Naval Kishore v. Kuldeep Singh Kharbanda



  




           

  



 !

$!%&'&"() % "*!+ ,  -

./ 0&'1"+!

---
 .- 02/$!!3 &(41 01+*($ ---   
 )

 



 +!'!( ) 1+&  "+5, $."% !

3! & &"(!+- 1+& 6&.!7 / 1&, $."% !

+!'3"($!( -



!- +/ ) 2/!-

!+$ #"+ 18& 1- 1+& 6&.!7 / 1&, $."% !

33!+'

+!'3"($!( -

9!+(!$
"2('!/ '2*:& !$ 1&'

2($!+ !% &"( ;
+--
- !($!+&(4 !.&$!(%!, ""

#"+:

"(/5, (:!/5, #&/!

3+".!

%":3/&(( , 1'

*!!( +!=!% !$ 4+"2($ .&/!$ $"

'"

"+ !.!(

(2:*!+ 5!+'-

9!+(!$
"2('!/ 1'

%& !$ $!%&'&"( 23+!:!

"2+ %'!

0- 2*+:(& .>'

0- :"$+

&$2, ?



&.&/
"2+
'!'

 
-

!

'2*:& !$ +!

"##&%&/ $"%2:!( '

1!+!

8'

/3'!

%//&(4 1!:

1!(%!

$!/5 #&/&(4 !($!+&(4 %%"+$&(4

1&:, $!'!+.!'

"(!

/'

%1(%!

 3+"$2%!

'&$ &++!'3!% &.!

''!'':!( 1"'!

$"%2:!( '-

!+ %"( ++5, /!+(!$ %"2('!/ +!'3"($!( .!1!:!( /5 "33"'!$ 1&'

3! & &"( '233"+ !$ &:324(!$ &(.& &(4 :5  !( &"( 3+  &:324(!$ 81!+!&( 1!+!

%/!+ :!( &"( @ "33"+ 2(& &!'

8!+!

4+( !$

3!+&"$ 1+!!

5!+'

/!$ $!#!(%!

*2  !:3 8'

3+"$2%!

("+ (5 ' !3'

8!+!

7!( !($!+ (5 '2%1

%%"+$&(4 1&:, $!/&*!+ !/5 $!/5&(4 3+"%!!$&(4'

&(%/2$&(4 3+"%!!$&(4'

."&$ '!( !(%!

8+$!$ 3! & &"(!+-

!

#2+ 1!+ &(.& !$ :5  !( &"( A&:(& "+$!+'

3!+&"$ 1+!!

5!+'

'2*:& !$ %"($2% $!/5&(4 3+"%!!$&(4'

$"!'

!( & /!

1&:

(5 +!/&!# 1&'

"2+ -

1.!

3!+2'!$ &:324(!$ "+$!+, '"

/'"

+!'"('

3+ -

+2!

4"

#&/!$ 1+!!

5!+'

%"('2:!$ &:!

.&/&(4 /!$ $!#!(%!

"(/5 1&', /'"

+2!

$&$ #&/!

(5 81!( 33!/ 8'

#&/!$ 1&:

/:"'

' 4!

#&(/ +42:!( '

'2%1 ( 8'

#&/!$-

!.!+ 1!/!'', ("8 8( '

3+"$2%!

3+".!

!3+ :!( -

( :5 "3&(&"(, 3! & &"(!+B'

%"( !( &"( $&$ +!#/!% :"2(

 8"2/$

+!/!.( '3!% 1"241 #&/!$ 4+* '&(%!

$!#!(%!

*"2 .!+5 .&/*&/& 5 '2:

'-C,C,> 8& 1 %":3/&(( -

# !+ //, #% *"2

: !+ "##&%&/ 1!+!#"+!

$!(5 "33"+ 2(& 5, 1"241

#2/ , 8"2/$ 1+'1 '&(%!

3+"%!!$&(4'

+!

!.!( 2//5 3!($&(4-

2 1!(, %(("

//"8!$ 1.!

'2%1 8& 1"2 *!&(4 3!(/&A!$ "+ *!&(4 '2& */5 %":3!(' !$-

:

1!+!#"+!

"3&(&"( '1"2/$ '$$/!$ 8& 1 %"' '

'2:

'-?,> .&!8 $!/5 1&:

'7&(4 !($!+&(4 85 '2::"(&(4

(%":!

!3+ :!( '

3+! %"($& &"( !($!+&(4

( .&!8 $!/5 3+"%!!$&(4'

(" !$ *".!,

1&(7 &(' !$ '7&(4 /""7&(4 $$2%!$, '1"2/$ 81"

'1"2/$ "(!

"+ 8"

$ !'-

#+!!

4&.!

(" &%!

$:& $"%2:!( '

!.!( 1!5 *!&(4 3+"$2%!$

(%":!

!3+ :!( &# $"!'

$:& 1"'!

$"%2:!( ', '1"2/$ 3+"%!!$ 8& (!''

(%":!

!3+ :!( 8& 1 $2!

%+"''

!<:&(!

8& (!''

%":3/&(( -

23'1"

*".!

$&'%2''&"( #"//"8&(4 3''!$)

@  & //"8!$D &&

&:324(!$ E2'1!$ '!

'&$!D &&&

'2::"(&(4

(%":!

!3+ :!( +!%"+$, +!/!.( 3+!'!( %'!, //"8!$D &.

'1// +!'3"('&*&/& 5 4!

!3+ :!( %"2+ D .

'1// /&41 "*'!+. &"('

*".!

4&.&(4 #2// '

8!//D .&

'1// $!3"'& %"'

35*/!

%'1 3&$ ".!+ '

3+!%"($& &"( '2::"(&(4 $!3+ :!( +!%"+$D .&&

# !+ +!%"+$&(4 !.&$!(%!, '1// $!%&$!

33!/ '

!<3!$& &"2'/5 '

3"''&*/!

(5 %'!

8& 1&( #"2+ :"( 1'

"$5D .&&&

3+ &!'

33!+ $ !

#&<!$-



G % "*!+ ,  -    "
 H1! 1!+ '3!7&(4>+!'"(!$ !'> H1! 1!+ +!3"+ */!

!'>