High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2807/2007allowed

Manoj Kumar v. Haryana Roadways And ORS.

2024-12-16Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma10 pages

#$%$!&'

# () * +, -

&!.

/0( * 11111122 33 & 4%1 *5 &

5%, $% *

&6 !8 *% 111111 %2!&6 &% '

;1 ; ; ;

" #

$$$$ ; ;

: %

( )* )+ +)),

- %..

%011 '

# &'

2 3 &'

34 # # # 5

,,)))5$

(

)7 %% +))+ +

# #

( ' &'

9 '

; ;;;

;:;

;

* # $

' &'

(

$ 4 &

# ' : %+6 4 ;

# (

4 &

(

# '

( &

(

# '

( ( #

(

# #

' &'

' &

( .

(

# 5

+*))5$

( ## # (

' 9 (9 -

;

# %1 '

( # $

4 ;

(

# '

' =: $%0 (

: %+6 4 ;

# '

(

# (

& 8 ;:

:= ; ,

# ( # ( '

/0( * 4%1 .

/0( *

&6 &!8 *

;02* ( !0* % % <-<

! "#$" "! %#"& ! !'" & !

#$ !(!

( (! "! " ( ! & ! # !'" #

"#" !

(#$& !%"! ! &" & "( $" "! #& ! '" # &# ! & $"&#" "! "" $"&

# ! #& ! " #&$& "!

$&!#" $" ! #& " "! "! !

)* + )"# ,&

+" " - ,./0)" *"1/2.

4 ( ! *,! 5!

)**

6 7"( #&/0*82/

! "! !! $"& (9

:% ( ; ! " (! ! "%!" 5 ( ! ( $"! "!

! ! #$"! (9 5 (!"( ! < # 5 "" ( " ! #& ="" ! % ->" &!

(? ( 3 ( "( ! "

'" $" 5 !@ (

5% ( (&

," $"& # !!

&"! ! !

,&" $"& ! !# ( ! #( !"! & ! # ! ("" ( " ! #& "" ! % !@ (

!% %%% %%% %%% %%%

! $" ! # ( $" ! " ( &

( ! #&

#!& # "

!# ( ( & "!& ( ( & ( ! #&% #" # !"! ( ( & ( ! #&

! ! $"!> % !

"#'"& % ! #& ( ! & ( ! % ! #&

( & ( # !#& #" ! &

! #& & " ! ( ( & ! !!(" "" $# ( !" ! "#$

% '

()(9

$"! (!10& !

(. 1000@> ! 3 ! ! #& # '" $"& 20A ! '" ! #& '" ! 10A

( & !#& #"

# !# " "! & #" ( ! * " # 9 " # !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "

A " 9 . 800@> " # (9/ !

5"" (9 800%/ 9 . 00@> '

(*(9

$"! ! (!10& ( . 1000@>

4 ! " ! ! ! #& ! 20A 4 ! $#

"! ( ! 4 (( & & # ! ( &$# & &#

#" ! "" ( & / * " # 9

" !9. 12000@> # 5"" ( "

/ A " 9. B/000@> " # (9/ !

5"" (9B/000%/ 9. 8 000@> '

(+( 9

$"! B & ! & :(("! " !

( ! " ! ! !

! # ! /0A $"! !"" ! '"! "( " "" ( & ! /0A

" # 9

" "!

( !# &! :( 9. 20000@> # 5"" ( "

/0A %! " 9. 8B000@> " #B & 9 !

5"" (98B000% 9. / 2000@> C- 9

(" !! " ! 6

("," * # ! " !!+"

, ' +- .

/0 > + ; +?

(

- %.. %.*$

%.1 /

%011 (

$ ?

# # @

2A4 - #

@ 24

# @ 2?4 ' # #

( @ 2=4 ;

(

# '@ $# :

&% #"

, " #(" ! & " ! " % "! # . 000 . 80000 ! . 000 &

( ! ! # 6" "!# > '" "

> 7 "! # !( " '" ! "!# ! (# & & ! "!# 0A & 7 !! !# " #( & !

1 .

$+- "#"#)+2"34

$ F/

'"!#% !#& "9

% %(5(

%(6(<

! ""( # ( B1 & &( $"!( - ," * &5 ! &) !G B0/ *H B/00 )*

, 82 ! $"!( *"6 & ! " !# "! ! # ) )

!G 3 * ! B00*H B)* , ((" >B & " # ( ( %! #&

! &!"!#& ! " !) * ! " " "# ! # ! /

%78 , ! !

!# !" H (! IG B0*H0)* !) ! + "$ "3 !I B0/*H/)*

7% # " H (! " 9

J , ( & # !

!## !

" & ! #& ! #& ! ! !

! " ( ( 9

"( ! "

"( !<

5 "!("" <

#& ! ( <

! %"!( & #'"!"! ""< !

5% J C "!D

! # ;! $"!( ) !+ "$ " ( " ! ( &"! !( & # !'" & "! ! #&"! ! , " " % ! #& !

@ ; ""

#! &K& "(" B0H " &B01

"$" !#" "!9 J, % 9

"! " "

"# #

"! "# #(

"1!8 I ( !

"# "( "

" "

"# #( 7 "! ( %! ( " & "( !#& !" !) * ! " 6 & ! "$" % =" #! 1 ) ! + "$ " &(

" !"" ! ! # ! 7 ""'" &

! !

( ! "" " # ! ( ! #& 1 A

'" # $"!( - ," * 5!

" & 2 !( (

"!# 0A " & $

"8 , ! !

! !"( " (A $"! " "!( H (! L "

G ( "!" !#& !" ! !A !#& *"

+0,+-9'0,

" ! &( !

" #& " & "! # !! 9 :

) 5 ( . 828%B%1 @00 . /@> ="" 0 !!

. 80@> ! %"!( ( "

. 8228@> 5

00000@> 5

! (& . 0000@> !"( . B00000@>

. 821@>

"! "#! . 821@> ! ( A "

! ! &

: %) " ( ( ( '

(

)* )+ +)), #

$ # #

# $ $ ;*1 !1 6% !(2 &% $!& 7 *6 6 % "# +*))5 + ;

7)6 0+)5$27)6 +*))4 *

"# *1.7)5$2*++)C%+4 D

# %+6 7.*,5$2%+6 *1.7)4 < 2%14 1*7..5$ .

1))))5$ , +))))5$ :

.))))5$ & %<)))5$ %)

+))))5$ %% D #

# <)))5$ %+ ;

# +))))5$ %* D

# 1))))5$ !

!(2 &% $!& %1<,<,-++A (!0& 7 *6 6 )5

*$)0& ,,)))5$ &8 &# 6

(!0& %1<,+,-++A

<,<,-++ , %% -

; *.

. @ < +

<. 0

.$ , $

;02* ( !0* % % ,

$ #

# # #

%+ " #

# #

( ( &'

(

( # #

# &'

# #

(

# 5

%* " #

' '

(

( #

# %7 ?

; ;

# () * +, -

G 95$ 9 9

G '