High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/8745/2017dismissed

Anup Singh v. Sardar Joginder Singh

2020-01-16Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill6 pages

!"#"$% $& '()* $&+,"$-. //0//

'#&# , '2 '-"$2 ',"$-. 0//

% 34 / , ,,44

% '// /,.

'5 *26!

* '

'//,/

$2.

*26!

* ' '

+'

'"$ +'

"$"# '8& #."$- "9 2:( '

&$2 "$; $# '&5 #!

*< '#.'

= 3>

#&55$"$-'2 '2

2//+ ## "$* -'&$2

"$

'9"

' !5+9 2 &$2 , "$;

.&-.!$6"!

2:(

9 &'

6"2 ?&2-5 !$6"!

$2 '2 '

2 @//*

9 6"2 ?&2-5

//) ## :(

22"

9, ##"$#&2- * &9/ 1"2 '2 ' 2

2 )/;/* ."# &'

7."9 "##&"$-$ 5 "$*+ ## 997"$-'2 '% A

'2/

2 !&$# 9 '

' #&:5"

'9"

' "9 2 :( '

'

<> +&$"#.

&$2 "$; $# '&5 !

* < ' #.'

!

>* "$ 7."!. +

!$6"!

2 :& "'# ++

&'

2 ."5 -"6"$- :#

"$# + B&'

"$!

- $2'

+,"$-.1#/, 6"

"'"

$2 (*<> <"6"9> :# '6"$-

# "9 2 :

B+"'( 2 (#*

' # '6"!

$

'/ .

' "9

"$ :

9

2 ."

&2"!"

9 -"#

* &9

9$-7"

. ++9"!

"$&$2 "$<:> !

9 &'

7"

.& !$#"2 '"$- ( ' + ##"$-

$('2 '!$2$"$- ("$ "9"$- *.

#&55$

5 "$ '/// $

$7."9 * &'

' +'!

2"$-# "$ #.

99 '

"$ #

"99 2"#+# 9

++9"!

"$ &$2 ' , "$ <:> !

2 :( "#* .7 '* 5 !9

" ++9"!

&$2 "$<:> !

2(:

$2 !"2 ' "# 2 !"2

' + ."# '2 9 &'

7"99:

9":

( +'!

2 &'

'7"

. /C 2 (* 9

2 !&$# 9 '

' .

'-&

"$"$- !$2 !5+9 2 :( !5+9 $2+ ##"$- #&55$"$-'2

$*"#

2&:9 ?

+'# !&

$2+&$"#.

2$

$7."!..

#+'

6"&#9(

9/

9"

9#+9 2&+$ ,"$-9 $!.?&2-5 # ."#&'

<;> D.

?1#/

'2

+,.

'5 *;<;> <'"5"$ 9>);

'"$!

E&5 '1#/,

&$?

: '*;<>

<'"5"$ 9>/ '.

$2*9

2!&$# 9 ++

'"$- '

7."9 9("$- &+$ ?&2-5 $3:9 + B &'

"$ - $2'

+ ,"$-.3# !

<#&+'

>* .

'-&

9

2 :(

# $ $ 5 $2 '

# $

!!&$ "$- +'

&'

/ .&#* "

"#

'-&

!$2!5+9 "9 2:(

?&2-5 2

2 //) :(

2 22"

9 , ##"$# &2- * &9* "# 6 '( 5&!.

$2 # "# #&55$"$- '2 ' + ##

"$/ .

'29

2!&$# 9 ' -$ .'&-. "9 "##&

"#'

8&"'

!$#"2 2"$ "$#

"# 7.

9 -'

'"$

'9"

'!5+9 "9 2&$2 "$;

2&:9 ?

$2* .&#* !$2 "#$

/ ?&2-5

2 //) + ## 2 :(

222"

9, ##"$#&2- * &9*"##9 9(:

?&2-5 "$- $2'

+,"$-.3#!

<#&+'

>/$

"2!

$3:9 + B&'

#.

#&$2 '%

<> A/, "$ !

+'

#!'":

52

$2# 9# "5 7"

."$7."!. '

&$2 "$ ; !

$ :

"9 2/ !5+9 &$2 "$ ;:(

' .92 '"$2& !&'# !.

8&

"$ 7'"

"$- $2 $

2# 7"

."$ $ 5$ . '5

$7."!. &# '"# $&$2 '!9 &# <!> +'6"# , ;/ .

'"2 $ 5$ . &$2 <:>:

-"$# '5

$7."!. &#

"$ .

'"# $ &$2 ' !9 &# <!> +'6"#

, ;/ 7 "

"# "

&'

2#& "!"

&# ' D"$- 7"

."$ +'

#!'":

'"2 $ 5$ .* (:

$:(

&'

+'

#!'":

2 + '"2/ 7* #"$!

&' $#7 8& "$ <"> "# "$ $

"6 * 7 :#

' .92 '"$2& !&'# !.

8& ( "9 #.!5+9 7"

."$$ 5$ . '5

2 !"#"$ "$ !'"5"$ 9 $2*"$

*2 ("$ "9"$- 7"99:

#.

6"$-:

$!$2$ 2&$2 +'6"# !9 &# <:> , "$ !

/ ."# 2"'

"$ #.

99 :

++9"!

99 #&!. + $2"$- !

# 7.

+'!

2 &'

' "$ 6"

7 &' $#7 8& "$ <">/ # 7 .

2( .

2 :

B+"'( 2 (# '5

'

"+ $ "##& 2&$2 '!9 &# <!> +'6"# , "$ ;"# $

'5"

+'

'(#

$(9

'#

/"#'

2( "# $9( '

#. !5+9 F $2 " !&92 $ 2 7"

."$ "5 +'

#!'":

&$2 "$ <:>* ."# '

!&'# "#

D :

+'6"#* #

"# ("$- &'

#& "!"

&# /C '5 "29 79 "227$:( $3:9 + B &'

* "

"# ++

"$ 7.

<> 7 # "9 2:

B+"'( '"22 (# "+&9

2 "$ $ 8&"'

2 &+$ 2'

' !.

8& &'

!-$"G

/7 !$2!5+9 $ &# "$.

#:

$.

("$ "9"$- #&!. !5+9 #.

99 :

.

!$2$ 2/ $ 5( +"$"$* 6 '( :?

9 ("$- 27$

9 7 "2 7 !&'

"9 +'

"9"$- +'

&'

#/ 7 '* :( -'

"$- 9":

( #. !5+9 # "$ #* 7.

# .

2( :

$ "9 2 7"

.& B+"'( $2

'( '"2 2 (#"$

'5# , "$;<!> * :

#:

$# '&!D# $ 2"9 ##/ ?&2-5 "$4 D.

?3#!

<#&+'

>"# $ 9+

' '

"2!

"

7

$!

# !$6"!

2 &$2 ' , * #&:# 8& &$2 ' , "$ ; !

"# $

$2 .

!!&# 2 7

2 "$ "2 !

/ ,"5"9 ' "# +#"

"$ 7"

. '2 ?&2-5 '"$!

E&5 '3#!

<#&+'

>/ $ 6"

7 :6 * "

"2

"9"$- !$2 !5+9 $2 +

<)> #&55$"$- '2 "$* 2&:9 ?

$6"

7 :6 *2$ "$2 $(5 +'

"$/ "#2"#5"## 2/ $& '()* 2# H.

',+

D"$-@

#$ 2% #@ H.

'

+'

% #@