Asish Bala v. State Of Haryana And Another
! " #$ %#&'(') '$*''' ') "'$
) )+ +, -. '/ / ('0'
1 / ' !% '$*''')' !$
/'
/ 3#'$
1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/
45 '$'
1 / ' !% '$*''')' !$
6 4 &'/( $/ "
1 / ' !% '$*''')' !$
755 ' / '/ " ')' !$
1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/
$'3!/ 3#'$
1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/
3'/ $/ "
1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/
5 / 13#'$
1 / ' !% '$*''')' !$
448 $ *'3'
1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/
$', 9(0!$/ &#/ !0 /'"
00
! " #$% &' ( !( ) $ * * +
' , ( , - , ... /'"
00.& % + /0123441552 /01232431 552 /015661552 /01235671552 /01235741552 /01 23681552/01238771552/01234351552 /0129651552 :
+ ( ( " & + (
+
+
4
( %
;
+ , % + " * *
* +
( ( &
" +%
% 529 * '
+ + + ( * 1
'/ / ('0' 1/ / ' !% '$*''')' !$ ( + :
+ <
+ ( " * + + "
23552 ( +
< " + %, ( ++ * * , ' & # 622524 ( +
524(
* =
% ' & ' " # = " 558524 ,( ** + # ) /**
(
+ * * =
% * &
# * 58355 <
5
"
:
539552 ,(
"
:
23552 , ( " +
/'
/ 3#'$ 1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/ ( + * *
539552 23552 < % %
2258 ,( * + %;)
2722526 < +
(
+ *
* #
*
*
# / & # 6852 "+ + "
( + + + *
4> <
+ " / * &
* , )&
* + (
& 5225528 ( ( ? <
"*
*
+ * / * & + " +
*
45 '$' 1 / ' !% '$*''')' !$ + + "
539552 23552 < )
, *
' " # & 558525(
* ' & - & # $ 5225529 + * & / @* - * , ' & (# ! 72552
"*(
*
# = " 558524 *
, "
"
' & #"( #
264524 (
"*" ( (
*
*# & 284524<
"* ( "+
6 4 &'/( $/ " 1 / ' !% '$*''')' !$ + " +
6
539552;23552 %;)
, 2925523 < (
+ * * # $
* $A "# @* - 558524
)
B ( ( " + )
, 0 ( * $A " ( ( ( + < + +
)
B ( "
* ) + )
, / :
322524(
( (
+ * * $A "
- @* -
* A
# $
& <
"* " +
755 ' / '/ " ')' !$ 1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/
$
*) ( +" & * % & + ++ ? *
< 21 % ' 5C %
"
558524
8
524 2(
+ * * **
' & %
# - * #"' &- ( # ! 5(
+ * * # - * ( ( " + *
+% 529
+ /01628431524 " +( ( + 722524 "
"*"
( + * / " +
2(
+ * * #"# ! * $ ' - ( 5 (
* ( * '
&"
- (
+
+ 5255
62255 % +
" *
*
$'3!/ 3#'$ 1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/ + *
23552 <
7
( % % " 5952449 ( " A (+ 2256 ( * 587525 , *
# *" 558524 (
* /& # $ 558524
% (
* &
-
# *" 264524 <
" +
*
3'/ $/ " 1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/ " 2742446 E 1+ * 2446 62258 ,( , , * , ) # $
& 62258 * 232527 < ( * * ' # $
& E 19 (+ 237527 578524 (
* & % # $
& 558524F F* & ( (
* & % ( (
* ' # $
& 56;5552 ( * ( *
? <
"* ( * ' # $
& !
552 + "+
5552 5 / 13#'$ 1 / ' !% '$*''')' !$ " * + 62352 * $ # $ !
52 ( * & , # ( < ( * "+ :
F
% # ( ( ( * $ # " * +
524 * &
# @* - ,( 5552 # $ * ( (
( & $ (
( "
+ 52 - G * %( & 56552 <
* " * *
539552 448 $ *'3' 1 / ' !% '$*''') !$/ ( & % B
"* (
"+ * + +
* $ # & * ( ' & # 86524 <
"* * * 5H
:
+ "+
'
++
+ + *
+%
+, %
% 529( + * " % "+ * (
:
" * " "
+ %
;, * + *A"
+ * * + * + * + *
A +/ - 1/ / + * + "
" * + ***/
9+ * 52 + ( 1 I9Basic Principles:
% + * "+
" + J
+ * 3
;
;A +
(
* + * + "
K *
+ * +
1
7. Merit criteria for allotment of posts:
# + * "" *
+ " +8
"" (% " "
"prime factor + *+
(+9 + 8
,( & + & (* (*
(( ((
++ "
*
( * *
+*?* * 5 " "
+ + "
+
/
% + "
"
" (1 SN Major Factor Sub-Factor Max.
Points Criteria for calculation 2 *
#+" 9 *" + L693
*?* *+
* B
*?* *
"
% + * ( * + * +
* + SN Major Factor Sub-factor Max.
points Explanation 2
=* 2 2 " +*
5 / +*
0(;
;
; *
+* * 7
+;(++
; *
( & 2 +* +
" 2* & 6 / *
0( ( 1*
* *
;
*
3 B " ((
" 3 7>9> " M 2 & "9>8>M 23 & "8>M5 & 7 #++ "
G 5 ) *
5 #+ # *" 5 +
;
*
/ 3 # + N#" #
N 2 G +
" <<
<
"
, < & < $
$ $ /( / $ < / # / ' 2
4
9 #++ " *
;0*
2>++ " 2 ;0*
*
2> ++ "
" *?* *2 /
F +*
3 B* D
( &
J
( ;- (
8 ( ; - ( 3 % A *
"
+ ;- ( %
4 * + * %
" ?* 3 =
+ ( "
+ * + 3>8>M2 8>83>M5 83>4>M6 4>43>M7 43>2>M3
+ *
* + * "
" * + *** -
/ + *?* * + + ( " * (
* * N / N " *?* * 5 +
"
F + " + *
+N# +#" #
N
=
"2 25
+(
( "& +
+
<+
" (+" ( & B
# * " ++2
"
" *" +*
5
/
8( + + * 52 1 I8. Definition of vacant posts:
% "( + a) Actual Vacancy:
" ( " * * & b) Deemed Vacancy:
< * + ( 1 "
* + ++
* :
+ A + O
" * * 1 " + " * *
+ *
,( (
"
(" * * +
* * +
G *
"
( " " ( + " ( * * *
* + +
* *
+ + * +
* %
+
*
* * " & * "& K
* + , + ( * * /
8
"
+ 222551
"
G * D% D * "
"
( I ; K
"
(
" " ( + " ( * * *
* * (
/
8
"
589552 ( 1 7+:) 1-
;<2- ;- +
( 1 "
* + + +
* :
+ A + O
" ;
; *+ ( ( + /
* 538552 (
(
+ ( 1 I< + ++ ** - 8;5155 /F1< 589552
" " < + - 8
"
* "
1
;<2- ;- + ( 1 "
B
# *
+ + +
* :
+ A + O
" * * 1 " + " * *
+*
( * * ( K < #*G
" * (
/
8
"
+ " ( +
*
6
/
(
" * ( 1 " + " * +
+
* " *< #*G )
+
* ( + + * % * 589552"+
+
* :
+
" * * <(
+
*(* * "
+ ( "
"
( + ( "
" * )
+
"** "
(
* " + +
* *
< ( +
" ( + * * +
* *
*
"
:
(
+ )
+
"
" + <
( " ( ) , ( + * " + +
"* *
8
+ * ( ( *
:
" + /
! "#$%
& %& ( " " # ' )157155 ) (
"* +
/0- 2344 23567238772368 23243 2965 + 552 ( "
** " *
"
* *
" -
:
+ /
8 + " %
% ,( * *
"* ( 23 + ( "
"
** * ( % " ( +* <
* /0 -23574+552/0-23435+552/0- /0-566 +552
"* + * ( " *
$ * /01 235741552 ( * * &
# @* - 558524 % + * +, & & "++ (/ ' + B
( + * +
7
+ " ( ( + + + *( +# * / (
" /** " +
+ ' ; 1'
# $ * ( + * &
+ ?
"*
% + + * +# $ * (
- G * %( & 56552
" ( ? < +
"* < + + + * 27
# @* - * + $ * /01 234351552
"* * % $
& ( ( (
* & +
F* & ( & (
(
* '
" ( ? * # $
& + 23
+ + 26
+$
& + *" 22+++225552+
5 ( < & /01 5661552 (
+ *
* $& * ( # * * ( + * ( ? *
) ,
"*
(
* * (
+ * ( ? *
% (
"
" *% + ( (
"*
" *
" + * + "
"
+ *
<
+ + ( "
< + :
+
" & *
* ++
* * ( * *
2255 /01581524
*
/01581524 ( :
( " +
* +
+
:
/1 ' ( +
* (+/
8
"
P +% 3952 + * * +
( & (
* ( * ( " & "< #*G "
* * # 2255( " # ' + /
57555 )157155 + 1 / - # ' + /
( +
* + , D" */
/+<=+( 1 / (+ . '
$
/2= 2 4> #+ + / 0 ':: . '
$
4 /2= 2 555. +< -<+?=+0 1 /+(@?. '
$
/2= 2 44
. +
" + + "
< *
" "
+
+ %
% 529 * !
552 < #* G
+ ( 1 "
*
+ ++
* :
+
A + O
" ;
; <
"* /
" % * * 1 " + " * *
*
( * * ( < ( * * " "
" *
+ ( " % +
+
* * /
8
"
* +52 + !
552 (
*
539552 "
+ "
+ & + "
<
? ++64552+ /0123441 552 ( ;( * + (
"
* /
8
"
( ( %
% + ( *( + * &(
* * !
552 *( "
+
* #
+ + (
/
** ++ + + 0 /+ +
+
* + " * * * + * *
!
552 "
+
*)
+
" + *
< * + /
8
"
+ * 52( + #*G
" * * 1 " + " * *
+*
+ * + ( 1 "
B
# * + +3
* :
+ A + < * *
589552 < #* G
+ "
B
# *
+ + +
* :
+ A +
" ;
;
" * * ( *
< "
"
* * ( " ( +/
*538552% & + * + ?
"
"
+
" + * ?
" "
+ *
(
* ? 52
"
* * ( ( * +
4
* * + ( "
1
+
*
* % "
? "
, (
"* ? + +
* * + " * +*
* ( * ( * * * *"+ " *
<
"* ( + *
(
* ' * "
*
(
"
* 538552 < < #* G
" * *
" + " *
*
+ *
( * * ( #
+ (
+
+ (
?
;? + ( # * + * * * 1 ?==+ 1 < ( (* # *
5
( # * * + * ( * *
? + 1 0 * * ? * " + ?
* ( *
*
? 2 1 < ( *
" /
*
"
:
* +
+ *
& < # * * *
& :
( " /'/ %
% + * ( + & ( + (
(
*
( ( *
? ' ++ +;@2 1 < ? +
+
+ :
* * "
* *
( " * * ( "
? " * ?
<
$ * $ * /01235741552 /01234351552 ( + * *
+
( ( " & ( ( " * + *
* + (
+ " & % (
* *+ ( "
* " + " *" +
/0 5661552 (
* ( # * * * )&( * +
( * * )
+
* +
*
( *
( < ++ ? *
#
+ "
? + + * +* *+ + + * + *
* ( " :
J +
"
6
* * + B? + ( + " + " + +"
< +
" "+ /
+
+ < + ( * &
& "
+ *
< " " , D" */
' ( )
* !/ -2576+555 26555 * + * + * * + ; < +
?
*
+ + " * <
+
( *
"
+* / ' +
75 A B+ ? 1 / - Q * + ( ( %
& + + * % % #
* (
+ "
" *
"+ * ++
0 +
/
9+ /
+
"
+ "
* + * ( + *
8
$ (+
*
"
"
539552
"
:
* "
" & (/
8 "
P +%
% ( 5255 /01581524
( "
" # ' )157155,(
/0 - 2344 23567 23877 2368 23243 2965 + 552 * ; (
"+ # * ( 23 + * + * *" "+ /
"
** * ( ( + * * "
%
:
+
"* -
* ( " &
+ + ( 23 + (/
4 ? +% % - * "
$ ( +
* " /0 - 2344 2356723877236823243 2965+552 + /0 - 23435 23574 566 + 552 *
+ +
0+ "+<< - . &2@ 0 & ;
@ ;- 0 " @ ;-