← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2939/2007allowed

Sukhbir Singh v. Raj Kumar And ORS.

2025-05-08Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma19 pages



     

    

!"

#$%$!&'

( )*  +  

  ,%-   

    '

./ 0- 0 0  0       

  !  "    #$ %&'

!

 

      !   (    !   ) * +,-  &

....

0  0

-

/

$     

      !        "   0* *002     !   /11! %  /3445   &$  6" #!   7  $ 7'

 !       !           

 8   ! *9 0008,    ! !!5  %      /4 *00+  *

!     

  !  : !    "5 $    !

! !  :  !!5

0000  /

0/0   0 ;

 $        !     ,

                5      $         "      

 ";*5! !    "  - 

5!      5



      <! !! "      !   5 6!= ! 5   !! 

+

>      !        

   "        5 !"      !/25

" "  !    ! !!5     !!   

   

<5/*5!   5   5

 

"

      !   ,-  &  5

"  5 " 5     !    5 $  5    

5!!



-   !   "  !  

 ! "

 ";*5!  !   "  -   5 -   

 "    /4 *00+    ! < ! "  ? 6"   5 !!5

     "   >"  & 5"

!*0 0/ *009 5"" ///+      ,3 $ $  5 "   

  !

 ! "  5    ,/0 5  

 "  !  !       5" 

@,-  



    5   $  

 "!       

$

 ""  5! 4;438,   !     ,/* $$  5 "

      ! 5 *9 0008,   ! !!5 

     @   ! "

 !!///+A   5   ! !! 5     5 "! " $     !

   /95   5  !   5 ! 6  

  !      /95!  " " 5   5 !   5  

 " ///+A ! !!5 

     !" 5

  5 ! !  !B $!

&!"!  5!

    ""    

$&"  ! 

   





  

$   !   , 

      



  ! " # $  

       %       

    

     & # 

& '( 

  !

& )    

&#

 *+, #  -

!&

 

 ! $ . 

 #            /#

  - -   !



 #  

     0

'(   

&0

  #

 

#

  

# ! #

-  

 & - -  &-  ##

1 2 & #

  

& !  344(5 # #

   #  ! !& ) 6!7  1

  8    7 !9              1

# - : #    

&#

& #    - -  &   - & 

  #

 

& !#    -

     -# #

&      #    & # 

5    # 

  # ; 3<5   #       & =



  & & 

-    

&  &  !  +4(    ,'(  5 

   #       # #    ! 

  -     !  #

=

 ! &

 !   

= !- & &1    



&  #   

!344( 

'4( !& ) -1 9

+

,.  ) 6! 1  ! " # 

$!% & '  ()*+&   ;

+>      

&

"15 =

#  

   #

 # 

&#

  

    # 

   - <   ;

?<5  

&#

 !& " #  $  $ ! 7 ! != )

       

&  #

      @4(   

  



& 

  &  !#       -      

  !& 

     # ##   

  

& 

 !

 =5 

/      

  

  ##        &-

 #      -   A   -  #  # # # 

! !

  & & #   !#     

&      !           344(   #

  

&  

?

        "15

= -

  # #     # 

- 

  

& =

  

& !& 

 @4(  #

  #   

         

&

#

  

& ,    -      -  #   !&    "15    #  

!& ) -1

   

#  &

  ! #

         !  #      !   #



#     # 5) -1 

 #   & =

 #

1

 #     # 

&

!     ! &   # #

#

 

& 

  @4( 

## #

 #!& ) - &    

 ## 

!

 B>      #  

&

! #=  344(  # 

!# # 9 CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC9 /0

- "!!   &!" !  5!

   90A  "         

//

C  " !    

   D! !!E !      !

 F &!-   !  ,!#" $

!% &  &"  -

  

    $   !      , 7

 &

8344444/  !& ) -    

  #   ! 

!    !  !



# # 

 

  

 

# &     # ! &   !   

  >  #  # # # #  

# 

   

    #

83444444/D8 5A =E 8344444/   !& ) -1 

# ! 

!    !

   

   ,



- 

 #  # #

 1

#   8 %  D  E A     A  D  E 

!& #    !  > #1 &

# # 

# 

!       -  

   # 

! - #=   >  

 #  # # #  ##  

    

           

  ##    7         - 

   #=  # #

   #

    2  

 !  #     &   -

:

F    -      

F    

    # 2  #   -

)

,37

 & 

  !& #

 

& !     

 #

 #

#

 ##      

&  /   # 

& - 



 ##         #

     

          #  ##  5   #  # # #   # 

#

#     

  -  -&  

  

!   &!  - 

  

! !



# 

     

   8344444/ &    !   -9 /*

-  "  !        5                ! !!    !     !

   C"  &    !    !! !!  5   !!  "  5

  "!5 -     ! !

     !5 ""      "!  " 5   $! &!"

 "       "   5 

.++./0&12. +% /;

 F     &        "        !

   "  5  $

<&  !   ,%- 3 (

&8 &!9 7

   05:7 6 !57  % % 1   , !# 3 ' '5  

"

G ## 3B,,DH# H 

= 

 #         !     #    



 

  !&  2 & 

 #

 



 ##  5 !

#   - -

=-

      -    

&#         !  2

! 5#  !   

   - !

#

& # #  

 & #

 #& - # # 

#

  

& 

# 2# 

!  

&

!#     & #  &!

      #      # & 5    

 !     !

&

     !

&



&

 

 #  

&!

 

   !

&

   # 

  #    D71%7!

>&5% =

>8 3B47  1 @+8)

-   1 D> 3BB'D3E711''3 $ =  -!&3B41<+E



+ 5  ## 

      

&#     -; 2 ' #) / #* E  *   

- 



  

:

   

 

  -

 

#   



EA    -D 

- E #   

 

! # -; D EA    -  

 

F D!EA     -  ##    

&

E  .

   #     

 # &   -  D    -E E -   -    # 2#

 DEA 

D /      #  -E D EA   #

 D   -

&E >

    &# # 

 !   &  D ED

ED E D E> & 

#  &    # #  #  ##  !

 #

#

 # 

 !-   &  D

ED!ED

EDE D E

     - ##      

&      #        

  D /          #      -E        #

      0 '5

 6"7



E D    

  - E 

     -# #

&

E5 # -    

&

#

  !

&    # 

!  

!  # -     -  # #

&  5

   &    # -         -# #

& 

    # -   



&D#  #  5 !  !   ## #  # -     -# #

&   # -    

&E

E5

    #

 



!2 &

       

&# -   # & -      

&5    -# #

&    

! !& 5 ! 

#

 # 

 & E5    

& &    # -

    -# #

&          

 ##



! -#

 

  #

 45       -   ! 

#

  % 88 ;5   =   -@4&     -8@444/ 



  ##   

H  #    

& 

!  # 2#

& +4(  # 2

   

&

      2 

   @4(  5         -  # #

& 



 !& 5 !  3'( !   # !#  #

#

  & !

   - 1 #

# 

 !   ;

 E  # !   ##  ;8@+444/ !EA     -   D3'(  

   # E; 8'<44/ #E"

  # !

#

 -;3 EA     -;D'<443E; 8B3,44/ % 8,8;5     -@4&   -8 @444/ 

)  

     

&

  +4()  

 

! #  - ) # # -

- &

 &  ! =  -

 &

!   &  =&

! 

#5 5 !          -# #

& '( 1 #

# 

 !   ; E  #  



 ##  ;8@+444/ !EA     -   D'(  

   # E ;8444/ #E"

  # !

#

 -;3 EA     -;D4443E;8<'B444/ %   8&8 ;  5       '  &          &  *-  -     ##    # 

  -   

 

  #  5     !    4(  

# #



  # #   2   #     -

        -



# #

&     4(5# #

# 

!   ; E"

   #    -

 ! &   *-  ;8+4444/ !EA     -   D4(  #    # E ;8<444/ #E"

  # !D'& E  ;3, EA     -;D<4443,E ;8'+444/ I

  ;  5   -  

    

  DE    D$E   &

# 5 - >

D1E  !    = #

 % "

 D  EJ /+

 F &  !% & '

  2' 9 ;

  2 0

2) < !"    /11 /1;,  /14!%  /344  !"

  , '

=   !          <           G #6'

  !      ! G #&'

!  !

5  G #='

   !            5    !

 !   ! <   "  G #@'

?   !  !   !!!  "   G!, 5!<5  $   !     , 5  =

 &

    ! >



    ! - # 

  

1

&  

  # 

       !  83'444  8<4444    83'444   #

& 5  #  

     ## ! # $ 

 

! # # # 2 

 # # =

 !#  -

 2 

 ! #  # -!  & &    #  !   34(    &    

  !#       ! -    #  #&     #     9 /9

 F &  ! . '2'   .:+ &    &; 4 , 5    #  # 2 

!

!&;

)*< <8 8<8 =8F 5    # 

  - !  -     @& & -

  > #1 &A

  &7  K 431L 44D71E>  <+   -  1 

$# #

&  

 

! 



!  #   7  G  D7

E  K  

5  1

 

44B1L3B,D71E>  - - 3''& 

 

!H3,H  -

 #

-

 

& 5   



 & !& #         7

  1

       # 

+

#

   

 

 !         #        

!H3,H 

H3H )6*    <  #  '  <      5    6'<( > >   #                 #

 

 



! 

  # 

L -     "

  M  K   43, 1L  3433 D71E    7  %    M

431LBBD71E  #

!    # 

L - D  E   ,; ?,>  # 

 & ! 

  #  

!!





    

 &

& ## 

!&  ##  



  # 

5   # 

# 

   -  # ;   -  

-  ##  F

A  #  # -  # F

5  !

& 

    

- 



F E " #   #  

&! 2 

 =  F  DE   #

 ? I     J 5     #    !   :    

-   7  %  # D  E

   - # &  - & ! 

2 

&   #         

&    ##  

2

>  #  #

   #  

 

&  #

 

      



/

:

    ,

## 

  

 !  & 3N&  - 433

L  &43@5   !

 ; ? <3 ';

 #     

 # !

!

   

 # !

!

 -    E  # @< M'

 #   -   DE !

#   # #  -   D  #    D

 # !

!

 -        

-  

   -    #  & #   

        

-



!& #     7

  

#  # $

 

&

   

   

   . 

 !

   3@ 7  %  # D  E   &

     #   #

  #   

! =

#  

   2  # &    

#

          # 

- 

    #   !   #    = -       

&    @33(  5 2 

  !  -

  > #1 A # D  E

 # # &  +3D

E



   -     !'4(  #   &   #  )*+  > > #           

   #   

B(  

   # # L - 6# D  E K   #  # -    

  !&

     #          #    #

    

B(  

     !&  &&?

% ,  5              & -      

 #  # #

# 

!&      

  ' &   

! 

   ;

@ 5       -   D83<+<,3@33/344 8B,3B,/ .

    #   D'4   #  

E 8<B4B,B/ " #   # -

 

# -   # 83,<+,+</  

 

 # 8'44444/     #     

   - & 83'4444/    - 844444/

8<3+B,@3/

)

5     !



# 

8<3+B,@3/ #

  -



    B(       

    &  $.%. /1

- "!   

" " 0* *002!   5     !" " 5  F &   

 ,       !      ", -   4;438,   ?  H90A 



-   / 9/ 0048,#/*94+I/*'

>  !  !           !  90A 5  90+8,#90A!/9/004'

 !/1  /* 01+8#2990+I/1'

  !!   / 0008,

  &   /0 0008, $   &   /0 0008, >! !!  + 0008,   =  *0 0008, !

= #!6: &% $!&

> 78 8' %- *)* 21?

85#$!&'

 "5$  %-+* ? &9 &# 8

6!5& !"

#!6: &% $!& %- * * 21?

 ) 21+  /2

 !      5  F  & / #A/,3  ' #       $



+   +&

  +



05:7 6 !57  % %  *

    5  H3A

 !!! !   !B

/4

   ,-  &  5       " "$ "  !" ! !  !  5!   $$   

 ,       $

 ,    !    $ 

/3

?  -    &  5                !  (    "  !" 55! !  5!     /4 *0*+ 5 & ?

J) /14*!*002

*0

  

  #'

! 5   !

0  0 

 



   C  8  ,  K   C  K