← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2872/2007allowed

Santosh Etc v. Satbir @ Kalia And ORS

2025-03-25Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

 

    

   



!

"#$# %& '"( )* )     

           &  +, -.

-  -

-    

   

   !"

    #$  % & ''''

-

-

.

(       

        "      ) 

*++**++,        (--  .   

(/00&  

 %  )1

 2 34     "     * /0 +++5#")  ,67  



  "

.  

  

 *8+8*++9 *

     

    :   ) &             ;& - -- -  ,   -, 

 - 8      #

       &    )            &           

    )  

         ) 9        #$  % &

)  &"   )  "

&   

        &    "

& "   &     

 6 $          )         -

  ) )     ) 66& " 

  ) <   ) ""   6((85#

     

 ) )""&   86++5#

  $  &   ) <   ) ""

  6((85#          &

 =<> ?    ) )   ) )

   ""   86++5# 

  

     %) &"  @ " %#  A

  %   Santosh and others vs. Mahavir and others

  ?

BC0-80#*+(9  +0(**+(,  ;

 )  )     &  

& ) )     (-(85#

 :      &:      (-(8D((D(*E(59 1   <   4F ( 6/ ,*+5#   

  )# -'.

.

/ 0 1%

( $ 1 E?& 4 (-(85#16((8#86++4 * G  )

  <  (59

 9+85#1(-(8D(59 8 $   (*(+5#1(-(8#9+84 9   (( 6

G &  ( 6/ ,*+5#1(*(+D(*D((4

,

   ) );" 

 ""

 -+,65#    &  )  &  &)&   =<A

        )               )"&          8+++5# 

    ) );"   

   )  ""   -+,65#    

     &

 =<A>)     ) "

 <      (5*  (59      ) &   )  <           )  

      ) :  "   % -

, ,3

 -

0 >3     %           Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 45

-17'0  1'

$$  8 

) )             # H30     

            

    

       

             

   

     

 

      

 

     

           

  

         !"#$           

 %#  !"&$

  

 &'   !"($      



 31)

        

        *  

         (+,                  







 

   

  

-  

    

 

      

      

 $           .  /

 

           

                *  

 



          



                32 

         

        (+,        

    (+,                    



 

         

             



 

        

    * * * * * * 42. )     

 

    &$          0

 1   $        !2    !(%+ %! %(

$ 

    

 3!4 %'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3

) !&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

  



   

 3!!(!((

35 (''+

34'!'(

 3(''4+

/ >3 %  National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 4 

- 68    )   (-- (-8#  (-0 .   

(/00  )"

 # G          "  <          I 1A4    ""   I 1%4

"     

&" I 1G4    "     

 &           <   )  I 1=4 ?   "       " ) @I # & <  &    @ "    # H52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 7/

8*

    7 %(+++       

  7  !+++++  

  7 !+++++ 

 

        

      

   7/

  0  9 

 





       



   

 

  



  

   :    

        6      

             

     



 



    

   

  

  

   

  ; 

       

       

  

       

     



   

  

             

   

*

   



        

 



 

       

    7 !(+++ &++++     7 !(+++  

                  

   <

    

   

 )                         

   

 

   



  

    !+,    

)   

 



  

 



  = = = = = 59.3)    

  (+,    

 





 / 

  &+

    

 #+, 

  

&+(+

* 

  

 (+'+



    !(, 6   

    

 59.4* 







 $ 

   &+,

  



  

    &+

6  %(,

  

 &+(+

 !+,

  

(+'+

   

    

  

     59.5.              

          #+#%0> ?  



    59.6. 



         

  0> @ &%/

 59.7 

        59.87   

        

 



 

    

 7

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++

   

    

  !+,  

A (+ >3     %            :0

%'

;

%$1'

%"

 07 %< ,#0# / =$.

%1

;# $ (1('1  ('$ 4  

- 28    " - ';

='0 $17'



'

% < - (# -17'

   )" "  

      # B216  <

  C  0 8         

  

         

  ;

   

      

 

*  

D D  

   



 D    D  D 

D D D 

            



 

 

  



    )  

      

       

  



%!! Spousal consortium   

        

         

    



D 

   

     

 /  D %!% Parental consortium      



              

   D    

   

     

   

     D %!# Filial consortium             

  

 

   6

      

          

 

   

    

     

              22  



 

     

       3 /     

 

  

E    

 

       

   

 3 /                

   

            

 

  

      

 23 3>  

6  

    

      

  

 

  

* 

       

             

               

C       

      

    6 6     

    

      

  

   

           

   

24   

   

    

 

   D

 D   C  0 8*  





  

  

   7 &++++  

  ,-

(( $) ) )& >3 %  @ "  

 )  ) 

*++**++,      

 "&     

 #                 # # Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded (  &$   -+,65# * ?  (67  /((5#1(67-+,64 G   )   < (59   (,9,5#1-/0-D(594 9 $   6*8/5#1-/0-#(,9,4   ((

G &  - /( 6905#16*8/D(*D((4 -  =   (0 +++5# , ?=<    (0 +++5#  %   ( /* +++5#   90 +++5#<(  90 +++5#<8

;

$.5* 5*)9> //# # %

  &: 

  $. *)5*>

;

 07%$

# % $. *5*6> 5 5)9? )5

/1"

# %

 ) &  $.*5*> %( %"/

0 1%

$.* *6>  565

(*        

  &>3  %Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma  5  2 6  R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation 

)

-17'0  1'

$$ * 

 #  "   /7     "     J (8  

      



                  

      

              

         

            

 

        



       )  *++**++, ! >)   #$  % &          C( * 

)  "    )  *++**++, (6 ?   $    % &                

  !"

  )   )& & 

    &  @ " "     #$%&$&! '()*  +#& &$$%

  + , 

 -.      

-

-







*6 *+*6 !   K   ;"5# ;"

 5C K