Veena Rani And ORS. v. Mahipal And ORS.











 
  















 



 

 !

"#
$ 
% 
 
&'

(())

$'

*

&()
 
&'

% ( 


 
 
 
  
  +'

'
 *',
- .
/.

0&&.
/
 

1# &.
/
'
&
(()) '
%2  &
)&'.
/
 

 /
$'#.
/
'
' (  
13

*' 
0#( 4
 
 

  



6&


(()
* '
"
!

0+0
'
)  ,
& ' 
(()
'
#
*)


&' ,
'
&
'



&
(() .
&
#

))7 
&
#
 

8

9'
4
 )
'
 )
 ( )

!" #

6&
(' 
(()
&
:
('''
,


&
7'




!
(



&
)#
(
)
* '
"



&
'

$&)
.

:4
&
)'


'
 
0)#
6':* ).
; '

'
&'.
<&
6':* )=
'
 & # 

#(


,' 

& )#

&
* 

%

. .

>

* 

&

;?
-&#:



'
$&*)'
 .
*''





 )


*
'
'# 

&
(' 
(()

   
@* *#

#(


7'
:4
&
)'


6':* ).

)

''

&


&
 
 
'@*'

:
'('*
'
&
8 
:'/4  

 
 


  6&
)'


*

)
'
&
)# (())
  
& &
#* 



:4
&
)'


6':* )


&
)7'

   '/

:
 & 
6&''.
&
)# (())
('4
&
& (' 
(()
:
))7
 
#(


:
 & 

('
) 
)7 +'
 '.
)'


*

)
'
&
' (  
13

*'  0#( 4
/&# )4
',*
&
&
)'


6':* )
&
''

,'  , #(



&
)# >(()) 
6&''.
&
('4
'
 #

) 
&
(() !
3
&/
&'
)'


*

)
'
&
('
 
('* 
& 7&)
''

&
 
$

    ; =:)
&
"*('#
0*'

&
 

Sarla Verma Vs.

Delhi Transport Corporation and Another % "

&'()*)
+&(, -.).
! !/.
)
7
&
)7



# 

#(


 
& ')/ 
('

&
#
'

* '

B30
 

    

    

      

     

 



 

    
        







     


    

            

    

  

 !"#$      



%#  !"&$      

 &'   !"($      




31
)

       

                   
 *      (+,         





 

       


-  



  

        

        $   

    
.  /

 



         

           

    
*  

 



                  

    



 

             

        
32
       

           

                        (+,         

  (+,      
       

A
   

  

                                  



 

      

     
* * * * * 42.)     

 

    &$      

    0

   1           $        !2  

 !(%+ %!%(

 $ 

   



  3!4%'#+

 3!'#! #(

 3!(#'&+

 3!&&!&(

   3!#&'(+

   

   



  3!!(!((

 35(''+

 34'!'(

  3(''4+

 ; =:)
"*('#
0*'

&
 

)

National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. % !0
!

#/
&

)'
&
)7
') ,

"



.
 
 


&
'

$&)
.
 .

&
))7 ,
 (

 *

('

)
 
)/ ,
C(


'# #*)() D

9 ")

#*)()'
(  ,

,

 D

0 ,

 

:
'
(()4 ,
#*)()'D

 % :)
,*'

 /  )
& .
#)4.
)

!

 .
)




'*#
 
* ')
C(

.
7& )

E **'
(' (
'
))
,'

('

 
'

' 
,

7&
('# 
2:D
)#()4
'
C

)'4
6&
')/ 
('

&
2*,# 

'('*

* '

B52. 6  conventional heads 

    

   

 7/

8
 *        7
%(+++     



7 !+++++ 

   7

!+++++ 

   

  


    

     

 

   
7/

  0      

  

     

 

              



  

   

  



         

  
 : 

     

            

  
6        

 
          

     



 

    


   

  

  

   


; 

  

    

  

 

 
  

      

 

  



                    

  
    

  

 * 

           

 

         

  

  

   

 

    

 7
!(+++
&++++ 7
!(+++


          

  
<       

   

 )               

 



   

   

 

  !+,   


 ) 

 

 



  

 



  = = = = 59.3
)   

  (+,    



 



 /     &+

        #+, 

  

&+(+


* 



 

 (+'+

    

!(,
6         

 

59.4
* 







 $              &+,    



  



   &+


6  %(,

  

 &+(+

  !+, 

  

 (+'+

    








 

    
59.5
 .             

       

  

       #+#%0 > ?    

    59.6.

            0> @ &% /


59.7
 

        
59.8
7   

        





 

     

    7  !(+++  7  &++++     7  !(+++


 

    

  !+,  


A ; =:)
"*('#
0*'

 
)

-1*-
)2)(-3

 
2.&(-24)
+*'-25
6*6,)7
8.
-2&
-*
-36-.
9&9(&
-*
:

,9)(.
% !#!#

!;/
'


' ,

-(3-
8)(*-
.&'(-
 

(-2-5
),96
&'(-
& )
&
)7
',' ,


'*#

%)/ ('

&
#
'
'('*

* '

B21
6  <

  C  0 8        

 

    

;

  




 *     

  D  D    

      



 D  

 D  D    D     D

 D
    

           

  

   

 

  

  
)

 

 

   

 

%!
!
Spousal consortium  

   

                     

    



      

  

    /  D
%!
%
Parental consortium     



     

D  

   

     

   

     D
%!
#
Filial consortium             

  

 

   


6 

      



       


 

   

     

     

 

          
22
       

  

  

      

       3  /     

 



  E  

  

   

  
3 /      

 

   

   

 
      

    

        

      

  

 
 23
 3> 

6  

    

     

  

 

  

* 

     

         

   

         
 C          

 

     



      6 
 6           

    
      



  

  

      

 

 
24
        

         

     

 

   D

  D   C  0 8
*  







           

   7 &++++ 

 






 
('* )

&
''
&7
&
&
,

&
 
7

!
4'


,

&
#

 
6&
*#

,
 
 (*
:4 &'

&
('4
:'
&
0*'
0

@* )4.
&
,

 


8

!
4'

3

*)4
/ 
'#
&
7'
&
+F;*8#
" ,&.

0)'8
&
('/
&
)'4

 

% .

 >
+
/
EC+

)'4
'

('* )

EC+
")'4
'
&7
&
& ,'

)'4

&
 
7
% .

 >
+
:*
'
*

*&
G+.
'
/ .
G3".
&
 
7
, ,
%   >
+
6& 6':* )
&


'
&
''4
&#
)'4

&
 

%   > +
7&)
)*) ,
&
#(

 
6&
?
6':* )
&
''


,
# &)4
)'4

&
 .



)
('( 

)7 &
))7 
 
('@* 
#* 
:


&
: 
)'4
'

'# ,
&
*)
)'4

&
 .
 
**'
(' (
#* 
: (()
&''
 '/'.
&
; =:)
"*('#
0*'


' 
 


Meenakshi v. Oriental Insurance Company, 2024 INSC 583
&
*'&'

' '
&
(  
6&
')/ 
C'

&
#

'('*



* '

!+
    

 

  

              

     

  



 


   

      /          

   

    (+, 

  

  

   



      
 !!
      

    

    F
 !  * 

            

₹

         !+&+!+++"

7

;

      $ 

₹

 

  &5(4+#(" 7

.    

       $
!%
)            

 

  

            

      

 

 



 3

'
)7
&
 )4
 #
C


:
*
'#
& ,'

)'4
'
'# 

&
*)
)'4

&
 

&' -*,
9 &

&
; =:)
"*('#
0*'

Vijay Kumar Rastogi Vs.

Uttar Pradesh State Roadways Transport Corporation AIR 2018 Supreme Court 819
&
,'))4
&)
&
&
 #

:


'
'

'# ,
#(


* '
&
'
$&)

 )* 


#')4
&

)'4
'
8&#
(4
:*
&
C:)
 #.
 )* /
 ))
))7 
 
('@*  
6&
')/ 
C'

&

2*,# :

'/

))7

B*     

  

 

              

   

   7
44&2+"   $               7
&&5'"      

  

      

    7
&&(!!"
* 

  



    



    

 

 

  
    /      

       

     

  

   / 

    National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Indira Srivastava and Ors.1  

  Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs. Jashuben and Ors.2  Kavita Vs. Deepak and Ors.3 * 

  B

  



    



 

        



 



 

 

    

         


A  0

@* )4.

/7

&
)'4
'
EC+
  2*,# 

; =:)
(C
0*'

Meenakshi Vs. Oriental Insurance Company's case

*('
6&
# &)4
)'4

 






%  . >
'
* ,
&
C
"
'

&
#*)()'

 '

.
& )'


6':* )
''

)7

(()4 ,
&
#*)()'






.



/7

&
)7
)
7
:4
; =:)
"*('#
0*'

Sarla Verma's case (supra). 6&
?
6':* )
) 

7'
 4
#* 
'
**' (' (
 
)


 
'/'.
&
#* 
7'
'
* ') C(

 
)




'*#


&
)7'

 
 '/

: & 
6&''.
&
7'
'@*'
 *), 

&
0*'     A
/7

&
)7
)
7
:4
&
; =:)
"*('#
0*'

& :/
'''

2*,# .
&
(' 
(()

))7
6&
7'




!

#
' ,)4
6&
(()) )#
'
&)
 )
 & 
#*

#(



('
&
)*)

#
&'* '

Sr. No.

Heads Compensation Awarded  &)4
3 #

%   >   A **'
(' (
H
!I %

>
!I

    *
7'
('

) C( *'
>' %

 >

J
>' 6)
3 #
% A

  *)()'
 !



*)
(  4
%  . . >

AJJ ?


E  %  .

> * ')
EC(

%  .

> ?


0

'*# % .AA.

> "(* )



% 
A .

>C +' )


% 
A .

>C  +,-3
+*')2.-,6+2

. !0"

#<

)7&4,6+2
#* 
7'
:4
&
6':* )

. # <

A
 29-24)7
-*+&2,

.!;;

"

#<
 !0"

#

#  !

"
'

&
 ' 
('

 '

.

&)
:4
; =:) "*('#
0*'

Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma !"

;!0
 
R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation
  

&'()*)
+&(,
-.).
!0
&
(()) )#

'
,' 
 ' 
H
I
('


*#

&
 & 
#* 
 #(


'#
&


) ,

)#
(
))
&




')K

6&
3

*' 
0#( 4' (  
1


'

(  &
 & 
#* 

#(


) ,
7&
 ' 
7&
&
6':* ) 7&

('

7
# &
'#
&
'(

(4

&
2*,# 
6& 6':* )

'

 :*'


&
 & 
#* 

#(


) , 7&
 ' 

&
*

&
)# >(())

('
7'




!
6&
)# >(())
'
'

*'

&
&'
: * 
)

&
6':* ) *'&'
3

*' 
0#( 4

'

 :*'


&
*''

&*)


'
%2  &
)&'.
/.
(*'

* 

''
 A
(




1 



:4
&
0*'.

7&

(' 
7 4
4
'#
&


'(

(4

&
2*,# +  ,
(()

.

 4.
) 
 
 ( 
 !!0

  
  G

  $9),9)(
.')-=621<()-.+2)7

).<+ $9),9)(
()'+(,->3)

).<+