M/S P.J. And Company v. Food Corporation Of India And Another




   
    

!"#$#%&'&()* + ,  -'  ./!(0  1 #"&"&(#2  3#2'4'

$2/2!"&(
($&!!($!("5#2    #'/($#("'
 


  
 
    


 

  

2#'#(")* 242.&($#26&(75862$9%!"#:&"5 2 6!2!8$9%!"#82"5#/#"&"&(#2 2;;4/"!8$9%!"#82 
 <<<<   
 

 &"5 "5# %('#("  =#!2(#$ %4('#= 2 >"5 "5# /!2"&#'8 "5# .!""#2&'>#&(7"!?#(4/!($5#!2$9&!9&$#%(#2#(%&(7 5&'/#"&"&(5!'>##(&=#$>0"5#/#"&"&(#2>#&(7!772&#9#$ >0"5#2$#2$!"#$@ @ :5#2#>0"5#2#/2#'#("!"&("5#/#"&"&(#2 !7!&('"2#A#%"&(5&'"#%5(&%!=>&$'4>.&""#$2!==".#("5!($=&(7!($ "2!('/2"!"&( %("2!%" 2 6!(7242 %#("2# 4($#2 "5# $ 2/2!"&( 
($&!&9&'&(!= &%#86!(72422!/#2&$":0#!2':!'2#A#%"#$ ''#("&!==0 "5# /#"&"&(#2 5!' 2!&'#$ ":724($' &2'"=08 "5!" "5#2#A#%"&(5&'"#%5(&%!=>&$.#2#=0("5#724($"5!""5#'/#%&!=/:#2 !""2(#02#B4&2#$">#&=#$>05&.!=(7:&"5"5#"#($#2:!'&(%./=#"# &'
 !($ '54=$ 5!9# >##( &7(2#$ !' "5# .&'"!?# %%422#$ ( !%%4(""#%5(&%!=!

4=":5&=#'4>.&""&(7"5#"#($#2$%4.#("'(=&(#!($ '#%($=0 "5# !%%#/"!(%#  "5# >&$  2#'/($#(" *!('  6(' %./!(0 >0 "5# 2#'/($#("* 
 &' !=' #22(#4' !' "5# $%4.#("' '4>.&""#$>02#'/($#("*!(' 6('%./!(0:#2#!=':2(7 !($!='#&(!'4%5!'"5#&(%.#"!C2#"42(:!'/42/2"#$=0'4>.



   
































































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
("5#=&75""5#!%"8"5#$#!

4="("5#/!2""5#/#"&"&(#2&' ("$#(&#$($?##/&(7&(9&#:"5#/29&'&('%=!4'# >

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

!%#$:&"5"5&'8=#!2(#$%4('#=!//#!2&(72"5#2#'/($#("*

$ 2/2!"&( 
($&! '4>.&"' "5!" "5# &''4# 2#7!2$&(7 "5# $##%"'8 & !(08 &("5# >&$ '4>.&""#$ >0 2#'/($#("*!('  6(' %./!(0 '5!==>##C!.&(#$!($$#%&$#$>0"5#2#'/($#("*!4"52&"&#'>0/!''&(7! '/#!?&(72$#2



   
































































($ :5&=# "!?&(7 '4%5 $#%&'&( '5!== !=' %('&$#2 !== "5# %(%#2(' #C/2#''#$ >0 "5# /#"&"&(#2 #9#( &( 5&' 2#/2#'#("!"&( $!"#$ + @ ((#C42# *+  '4>.&""#$ '4>'#B4#(" " "5# $&'/'!=  "5# /2#9&4'/#"&"&(&=#$>0"5#/#"&"&(#2
("5#%&2%4.'"(%#'8:5&=#:#$&'.&''"5#/#"&"&(!'!2!'"5# %5!==#(7#""5#2#A#%"&("5#/#"&"&(#2D'"#%5(&%!=>&$&'%(%#2(#$8"5# /#"&"&(&'$&'/'#$&("#2.'"5#'"!"#.#(".!$#>0=#!2(#$%4('#= !//#!2&(72"5# $2/2!"&(
($&!2#7!2$&(7"!?&(7!$#%&'&(>0 /!''&(7 ! $#"!&=#$ 2$#2 &( 2#'/#%"  "5# #222' !($ $#!4="' "5# >&$ '4>.&""#$ >0 2#'/($#(" *!('  6(' ./!(0 !==#7#$=0 '4#2#$2.
" &' .!$# %=#!2 "5!"

 & ' 2#B4&2#$ "5# $ 2/2!"&( 
($&!'5!==7&9#$4#//2"4(&"05#!2&(7"2#'/($#(">#2#"!?&(7 !(0$#%&'&(
"&'42"5#2.!$#%=#!2"5!":#5!9#("#C/2#''#$!(0/&(&( ("5#>A#%"&('2!&'#$>0"5#/#"&"&(#22#7!2$&(72#'/($#("!

6('./!(0!($"5#2#2#8"5#2#'/($#("*!4"52&"&#':4=$>#!" =&>#2"0"#C!.&(#&">0"!?&(7!=="5#!%"'!($!%#"'&("%('&$#2!"&(5# 2$#2 2 $#%&'&( ' "!?#( >0 "5# $ 2/2!"&( 
($&! ># %..4(&%!"#$ " "5# /#"&"&(#2 " #(!>=# 5&. " "!?# 4/ !== "5# 2#.#$&#' !9!&=!>=#"5&.4($#2"5#=!:!7!&('""5#'!.# &"5"5#'#>'#29!"&('8"5#/#"&"&('"!($'$&'/'#$  

3
6;    
  6




 FF
  

+ ,