Mohinder Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others




   
 

 !"#!$%&%"'()!* !+,!-./

"0%'1!-)%'20  

 )

3 ) ) )  !"# 4'5,'1" 0!-&  ) )

 ( 67

 )
)8





  



 

 


  




 


 
  !

"

)'5984+-/ #$ %&%'()%*+*+ ,-.
 



.

.






/. #


 
 

 

 




" 


. 
 



/. #$&%0'*1%*+*+ 







"
.
  
 

 
" 

 
 

2 1

3

  


 
 
*( *+*+

4


 
   
 



 
 

  
 
.



* 
.
"
 
 


 

)* *+*+

   


".

 
 


!

"



 




5 

"
6 
7 
8


#






 
.

 




.


"
 



 
 


  

 






 

 



   .

 

 
9

 
 


 
  




 .



 



 







  
  ! 
 
:
;

 

 

)1(678 #  #
.





 
 
!  




 
7



"
.



 
 
<
 





. 




.

9
 




 


 
 
"

#
4

 7:% 84+-%;&";!-'+!' "#  <=.

)=>



 
 

 

.


.




"



  




 = "



"
..

 

 
.
#

 



 


% 6=
';%!?"# 0!#"-!&%11%&$4&&%"'/?!0":1( ==0!-!2%& - %"'"# %&+'1 "-94'1!-)!$ %"'=.

"#  0!  "1!/  %#  0!  %'#"-+ %"'  1%&$:"&!&  $"++%&&%"'  "#  $"2'%@,:!"##!'$!'1'"*-!:%+%'-9%'A4%-9%&*!-+%&&%,:! %'&4$0&% 4 %"' =
# 0!%'#"-+ %"'-!$!%;!11"!&'" 1%&$:"&!$"2'%@,:!

"##!'$!  ,4  %'1%$ !&  0!  '!$!&&% 9  #"-  '  %'A4%-9/  *-!:%+%'-9  %'A4%-9  +9  ,!  $"'14$ !1  "':9  "  &$!- %' ?0! 0!-$"2'%@,:!"##!'$!%&1%&$:"&!1"-'"  =B
# 0!%'A4%-91%&$:"&!& 0!$"++%&&%"'"#$"2'%@,:! "##!'$!/  0!   +4&  ,!  -!2%& !-!1 
'  $&!&  ?0!-! *-!:%+%'-9%'A4%-9!'1&%'$:"&%'2 0!$"+*:%' /$"*9"# 0!  !' -9  "#  &4$0  $:"&4-!  +4&  ,!  &4**:%!1  "  0!  #%-& %'#"-+' #"- 0?% 0'1'" : !- 0'"'!?!!C
+4& 1%&$:"&!-!&"'&%',-%!##"-$:"&%'2 0!$"+*:%' '1'" *-"$!!1%'2#4- 0!- =.0!*":%$!"##%$!-$''" ;"%10%&14 9"#-!2%& !-%'2 "##!'$!%#$"2'%@,:!"##!'$!%&1%&$:"&!1$ %"'+4& ,! C!' 2%'&  !--%'2  "##%$!-&  ?0"  1"  '"  -!2%& !-  0!   %# %'#"-+ %"'-!$!%;!1,90%+1%&$:"&!&$"2'%@,:!"##!'$! =0!&$"*!"#*-!

:%+%'-9%'A4%-9%&'"  ";!-%#9 0! ;!-$% 9"-" 0!-?%&!"# 0!%'#"-+ %"'-!$!%;!1,4 "':9 " &$!- %'  ?0! 0!-  0!  %'#"-+ %"'  -!;!:&  '9  $"2'%@,:! "##!'$! =& "?0  9*!'1%'?0%$0$&!&*-!:%+%'-9%'A4%-9 %& ",!$"'14$ !1?%::1!*!'1"' 0!#$ &'1$%-$4+& '$!& "#  !$0  $&!  0!  $ !2"-9  "#  $&!&  %'  ?0%$0  *-!:%+%'-9 %'A4%-9+9,!+1!-!&4'1!

 -%+"'%:1%&*4 !&D#+%:91%&*4 !& , "++!-$%:"##!'$!& $ !1%$:'!2:%2!'$!$&!& "--4* %"'$&!& !

&!&?0!-! 0!-!%&,'"-+:1!:9D:$0!&%'%'% % %'2 $-%+%':*-"&!$4 %"'/#"-!E+*:!/";!-B+"' 0&1!:9%' -!*"- %'2 0!+ !-?% 0"4 & %&#$ "-%:9!E*:%'%'2 0! -!&"'&#"-1!:9 0!#"-!&%1-!"':9%::4& - %"'&'1'" !E04& %;!"#:: $"'1% %"'&?0%$0+9?--' *-!:%+%'-9%'A4%-9 =F0%:!!'&4-%'2'1*-" !$ %'2 0!-%20 &"# 0!$$4&!1

( '1 0!$"+*:%'' /*-!:%+%'-9%'A4%-9&0"4:1,!+1! %+!,"4'1'1%''9$&!% &0"4:1'" !E$!!1F19&0!#$ "#&4$01!:9'1 0!$4&!&"#% +4& ,!-!#:!$ !1%' 0! !'!-:%-9!' -9 =)%'$! 0!!'!-:%-9D)  %"'%-9D%:9%-9%& 0! -!$"-1"#::%'#"-+ %"'-!$!%;!1%'*":%$!&  %"'/?!1%-!$ 0 ::%'#"-+ %"'-!: %'2 "$"2'%@,:!"##!'$!&/?0! 0!- -!&4: %'2%'-!2%& - %"'"# "-:!1%'2 "'%'A4%-9/+4& ,!

+'1 "-%:9'1+! %$4:"4&:9-!#:!$ !1%' 0!&%1%-9'1 0!1!$%&%"' " $"'14$   *-!:%+%'-9 %'A4%-9 +4& :&" ,! -!#:!$ !1/&+!' %"'!1,";!6 


 



 
 


5 

"
6 
7

8
 
 


 
 

 

  *( *+*+
6-
%18

.

  


  .
#





"
 



 

 "

 



 

 




."
+(
*+*+




















































6
!

>.


8 > 

? &  
  @ 

@2 &  
 "

@2