← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2806/2007allowed

Devender @ Dharmender v. Haryana Roadways And ORS.

2024-12-16Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages



     

     

 !

"#

!$%&%"'(

!$!)*!+  , -

!.!'/!+

1+)!'/!+ 22222233!44'

5&2 +6'

"/76&, %&+ '/ " 1!+& 222222!&3"'/!' & ( 89 :2 : :  :  

  

 

     

  

 













!  

 

   "  #

 $$$$ :  :

2

9 %



 '



 

(    )* )+ +)),

  #

 

 - %..

 /

 %011 '   

  # &'



2  3 &'

34   # #      # 5

   06)))5$

( 

 .7



 # 

    '



 /

    )8 %% +))+ +

   # 





#  

(  '   &'



         

:

   : '

::::

  9

:9:

  :

*       # $

  

# #  

 '   &'

 ( 

  $ 4 &  

#   ' ; +)7 4 <  

# (    

#       

   4 &

#

(  

    



#   '

  (  & 

 



'

(

#   '  

  (            ( #

   

( 

 

# #  

 '   &'

  '   & 

  #

"

        



  (    .



(    



  

  # 5

 '



 +*))5$

 #

  ( ## ( 

'  : (: - 



<    %1 '

 (   # $

 4 < 

  ( 

#   ' 

  '   =; $10 (

 ; +)7

;

4 <  #     

    



#   '

  (  



# (    

#       

  



  &  9       :9

9<  : ,

>'

#     (    #   (    '

;

  

= >?)+ 5&2 =6 >?)+ '/ '" 1!+

  :?3+!)!

"?+ &!& ;-;  

$         

     

    ! "#$"     "! %#"& ! !'" &       !

#$ !(!

( (! "!  "    (  !        &     !          # !'" # 

"#"      !

(#$& !%"! !  &"  & "(  $"    "! #& ! '"  #  &#  !  & $"&#"   "!  "" $"&



   #  !  #& ! "   #&$&     "!

$&!#" $" !  #&   "  "! "!  !

)* + )"#  ,&

+" " - ,./0)" *"1/2.

4  ( ! *,! 5!

  )**

 !

6  7"( #&/0*82/

   !  "!         !!    $"&    (9         :%   (         ;   !   " (! !  "%!"  5 ( ! (   $"! "!

 ! ! #$"! (9 5 (!"( !  < #  5    ""   (    "      ! #&

 ="" ! % ->" &!

(?  (  3 ( "( ! "

  '" $"  5  !@  (

 5%  ( (&

," $"&    # !!

&"!  !   !

,&"  $"&   ! !# ( !       #( !"! &   ! #    !  (""  (    "       ! #&  ""  !  %  !@  (

!%  %%% %%% %%% %%%    

   



 !  $" ! # ( $" ! " (  & 

 ( ! #&  

#!&  # "

!#  (  (  & "!&  (  (  &     (  ! #&%      #"  #  !"!  ( (  &    ( ! #&



!  ! $"!>   % !

 "#'"&  %  ! #&    (  !  &    ( !     %      ! #&

 (  &  (    # !#&  #"    ! & 

        ! #&  &  "    !  (         (    &    !   !!("  "" $# ( !"  !   "#$ 

 %

%%  

& 

%  

% '

 ()(9

$"!     (!10&  !

 (. 1000@>      !  3   !        ! #&        #    '"       $"&    20A  !     '"   ! #&  '" ! 10A

  (  &   !#&  #"    # !# "   "! & #"  ( ! * "    #  9 "  #  !9. 12000@> 5"" ( "

 A  "  9 . 800@> "  #   (9/

!

5"" (9 800%/ 9 . 00@> '

 (*(9

$"!  ! (!10&  ( . 1000@> 

4 ! " ! !   ! #& ! 20A 4   ! $# 

  "!    (  !  4       ((  &    &  #  ! ( &$#   &  &#  

 #"   !  "" (  & / * "     #  9

"    !9. 12000@> 5"" ( "

/ A  "  9. B/000@> "  #   (9/ !

5"" (9B/000%/ 9. 8 000@> '

 (+( 9

$"! B &  !  &  :(("!  "  !  

    (  !  " ! !  !

 ! #   ! /0A  $"!    !""    !  '"!      "( "   "" (  &   ! /0A

 "     #  9

 "

 "    "!

( !# &!   :( 9. 20000@> 5"" ( "

/0A %! "  9. 8B000@> "  #B &   9 !

5"" (98B000% 9. / 2000@> C-  9 

  ("  !!    "     !  6  

&  

("," *   # ! "    !!+"

  "

>'

#   

,   '  +- .



/0 @    : A    (

 - %.. %.*$

%.1  /

 %011  (

$ ? 



 ;

 #   @ 2A4 -     

  @ 24

    '

 

  @ 2?4   '       #     

 ;

 (  @ 2=4 < 

  

 



 

 (

#  '@ $#   ; 





#   

$

   &%  #"

 ,  "   #("   ! &             "  !  "  %  "! # . 000 . 80000 ! . 000 & 

(  !  !   # 6"  "!# >   '" "

>   7         "!  # !(   "   '" ! "!#  ! (# & &  !    "!#   0A    &  7 !! !# "  #( &   !

>'

#   

1  .

 1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34 

$ F/

     '"!#% !#& "9 

 %  %(5( 

%(6(<

  !  ""(  #  (      B1 & &(   $"!(   -  ," *  &5 !   &)  !G  B0/  *H  B/00  )*

 ,     82        !  $"!(    *"6 &  !  "  !# "!  !  #  )   )

!G  3  *  ! B00*H B)* ,  ((" >B &   "  #   (   ( %! #&

  ! &!"!#& ! " !) *  ! "   "   "# !     #   ! /

-

%  

%





   %78 ,          !            !

   !# !" H (!   IG B0*H0)*  !) ! + "$  "3 !I B0/*H/)*

7%  #  " H (! "   9 J  ,  (          & #     !

!## !

 "        &  ! #&   !  #&   !    !       !      

!        "    (       ( 9 

   "(  !   "

 "(     !<



5 "!("" < 

   #&            !       (    < 

! %"!(    & #'"!"! ""< ! 

5%  J C  "!D

  !  #  ;!   $"!(   ) !+ "$  " (   "  ! ( &"! !( &   # !'" &    "!    ! #&"!  ! ,  " "   %  ! #&     !

@  ;    ""

#! &K&  "(" B0H " &B01

 "$" !#"  "!9 J, % 9 

"! "  "

" 

 "# #  

"! "# #(   

 "1!8 I    (  ! 

"#  "(  " 

 "  " 

 "# #(  7  "!  (   %!       (     "   &           "(  !#& !" !) *      !  " 6   &      !  "$"    % ="  #!  1 ) !  + "$     "       &(  

"  !"" !   !   # !  7  ""'" &    

     !   !

   ( !  ""  "   # !      (   ! #& 1 A

'"     #  $"!( -  ," * 5!

  "   &  2 !(  (     "!# 0A  "   &   $ 





 

  

    "8 ,   !     !

!   !"( "  (A        $"!   "   "!(     H (! L "

G   (  

"!" !#&  !" !    !A    !#& *"

+0,+-9'0, 

"   ! &( !

  "   #&    "    & "! # !!  9 :

)  5     (    . 828%B%1 @00 . /@> =""     0    !!

. 80@> ! %"!(   ( "



. 8228@> 5   

    .

00000@> 5         

 !   (& .  0000@>   !"( . B00000@>

  . 821@>

   "! "#!    . 821@>   ! (       A "

  !    !   & 

9 %) " ( (  ( '

>'

#  

' 

#



(

(    )* )+ +)), #



 $ #    #  

    $ $

:+2 "2 !/& ")3!'& %"'

7+/!/ % "#  +*))5$ + < 

  8)7  0+)5$28)7 +*))4 *



"#  *1.8)5$2*++)C%+4 D  



 +)7  ,,+15$2+)7 *1.8)4   2%14  %*0%)85$2,,+1C%14 .



  %)))))5$ ,    *))))5$  ;

  ,))))5$ &       +))))5$ %)

    ++)))5$ %% D #    #  6)))5$ %+ <   #  +))))5$ %* D

#   0))))5$ " 4 ")3!'& %"'

&2-,B ,-C )"?'

7+/!/ *6 1!

+%*?'4  06)))5$ '1'$!/ )"?'

&2-,,-C

-,B ,- , %% -



 

 '

>'

#    

; *.

  

. B  ;

<. 0

 .$ , $ 

+ 



:?3+!)!

"?+ &!&  ,

 $ #   



   

# #     #

      F 

%+   "  #

     

# #  

(  ( &'

(

 ( # #     

# &'

 '

  

# #  



( 

  # 5

  # 5

    '

:

   &'

%* "  #

 '  '

     



!  

  (

 (   #      

# %8 ?  

 %6 

  



   

:  :

 

!$!)*!+  , - 



G :5$ : :

G   '

H