← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15797/2011allowed

Joginder Singh Rathee And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2015-02-13Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan9 pages





         

 !"!#$ %&'

&()*   +!#,&-!#+.

./ .&" 

  -

 &( / .&" 

     

 !"!#$ %&'

&()*  0&!".

#

1/ .&" 

  -

 &( / # .& 

  ))  

 !"!#$ %&'

&()* 

20'1 &/ # .& 

  -

 &( / .&" 

  )345  

 !"!#$ %&'

&()*  +!#,&-!#+./ .&" 

  -

 &( / # .& 

6$ 786  -  - 6-        

     !""



 

  $ !     

 % "

&

 !   (((((



  - 6-*  ) "   *' !

+

     #,-.

/010 20/

0 34 #2 !

"#

 !

5  !  ! 

"

 !6

" 7   #7'



 

 6!

  "'     6

5    97



% 

 

"

 !   #& 6!

!

%

 

5

& :

  

7)##

 

  "%

,

" 13!

#  #

;13"; ,

#

  !   !'#"# ""

5 ! < <"

#

8 " "  !

=

!

57





!

7

7' !

!#

 !



! !

7'6' # !

>

 !8 #



 !#  "

5 7

#

!

,-.

/010 #2 ";?

5!

 !@    #& @ ; +   !

"#

 !  ! 

 

#

 !13"A"

<

 !

 !  !"

'

5%

   !

"7

"  !

"!/' ;



 !   B!

7



' #

  

 !

#"# ""  ! < <"

!7



"1 # !13"6!

!"6 ! ! !





 !'6 

 !7 # #

 & #

 !  !13"6   

  2423113

  #

97

 !' "< "  !  #," 8!7



7'



#,"; ;

"16!

2C #



7#



5  !97

#

97

  # !32C 77'6' #



#

 

  " !

5! !

!7 5  ! ' "<"  !  #," 87 

 !  !"7' ! %

  !' 

#

8 !  < "

  #  !  ' "   !  #    ," 8  7  

"'  !

 "

'6!

!

5%

,  + 

# !

"!" "



*

!=5 # !

,-.

0 #220 ";

5 $!    #& @

;





2223

D "  !=5 # !

,

,-.

022 #22 ";9 "@    & @

;





1202

D 1 &

 !  !#  !  !=

! 7

  *  ! 

5

5

=

 !=5

!!7 7' !

*

   5

 6!

! !

"9 

#

7' !   #&       !  6  7

57 

!7 7

5! 

# !,

!  5    !      6  "

 !

5  7  ""

6   &



#

 !  !6

  7""

6 ) !

"#

7  !  

 6

""'

 ,"+"

' 

:

   7 " 

97

 !' " #2/2/12+  !' 113  !13"6    !  #97

67 "

!  ! #

97

6

 6!

,"+++  5

'%

,!

5 ! ' " # 2/2/126!

< "  !  #," 8

 !  #97

  7 "

!  !'  6

5 ! ' ","  !'



 !7 # #



8 "1 # !13"&

 ! 

""'

    20113  

D     6   6!

"""

'!

5%

,     6!

 !' "" !

<"  !  #," 86 !"

87  7<

  /111 

D   "

!7 6 ! 6 #

6!

67"

%

,  6 "

7

 !7 # #"1 #13"&   !  !

*

!=5 # !

   6"

56 ! 

 6!   ! 

    20113  6  "

7"   #

 ! =5 6 "

!" !

&

 ! !

6 # !"  

6 5  6 "

57#

 !&

;7" , #   !  " !9 #

7' !   #& 

/

, "  #

 ! 

  !  "   "

  

 !

*

!=5 # !

,-.

1/ #224 " ;!

5!   #& @ 



323224 6!

6!" !  "

'!

5%

,    6

5 ! ' "," 8

"

7"#

 !13" &

5"'

 !  !6



7

56   '    " +!

 !7 

7' !

"#



 6 ! !

  

!5

 !

5! !

  "1 # !13""

 D*6 "7 !  





! !

 <



 

B! "

#"1=   D* # ""

6     

                    

     !"

        !"

    "#   !$  !    ! %  !            & % 

    ! '( #$%&'() !"

 )        !  $       *! 

4

+        !, -.  #  !  / ! $ %

 .      1     .  &      23  4! % 

  1 6    '(

" # !7 "6 "!

6 !  "

'6!

7"

5 %

,  6

5' "<"



 !  !  # ," 8

#

#," 2C< & 6

"

'6!

7"

%

,7 ! ' "  "  !  !  #    ," 8    "

7"  #

   B!

<



%

 "

'  ! !!

"7

" 



6 5  !' " # !  !"7'!

B! "

"

'#

%

 "

' # ' 

6 !

"

<"

 !7 #

' #



"' B!

!

""'

 !  !' 6

#97

%

   6!

!# !

7   7' !

6    + !7

"

7!"#

 !  ! #97

!7 7 "

!7 

E   !

## !7

"

7 

  !

+ 

#,"; ;

"17 "

"'

#

 !

" #

97

 !  #

97

B!  # ""

6  &  +   7

 089           +

0

  % 

 :89 ! %

   !            & '( B!

,"; ;#"  ! 

6 5

 !  7 "

# !   # 97

 &  !   97

7 7 "

!

"

!7 #

 #

#

97

"! ,"; ;

"17 "  + 6 "

7   #6' 

!  !  !



#,"; ;

 !13 "6 

 2423113+ 

#

" !  !

 !

5 ! #97

!

 "'

%

   +# ! 7

6 "7

7 # #

"1 =  # !13" 6  D*   "'

!

" 

 ! /' #

#97

 +  6 # !7  "  !  !

 "

7"#

  !13" #



7' !



  !' !""

7"#

8 "

" 7' !

"#

!

  =5  

7 # '!"



 !  

6 !

5  ! #

97

,"+++%

,   #  ! 

3

 !' "< " # ! 86!

! !, !"

 !

"

7"#

"1= # !13" 6! 

  

 6

#97

 %

   #

!< "

 # !' "

" 6 ! ! #," 8<

  "1= #

%

 "

'#

#," 8 

" 6 !/' ;D

%

     D*

!"  !

 !7 #

' #



 "'

5 $!

!6

$  5!$ ! 7

6 6

#97

6 =

 #97

  6!

!  #  

     7'  ! 

  

  ! 

 

 !  !' 

8#

 !  !

=

6 

 #

  !

 5" 7  !=5 7'

+;   6! 5

 "'" "

'  !

!7 !"

 8 !7    !  !

 !

!7

 !7 # # ! =5 

 +  6 # !7   !6  ""

6 

 !""

7"#

" 1= 6  D* #13" 





 !

#

1

8#

 !  !

=

6 

 6



# 6 

!#

 !  #   #

'





#

!""7 

 !D  3

!

 !  ## "

# !6

 B! !""7



  9  - 6-:

%&'

&()*    1