Shiv Narain And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"#$%$!#$#& '%
( "() &$&'* $%+$#$$#& '%
%,
( ( -. (/ 0$12- /1"(30$1 (-, (
( $ 4)(.0$.
$5 (6 2- ( (,(4---(0 ( $50 (6 ( )(7-80$50 (6
( $ 4)(.0$12-
( -135(80$1( "
$ ) ( -: $;) $0 < -( ( ((( =- $ < > 73 )
?
<
&-373)76-.( 3) ( @-$< 0 @
$ 2( (3
-$< 73( (0
?
&-2((.( -(, 7 8( (3 $ - %8- *( 3, &( ,( 6 : $;) 0%-7. $ %.3 $0
-( ((((-=$
>073 (
-()8- (6 $#
<0-)(.-. .(>(3 ;)
&- ,(3 ( ( . 8 - 71 (. - ( 73 ,(4 (3 - 1 )30 - - ,( (-1 .6(1-3, 3) 07).(3 )3 ;) - . .(> 7 8 8(. 3, - 1.,3 .17 83-(
%). .60-(76-2( (.
7.3(-(-, ((3,..6,,(3 -711 3(.A 8 ((0-)(34 8.31 1-((-(73 8A3,(73 8(.(3 ;)
&-71((8)3 .733(.0,().
-(,.6 1)( --2(, .(0-- ( -,). 0 .2..17.0-(76- (.1 ,)7.,)(,2).7)(-(0 B(03673,..6 . ,(3 78 ,)7.,)(,0- 1)..- (. .( (
!
(-.3( , (;)- -;) ,( 8 ( 0-.3(17( (7(-)(081 -.373 8(.((
?
?0 073 8. -()8- ((3-( 0
?
@
,)).6), 1 82 (-,1(-;)( . 0 - (, ( 0 -) -,, 8 )
),(0-(762- - 737.)2 ( - ;)( . %). .6 13 3,. ( 7.) 2 (-,1(-;)(. 0 -(, 0-)34
2..3,2(2- -37-1(( (76 C7.$,A )( -
!"# #$"% & ' '() *+,
- - )1 34.-;)(. -()8-,)7.)
&-)0 -1 7 8 ).D0-A( 8-71,2( 76 7.)2 (0(-( 7.0-(76-) 3 73-76- (6 0-)2)..(). -()7 (1 83-(,)7.,)(, &-((0A, 1(6((( A, .()3 0 3)-0), )(( ( ), A(7 )3 3, 3 7 8 (3 0 -) 34 8-(.;) 0) ()7)( - A-;)(0 -)0-(76-)(6,(3() .6() 17.6 ( - ;)( . 0 36 73 , 76 - (6 21(0-71A, ( 1.7. -(( -
?
'1 -(20-;) 2.2)..6 (3 -6(
0 0-)8--71,(1 73 ( -$
0-()8- (6 $#
3 -6(
<0 0-)8--673((,1.6,,.7.(3-6(
07)6-)(6,(1 ),(0
71.- 7.8 (02- -7 .( 1(376- )( - 0.=.$ ""
/01 2"
4 '&3"
1 '5 7"'&8 9'2 :3# !#
2&
$ ">-0 -3,(-71)(6,(3((A(3.6.30 0 A(33(8 ()3 (1(02- .7
,.-( 0- -;)( 8(.3, - 1.,3 .,. 0 0. 8(87.,(-,)7.,)(, (2---;)(. ()7E;) 0-(76-71
)(6 ,(3( ) .60 0 ) 17.6 ( - . -)() 1.7.737.6 1-2( (
<
(1(0-(.,. 40), -,.6 ),(0 -(.
78( -, (0-.( ) .0 - ??
0 ,. (( 33)
(-$15 (.0 (6 76-* .
33 (0%1 ) $.
- ((6-51( 3 (6 0 %1 ) ( 83 0 2-( 0 -( )( ,4 8- - ,.6 ) ( 1 ( -)( 2-(2.7 83
*)(-(0 - )( (.( .$ ""
/01 2";"
9"
"71 - . 8-.2-3.() 2(,
&-(.1 ,(8(,--1( ),((A(-( (
' $$ $ '&&
$ 8'" 7 <$'&3 '&" '
&
9'
& * '& $ *9
'"
" $ 7&7' '=3( 9>7' 3 &3")
) '"
'0
<?9 '"
&< $ 5 &0&
3& '
& 2 "79$ &3") @$'9$ <9 0 7&5'< ( & & ""&' (
$ 5 &0&) "
9>7' 3 7&3 $ *9
A B
'' $$ $ '&" '
&
9'
& * '& $ *9
9& 8'5 '"
&@ 97"
9'
&) '&
5
$ @& &9 &3)
9$ &8 $ @ 7 2 &9 733 9>7'"''
& 93'&8") 7&3 $ *9
A B
''' $$ $ @& &9 &3 $"
5"3 '8$
"" $ $ 9>7' 3 $"
<9 0 7&5'< ( & &""&' ()
& $ 7&3) $ $ $"
& <& 7' '=3)
) $ &'&7"
< $'"
""""'
&) 5& & 7&90&
$ @ 3 B
!" $ # % & $ ' (
& $ # %
&& $ )*+
) ! & $ )*+" " $$ # % , $-
# ) & ." / & $ )*+ & 0 0 , 1 " $ $ " $$2 3 * " $ " "/ .& "4$ )* & 0 0 %# !"
+$ # %" 4$ )*
"
$ !"4$ )*
1 " $ !
" $ ' ! &
"/ '
%+ " $ "/ 5
0 0& &2
'99'
7"
17< '9 17 1 " 01$"'"
"711 '3 %) $ ,6" 7 " $$ # % 5& "/ & $ )*+ 0 0 1
0 ++ ! 2 3
" / ' & 1 " $ $ # % " ' & $
8 23 !
23 1 " & +
9 & " / .& &
& +* ! 1
CD* +D/ E# + ! " $ $ # % 50& & $ )*+
0 0 CD* +D/ E# ++ ! - 23 ! " $ & $ )*+ CD* +D/ E# +++ ! ! &
0 0 5
;) .60-)( 3( , 0-3-(7632-%
B), -- (7(-2-,76-, (2--=7&?< 2& '8$ 7 %;"
*""
9''
&>
83.. ),,.
0 60 0,
!"#"$
%&'()&
&(%&(*)+(,-./01*(,)2/(3 ()12
&(%&(**(+2*%,4'( ()12