High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/434/2014disposed of

Suman & ANR v. State Of Haryana

2024-11-11Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra8 pages

IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH

, -.+. ##

) ###/.. + *++ + ###+0

# $%&'"

& .

/- ,+ Mr. Neeraj Poswal, AAG, Ha aryana.

& ( $#

0, + , 1 & ,&&

+1( , & -& , 2 & '

!"!

#$%

" ') ) $ &' ('*, 1(,+*,&

&( + ,1&

' * *, ' ) $ * 4 + + ( * *, & & 0, + ,& ,&&,

)+1(, &- &'2 '

&-++&

%- &

*,1 1(*,& +,&,

& 3 +1(,&

, ++&,+* - & &,+ + , 5, + , ,4,1+1 11,+ ', +,&& ,+

+ 1( 1&* , 5 1 +1 , & 1 , *,, , +( 1( + 41+1 1+7 -1,+ ,1,& &(1( (, & + + ,1& ' *,'

')$ ,(

0,+,,& ++&1 ,&++&& ,,1 , ( 0, + , , + , +

)

+&(,* * + ,+(, +1, 0, + 1&,&1 ( ,*,&* , 0, + + + , ( - + ( + , & (), ( (*,+ (

) + ,

& ) , 6( 0,+ & , & , ( 0,( ,* 1 & ( , & ,+ 0 ,(&,++(+ &

&*, ,& 8& &,+, ,,+ &,1 +1

(,1 &1(,+ ' + *,,, +, , &1 1 ,( & ( , > ' & , 1

,&+( 1(,+

:,+( 1(,+& ,+ 1& ,&5 ,&*,+ 0, 1 , ,1-1 1(891&-+4

! "

#$ %

8 ?1& '

*,&,+ +,1-,,& &

;0,1< -* * , * + , & +1 ,*, 0, 1 , - + , ( , & 1 & & , *, , & , ( , & + & 0, 11 3 * *, ,+, &+&(*, ,, , & 1 1 1 , & 1

+ = ,1 &,( ,+ &

-&, , , 1 , & 1& ,1 1 &11 ( & (

*, ( +,* ,& ;

%&&1+&

+ +

, ,- !

& #

% *

( ! "

#$ )) )*, 8?1& '

, 5 , & * %& + +, * ? @ + A ;0,1< - 1 & *, + , ( 1 &&( ,1& ( - &, & &&(1 ,*+ , & 1 , *,, , ( + && 0, (&(* *, & , & *,, , ,(* *,,,( ( + + + , , 1 $& + ,,1 , , &&( ( * ,& , ,= 5 :

, * *, (,+, ,,( (1 1&&( 5 &*( &, ,(&+(,& & 1(, *+( 0,1 < - , + & & , +1 ( *,1( , 1 ,1& ( - &5&*, ,, *, &+,5, , ,& (1& 0, 1 ,1< <-+, ,1 B-'5 51+1( *,,+ *, , (

1 , 15 + , 9 & & , & ,, @C&,2 &

@ 6A + A C C* % '

,& @+& &( ), C @ 6)"A+A ; "

$*,&* &*

,3 ,1, ,*,,,+ & ,1+1 7$,+ , ,*,3 1,

0, 1 &( , + ') , 1 < -

' D ,, 1 & & , & 5 , & *,, ,( &5&( 1 4+ & , *,,,,1 &&, & 0 0, ( & , , *&& , * & , 0,*

&&&( ,, , , * & +,+ & 1 4 4 +

& &,&, (*,& ,+, * , , , (

+ + , 1 1 ' , 1 - 0 0, +1(,5+ ,( &3 ! *( , +1&( & *, , & ,&& 0, ,1&+, , 1&1 &&(

2 * 0,&,& & ++1&* + + &(+, *,,,(* & + 0,(++ *,,+& , && , +1 &* , *, , & 1 , *, , ( (*5, + :(+& , +1, , ,, && & ,& ,+ 1 & ,+ +*,,3

, , ( + $ ,&+ & * & 1( 5+ ( *( , + '

& *, &, +1 *, '

"#$ % &

0,, &,1 & + , 1 - * & & , 1 & ') ,+, & ,,+ , '* &,,& &&+&, 1 , &&& ,1( , , +& +* &, +15+ , , ,, , , &

3 *,

>5* ') , 1 - + & , * ( + &( , + , ,1& *, , , + & 1( *,, , + & &(,+,, , , & , , ,,, 4+ &,+1 ,*, (, ( , &* , 1 ,

( , (+ ,,, 1 & ,1*, ,*, ++ *, && + , + 4 , , (, , (, 5+,+ 1 1 , 0,&'

&,5*&, & 4 ,&&+

0, * , 1 * *,& 5 , ( *,, , + , ,

+&++& , &(, , , ,+, &+ +* &1 1( , & ,+ , + ,( 1 & +1 - &(,+ 1&+1 , , +&1@*, ,A, % ! , *,

(,&5 1 ,&& , , ,( * & 5+ , + 1 1, + *(,+ ,,&& &

4 , , + @A +, 1@A 1 , & , , 1 & , , ,( 1 & (&&&, * ,1(,&& ,&&

- , , + ,1( , +

+,& 8* , &( , 4 , + ,1

& , & 3 +& *&&&&* *&( (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE ##

Whet Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No ther reportable Yes/No