Chuni Lal v. The Commissioner And Others




    
    

 !"!#$  
   

 
  

%$  &'%  (
 )() % 
  &'%  (


) % 

 

 !"

#

$$$$

)() % 
*+ ', %



 #!
 '

() (* +(),  "

 '

-) (- +(). 
  

), (/ +()*

01 # .3 4# 



*# 1  
3   4 !"

)/5)3# 6 !"

74 ,3 4 ''      # 1 "

'  



2 *,'"   1 1 "

 

 

'

 '

'+5 (+ +((* # , 1    # 



82 *,  "



! 

+5 (+ +((*'"  1 1  2 ,.1 ' # 

  ,'  "

  #


:+:

*,      2 .  '          # ! '1 '"

 '    #

# '  

 # 1  ,' '   #

 ' '

 

'  1"8 

! 
   &      '   !#

     

! 
   &      '   '

 

  "   # '  

  

)+ )+ +((* ! 

)+ )+ +((* ,#    1 
    '  '"  '      +;

(;

+((;

 % #   1  ,1 
 '   )) )) +()(

, #  '

2 +-+/)# +()(    "        

  +5 (+ +((*  +;

(;

+((* )+ )+ +((*+;

(;

+((;)) )) +()(  % '

'  '

    +5 (, +()+     

  '      1"8   

! '  " 



 # #

  #     ""

  !#

  '       "     () (* +(),   %  

<  2 .      "      

() (* +(),1 ' #    '#



1   #   1    '  

-) (- +().1 



 ' #  

:-:

 " #

  = ) ;

  #     "" '  #

  

#      1

 '"' 1  

), (/ +()*

% #1 "

# #    

    #         2 ,  '        





 '"1

 82 *, ##  1



1   #    8





  
  #    " #

  

 
 '  '   '  

   +5 (, +()+ 1   '  # #

  #    1 

 #"

 1

 ' ' 

# 1  .'" 

. '

  " #

1

#     '"  1  1 


'

   1 

   >'

 1

 
 1 '


   8  

#"

 "  1 #

   " #



'

 # "  
 1 '

8  "   #"

1  "1 

:,:

.''

1  '#  "

1

1 1 

 ##  #1   "



  ''  

2   1

 1 

0 '# #"

"" "

# "      # 

# '

   1   
 1 '

 

 

)() % 
4   3

) % 
4        9

 8<  ?

<2 9

  1

?

<2