High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12885/2012allowed

Rajni v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Ambala And ANR.

2016-02-11Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari9 pages

!"#"$%&'( ')

!"#"$%&'( ')* + * + * + * + ,$"

"$'

-'#(# .'#" "$/

"!' $ .'# #0$ $ 1% 1% 1% 1% 231444 231444 231444 231444 '#$ % '#$ % '#$ % '#$ % 1' /'

54"$/.$'* 6!

' "$' 1'4 $ 0.

' 7 ,* 6!

''#0$ $ 88888 88888 88888 88888 4* 4* 4* 4* "9 ."#0 "$($ ''

"!9 +

. $# "$ $ "

#:"$/ 7'"

"$ . $

'" ';( #."$/ '

< =$$>('

? "$' .

"# $ $ (# 9 "#0( &) #'6"$/ 5 $ $ "!

A =$$>(' ?

99$/"$/ .'

"$ . 00'0'"

6'$5$

'' . # " "#0( ' ,( "!

"$ . $ (# *5& .!

# "$'*"$&'"

#..

7': $B ) 7"

.'#0$ $ 4!.9 '5(9) @@ (0 A

A 4'6"!# "$' 7'

"$ 6"9

"$ . 0'6"#"$# . $ (# "#0( #!

*@CA=2!

2 '#.'

#0$ $ 4!.9"$"

#7'"

6''

&#$ '5 ( )7

A "$'7 6"# ,"$.' ( )6" '/"# ' 9

A*&( #..

"9 ,"$.' ( ).(#*

"$' .

.'#9 & $ $ . ,& ('"$/ !$!"9"

"$0'! "$/# 9#*0 "$'7 #: ,"$.'

)*&( #..

"9 # $ . 09 "$/# "#* 997"$/ "##(# 7' 5 &) % D .

.' .

"$ #'6"!# 7':5 $"#9"

&9 &# #" &"$/7'$/* "99/ 9*$(99 $ 6" ! .7':5 $"# 9 & '"$#

"$ #'6"!7"

. (99 & !:7 /# 99 .&$ #"$!9( "$/ !$ "$("

) #'6"!E .

.' . !9 "5 #

"# $

"$ &9"$ .0'#$ '5E1 < .

.' .7':5 $.

#$!

(# "$

"9 .0'#$ !9 "5#

E1 C 9"

F "# 9 ."' 6" $! "$ #(00'

."'

'#0!

"609 # .3 6" "

< !9"$ .'

'$!#(/.

&) "$' $!* 0'#$ 0 "$&) "$'7':5 $ '$ !($#9 ' "$' .

# #(&5"

"$' .

7': ' + ) '# 7"

. '#0$ $ 4!.9 $ .' #'6"!# .

.( !509)"$/7"

')0'6"#"$# .!

< .09

:$&) .'#0$ $ 4!.9

"$'

& $ $ .,&#

9#"

" '5

"$' .

#'6 5 $ $ "! $

A "$'7 )#'

) $ 7"99"$/ ,"$.' ( )*&(

$ &$0'5"

,"$.' ( )&) .'#0$ $ 4!.9 '$ !($#9 ''#0$ $ *$ . .'

$ *.

##(&5"

& $ $ .'

#'6"!# $

* ('"$/!$!"9"

"$0'! "$/#*0 "$'

#: ,"$.' ( )*&( #..

"9 # .!

# "$'7

#..

0( "$ + ) '# #'6"! 7"

. . '#0$ $ 4!.9* &( .'

#'6"!# .

.( !509)"$/ 7"

') 0'6"#"$# . !

0'(# 9 . !9 "5

=$$>(' <? '6 9#

"$' .

#0!"

99)09

#..

7': 7"

.'#0$ $ 4!.9$'/(9 '& #"##"$!(9)@@ "99

"$* " A

A $ ."# '/ ' * !9 "5#

#($ '% G.

.7':5 $B!9 "5 7 00"$ $B ) &) . 5 /5$ $ '/(9 ' & #"# 7 (9)@@$ 5$ .9)# ') # B0'

5$ ..7':5 $B!9 "5 .

#&$0'

'5"$/ .' ( "# $B )

(99) $ #"$!'9) 7"

.( $) !509 "$ '5 $) ;( ' $ $

!!($ .'.

' 7': $ #"$!'"

).'# ') #"$!'

# #

B76'* ( ."/.

0'"!#*"

7 #6') "

"!(9 ' .7':5 $ .

7 "5#5 9 9# '.'

5"9)55&'# '5

. # " 5 /' # ') 4* #. ';(# /5$ "$!'

# .' # ')

9 5"$"5(57 /# .5 /5$ "$!'

# ') .7':5 $B!9 "5 #

B7 A

A7."!.7 #0 " "$ .5$ . (/(# *

A ##(' . 7':5 $B!9 "5 '

$!"$/.'# ')(0 .5"$"5(57 /#7"

$$( 9 "$!'5$ # 7

A* &( /5$ '#0$ $ 7"

" "$ "$

$ (9 '"'5 "6#

.#'6"!# 7':5 $B!9 "5 7'$/9)* "99/

99) "$# 0'"$!"09# $

9,(# "! #799 #"$6"9

.0'6"#"$# .$ (# 9"#0( #!

7 A

A $ 7.$$

A"$ .5'$"$/

.7':5 $7$ 0'

'5.' ( )#.7 #$

997 6$ $ ' .#!.90'5"##7.

) ,"$"$/ $ 0'

'5"$/.' ( "# 9

.' #'6"!# .

6 &$

7 A@

AF 09)=$$>('C? .# " 0 /'

0.'

#($ '% G.

0 $ . !9 "5 #

"# 7'$/* "99/ 9 $ 6" 5'"

# "# 50.

99) $"

. 0 #&$ 0'

'5"$/ . ( "#

(99) $ #"$!'9)*

99/ $

* "$' " $ !509)7"

9 #799 #7'"

$ "'!

"$# '#(5 )&#" #6 '"(#5## /#7'#$ "$ ."# '/ ' * &( "$#0"

99 &#

# &)

$#7'"$/'#0$ $ * "$' " $ ,"$

. ( ) 7"99

(99) 7"

.( $) "$ "5

"$ '

"$ '5

"$* ##(!..

& $ $ .#'6"!#

.'7$ "# ('

.' $"

.#'6"!#

"$' 7'

# 99/ "#

.' $"

$ @

A "$'6'

5 '#(5."#B.' ( ) $ 7 #$ 997

$ ' .#!.90'5"## .0 !: (0

9# '"69(#

' .(/.

') 5"#(# .0'!## 9 7* '7."!. "$'"#$ $ 9 ' $)'9"

F .(#* . '#0$ $ 4!.9 .

$ #0!"

99) $" . #'6"! 0'" "$' "$ . 7'"

# .'#0$ $ 4!.97

& $ $ .'#'6"!#.# " 09 '#0$ $ 4!.9 #

$ # &9" '5 .

"55 "

'.'

"$*0 '

"# $ (# 9 "#0( &)#'6"$/ 5 $ $ "!

=$$>(' ? $!

#* &#$ '5 )* . '#0$ $ 4!.9 #.(9 .

6 .9 $ "$;("') 76'*"$ .0'#$ !

#*$"$;("')7 #.9 "$# "$' #0$ $ 4!.9.

> 5"$ 4(:.,"$ '4"$/.

#10'(# 9 .#

1'!' & '

=#.7$ ('"$/ .!('# '/(5$ #?* '6 9#

"$'7 #$/

# ) $ A@@<$ "9)7 / #0'';("'5$

,& 7': $ "$ '5"

9) 7': (0

A ;(# "$7 #0( .# " 7"

$##"$."#!'##> 5"$

7 .'#0$ $ 4!.9'

) 997 "$'

,"$.' ( ) ."#;(# "$* .7"

$## $#7'

.,& .'7$ .0# .

&$ "99 (0&)( #('!"$/*#.!(9 $ &0'5"

+ ,"$ . ( ) .0# 7 #$ "9 &9 .(#* .(/.*"$ .7'"

"9 &) '#0$ $ 4!.9*#'6"!0'" $

&$#0!"

99) $" *&( 7."9 '"$/"$ .7"

$## &>* 1 4(:.,"$ ' 4"$/. .

#0!"

99) #

"$' .

7': 7"

. .5 '5 (9) @@ (0 A

A$ "9)7 /# .'#0$ $ 4!.9.

0' (! $'!' $)

$!'0 )'/"# 'B0 )'99#

#.7

$ 7': ' C )#"$ ) '0'! "$/

"$ .'#'6"!# $

$ !"'!(5#

$!# .0'#$ !

99"$'''7."9.9 "$/

"$'

"9 #

&9"#.

#. .

$ 7': 7"

. '#0$ $ 4!.9 ' C )#"$ .9 $) '0'! "$/ .'

"$#0$ $ 4!.9.

"9 #

&9"#.&) 0' (!"$/ .'!'

$ 0( "$ C

)# #'6"!"$ .) '0'! "$/.'

"$.(#*"

"#6" $

.#'6"!# "$'7'

.( !509)"$/7"

')0'6"#"$# 4!

$ . !

# 1($"!"0 9 ($!"9* "$ '* 1($"!"0 9 ($!"9* "$ '* 1($"!"0 9 ($!"9* "$ '* 1($"!"0 9 ($!"9* "$ '* .#"9 .#"9 .#"9 .#"9 H"#

#0('-'#(#'#" "$/

"!'*3 &('

H"#

#0('-'#(#'#" "$/

"!'*3 &('

H"#

#0('-'#(#'#" "$/

"!'*3 &('

H"#

#0('-'#(#'#" "$/

"!'*3 &('

*('

#0(' $ .'* ('

*('

#0(' $ .'* ('

*('

#0(' $ .'* ('

*('

#0(' $ .'* C=C?4 C* .(99 $!. ."#('

#9 " 7$ 997"$/0'"$!"09#% ="? I0"$/"$6"7 .'!/$"# 07' $ (# 9 '"&($ 9 "'!

'"$#

!!($ .6"9

"$ 4!

"$ .!

.# 5!

$$ & $" #99)$ ./'($

00"$ # 7'5 &)0(&9"!& "#

"$# 0(&9"!0# $ 7'$ "$ !!'

.'96 #

')'!'("

'(9# =""? . #

9 0#"

"$ 9 7 # .

# &$ #(/.

& '## &) ."#('

0'6"#"$# 4!

"$ &"$/5

') $ !!($ 6"9

"$ . # 5* '$!.5$ 7(9 &6" &"$"

" #"

7 $6'"$0'

"$ $ * .'

'* .509) 7(9 & 5 &!$ "$("$/"$#'6"! ="""?.'"/.

'"$#

*.76'*"#$

"! '"/.

# #(!. $ 7."9 "'!

"$/ '"$#

* 7"99.

"$ !$#" '

"$ 6 '"(# #0!

# #

(' 00"$ * "9 &"9"

) 0# *

"9 &"9"

) 7':*7.

.' 00"$

#0'#'(9# .#

')0'6"#"$#

.9$/ . #'6"! . 9 )"$'

"#"$/ "$ (# 9 "#0( & ' $) '

'"$#

!(9 997 "$ !

## 0'#$#

00"$ $ #.'

'5 & #"# # "9) /'# $ 7..

$ 7': '9$/0'" &( #99)$ .# '$/ . .

6"$/!509

)#* 7(9 $ 0' # & $ 9 '

'"$#

# #(!.* 6$ .(/. '$!.5$ 7 #6" ="6? . # " '

'$!.5$ &"$/ 6" 7(9 * .76'* $ $ 9 . 7':5 # #(!. ;( 9"

) ' !9 "5 '"/.

' '/(9 '"J

"$ $"

.' &) $ ' ' '"$#

* 0'5 $$!) !(9 & /'

. # 509) $ $9) . 7(9 & .9 & 9 "$!$ "$((##'6"!$ .# 5#

#.7 #7.$."##'6"!#7'

=6? .509)'7(9 .

6 '"/.

."5 "$ !!'

$! 7"

. 9 7 &) !509)"$/7"

')0'6"#"$# 509) .

6"$/ $) /'"6 $! "$# #(!.

"$ !(9 !.

99$/ . # 5 "$

!!'

$!7"

.9 7 =6"? . "#!'

"$ . $ (# 9 ,( "!

# .(# .

6 & '#0!

. # ,( "!

:0"$5"$ .0'"$!"09#9 7$&) .0>('

* #$ "! &6 =6""? $ #(&#!'"& . 6"7

0(&9"! .'"

"#!(9 !9 "5

9"55($"

) 0' "$ '5 . 0'6"#"$# 4!

"$#

. !

:"$/ '#'

#."9 "$/ .5#96#$ !!($

.0# #7'$ "99 (0"$ !!'

$!7"

'96 #

') '!'("

'(9# $ *

'* 0' # . 7':5 $ !(9 $ !9 "5 '"$#

F 4"$! .7"

$##7..

' $&.

.'#0$ $ 4!.9.

."##

/* .) "

$ .

6 $) 6 $!) # . 7': 7 # &"$/ / $

.'(/.( #('!"$/*"

7(9 $ &,(# $ >0 "$ ' ' . '"$#

"$' $ "$ 9"(

'"$#

* "

7(9 & 00'0'"

' 9(50#(5 !50$#

"$ "$' !!' "$/9)* ."# 0 "$ "# 997 50(/$

' 0 ## &)

< "##

#" #0$ $ "# "'!

0 )!50$#

($ K<*

B "$'7"

."$ 75$ .#

'!"0 !'

" !0) ."#' '*

"9"$/ 7."!.*0 "$'7(9 &$ 9 '!"6 5($

!50$#

"$ 9$/7"

."$ '#

@L0' $$(5

0 ##"$/ ."#' ' "99'

9"#

"$ =4?

=4?

&'( ')* + &'( ')* + &'( ')* + &'( ')* + 6"'