 3'9-6!# &3!#.-

"0/ &'"

0& &

<"-5#'&!#. '&"

&.'4 "?)

" ( # * @ @# !8(5 "/ && :'!&

6% 5&9 # !#

&4!

8( 5&9 '/

!#5 "/'

!5!

""!#-!" &""> = 4!#

>3 -8&

( 885

6!#- &'

( -!":'

!#) "" #"5

6% &5# /"

# !88 '/%('

"'& !#.)"- '8# &4!

* 6!# '

( /"

"# %8 -'") -'.-)!# 5&!

>3 -8)"

#"/ 88( #!

)%'

5-!8 //

&!#.!# ""> %=) 0 3'9-6!# & 3!#.- - "/ 88( "

& - 5&9 5!

- 4 &4 * @ @ '/

# !8(5 " - >3 -8- #

/&'

#& & #(

&/ (& .!"

&A/ (&88"

"-5

# 5&9 & B ("!#

(

&/&

!#.

!# " #

# !& '4"

" /& )

88!# &&&5-!8 -8!#.

%8!"-

"- # 5&9 5!

>3 -8 & B ("!# 8 # (

&/&

!#.

!# >3 -8-

%8!"-%( /&' !#. &

# /'

!# B

(" !# (

&/&

!#.-

!#-'")!

!" ,!

4/8(!#.5!

&(/&,!"!#" 3

C> # 0'#! !/ 8 '# !8) !# &) 0'#! !/ 8 '# !8) !# &) 0'#! !/ 8 '# !8) !# &) 0'#! !/ 8 '# !8) !# &) -"!8 -"!8 -"!8 -"!8 H!"

'& "/'&+ &"'"& "!!#.

&)2 %'& H!"

'& "/'&+ &"'"& "!!#.

&)2 %'& H!"

'& "/'&+ &"'"& "!!#.

&)2 %'& H!"

'& "/'&+ &"'"& "!!#.

&)2 %'& '& )'& "/'& # &) '& )'& "/'& # &) '& )'& "/'& # &) '& )'& "/'& # &) B<B?3CB) '88 # - -!"'& "8 !5# 885!#./&!# !/8 "$> <!? I

/!#.!#,!

5 .#!"

/5 &

#'"

8 &!%'# 8 !&

'# ,!8

!# 3

!# C>

## #!

"8 8(# .&'#

//!# " 5

%(/'%8! %!

/'%8! /"

#5 # !# &

&(& &'!

&'8 " <!!?

/"!

!# 8 5 " - " %

"'.- % ""

%( -!"'& !"

/&,!"!#" 3

!# C>% !#.4

&( # '# ,!8

!# )

# -4 5'8% ,! %!#!

! "!

&!#/

!# #)

& 4/8(

5'8%

% # !#'!#.!#"

<!!!?- &!.-

)-5 &)!"#

! &!.- " "' - # 5-!8 !&

!#.

5!88-

!# #"!

!# , &!'" "/

" "

//!# %!8!

( /"

)

%!8!

( 5&9)5-

//!#

"/ &'8

&(/&,!"!#"

8 #.

- (!#& !"!#.

!#'"

8 !"/'

& #( &

'8 885 !# " &"#"

//!#

# "-&

&4 % "!" # " !8( &" #5-- # 5&9 &8#./ &! %'

"8 8(# #.

- ,!#. 4/8

(") 5'8 # & "

% &

" "' -) # -'.-

# -4 ",! <!,? - ! &

# -4 % !#. ,! 5'8) -5 &) # 5&94 # " "' - :'

( & 8 !4 &!.- & & .'8 &!J

!# & %( # & &

)

&4 # ( '8 % .&

4/8(

# #8( - 5'8 % 8 %

!# # !#''""

"- "5- #-!""

<,? 4/8( &5'8- &!.-

-!4 !# & 5!

- 8 5 %( 4/8(!#.5!

&(/&,!"!#"

4/8(

,!#. #( .&!

"' -

!# '8 - #.

& -8 5 <,!? - !" &

!# #'"

8 6'!

& " -'" - % "/

# 6'!

&- 9

/!#4!# /&!# !/8 "8 5#%( / ='& "# %, <,!!? # "'%" &!% ,!

/'%8! -&!

" '8 8 !4

8!44'#!

( /&

!# &4 /&,!"!#" 3

!#" C>

# C> %(

9!#. & "& "-!

8!#. 4"

8, "# '#

"5 # !88 '/!# &

&( & &'!

&'8 " #)

& ) / & "

5&94 # '8 # 8 !4

F 3!# ""5-- //

>3 -8-

-!""

# #( ,

# ( " 5&9 5 " % !#. . #

-&'.-'

"'& !#.)!

5'8# 6'"

=/ & &

& # !# 8!

) !

5'8 % //&/&!

& 8'4/>"'4 4/ #"

& &!#.8() -!" /

!# !" 885 4/'.#

&/ ""

; !""

!"!&

/ ( 4/ #"

'# K;)

)

&5!

-!# 54# -"

!/ /( -!"& &)

!8!#.

5-! -)/

&5'8% &

!, 4'#

4/ #"

!# 8#.5!

-!#

@L/ ##'4

/ ""!#. -!"& !88&

8!"

!# <3?

<3?

%&'

&() * %&'

&() * ,!&