State Of Haryana Etc. v. M/S Poddar Industrial Corporation

2023:PHHC:131031








 

 




!
"#$# %&
'()(*


 

  















 
 



  
  










  

 &
 +,
 (
 -


.
-
,,
   
  

 
!"
#  
 

 

 
$
  
!"

 
%&



.
-
,,/
(

&


 

$ 

()*+(**,

- 
 
. "
/
 "

0
1  -


 
" +)

 
 - 
 "
"
&223
4   
 


5 
"67


- 

 
"

 
1 

+*&((**)

- 
 - 

-
 

(


 

 !
  

 


5
  

1

 6
 
-

-
 
%&
1
""
 
" 8 


 

*,*&&222
1
"
- 
1
 
%&

 
59&:

 0



%&:2(9&2;2
 " 


  
1

"

" 
 

&:

  

"
 
"


4
(
7

-
 
 "



 !
"" 





 
--
 
 
"
<9  

  

 
1
9 --


- 
 6

'


"" 
 

 !

 

 "
 

1 47
;*


  

2(+*,

=
3,9

47
&**


  

,****

=
2+:*

+
  
 
 "
1 

-

-
*3*:&222
 


 
 
 "

3(+*,


;*


  

4

2(+*,
7
1

-
 
%&
1 
 " -
 

*3*:&222

'

 
  

 
8

-  
%&
 
 


1
  
> 

+**3&222
 
- 


 
%&

 
+****


;*


  

 
&****


&**


  

4

,****
7


 
1 
- 
> 


+**3&222
 
%&


 
  
8 

;*


  

-


  
,****


&**


  

8 

-

 
%&
1
-


 &****


1!



 
>

 
> 
 
 
%&

 
:****


&**


  

! 

- "

 ! 
&****


&**


  


)
 "
 

 
  

 

 

 
1 
! 
 
 

! 


? 
  
  
1 

 


&**


  


 


,::*

 
1 
 !0 
5@
6

4
+
7



(&

 
  "
 "

0




&**


  

! 
-
 
%&

 


,::*



 
 "

2+:*


&;


  
 "

 !
- 
 
%&
 !0
 -    

- 

"  9" 

A 
 - 

"   

 
" 
1 
 
1 
  &,

!1

 
-!
 
 
" 

 

"!
  
 
 
 "

  


 1 
 7
;*



=

3,9


-7
&****
 

&**




1 
!
 
=

2+:*


"7
:****
 

&**






!
 
=

2+:*


9
(C
 






 
!

 
" 




""
1
-

- 
" 
 

$  
 
"!
  
 

1
-
 

"!
 
   
  
 

 
  "
 
1  
=
&;C




  

 
  
-" 


 


"! 


" 
 
-
 

"!
  
 
  

1
"!

&:
 

 


!
=
&;C



  


-" 


 


"! 

'


""
 

-

- 
" 


" 
 
0
 
"" 
  "
  


 
  
  

 


1 

 "
-!
1

 

&:
 
  
"

 
" 
1 

 
 


 
 
 
 
.


" 9"

"0 
 
 
 
 
 
 
""


4
)
7

" 9"

"0 

 
" 
 
 
.

1

 

&:
 
  
"

 
""
"

 
  " 
 
 
 


 
" 
 
  
 

 
 


1 
1

 

)


  


 
" 9"

"0 

 
" 
1  
=
&;C




  


1 




 
1 
" 
 
-
 

"!
 
  
 

 


1 
1
 
  
=
&;C



  


1 

 





  >" 
1 

'


 
 


-
 
1
"
0
!1
 
"
" "  "

 
"
 
"

 
1 
-
 

 
 
 
 
.
D
:


 
 !
- 
 
1 

+*&((**)



 
"
+)

 
"
- 
 
 

 
. "
/
 "

0
1
1
 
!
$ 


()*+(**,


3
A 

" 
1 
"

 
1 

+*&((**)

- 
 - 
 
$ 

()*+(**,

- 
 
. "
/
 "

0

 
1 
-   47

 - 


 

"  
5@
6

    
1  
1
 
! "

-  
1 

 
1 
1 
 !
- 
.# .
 
1 


&**


  


 


,::*


 
 

8
-
 
%&

2+:*


47

 - 
" 
 


 


 
5 0
6

9&)

 
  "
-     ! 
  
 "

 
 "


 
 

!
-
" 
1
3

1  
 
 ""
   

4
:
7


 

"

 
 
 " 

 
 "


  
! 
 
-
 
1
3

47

 
%&
!


*2*((***
- 0




&**


  


 
"



,::*


! 
 
! 
"

 
> - 

 !


 


2+:*

4!7

  
1 

 


&;C


>  




 
1
 "
 

4!7

 
 - 


!
"
  

 
1 

+*&((**)

A 

" 

 



 
 
-  
"
 "


$ 

 6-
  
 
 

 
<
  
A 

 
# 
  $  
4(*((7
)

)3+

,
< 

 
" 
   
 
%&

- 
 
 
1 

+*&((**)
 
 
$ 

()*+(**,



 


 
 !
-


0 
"" 

 
"
! 

$" 



  
- - 
 
"



 
"
+)

 
"

 
 
 
 
  




 ! 
 
1 


!

  "

 
$"
 
"


-
   
1 

;

 

"  
 
!
-  
 
- 


2



"

  
" 


 
-  
 
 


1 
 "

8 
1 

-

4
3
7

! 
-
 
%&

" " 
  




"



<

 

 
"
- 

47
;*


  

9
2(+*,


47
&**


  

9
,****

 
  
" 



;*


  

42(+*,
7

! 
- 
> 


!

+**3&222

1!



&**


  

,****


" " 

&****


-
! 
- 

> 

 
 "" 

1 
 
0
 
! 
 


1
 

? 
  
  



&**


  


 


,::*

-
 
%&
-8 
! 
 
:****


&**


  

! 

- "


&****


 ! 

@  
 

 
" 


&**


  




E
F 
=
,:9

%! -
&222

 
2+:*
8
 
 
1 
 

 !0
5@
6
"  
 
  "
1


 B@AA
AGH
'


 "
"

 
 
  8 

  
 

>"


1 
1
 "

1 
   
 
 

 "
" 

 

.# .
%1
. 

#!


  G  0 

 
 
  !
 "  "

 

 
9"  "





 
  
!
 "  "

 
 
""
   
"
 

 "

8
 



 

 
 "
1
  "
"

 -
 
 

  "  "
 
   
 
  1 
"

" 
  
"
 
 "
 -
 
 

  "  "

 
 


 


 
 "

"

" 

 
 
"  "

 
!

'


""
   
 
    "



 
"

1


 
" " 
  <"   

'


   
 

!

" "
 

4
,
7

-
 
 

"

 
-
 




1 

 
8
-
  
.# .
%1
. 
 
 

#!


"
  
"  
 

'


  
<"
 
-
8 

  
 
8
" "

!
- 
" " 
 
-
- 
 


D





&*
'




 

"

 
1
1!
" 
- 
 - 
1 
- ! 
 

1 
-


#!



E
F 
1 
"  

&9&*
  
 
1 
1 

 
1  
&**





 
1

&9&:
  
 

1

 
 
--


 
" >

 

"


56


>
1 
 

0

 
"
-
 
" 

 "

 B  

"

" 
 9&:I
  

"
 
"

-
 
 "



 !
"" 





 
--
 
J
< 
"
<9 
'1
9 
--
 
- 
 D
&&
'

 



 
 "

-
 
%&
1 

  
8 

 "
  



" 

 1
 
 




E
F 
1 

 
8


9 &:
 

1 
""  
-
" 
--
 
"
 
-
 "



 !
 
"
 
"
 


"





 


E
F 
"


-
"  
1 
 
 
 
 
 
  
"
- 

  
8 

'


"  

 
 

- 

 

!

 
 

 -
$"

4
;
7

&(

 

> 
 
"  


- 

 
  
5 0
6

9&)

 
  "
 

-
 
1


 B&)

 

 


!

"





 
 
-
 

-
 
 "

 
"  "
 
 
 
"  "


!

"

" 


1 
 
 " -

"

!

"


 

 
 
 



1
-
-$"

(C
 

" 



"! -
 
!

 
 



"





- 
"  "
"!
1
-

  
-

  

H 


" 

1 
. "

 
.
 
 !
  47
%
"!

 
1
-


 
  
<"
""

 

-
> 
!
 

(
10
-
" 
1  
 
>" 
" "  "
1 
- 
 
"  

 

 
  
1



#!



4-7
 
 

 
 



 

(
10




> 

!
 
1
-
 
-   
<"

 
. "

 
.
 
1

" "
  
 
  
 


 
 

 
 
 


1


#!



"
> 
!
 

1

'


"
1
-
"


 
- 
"

 
. "

 
.

'

> 
1
-
1
- 
 
. " .
. "

 
.

 
> 

 "

 
1



 

"
-!

"  "
 
> 
1
-
1
-
. "

 
.
 


"
 !
 

> 

 



  > 
 
-
"! 
  
 


4"7
< 
 

 


0

1 
> 
 

  1
 
"

"

  
"

. "

 
.
 
0
 "



 "

 
1
-

- 
. "

 .
 
1
3


 
> 


4
2
7

!
 
- ! 
  

8 
  
 

 
0 1
 

'


>"
"

 
 " 
1
-
"! 
  
 
  
 
-
H 
 
" 
1 !

!-

'


 " 
1
-


 ! 
 
"


 
1
&:
 D
&+
A 

" 
1 
  

-9"
4"7

 "
-!

! 
 
 
" "
    
 
"

 
 " 

"

 "


  

 
8 

-
 
1
3

  

!  
 

-9"
"


-
   

  
 "


 " !

-
" "
1
3




-
- 
 
 - 


    

"
" " 


&)

 

 -

-" -

 
 
  
  "





"
 "


  
! 

- 
1
3
  
> 

!
 
 

"
"

!
- !0
 
 
 
! 
- !0
 
"


0
"

 !0
 

"

&:


"


1

 

"


"

 
"  "

"-

   

1
1 
 
 - 

   

 

"

1 
 
!
 

"

   
 
1 
"


-


 
 
-

"

  
 
  




  -

 ! 

 
  
"
 
   



"

- 
 - 

- 
 
-1
"


-


-
 ! 


 


 

""


"

 
 
  - 
1 


-
 1 
1 

 
 - 
 

4
&*
7

 
 ! 


 

1

 
 
 - 

  1

" "

 
 1 
  

 
 -
  

-
!1
 
-

  
 
" 



" 

$    "
- 
" 

'


"   
 

 

-
  
 

 -
$"

&3



 
$ 
 
 
 !"
-
 

" 
   

  
"
4 7

" " 
 
! 
> "
  

$ 
 
 "
   B)&


- 
 

        

 

 

 !
 " #

 $%
"
-
 
  $
?1 
 
" 
  

- 

  
"
+)

" $ " 1
"
:

 
&223
"
0

"
 

 - 
1 
 

! 
-
 


 
&223
"
"

-



  

 
 
" 
+)4(7
 
4+7

 

"
 
  1

 
"   

"

 


1 
 
"
+)

 
&223
"
"


0
 
  

 
1 
>"

1 


" "
1 
-"
"


 

 !
 "
+)4(74-747

 
&223
"

)(

   
4 7
 
 

 

1 
"
-


 
 
-"
"


 
 

 
1 " "  " 9
)(&
E
1 



"

 
!



 ! 

)((

E 
 -   - 
' - 





$"
 "

" 


)(+
E
1 


! 
  "

 
$"

)()
E
1 

  -

 ! 

)(:
E
1 

 

1
1
 "

1 

 
 ! 



- !
1

 


 
- "


 &223
"

4
&&
7

)(3
E

1 

"  

 
  

 

 
$"


  
 
 

 "0
 
" " "

 
 

)+

 - 
' - 
- 

"  

"  "

- 

"

 
 
"  "
 
1


" 

1 
"
-


-
 

1  
 
 - 
' - 



"

 

  "


  
 
""
 


"  "

))
1!

 " 

-
 1
-1
 

"

 


 "
 

  
   

 
 


"  "
  - 
' - 

 

   
 
 
 
"  


 "
1 
$" 



 
   


 "


"
1  
  

!
 
1
- 

 - 



 - 
' - 


 
1
$ " 

):

 





!
 
1 

-

 - 
' - 
'


 


      
1    
- 
 - 
' - 


"  "
 !
 
"

  

 
  -

 ! 
E  

"  "
 !

 -


"-

-   
  
1 
 
 
 
"


   
1 
 - 
1 

-"
  


 
  
 
-
   
1
!
- 
-
 D

&,

 

 
 
> "
 "
 
"

    "
 
"
+)

 
"

-
 

'

 

"  


 
 
 

1

  

$ 

1!

 


 
  
"

-
"

1  

"
 
-

 
1 

  -


 
 
-"
"


 


 ! 

  


 
   


"  "
1
" -


-
 
  -


"


"


 !

- 
  

$ 
1  
 
- 
  "

"

   "
 
"
+)

 
"
!
-
 

4
&(
7

&;

  
" 

  
 

" 

- 



*2*((***
 
-
 
%&

 

0


 


8

 


,::*

1
! 
  

 
 
 
!
 "


> - 

-
 
  
"
 


1


 
 
 
 
-


1  1
-
 
%&
 





  
 

 

!1

 
"


" "  "
"


-

 


"  " 
 



 " 
  - 
    


"  

1
-
> 
1 
"  "

  
 
 
  
-
"-

"

 
"  "


-
  






&2

 - 
1 
   

 
"!

  

8 

  
 

"

 

 


(C

"" 


!


"
 
!

" 



'

 
1 

 

-
 
 -
 



 

  
(*



 


  

 


&;C


" " 
 

 

"   
  0

-
! 
 

 






1 
 
 
%&
1 

! 

- 
" "


1
!
" 
"
"
 "" 

 "
"  "







 
1
!
 


'


1 

8


 
(**)


"


 



 




   
1 
1 
 

" 

4
&+
7

(&

"   
 

 

!

-
"
  
- 
 - 
"


-
""
  "


!







-

1

- 
 - 
 
 ! 
- 
1
- 
 
. "
/
1 
" 


 
"
+)

 
"
 
! 
 
- "
 
1  

"  "
 
    "
1
-
$

@  
 "

    "
 
"
+)

 
"

 
 


 1
 



1 
1 


 
  

 
  

 
  "
 

 
 

  "

 

  

 
<
   6
"
4 7
 

-!
 
 
"
-
    "

 "

"

" "  "
>
   
"



1  


   "
 
1 

1

 $ 
 

 
 -
 

@ 
 
 
  

 

 -
 

'()(*



.
-
,,  







 
 
0    $0
 
 - $0