The Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Seema And Others
!!"#$#%&' (! )#!% *%$+) %"!,- %./#,# !0 1--!** % 2!)$+$ 3!!, %0 (!)$ 1 !$-%0!% $
4
(! )#!% *%$+) %"!,- %./#,# !0 1--!** % 2!)$+$ %5+ %# %0 (!)$ !$-%0!% $ & 6/
327 8/
27 8/9 /
!" !# $!$% & '()
* + '), ( -#.. /#011+ /, $ 2( 3$$ #$ $!$# & 4 (& 5 ( 6 5 ( * 7 *8
& 9 ) ( & (( 45 (65 (*
-2- 4(1!!!!!!: ( &7*8 (( 5 #' "
; $$ #$ $!$# -2 <( -4 ( & 4 & &44 8 ) - =* >4 >'5 & 4 & (4 (& &4 2( -'&* = ; $"
#$ $!$# - -4 4 ( $$ #$ $!$#5 (74*( 3 ( 3& 3(* 5 ( 7 (& 44 >5 0# ?"1$(3 )/- - -4 (& 4 4 @ >5 !% ' 0$.? (3 88 A & 38 B4 - ' 4 4 @ >5 =% ' =%.?+4, 4 & & 4 44((( 4 34(& 4 &5 (
5 (7444 (&4 >4 ( 4 5 (7 ( 8
-3- % 4B254 -#?"' '
(4 4 .
)( 2 (
& 4@ #$ ( @ . ? ( ) (& (4 &4 ( ?
B( 4 4 (
!"#$%&$ %&'( ! # ) *
+
,- . ! / 0
) ) / 0) ) 0),- 1
)
)
),-# %
)
) ,-# &
)
) $+ $+
,-# ' !0
)
,-#213
-4- ( # 4 ) ') 5 ( 793 44 4 4 & 4 C ( (45 ( $=& >
(/'(&% .& DB (D9 . & 5 ##$#0: ( >( ( 5 $!!!!: ( > &( ( & &'(( * 5 #%0%=: ( 4 ( 94(( !
. ) 5
/(2%3##2
36 5 ) 57 8 / 6 213 ## 2
3 ((( ( ".11="$: ( #!
7*8 ( $#&( 344 5 %!!!!: ( ) ')4$#& - ( 4 ( 34 ( & &'((* 5 #%0%=: ( 4 ( 9 4 (( ! . ) 5
2 3 5
-55 7 8 2 3/ ( 5 $==$$11: ( ## - 4 44 &&4 2 '(& #$ 44 & (& #"
) 4 ( & ')4( & & '(( * ( (( ( 4 &- ( #= )' 4 ( &
( ( ) 8 4( 4 (( ( 4 ( ( A4#0=1 49 & &'((( &( 4 4& 4((( ) 3 &' ' 8 4( & 9:-!1((( !
. ; < ) # )
&%= 9:-!116'
!0.
: ; ) 7
6&=> 8 4(& 3 2!
. ) ; > 7
-6-
9:-!(=
1'
' E( )&
&2 '(& 5 8 4( ' # )? . ) ; @
62138'=% )' (&8 4(>F 9' & 4(< "
&2(3 &/# )
>
/#
):
. ) ; 2131' (&( (( ( 4 (& &3 3 ( ( & ( 2 & >F 9 ' ' ( 3 ( (C & (&&4 4 & 2 ( 8 & 3 ( 9 C & ( ) 2 '(& 4
(( &'((
)4' A .
# )? . ) ;
) B
2 3/
)
) ))0
> ))
:
/ 6%= 0
0
.
& C
-7A& . +
) "B ) D
+ ) > 5
:
)
/
)
) )
+ ) )) 0
)
> ))
:
0 + !
/ ) )
0
)
)/ ) 0
)
8 )
0
)
8
)
) E
8 8 D 0 0) ))0
E > ))
:
0
) 0 ) +
0
8 )
0/ 0
0
4 "F )
< " 5
G- /&2(3&/ C$ %
E )
)
0 ) ) , ) +
) "
8 :
E )
/
0 0
)
/ %/&D$ ) :
? )
-8- >
1> ))
:
/ 6%=/ )
=D$
/ 0 0
) ))0
) ) ) > ))0
/ ? )!
)
)
) ) )
E8 /0 0 0 +
B
0
# &D$
2# %/&D$ ) #&%/D$ )3 0
)
0
+ 9 /8 0 ) ) ) #&/D$ ) ) # ('/&D$ 2# %/&H()3A .
A# )
>
/ #
) :
. ) ;
) I J213 1'K"B ) C A%.
/
1& 0 0 0 # %&D$ ) )
8
) 8 )#1D$ ) 0
L %/0 #D$
8 ) 0 @ / . ) 0 /
)
) 8 / 0
)
)
) ) ) # 1D$ ) / 0 0 /0
E ) )
-9-
).
))
) /
0/
/8
)
)
) / 8
)
) )
.
.
/
) )
E
) )
/8 )
) )
) ) ) 0 /0
)
).
/ 0 0
/0
0 0 # D$ &D$
# %&D$ ) .
0/
)0
/ / 8 ) ) # %&D$ # 1D$ )/ /
) ) 0 #%&DA 1; $ ) ) ) /
/
> ))
:
/ 6%= "0 / $ ) 0 0 0
) ) 8 )
> ))
:
/6%= %80 ) /> 7 / ! / 0 E E ) $ $ 0 > 0 )#/D$ ) 0
) / ) 0 #%/'D$
-10- )
7 )) /
) &. ) ))0
)
) )
) .
0 +
) "B ) ) 0
)
)
)
"0 / ) )/
) +/ 0
0
) E
)
.
/
0 ( B )
)
0/) ) 8)
& ' 2 ! 1/ 38 ) 0
/ )
/ /0
8 )
) ) )
)
)
A #% 2 (8 4( @ 2 '(& <
&>F 9' -< 4 -<@ #$0."$!$$@2 '(&<
( &>F 9' != !1 $!$$ ( 3 &' ' && 8 4($= !"
$!$"B;@ #=="$!$" @2 '(&< - '
( 8 4($.
!1 $!$$
-11B; "%1" $!$$ G 2 2 '(& <( 58 -4 2 )
C &E ( )' 4( 38 4( (8 4( & ( H #.
54 & 4 5 ( 4 $= & ( 4 && 4 ( -(&7*8 & 4$#&4 (& & &44 #?
2' 4(& (5 #%0%=: & & '((*934 37$!$# & & 4(& 2
( ( ( >, - (' 2
M M
# ) 5 > ) *
/2%3##2
3%6( 4 3 ( ( 4 ( 44( 5&4 8 4( 4 4
-12- ' & 4& & ') 4 ) 42&( (4&( 4& 27 8/ +*.9 53 A34: 7:@ A 7:@