High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12641/2024dismissed

M/S Drs Plastchem Private Ltd v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-07-15Mr. Justice Arun Palli,Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal10 pages

!"# $#"# # # %

&' ! (

)*+ #,- , !( # # -)# ,- - . ,&', /0# ,- - . ,&', /!

(/,- # #1 ,- , !( 22222 3 # 45 # # !+ ) 64, 3 # 7 3869!# : !;#( ( <= > (! :' ! ( # # " # #1#

:" ## $#"# ,( >!#!6

" 9-? 6= > # # ! ( # # -1" ,## " !6

" ,>

? 8! #( ( > !> " # 5 5

9-?6 =, 6('" ! 9((?#" '=, ! # >!#! > 1# # ! "( # 8! (( 1# ! # > #"# 59-?6@= 3: > !( # #! >#((! !# 8!

# ># ( # # ! ! : # > 6

, >!# ! ( # #!1! ' !"( ##1 !('

$$ !(( 8!#># ( # #>#( 4 9-? 6 =, 1##1 #: ' # (( : ! !# ' ( " !#1:":' ! ! !(( !:

# :' ! ( # # : # " >, ! , :

5 8!( # #1#)) ! !# :'>' 6

,)#1# # !( 6 ! !" ":' !"8!#># ( # #> #( # 9-? 6=, ># ! # # ! ((

!# ' 1 # ! # ! " ! "( #:#1" " !( # #

-# #1 ! "( # ! ( :' ! ((

!# ', !( # #!1#)) ! !# :'>' !# ( # # $ ( #1 ! ( # # ' 1 ! ! #"(1 #: > " ": *1" # # ! ># ( # #

> " # !# ! ! "( # !(:' ! ((

!# ' #:

!-)# ( #1 !( , ! ,( : (' *1"

5( :'# +!#66 5 #

,>!# !( # #!!

1 ! ' " ! ># ( # # ! : #"# 3 > :"# ! !# ># ( # ##1: !( > ! 6# ! # ># ( # # !#1 : #"# "# " " # ! >#

$%$ ( # # :#"# !#1 8 !#, ( #1 ! ( # # :"# ! !>((#: !# :' !( # # 4 ! 1# !1!

# # ! # # ! @ -"# ', 66 5 > # :' ! ( # # # >!#! !( # #!!

1 !"( # 5 5

5 ( # (( 8! " > 1 "# !( # #>#"#

5:'# +! !# 1(!,5 > : !(( !( ( # #6 & '( )(*+*+ ,(- './ .))- .0'(1 *'+/ 2-* )-.3+,4 "

-$ //2.,0( ".5-+* "0(-*+ -.-+"

-62./'+,4 *'(-(/27)*+ -1(-1.*(1 %#%##8,,(92-( $ %:).//(1;3-(/) ,1(,* %./5(<<./62./'+,4

-1(- " *'( ))(<<.*( 2*'

-+*3 1.*(1 ## #% 8,,(92-( $

:.,1"2-*'(-)-.3(1"

-1+-(0*+,4*'( -(/) ,1(,*/ * -(/* -( *'( -(/27(1 /+*( +, ".= 2- *'()(*+*+ ,(- 999 999 9999

% , =+(5 " *'( .;

=( 1+/02//+ , *'( ".0*/ .,1 0+-027/*.,0(/ "*'(0./(5.--.,*, +,*(-"(-(,0( ,<3 *'(42,1 "=+ <.*+ "*'()-+,0+)<(/ ",.*2-.<>2/*+0( (/)(0+.<<3 +, *'( ;.0?42,1 " *'( /)(0+"+0 -(;2**.< ;3 -(/) ,1(,* % +, *'( -(/27)*+ -1(- 8,,(92-( $%:

5+*' -(4.-1 * /(-=+,4 "

2- , *+0(/ +//2(1 , #@#A#

# %#A# C .,1 #C#C# C , *'( )(*+*+ ,(- ;("

-().//+,4*'(-(/27)*+ -1(-

! ,*'(<+4'* "*'(."

-(/.+1)-+,0+)<(/5(1 , *"+,1 .,3 42,1 * +,*(-"(-( 5+*' *'( -1(-/ ).//(1 ;3 -(/) ,1(,*/ .,1 % (/) ,1(,* % './ , *

$!$ 77+**(1.,3+<<(4.<+*3;3 -1(-+,4*'(-(/27)*+ "*'( /+*( , .00 2,* " , ,$).37(,* " *'( (,'.,0(1 7)(,/.*+ ,$./*'(/.7(5.//)(0+"+0.<<3/*+)2<.*(1+,*'( .<< *7(,* <(**(- 8,,(92-( $ : (/2<*.,*<3 5+*' *'( .;

=($/.+1 ;/(-=.*+ ,/ 7.1( *'( )-(/(,* 5-+* )(*+*+ /*.,1/1+/7+//(1 '

5(=(-5+*', -1(-./* 0 /*/D -( !*1" !> ! # 1" > :' # ( #1 !( # ## !# ># ( # # :' ( #1 !( ,>! >( #!#1:8!# +! # !" "

1 !* !># ( # #3 # " 1 ! !# !:># !! :' !( # #

" !# + (#1 !, # > : # ?"# >! > : !

! !( # # 3 #>

! ' # #1 ,>!((! ! , > ' ! !># ! !# ': # ! "( ! - ( # # >!#! ) # # : ! ( > # #:

: # !' !! 3 !

# %8:%C@ ! (" 3#> #1 ># ! (( 1# 5 ( :' ### +! !-

!:&#1! 9$)>+!=#>!#!, !&#1! ! #"# ># ( # # # :' /#! "# >!#! #>#

1 #6## #1# !! .!#># ! )!-( " !#>!#!>#, !# : ( ! > ># !:' !-(? 8! :(##( "1#1 "####>(#

$B$ :' ! (" # >! 6 ;C 5( /'.<< 1(.< 5+*' *'( 62(/*+ , 5'(*'(- ;

*' - .,3 " *'( )(*+*+ ,(-/ +, +=+< -+* (*+*+ , /

.,1

BE#

.-( 42+<*3 " /2))-(//+ " 7.*(-+.< ".0*/ , * .))- .0'+,4*'( 2-*5+*'0<(.,'.,1/ .,1*'(-(;3.;2/+,4*'( )- 0(// " *'( 2-* ("

-( 5( 15(<< 2) , *'( ".0*/ .,1 0+-027/*.,0(/ "*'(0./(+,'.,1 <(*2/-("(-* / 7(0./(<.5/ 5'+0' 5 2<1 '(<) 2/ +, 1(.<+,4 5+*' *'( )-(/(,* /+*2.*+ , 5+*' 4-(.*(-)-(0+/+ ,'(0./(/ ".;2/( "*'()- 0(// "0 2-*.,1 /20' .<<+(1 7.**(-/ '.=( ;((, .-+/+,4 ;(" -( *'( 2-*/ ,/+/*(,*<3 '+/ 2-* './ '.1 7.,3 00./+ ,/ 5'(-( +* 1(.<* 5+*'*'(0./(/ "*'+/?+,1.,1+*'./0<(.-<3/*.*(1*'()-+,0+)<(/ *'.*5 2<14 =(-,*'( ;<+4.*+ ,/ ".<+*+4.,*5'+<(.))- .0'+,4 *'(0 2-*"

--(1-(//.< ".,34-+(=.,0(.,1*'(0 ,/(62(,0(/ .;2/( "*'()- 0(// "0 2-*(7.3-(0.)+*2<.*(.,1/*.*(/ 7(

"*'()-+,0+)<(/*+/1+""+02<** /*.*(/20')-+,0+)<(/(9'.2/*+=(<3 .,15+*'/20'.002-.03*'.*5 2<12,+"

-7<3.))<3* .=.-+(*3 0./(/'(/(.-( 8+: 2-*/'.=( =(-*'(0(,*2-+(/ "- 5,(12) ,<+*+4.,*/ 5'

5+*' +,*(,* * 1(0(+=( .,1 7+/<(.1 *'( 2-*/ +,+*+.*(1 )- 0((1+,4/ 5+*'

2* "2<< 1+/0< /2-( " ".0*/ .,1 0.7( * *'( 2-*/ 5+*' 2,0<(., '.,1/ 2-*/ '.=( '(<1 *'.* /20' <+*+4.,*/.-(,(+*'(- (,*+*<(1* ;('(.-1 , *'( 7(-+*/ "*'( 0./(, -(,*+*<(1* .,3-(<+(" 8++: '()( )<( 5'

.))- .0'*'( 2-*"

--(<+(" ,.,(9 ).-*(/*.*(7(,* .-(2,1(-.0 ,*-.0*5+*'*'(0 2-**'.**'(3 2<1 /*.*( *'( 5'

<( 0./( "2<<3 .,1 ".+-<3 * *'( 0 2-* .,1 5'(-(*'(<+*+4.,*'./;- ?(,/20'".+*'

*'(1+/0-(*+ "*'( 2-*0.,, *;((9(-0+/(1+,".= 2- "/20'.<+*+4.,* 8+++: '( ;<+4.*+ ,* .))- .0'*'( 2-*5+*'0<(.,'.,1/ +/.,.;/ <2*( ;<+4.*+ ,.,1'./-()(.*(1<3;((,-(+*(-.*(1;3 *'+/ 2-* 8+=: F2(/*/ "

- )(-/ ,.< 4.+,/ '.=( ;(0 7( / +,*(,/( *'.* *'

/( +,= <=(1 +, <+*+4.*+ , 1 , * '(/+*.*( * *.?( /'(<*(- ".</('

1 .,1 7+/-()-(/(,* .,1 /2))-(// ".0*/ +, *'( 0 2-* )- 0((1+,4/ .*(-+.<+/7 )) -*2,+/7 .,1 7.<+0+ 2/ +,*(,* '.=( =(-$/'.1 5(1*'( <1(*'

/ "<+*+4.*+=(=.<2(/"

-/7.<< 4.+,/ 8=: <+*+4.,*5'

.**(7)*/* ) <<2*(*'(/*-(.7 ">2/*+0(

-5'

* 20'(/*'()2-("

2,*.+, ">2/*+0(5+*'*.+,*(1'.,1/ +/, *(,*+*<(1* .,3-(<+("

+,*(-+7 -"+,.<

$ $ 8=+: '( 2-* 72/* (,/2-( *'.* +*/ )- 0(// +/ , * .;2/(1 .,1+, -1(-* )-(=(,*.;2/( "*'()- 0(//*'(0 2-* +*5 2<1 ;( >2/*+"+(1 (=(, +, +,/+/*+,4 , "2-,+/'+,4 " /(02-+*3 .,1 +, 0./(/ " /(-+ 2/ .;2/( *'( 2-* 5 2<1 ;( 12*3 ;

2,1 * +7) /('(.=30 /*/ 8=++: '(-(=(- . )2;<+0 +,*(-(/* +/ +,= ?(1 *'( 2-* 72/* (9.7+,(*'()(*+*+ ,0.-("2<<3* (,/2-(*'.**'(-(+/4(,2+,( )2;<+0 +,*(-(/* +,= <=(1 '( /*-(.7 " >2/*+0( /'

2<1 , * ;( .<< 5(1* ;() <<2*(1;32,/0-2)2< 2/<+*+4.,*/ 8=++: '( 2-* (/)(0+.<<3 *'( 2)-(7( 2-* './ * 7.+,*.+, /*-+0*(/* =+4+<.,0( =(- *'( .;2/( " *'( )- 0(// 2-* .,1 -1+,.-+<3 7(11<(/ 7( ;3/*.,1(-/ /'

2<1 , * ;( 4-.,*(1G=+/.G.,3/ 0+(*.<) <<2*.,*/0-(.*(,(5)- ;<(7/

"2,-(1-(//(14-+(=.,0(/.,1*'( 2-*/'

2<1(,12-(* *.?( 0./(/5'(-(*'(>2/*+0( "*'(<+/5(<<$>2/*+"+(/+* ("(-

!"#$#% " && $$'( )

* +"#$$!,%&!& %-./0 !"#$$%1 && /2

& 5 + "#$#!$% & !& % .'"0 "#$#!$% )6 -1"0 "#$#!$%&7/#10!"#$#%-&&'#"8 5 3 >! ! ! (" !# ' ! ! # *' 01 # # ! ! " ! ( #1, " 1" !( #, !# !:# !* # #'' "3 > ! 6 &% +*'*'().//.4( "*+7( +*'./;((,-(.<+/(1*'.*)( )<( 2/(1* "((<)- 21* *(<<*'(*-2*'+,*'( 2-*/ +--(/)(0*+=( *'(0 ,/(62(,0(/;2**'.*)-.0*+0(, < ,4(-)- =(/*-2( +,.<< 0./(/'( 2-*1 (/, */+*/+7)<3./.,27)+-(+,.0 ,*(/* ;(*5((,*5 ).-*+(/.,11(0<.-(.**'((,1 "*'(0 7;.*./* 5'

'./5 ,.,15'

'./< /*;2*+*'./.<(4.<12*3 "+*/ 5, +,1()(,1(,* " ).-*+(/ * *.?( .0*+=( - <( +, *'( )- 0((1+,4/ .,1 -(.0' .* *'( *-2*'

5'+0' +/ *'( "

2,1.*+ .17+,+/*-.*+ " >2/*+0( '(-("

-( *'( *-2*' /'

2<1 ;(0 7( *'(+1(.<* +,/)+-(*'(0 2-*/* )2-/2('+/0.,;(.0'+(=(1 ;3/*.*2* -+<37.,1.*+,4*'( 2-*/* ;(0 7(.0*+=(/((?(-/ *-2*' (,.;<(*'(0 2-*/* 5.-1 ""2,>2/*+"+(1+,*(-"(-(,0( +, *'(+- 5 -?+,4 *'

/( 5'

+,12<4( +, +77 -.< .0*/ <+?( )(->2-3 )-(=.-+0.*+ , .,1 7 *+=.*(1 ".</('

72/* ;( .))- )-+.*(<3 1(.<* 5+*' '( ).-*+(/ 72/* /*.*( " -*'5+*'

$A$ /2""+0+(,*".0*2.<1(*.+</* *'((9*(,**'.*+*-(120(/*'(.;+<+*3 * )2*"

-5.-1".</(.,1(9.44(-.*(10<.+7/.,1.<+*+4.,*72/* .))- .0'*'( 2-*5+*'0<(.,'.,1/*+/*'(;

2,1(,12*3 *'( 2-** (,/2-(*'.*1+/'

,(/*3.,1.,3.**(7)** /2-).// *'(<(4.<)- 0(//72/*;((""(0*+=(<302-;(1.,1*'( 2-*72/* (,/2-(*'.**'(-(+/, 5- ,4"2< 2,.2*'

-+/(1 -2,>2/*4.+,* .,3 ,( ./ . -(/2<* ".;2/( " *'( )- 0(// " *'( 2-* ,( 5.3 * 02-; *'+/ *(,1(,03 +/ * +7) /( -(.<+/*+0 - )2,+*+=( /*/ %% '().-*3, *.))- .0'+,4*'( 2-*5+*'0<(.,'.,1/ 2<1;(<+.;<(* ;(, ,$/2+*(1.,1/20').-*3 5'

'./.</ /200((1(1+,) <<2*+,4*'(/*-(.7 ">2/*+0(;37.?+,4).*(,*<3 ".</( /*.*(7(,*/ 0.,, * 0<.+7 -(<+("

(/)(0+.<<3 2,1(- -*+0<(

% "*'( ,/*+*2*+ ,'+<(.))- .0'+,4*'(0 2-* .<+*+4.,* 72/* /*.*( 0 --(0* ".0*/ .,1 0 7( 5+*' 0<(., '.,1/ '(-( /20' /*.*(7(,* " ".0*/ +/ ;./(1 , / 7( +,"

-7.*+ , *'( / 2-0( " /20' +,"

-7.*+ , 72/* .</ ;( 1+/0< /(1 *.<<3 7+/0 ,0(+=(1 )(*+*+ , .7 2,*/ * .;2/( " *'( )- 0(// " *'( 2-*.,1/20'.<+*+4.,*+/, *-(62+-(1* ;(1(.<*5+*'<+4'*<3 ./.)(*+*+ ,0 ,*.+,+,47+/<(.1+,4.,1+,.002-.*(/*.*(7(,* +" "+<(1 * .0'+(=( ., 2<*(-+ - )2-) /( .7 2,*/ * .;2/( " *'( )- 0(// "*'(0 2-*<+*+4.,*+/;

2,1* 7.?(G"2<<.,1*-2( 1+/0< /2-( "".0*/G!07 9

5 )+:$2/2!$%&&$$#8() 5

)

;

)+ "#$"!-% & !& % $0 "#$"!-% ) >65 !)6%,/0!"#$"%/&&'-#(& ) 5 < + $22,!$% & !& % "$#0 !$22,%&&!$%'"$()?

* + "#$"!$%&7/'$0!"#$$%/&&$',(

= 3

) )+"#$$!,%&!& %-210 !"#$$% 1 && /-2( * )+ "#$"!"%&!& %/"/"#$"!"% ) >65 !)6% "'"0"#$"!"%&7,,$0!"#$$%-&&".1% %! '()(-/ ,/((?+,4(62+*372/*1 (62+*3*+/, *>2/* *'( 0<(., '.,1/ ;2* .</ 0<(., 7+,1 0<(., '(.-* .,1 0<(.,

;>(0*+=(*'.*.-(*'((62+$"2,1.7(,*.</ ">21+0+ 2/<+*+4.*+ , '( <(4.< 7.9+7 >2-( ,.*2-.( .(6227 (/* ,(7+,(7 027 .<*(-+2/1(*-+7(,* (*+,>2-+."+(-+< 02)<(*+ -(7 5'+0'7(.,/ *'.*+*+/.<.5 ",.*2-(*'.* ,(/'

2<1, *;((,-+0'(1;3*'( < // - +,>2-3 * ., *'(- +/ *'( )(-0()* "

- 2-*/ +1( >2-+/1+0*+ "*'(0 2-*/'

2<1, *;(0 7(./ 2-0( ".;2/(

$@$ *'()- 0(// "<.5;3*'(1+/4-2,*<(1<+*+4.,*.-("2<(9(-0+/( +/ .</ ,(0(//.-3 * (,/2-( *'.* *'( <+*+4.*+ , +/ 4(,2+,( , * *+=.*(1 ;3 (9*-.,( 2/ 0 ,/+1(-.*+ ,/ .,1 +7) /(/ .,

;<+4.*+ , 2) , *'( <+*+4.,* * 1+/0< /( *'( *-2( ".0*/ .,1 .))- .0'*'(0 2-*5+*'0<(.,'.,1/ %B <+*+4.,*0.,)<.3'+1(.,1/((?5+*'*'(0 2-*/ -.1 )* )+0?.,10'

/(-2(".0*/ 24'** ;(1+/0< /(1./*'( 2-* ?, 5/<.5 ;2*, *".0*/ ,( 5'

1 (/, *0 7(5+*'0.,1+1 ".0*/ .,1 0<(., ;-(./* 0.,, * '

<1 . 5-+* " *'( 0 2-* 5+*' / +<(1 '.,1/ 2))-(//+ - 0 ,0(.<7(,* " 7.*(-+.< ".0*/ +/ +7)(-7+//+;<(* .<+*+4.,* -(=(,./.*(0',+62( ".1= 0.03 , /20' 0./(/ *'( 2-* +/ 12*3;

2,1 * 1+/0'.-4( -2<( ,+/+ .,1/20'.))<+0.,*+/-(62+-(1* ;(1(.<*5+*'"

-0 ,*(7)* 2-*"

-.;2/+,4*'()- 0(// "*'(0 2-*! )5

* +:!"##.%$"&&'.$8 !# #1 !# : ( >,# > ! 6 &!B - 7 *'( .;

=( /)(0+"+0.=(-7(,*/ 7.1( +, *'( 5-+* )(*+*+ ,/ +* +/ 0<(.- *'.* ;

*' *'(/( )(*+*+ ,(-/ '.=( .))- .0'(1 *'( 2-* 5+*' ".</('

2,0<(., '.,1/.,1'.=(7+/<(1*'(0 2-*/;3/'

5+,42-4(,03 .,1 (9+4(,0+(/ +, -(<.*+ , * ., +,0+1(,* " %-1 (0(7;(- ## 5'+0'

+,".0* .00 -1+,4* *'(*'-(( )(*+*+ ,(-/.,1*'() <+0(5./".</( '.=(*'2/.;2/(1 *'( )- 0(// " *'( 0 2-* .,1 7+/2/(1 *'( >21+0+.< )- 0(// '(3 7.<+0+ 2/<3 .,1 5+*' 2<*(-+ - 7 *+=(/ (,0- .0'(12) ,*'(=.<2.;<(*+7( "*'( 2-*.,1 5./*(1 )2;<+0 7 ,(3 * +/ . /(**<(1 0., , *'.* , <+*+4.,* './ . -+4'* * 2,<+7+*(1 124'* 2) , *'( 2-**+7(.,1)2;<+07 ,(3+, -1(-* 4(*'+/."".+-/ /(**<(1 +, *'( 7.,,(- ./ '( 5+/'(/ '( )-+=+<(4( (./3 .00(// * >2/*+0( './ ;((, .;2/(1 ;3 *'(/( )(*+*+ ,(-/ ;3 "+<+,4 "-+= < 2/ .,1 7+/0 ,0(+=(1 )(*+*+ ,/ , *'( ;./+/ " +,0 --(0* .,1 +,0 7)<(*( .<<(4.*+ ,/ *'(3'.10-(.*(12-4(,03"

-(9)(1+*+ 2/ '(.-+,4 "*'()(*+*+ ,/ 5'+0',(=(-(9+/*(1=(,*'+/

$C$ 2-*'.1* /)(,11.3/* -(.0'.**'(*-2*' -+7. ".0+( +* +/ 0<(.- *'.* ;

*' *'(/( )(*+*+ ,(-/ '.=( 7+/$ /*.*(1 ".0*/ 5+*''(<1 *-2( ".0*/.,1 (=(, 4+=(, ".</( .,1+,0 --(0*.""+1.=+*/'(35(<<?,(5*'.* 2-*/ .-(4 +,4* -(<32) ,*'(+-)<(.1+,4/.,1.""+1.=+*/ 5'+<( ).//+,4 .))- )-+.*( -1(-/ '( +-(0* - (,(-.<

<+0( 5./ -(62+-(1 * "+<( ., .""+1.=+* .,1 1+-(0*(1 * 0 ,120* +,=(/*+4.*+ , -2*';(+,4*'(;./+/ ">2/*+0(1(<+=(-3/3/*(7 +*5./ +7) -*.,*"

-*'+/ 2-** -(.0'.**'(*-2*'

5'+0' 5(5(-(.;<(* -(.0'.*5+*'*'(.;<(.//+/*.,0( ".<< *'(0 2,/(<.,1'.=(, '(/+*.*+ ,+,'

<1+,4*'.**'( 0./( " ;

*' *'( )(*+*+ ,(-/ /2""(-(1 "- 7 ".</('

5./7+/0 ,0(+=(1.,15./.).*(,*7+/2/( ">21+0+.< )- 0(// ;2/( " *'( )- 0(// " *'( 2-* .,1 , * .))- .0'+,4*'( 2-*5+*'0 7)<(*(".0*/.,10<(., '.,1/ './0 7)(<<(1*'+/ 2-** +7) /('(.=3.,1 )(,.<0 /*/ ,*'()(-/ ,/.0*+,4./,(9*"-+(,1/+,*'( 5-+* )(*+*+ ,/ ;("

-( *'( +4' 2-* '+/ 2-* 0.,, * )(-7+* *'( >21+0+.< )- 0(// * ;(0 7( ., +,/*-27(,* ))-(//+ - .;2/( - * /2;=(-* >2/*+0(;32,/0-2)2< 2/<+*+4.,*/<+?(*'()(*+*+ ,(-/+, *'()-(/(,*0./( 8!#(##( ># :' ! (" 3## ! <& 9

)

# 8 : %% ! #1 ! ( # # ##1"# #1 # " , ' !# #((," : ( ! 3 > ! ! >! ( ((! A# ', # ! ?# # ? #' *## #,# #?( ! !(>#

((! !# ' ># ! !, : ># ! "#, ! :* #

$ #$ - ( ! # ' !> ! ! "( #1# ># !#> "# ! ! : ># !

' ! # "'

## ! (

# #1 !( # #-1 !( , !(' !># ( # # # 66 5, !

1#1 ! " #"(1 , !:!

1# !# ( # # !( !,! :( # !" ## !># ( # #: !># ( # #!#1: # !#1:#1# ! ( # #3 #, ! , #: "( !( !( # # # " ! ># ! #> "# ! : # " :

7 (# # A' ( ( #1 !( # #,!#"( ':"# ! !( # # ! # ! !#" 8!# ! ( # # # 1 '( 3#> ! " # #" ,> # " #1 !"# ! ' !1 " # !#1((! ! ># ! !,># # #"# !# ># ( # # 4 - #, ! ># ( # # #"# /(#1##> ! !( # #!: :, >#"( )!( !( # #,>!#!!

:(# ># ! ! &#1! $1 # ""# ># !# (# >) " ', # #1 >!#! ! " !

: " ! ( # #,#># ! > 8

: 8 :

(/(-=(1 ,A#B#!

- , 2,0(1 , B#A#! 11 ! !()#1 B ! !( :