M/S Excel Group v. The General Manager,Northern Railway And ANR
!"#"$%&'()
*+,-
. /#&# - ) -0+
%1 2-
+ +-+--
!"#"$%
! "#$%
&&& -+--) '! " ( ) ! +$ ,,) ! -.!/$!* 0!" 0" 0
, 1
, 2"
3 $2"*4! 5"* !"
"2" 0
, 1
," *4! $"4!!
2"
364"*7!$4!!4"7
*7! 6 8
2"
31$ 90! : ;" ! %<0 4"*7! )
2"
3,
+" 8 !0 = " ! "* ! $ *"7 0 < 0 "4!!! 4 *07 4% $ ! *<0" ! 4 ! " $ "* $ 20 ! 0" ;" $"
>
!0 "
* 0%
<0!4
! '!$"* $ ! % " 1
2"
3 >$ 0 *9! "
*0*7!
$4!! 0 !"
5 4 "
! ! ! $ !* 9"
"!# 0 0 ! %"!0 3>,>3
%*7!44! 4
4!* 7
!! "
0%0* " = " !%! 7 0"! ! % "$ ! # 0 ! !! "
"0!**7!
7 " "0!* *7!
0 !9"0 *7! :*(" +"
$ / '
/3 $"4 "$ /
"'5 ( ' ! /""!
"$ .# *# 1+ 1+
-.
) +65$!"$ 7!!* 4 7 *! ! = " 7!2 " !2 ! "*9 !!
!"7"00 "
% >
#?
*0! '! $!4% $ !04 ! ! !! +"
"9" $4!!*% +"
!0 " ! !%0!
"0!!
% +"
!0 $4!! 4! $ "
! " #
"
#"
# "
# $ % #
&
" ''( %
)
# $ * "!!"!!"!!!+ * ,
&
-.
,
*
- /#
-.
*
$
(!
*
7$!%" ! 2 $
$
$
@3 '! " ! 2"
0 @ , 1
, 2"
3 *4! "! !2 ! " ! *"*4! "= " !
"* 7 ! %4 (
8 ! 9"0 ! :*(" +"
!" # $$! **7!# 0 3A '! :*(" +"
% !* %"
!
" !
!
" !
! !
"
!
!
!
"
#
!
!
!
$
!
! # !
%
!
! !
#
% &'
( ) $
*
!
% + !
!
!
! ! !
,
!
! ! ! !- !'
! !
!
, ! .
!
#
!% $ /%0% &)/%1&20 ! $ 5!0% " 2! ! !"*4 ! 5" >
! * !! 07$ (! $A (B"0 $ " ,$C2)$
D?(!$("7C%$D! $((0 $!
"9*
5 > $*,1 6,$!(
%!"@
*4! "*9 * *7! " ( !4!
0 ! 7!"*4 ! '! ! 04!! " ( ,3 !'! !* 4!!E"
!(!" !$
** ;"7*7!
7 ! *! (! $ A (B"0 $A (B"0 ! 40 3 " ,$C2)$ D?(!$("7 C%$D! $((0 $!
"9* 5 > $* ,1 6,
07 -"# "''
&'() &73 (" F!! <0@
G@ F!! *
G@