High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13262/2012allowed

Narinder Pal Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab & ORS.

2016-03-29Mr. Justice Darshan Singh15 pages

!

!" "#$%$&' (

)'* +), -

#

$%&'$(& ' &'$(& )* +,-.+/,0+.+,

1&'$()* +-0/.+,

2

&'$()* +.+.+/ 34

! &' ' & +" 5 *

6 5 - . +

)* +,- .+

& )* /,0+.+, & )* +-0/.+,

7)* +.+.+/

8(

( ((89((

)* +,- .+ !($("

( (

(( 8 ( 88( 6 "

( (8 ( ' ("

8 ( %8.+&+;;-$

$ ) 2 & 8 (

8 ( 8 (( (< "

( 8 $(

(#= 6( "

' ) ( : >( 686( " "( *! '

: , & 8( "

88 $ 8(

8( ' 8 2 '

: ! 6 "& & )$ * +.?,..,& @

!

$

A& 8 $ 8( 8( $

6>B 6:B': 6 "

* (8 )..?.+.( = ( & $ 8 ( '

: ! 6 "& $ & 8( $ ! ( B( ('(8 %

>..?.+.)* +.?,..,& ( '< = 2( ( %

>..?.+. ' : $

8 ( #= /%# 0" %1"2!3 /44$%%$& /" 2% ,"25$#"

67$5 0"&!1 /%# 0"

%1"2!3 / 44$%%$& 0??.=+,/.. ?...

* ?...B= +/-..=,;+..

8/..B= +../=+/+..

'8$( +/-..=,;+..

8--..

+...=+//..

';8$( +/-..=,;+..

80-..B= +,..=+?+/.

'+8$( ,0..=-0...

8?-..B= / 8( 8 8'

$& ( ' +-&.+8$ , $ 8 8 (

' "

$( $8 "

(( 8 >% 8?&.+/ )C1 '

&%D ( $(((

$ $ (#= !"# $%&'()%(' *

+

!" #

$

# "

% &

!"'

(

%

&

#

#

)**+,*--.%/

"

!"

" #

*---,*-,3 , % - $ $ .

.$ ' / ' '.

' ' . .. . 0 ' )-)1()%1' . .$' '/ ' 0 -'234 ' .

+ 45

6$,5$*67-$-%,$-866+ )**+,*--

'#7 7 %

!" # :

;

$ %

& .%/ 701 #

/ -5--,*-- < / / / / / 0 " 9

!" # 9

!" #

,)*<,*-, .%/ '7,1

"

9 #"

"

"

=

=

,)*<,*-, /

" =

:

#"

#

% & " >" # *5*6,*-* : 2 -*6,) ,**) #

%

&

>" 56,*-* "

# " 9 8

,)*<,*-,

" " /

#

:

!

"

" " /

#

3 56.'.. 6 $ $ . ,.

. 5 7,58 $. '

.

.

..$ 9./', .

. 5

$.

' :));()%%7,6 28' /. ' '

.

$ * , $ *' ' , $* %-%%()%% 0 . 9. / . ):)1()%( 7,6 (< 8' 6

$ /9. ' $ . + 4= "

#

# "

3

' 6 $ /9.$ ..

$ /9.' '

. .$ $ 10 .

'1. ..

$'

$'.

6 = . $ > ,%%)&()%1?

- 6 9( 8 /( (($

8 8 ) 8 8

<"

$ )' /&.+/ )

#= !, . .

. $. . $ . * 3 .

".' /$ /.'

/' 1 . ,/ $. $$.

' 6.. $

$ . $ $ . = ):%(()%1 , .$ . ...?

0 2 $) ' $6 C"D $8( $ 8"

(

$ "

) $

( <(!

( $& <((

( ( 6( .,&.+/( ( (* ( %8+/& .+- ( ( (

( ( 8! 8 "6 2

( ! ==( "6 ( ! 8> (

! ( ( 98+0&.+-

98 +0&.+- ? > ( +.& .+- ) ( <( ( & & ( ( "9(& 6 $ ) < !(( $ ( ) 8 $ ( $(

8E "6 8 ( 8 "

! ( $ % 8?& .+/3(4 ; "8& 6 8& 2'

& (8 9( ! & ( (8") )($ $ ( 8 $< "

8 $

8 8

! &' ' &

($ ( 2 ' !

8 $ $

8(

)"

"

' $

8 (

8 %8++&.+,2 ( ' (

9 8)

(

8 ( 6>B 6:B': 0-?.=+,/.. ?...B=2 8( '

( 8 8 , 8 8 ( 8 8' 8)

!8(

( "

8' 8)

<(($ +&.++"

& &8 $ $

( (1 ( =8

(

8 )

($ 8 $

( F"

$ $<(($ $ 8 ( <( ( ( 8 9(6 8 $

( +. 2

8

8( ( (

"

(

($ 8 "

(

( G$( ( $ $ 8 ) $ 8 ( "

(

8

( ( ( ' "

( " (!8 $( $ $ ( (( 88(

8 ( ( ( '( + ) 2 F 8 ( * ) <( 8$(( F 8( 8( 8 "

*)

$ ( ( 8( 8 6 $ (

( 8"

( ) ( ( "

( ( ) F$$"

) ((

F ( 8 (8(( ( 8( "

F 8 ( '( + $( "

(

$

$8( F 8 (

8 )

2 8' 8)

( $ $ 2

$ ( ( 8(!

++ * 8( ((( ) (8 $& $ 8

8$(

( 8( ' 8

G8 8 )"

$ 8 $ (

8 ( "

F 8( ( !$ 88 $

(

( (

( $($( + 2 8 ) 7 ( >(&686( " 8( ,0?.B=( "( &*!

' : 8 ( 8 /,,/.B= "

"( & *! & '

$ ( 8

(' $( +;?/& &H

88 '

: & $ $8 9 & 8( '

(

8$&;+8 $( ( ( (8 ( "

)* +,-.+ ( 8( +;;.$( 8 ' 8 8 8 '

: $ 8+8$("

$ < (( 8( $ ( F ( (

' : "

<( "

8 8 ( + ! ) 7 ( >( 8 $'

8 82 (8 $( ( ( G ( 2 8 $( (& 8 (

8( 8 (

&

( $(( $( +, :$ "6 ( G $ 8 (

$ 8

,.& .++ 3'< =-4 F (( = 8 "

!:

8 8 (8 +

( 8< $

"

8 ((

8

' ( 8 (

' ( 8 & 8

(

8( $ 8( "(

&*! &' +/ (F

8)

(

(

8 8 6 8&2'

& 9( (8& $ (( $ 8

( 8

$

$ "

) ( ( 8 9( $ "

) ( "

& ) ( ( 2

$ ( 8' )

($ $ ( 8

> &

(

( 8 )

<($ ($ $ 8( ( ((

8(& 8 & ( $ 8 8 ($ ( 8 ( ($

8 "

( ( (((

$< $&

! 8 !(

( ( +- $ - !& 8 ("

&8 - 8 ( 9 - :

(