High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13212/2012dismissed

Hafiz Abdul Hameed v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-04-22Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath8 pages

!"#$ %&&" '&(( )&* +&*,#, -( #).

! )" (/&*, '&,0 )"&)(, !"#$%&#'!" *&,&)(1 2* *3)"&*-)4/5"3 6 (&5

*(/&0&(( )&* 2* + %,7 * 05""$ 5#).

2* #$ % !2 $85"3 6 (&5 **&,0 )"&)( ,

2* - )5"3 6 (&57(/ 2* 8,/ : )5"3 6 (&5 *(/&#).

! $%&#'!"(" /, *"&* ,/ $$ ",0 ,& 3& 0&(( ), !& *)4 ,

< 5

<< )" = >< , (/& ,,#&, )3 $3&") $$(/& 3&6 ,&,,(/&, %& 7&3&*5(/&

6(, *&!&)4 &?(* 6(&" * %

/&0&(( )&*7 00 )(&" ,% % (/&2 ,."$ !

*-/ /5.( (&5 ( $ );

;=A)(/&0 :,6 $& =B<B;CDBE

7(/ (/& *&,0 ),!$(: *&$4 #, &"#6 ( )5 6$& )$)&,, )" $4/()4 (/& % ,F#& /& 0&(( )&* , 44*&3&"

),( (/& *"&* "

(&" D

0 ,,&" !: (/& / *% #).

! *"G/&*&)

(&**& &**&"( ,(/&H *"IJ!:7/6/ /&/ ,!&&)*&(*&"

(&* (( ))4(/& AD:& *, #),&$ * (/& 0&(( )&* / , ,#!%((&" (/ ((/& (%& 7/&) (/& 0&(( )&* 7 00 )(&" , % %5 (/& 6(5 ;D< G/&*&)

(&* *& &**&" ( , (/& H6(IJ5 (/& #).

! #$&,5 ;A< G/&*&)

(&* *& &**&" ( , (/& H#$&,IJ )" (/& #).

! ( ),5;AAG/&*&)

(&**& &**&"( ,(/&H&4#$ ( ),IJ7&*&) 0&* ( ) /&0 7&*( % 8&*#$&, $ 7, * %-&6( )A= )"( % 8& ( ), * % -&6( ) A> (/& 6(5 ) 7/6/ -&6( ) A>GJG&J 0* 3"&, *(/&*&4#$ ( ), (/&(&*%, )"6 )"( ), (/&,&*36&

)",&*3 )(, (, #*(/&*,#!%((&"(/ ((/& (&*% H&%0$ :&&I , "& )&" ) &4#$ G"J (/& &4#$ ( ), ( %& ):0&*, ))(/&&%0$ :%&)( )")6$#"&,% %,5 # ),5 *&B( 8&*,5 & 6/&*,5 9/ "%, )" 2#.

7*, ( , ,#!%((&" (/ ( (/& (&*%, )" 6 )"( ), (/& ,&*36& % % *& "& )&")&4#$ ( )D 57/6/,*&0* "#6&" ,#)"&*1B HD

&*%, )" )"( ), -&*36& % %,5 # ),5 *&B( 8&*,5 & 6/&*,5 9/ "%, )" 2#.

7*,B -&6( )A>G JG&J1/&0* 3, ), *&4#$ ( ), * % ( ,/ $$ ) ( 00$: ( % %,5 2 # ),5 *&B( 8&*,5 & 6/&*,5 9/ "%, )" 2#.

7*, ) ,

* (/&: *& )6 ),,(&)(7(/(/& $$ 7)40* 3, ),1B GJ /& 00 )()4 #(/ *(: )"(/&0#),/)4 #(/ *(: ) (/& 6 % %,5 2 # ),5 *&B( 8&*,5 & 6/&*,59/ "%, )"2#.

7*,,/ $$!&(/& $$ 00 )(%&)(,( (/&,&0 ,(,,/ $$!&% "& )(/& *&6 %%&)"

&$4 #,

*, %%((&&

/& &$4 #,

*, %%((&& 7$$)(&*3&7(/& )""

(&,5 (&,( (/&* 8) 7$&"4& )" ,#!%( (, *&6 %%&)"

( ), ( (/& /& % %, ,/ $$ 0 ,,&,,(/& $$ 7)4F# $ ( ),1B )""

(&, 7/ 0 ,,&,, (/& "&4*&& H *4/#$B&/,$I ,/ $$ !& 6$ ,,&" * "&B G!J )""

(&, 7/ / 3& 0 ,,&" H

" *I * *&

*7(/8) 7$&"4& 2#,$%(/& $ 4:5,/ $$!&6$ ,,&" * "& 0&*, ) ( !& 00 )(&" , 2 # ) ,/ $$ 0 ,,&, &$&%&)( *: 8) 7$&"4& 2 ,,

$ %

G<J 0&*, )( !& 00 )(&"9/ "% *2#.

7*,/ $$ !&H B,/ * I5!&*&4#$ *)(/& !,&*3 )6&

)" % !& 6F# )(&"7(/H (&/

* "I

)"!&0/:,6 $$: (( % )( )(/&

*4 / GDJ $$8)", $& 3&( % %,52 # ),5 *&B( 8&*,5 & 6/&*,59/ "%, )"2#.

7*,,/ $$!&, )6( )&" !: (/& -&6*&( *:

/& -&6*&( *: ,/ $$ $, % 8&

()4 ** )4&%&)(,5)6 ): (/&0 ,(,

$$ )(5 ) 6 ),#$( ( ) 7(/ (/& / *% )" ) &%&*4&)( 6 ,&, /& 6 $, ,#,0&)" ): ,#6/ &%0$ :&&7(/(/& 00* 3 $ (/&/ *% ) #((/& -&6*&( *: ,/ $$ 0$ 6& $$ 6 ,&,

()4

** )4&%&)( )",#,0&), )!& *&(/& *"57/6/ %&&(,%%&"

(&$:

(&*,#6/ *"&*, I (, #*(/&*,#!%((&"(/ ((/&6(/ ,!&&)*&0& $&"!:-&6( ) (/& 6(5 ;;D G/&*&)

(&* *& &**&" ( , (/& H6( ;;DIJ )"7(/(/ ((/&*#$&, )"*&4#$ ( ),/ 3& $, !&&)*&0& $&"

)"(/ ((/& *"/ ") .#*,"6( )( " 0((/&*#$&, )"*&4#$ ( ), , / , !&&) " )&) (, %&&()4 ) =

D5 0* 3"&"#)"&*-&6( ), )" (/&6( ;;D57/6/ *& $, *&0* "#6&" ,#)"&*1B

H )! '$ !*# + % ,!-GJ /& *" % :5 7(/ (/& 0*&3 #, , )6( ) (/& -( 3&*)%&)(5% 8&*&4#$ ( ),) ()6 ),,(&)(7(/(/,6( *(/&*#$&,% "&(/&*&#)"&*5 *6 **:)4 #((, #)6( ), #)"&*(/,6( )0 *(6#$ *5 )"7(/ #(0*&.#"6&( (/&4&)&* $(:

*&4 )40 7&*,5,#6/*&4#$ ( ),% :0* 3"& * $$ * ): $$ 7)4% ((&*,5) %&$:1B (/&(%& )"0$ 6&, (/&%&&()4, "#)"&* ,#!B,&6( )GJ -&6 =K G!J (/& 0* 6&"#*& )" 6 )"#6( !#,)&,, ( (/& %&&()4, *"K G6J (/&6 ),((#( ) #)6( ), (/&6 %%((&&, (/& )" (/& 0* 6&"#*& * (* ), 6( ) !#,)&,, ((/&%&&()4, ,#6/6 %%((&&,K G"J (/& $$ 7 )6&, * &&,( !&0 "( (/&/ *0&*, ) *%&%!&*, *" *%&%!&*, 6 %%((&&,K G&J (/&(&*%, )"6 )"( ), ,&*36&

(/&* &%0$ :&&, (/& *" #)"&* ,#!B,&6( ) G

-&6 <K (/& *%, 00$6 * *&4,(* 7

#*(/&* 0 *(6#$ *, ( !& 6 )( )&" (/&*&) )" (/& % ))&* )"0$ 6& *&4,(* 7 ,#)"&*,#!B ,&6( )G -&6 AK G4J

#*(/&* 0 *(6#$ *, ( !& 6 )( )&" ) (/& *&4,(&* ,#)"&*-&6 =K G/J (/& *% ) 7/6/5 )" (/& (%& 7(/) 7/6/5 (/& !#"4&(, 7 ,% :!&0*&0 *&" )",#!%((&"!: (/&%#( $$ 00* 3&"!:(/& *"#)"&*,#!B ,&6( )GJ -&6 <<K GJ (/& ! 8, 66 #)(, )" (/&* ! 8, ( !& % )( )&"!:(/& *"#)"&*-&6 =;K G.J

&&, 0 :

!$& * ),0&6( ) 0* 6&&")4, *&6 *", (/& *" * * ,,#& 6 0&, , %&K G8J 0&*, ),!:7/ % ): *"&* *"&6, ) % :!& #(/&)(6 (&"K )"

G$J

): (/&* % ((&* 7/6/ / , ( !&5 * % : !&5 0* 3"&"!:*&4#$ $$ *&4#$ ( ), % "& #)"&* (/, ,&6( ) ,/ $$ !& 0#!$,/&")(/&

$ &((& )",/ $$/ 3&&

&6( * % (/&"

,#6/0#!$6 ( ) .+* !# !*# ! / .* #!003&*:*#$&,% "&#)"&*-&6 ; )"&3&*: *&4#$ ( )% "&#)"&*-&6 ,/ $$!&$ "5 ,, ) ,% : !&

(&*(,% "&5!& *&(/&-( (&L&4,$ (#*& I #),&$ * (/& 0&(( )&* / $, ,#!%((&" (/ (&3&) *(/& , 8& *4#%&)(,5 ( , 0*&,#%&" (/ ( (/& &4#$ ( ), 7 #$" ,($$ ,#*33& ,) (/&**&4#$ ( ),/ 3&!&&)% "&#)"&*(/&6( ;;D5 ,($$ (/& &$4 #,

*, %%((&& )$: / " (/& .#*,"6( ) ( *&6 %%&)"6 )""

(&, *(/&0#*0 ,& (/&* 00 )(%&)( ,% %,5 # ),5 *&B( 8&*,5& 6/&*,59/ "%, )"2#.

7*,( (/& !#( )&(/&* (/& &$4 #,

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

66 *"

)6& 7(/ (/& $ 7 )" ) (/& $ *4&* 0#!$6 )(&*&,( ( ,

,#!%((&"(/ ((/&0&(( )&*/

$&"( 6(& ):0* 3, )&(/&* (/& 6( * (/& 6( ;;D * (/& #$&, )" &4#$ ( ), 7/6/ 0* 3"&, (/ ( (/& % % / , ( ,&*3& (/& *" (/* #4/ #( /, $ &5 * (/&* (/& *&,0 )"&)(, / 3& *& &**&" ( &4#$ ) 7/6/ ( , 0* 3"&"(/ () &%0$ :&& *",/ $$!&*&( )&"

(&*(/&

AD:& *, &4#$ ,*&0* "#6&" ,#)"&*1B '1# !+!'B-&6( )A>G JG&J1BGJ/& "

6 %0#$, *:*&(*&%&)( )&%0$ :&& ,(/&"

(& )7/6//& (( ),(/& A:& *, &% : !& *&( )&" ) ,&*36&

(&* (/ ( "

(& ) &?6&0( ) $ 6*6#%,( )6&, 7(/ (/& , )6( ) (/& *" ) 0#!$6 4* #)", 7/6/ %#,( !& *&6 *"&" ) (/& *&, $#( ) *"K 0* 3"&" /& , %&"6 $$: (5 !#( /& %#,( ) ( !& *&( )&"

(&*(/& AD:& *, &?(&), ),/ $$!&4* )(&" *% *&(/ 0&* "

)&:& * (%& )")(/&6 &?(&), ) $ ,,

)" $ ,, &%0$ :&& !&: )" (/& A (/& %&"6 $

()&,,

*&, ",/ $$!&6&*( &"!& *&,#6/&?(&), ) I (, #*(/&*,#!%((&"(/ ,0&*-&6( ) < (/&6( ;;D5 (/& ,&*36& 6 )"( ), (/& &%0$ :&&, (/& *" / 3& ( !& *&4#$ (&" !: (/& *&4#$ -&6( ) < (/& 6( ;;D , *&0* "#6&" ,#)"&*1B

! %! '1 + % ,!-GJ /& *" ,/ $$ / 3& (/& ,,,( )6& ,#6/ )#%!&*

)" (/&* &%0$ :&&, , % : !& )&6&,, *: * (/& &

6&)(0&* *% )6& (, #)6( ),#)"&*(/,6(5"&( $, (/&*& ,/ $$!&"&(&*%)&"!:(/& *")6 ),#$( ( )7(/ (/&-( (& 3&*)%&)(

/& 00 )(%&)(

)" (/&* &%0$ :&&,5 (/&* (&*%

6& )" 6 )"( ), ,&*36& ,/ $$!&,#6/ ,% :!&0* 3"&"!:*&4#$ I (, $, *4#&"!:$& *)&"6 #),&$ *(/&*&,0 )"&)(,(/ 0&* -&6( ) (/& 6( ;;D5 ) (7(/,( )")4 ,#6/ *&0& $5

):(/)4" )& * ): 6( )( 8&)#)"&*(/&, "6(,,/ $$!&"&&%&" ( / 3&!&&)" )& *( 8&)#)"&*(/&6 **&,0 )")40* 3, ), (/, 6( / 3& /& *" $& *)&" 6 #),&$ * (/& 0 *(&, )" &?

%)&" (/&

$ !$&*&6 *"7(/(/&* !$& ,,,( )6& (, "%((&"

6((/ ((/&6(/ ,!&&)*&0$ 6&"!:(/&6( ;;D )" (/& #$&, / 3& ) 7 !&&) ,#0&*,&"&" !: (/& #).

! #$&,5 !#((/&&4#$ ( ),/ 3&) (!&&)*&0$ 6&"#)"&*(/&6(

;;D )"/ 3&!&&) " 0(&" )=

D *& 4 3&*))4(/&,&*36&6 )"( ), (/&&%0$ :&&, ,(/& 0&(( )&* /%,&$ , *&$:)4 #0 ) &4#$ ( ) D ) /, 0&(( ) ( 6 )(&)" (/ ( (/& &$4 #,

*, %%((&& / , )$: 4 ( (/& .#*,"6( ) ( *&6 %%&)" (/& 00 )(%&)( 3 * #, &%0$ :&&, ( 00& *, (/ ( (/& 0&(( )&* / , %,,&" &4#$ ( ), ) 7/6/ ( , 0* 3"&" (/ ( (/& * 6 %0#$, *: *&(*&%&)( )&%0$ :&& *",/ $$!&A:& *,57/ % :!& *&( )&" ) &?6&0( ) $ 6*6#%,( )6&, ($$ (/& AD :& *,

(&* 43)4*&0& (&"&?(&), ), )") *"&*( 3&*6 %&(/ (,(# ( )(

*,&(%& )5(,"&6"&"!:(/& *" ) ;

= ;;=( ?(/&

*&(*&%&)( % % ,AD:& *,),(& " A:& *, ),

* ,(/&0&(( )&*,6 )6&*)&"5/&/ $*& ": (( )&"(/&

AD:& *, )",/ #$") (/ 3& ):4*&3 )6&&3&) (/&"&6, ) ,( 8&)!:(/& *" ) ;

= ;;=( ?(/& AD:& *,),(& "

A:& *, ,(/&"

*&(*&%&)(!#((/& *"5) ):6 ,&56 )) ( &?(&)" (/& *&(*&%&)( !&: )" AD :& *, ) 6 )(* 3&)( ) (/&&4#$ /#,5)3&7

*&, "

6(, )"6*6#%,( )6&,5(/&6 ,&(#0!:(/&0&(( )&*6 )) (!& 66&0(&"57/&*&/&/ ,,#!%((&"(/ (/&*&,) 0* 3, ))(/&&4#$ ( ), ! #((/&"

*&(*&%&)( (/&% %57/6/,6$& * * %&4#$ (/ $$&%0$ :&&, *"/ 3&( *&(*& ((/& A:& *,7/6/6 )4 #0( AD:& *, !:7 : &?(&), ) )",)6&(/&0&(( )&*/ $*& ": (( )&"(/&

AD :& *,5 /& / , *4/($: !&&) *&(*&" * % (/& ,&*36& ),&F#&)($:5 $$(/& 3&0&(( ), *& /&*&!: ",%,,&" !&)4"&)#"&" ):%&*(5(/ #4/7(/ #( ): *"&* ,( 6 ,(, 1!

(

G$%&#'!"3 3) " "#*