High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/436/2015allowed

Amit Narang v. State Of Haryana

2015-02-19Mr. Justice Satpal5 pages

!"# #$%&%'( )

*%"!+!', -#+&.& /"!"# !+0!'! / (12 3/ /3/ 33 (12 3/ /3/ 33 (12 3/ /3/ 33 (12 3/ /3/ 33 +#&#'"(+//!45'#06 78$!"#6

+"5#9#"%"%'#+ +!4!'%+75!+6 77: !+0!'! 3/ 336 3/ 336 3/ 336 3/ 336 +!: #"%"%'#+ %& !,,+%#8#7 !,!%'&" +7#+ 7!"#7

9!&&#7 ;0 :#!+'#7 77%"%'!: /#&&%'& .7,#6 !*.'! !,!+ !" !,5!75+% 45#+#;0 5%& !99#!: !,!%'&"

<.7,*#'" !'7 $'8%$"%' 7!"#7

!'7 +7#+

&#'"#'$#7!"#7 =

5!&;##'7%&*%&&#7

9+&#$."%'!'7'*#+%" #"%"%'#+45%&"5#!$$.&#7%'$*9:!%'"$!&#

.'7#+"5#+#8#'"%' 7 7.:"#+!"%'

$"6 )4!&$'8%$"#7!'7&#'"#'$#7".'7#+,&%*9:#

%*9+%&'*#'" +!9#+%7 *'"5&!'7"9!0! %'#

>16%'7# !.:" 9!0*#'" %'#" .+"5#+.'7#+, &%*9:#%*9+%&'*#'" +!9#+%7'#*'"5 #$5!::#',#75%&$'8%$"%'!'7&#'"#'$#;# +# "5#!99#::!"#$.+" #"%"%'#+2& !99#!: 4!& 7%&*%&&#7 ;0 "5# :#!+'#7

77%"%'!:/#&&%'& .7,#6 !*.'!!,!+!" !,5!75+%'

9+&#$."%'!&4#::'*#+%"& 3#!+'#7 $.'&#: + "5# 9#"%"%'#+ &.;*%"& "5!"

"5#+#%&'!""#*9"'5%&9!+"""5#7#:!0 9+$##7%',&%'

!'0 *!''#+ # 5!& '"5%', " ,!%' ;0 $!.&%', 7#:!0 /9#$% %$ +#@.#&" + !' !7<.+'*#'" 4!& *!7# !& "5# !+,.%',$.'&#:4!&'"!8!%:!;:#'"5#7!"# %A#73#!+'#7

99#::!"# .+" '" %'7%', *#+%" %' "5# +#@.#&" + !7<.+'*#'"67%&*%&&#7"5#!99#!: 9+&#$."%'

!'7!77#7"5!""5#!99#!:%&7%&*%&&#7'*#+%"&!&4#:: 4#8#+6"5#+#%&'"#8#'!'!78#+"!'$#""5# !$"& "5# $!&#5#+# +#6+7#+7!"#7

%&:%!;:#";#&#"

!&%7# 3#!+'#7$.'&#: +"5#/"!"#&.;*%"&"5!"%"5!& ;##';&#+8#7"5!""5#9+#&#'"!99#!:%&'# "5#:7#&"

!99#!:;# +#"5#!99#::!"#$.+"!'7%"4!&':0!'!""#*9" ' "5# 9!+" "5# 9#"%"%'#+ " 7#:!0 "5# 9+$##7%',& 5#+# +#6%"%&.+,#7"5!"%*9.,'#7+7#+7#&#+8#&";#

.95#:7 5!8#5#!+7:#!+'#7$.'&#: +"5#9!+"%#&!'7 ,'#"5+.,5"5#+7#+7!"#7

45%$5+#!7&!& .'7#+( B7!0 "5# $!&# %& %A#7 + !+,.*#'"& .'&#: +!99#::!'"/5+%C #5"!6 78$!"# &.;*%""#7"5!"!+,.*#'"%&";#!78!'$#7;0 !'!78$!"# 5!'7%,!+5!'7"5!"!78$!"# $.:7'"!99#!+;# +#$.+""7!07.#"5%& *!++%!,# !''%8#+&!+06 &6 $!&# *!0 ;# !7<.+'#7 #+.&!: $!&# %:# 7.:0 +#8#!:& "5!"

9+#&#'" !99#::!'" $5!::#',#7 "5# <.7,*#'" 7!"#7

!'79+#&#'"!99#!:%&'#

"5#:7#&"!99#!:9#'7%',;# +#"5%&$.+" & 9#+ '&"+.$"%'& '2;:# %,5 .+"6 .''#$#&&!+0 !7<.+'*#'" %& '" 7#&%+!;:# #+.&!: $!&# %:# 7.:0 +#8#!:& "5!" $!&# !7<.+'#7 &#8#+!: "%*#& ' "5# +#@.#&"

!99#::!'" 7!0!:&!7<.+'*#'"&.,5"' ;#5!:

"5#!99#::!'"'"5#,+.'7"5!"5%& $.'&#:%&'"9+#&#'"%'"5#$.+"7.#"5%& *!++%!,# !''%8#+&!+0 5# ,+.'7 + 5# ,+.'7 + 5# ,+.'7 + 5# ,+.'7 + !7<.+'*#'" +!+,.*#'"&%&'"<.&"% %#7 & !7<.+'*#'" +!+,.*#'"&%&'"<.&"% %#7 & !7<.+'*#'" +!+,.*#'"&%&'"<.&"% %#7 & !7<.+'*#'" +!+,.*#'"&%&'"<.&"% %#7 & !+,.*#'"&!+#'";#%',!78!'$#7';#5!:

!+,.*#'"&!+#'";#%',!78!'$#7';#5!:

!99#::!'"!'7!:&'9%'"7%&$.&&#7 +&#""%', !99#::!'"!'7!:&'9%'"7%&$.&&#7 +&#""%', !99#::!'"!'7!:&'9%'"7%&$.&&#7 +&#""%', !99#::!'"!'7!:&'9%'"7%&$.&&#7 +&#""%', !&%7#<.7,*#'" :#!+'#7:4#+$.+"';#5!:

!&%7#<.7,*#'" :#!+'#7:4#+$.+"';#5!:

!99#::!'"6 &6 9+#&#'" !99#!: %& 5#+#;0 !99#::!'"6 &6 9+#&#'" !99#!: %& 5#+#;0 !99#::!'"6 &6 9+#&#'" !99#!: %& 5#+#;0 !99#::!'"6 &6 9+#&#'" !99#!: %& 5#+#;0 7%&*%&&#7 9+&#$."%'!'7'*#+%" 7%&*%&&#7 9+&#$."%'!'7'*#+%" 7%&*%&&#7 9+&#$."%'!'7'*#+%" 7%&*%&&#7 9+&#$."%'!'7'*#+%"

99#::!'"45%&9+#&#'"%'$.+";#"!D#'%'"

$.&"70 $.&"70 $.&"70 $.&"70 *95!&%& !77#7 E!++!'"

&#'"#'$#;#9+#9!+#7!$$+7%',:0 +%!:$.+" +#$+7!:',4%"5!$90 "5%&+7#+;#&#'"

;!$D " "5# $.+" $'$#+'#7 99#!: %:# ;# $'&%,'#7 " +#$+7 +* !

"#+ 7.# $*9:%!'$#F

9#+.&!: "5%& +7#+ +#8#!:& "5!" 45%:# 7%&*%&&%', "5# !99#!: ' *#+%"& %'7##7 "5#+# %& ' !78#+"#'$#""5#*#+%"& "5#!99#!:6#8#'"5# !$"&5!8# '";##'*#'"%'#7 .;":#&&6"5#*!""#+$!''";#D#9"9#'7%',%' +7%'!"#:0 ;." !" "5# &!*# "%*#6 "5# !99#!: $!''" ;# 7%&*%&&#7'*#+%"&%'!+."%'#*!''#+ C##9%',%'8%#4"5# !$"&!'7$%+$.*&"!'$#& "5# $!&#+7#+7!"#7

%&&#"!&%7# 5#*!""#+%&+#*!'7#7""5#:#!+'#7 77%"%'!:

/#&&%'& .7,#6 !*.'!!,!+6 !,5!75+%5#!99#!:&5!::

;#+#&"+#7!"%"&+%,%'!:'.*;#+5#&!*#;#5#!+7' *#+%"&!'77#$%7#7%'!$$+7!'$#4%"5:!4 "%&54#8#+*!7#$:#!+"5!"' .+"5#++#@.#&"

+ !7<.+'*#'" &5!:: ;# #'"#+"!%'#7 ' ;#5!: "5# 9#"%"%'#+3#!+'#7$.'&#: +"5#9#"%"%'#+ &.;*%"&"5!"

!+,.*#'"&&5!::;#!77+#&&#7';#5!:

"5#9#"%"%'#+'

"5# 7!"# %A#7 !'7 ' +#@.#&" + !7<.+'*#'" &5!:: ;# !78!'$#7 !+"%#& &5!:: !99#!+ ;# +# "5# 99#::!"# .+"6 !*.'!!,!+!" !,5!75+%'

'&#@.#'":06 "5# 9#"%"%'#+ ;# +#:#!&#7 ' ;!%: 9#'7%',!99#!:&.;<#$""5%& .+'%&5%', +#&5;!%:;'7&!'7 &.+#"0 ;'7& " "5# &!"%& !$"%' "5# :#!+'#7 99#::!"# .+" #"%"%'%&!$$+7%',:07%&9&#7

)

3/ 33