High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3153/2007allowed

Anita Rani Andors. v. Union Of India

2019-03-13Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan13 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

) '%"!!'% !'*"+#,&

'%' '*%!

!"#$% &"'

"!!((" )** " "#$% &"'

"$! *#$% &"'

$+ ,,,,

#- "( $.

/ "!!"( 0!'$01

"*(*.

$"$ 23453446 !"

$ * "

+78273448 01

"*(9"1("*

*0 "(# "$*." & # "$*." - *"''$ : *0 "(;/ "!!(*&"* 0'*($01 +"!!(*&"

-"!!((" */#9

" 9*$ 9# * $" .

"$ *

$# $&* 2< "*(9"1("*

*0 "(&#2=>6#

?*."&

5#44#4447+ "&& '$" '

0"$ &("* "+"!!((" 2#%*@#"9") " "*" 9"$*&*$ *''"& #9 "&

"1 0$*

& *$"* "!!"(# "$ "$"

&("* "% "$ " " * &("*

"!!(*&"* ""9") " "- *&$&"

$/9"

"' *"$ ."0(

((9"

(*%*."( 9* '"

*(1* "*$"0 &"1*.

%."0(0 *

*"$* *"" .

*.'

"*$" *"""$&

0"&?* %*.%1$"1 "$ "$* "!!(*&"* " '"' ($"1#*#

82233443#$&"

$+"9") " "9"

*.'

*"" "*$""$#9 *( *! &

'0 "$*. "*# "*

%*."$ $'(($ 9 "&?"$&*%$'""(&

*A * &"

$*"$"

"$ "%*.0"?01 # "*(9"1 "$ ** "* & $ * 01'*(*. 9* " $1*. "% "$01 +"!!(*&" 9"

$*$ "&&*$ ($&

$ "

0* $'*** '"*(9"1 9"$*&*$"

"*$*&* 238-&/ &#2=>=- *"''$

: &;/* 0*." !"

.9"

"((.$"

A 1 *&?& ($0& %$'

0 $1 $$ *. "& "$01 !

(*&"$#

#" "$9"

"? " *($'

"1 " 1&

'&* 235+ ': &;

'*%"(!("$*.

!"* # *0 "('"

$ (( 9*.*

+ :-2/B $9"

" !"

. $" ' *&*$C -3/B "((.$*&*$'"(( 9* * "

0* '&* 238-&/ &#2=>=C -8/ "!!(*&"*

($!$ $C -5/

(*';

$ "0(*

*&"

# 9*$ 9 $+*"

"* $ &$ ('"

"$9"

+D"

*$01 $+

"*(9"1

*1 $+ "*(9"1

*1 ! $ &$ $%*.

.* *% & &$"*# *"9"*"(#9

""* "

# *"""$ *)""*.

"$ & &$"*"

+"!!(*&" "% "(

! $ &$ &"*$

" $& !* 'E !

#F"$+"

"+"("

*#B*

-"(( $ ' /#

" "* "

"$ " ' "$# *%"$ * 0"& " "( "*$ 0($0 $ 9%#* 0 *&$01 *0 "( $

9! $ &$"%1(" ".#*#" ". '".

# '

*1 ' * 0 "( & ($ 0 .*% $+

*1 *0 "( "(

*&$&"*$* &!"&* * " ("$ !* "$ *.*"($ 9**

(". ".F D"

!(# "

'0 $ 0 "$* A"0*"

0 * *$* " ("* # * * 9* "

"$ *

# *." "$ %# & !1

0" *." '$*&"( ''*&#*%*(

!*"(# " *$"# 0 * " $ & !* *$ " " !

* ' * #

*." "$ "(

!((1 0(*"$* "(

*&$ ""

! "*(9"1& $# *&*$

?!("& 82233443""0 2=GG

* % "*(9"1 (*& !"! # * "&&*$

9 0"

4<24 42423448

#*%*9 "'

"*$

- %"*"* # *0 "(

& &( "*9 ($ 0!

*0( & +("

"$ E !

9* $ %*$&*$*&"*. "*&*$ "$"?!("& 82233443 * "(

*&$ "A 1*&?9"

0 $1

&( &9 '

$& $** "$ "0(*

$* F"$+"

"+"("

"%"*("0( & $9 &("(1

" *.9"

& %$ $ *. "& !

$* "(

"$ *&$01 *0 "(* * ! .$ $.

"% "%$* *&"

*&?9"

0 .

01 $* *! &

*! & '"1!

'"'

"*$$*

# *0 "(

&( "$&"

$&" 0& *$$ 0" !"

."$ "&&*$$ '"((9* * "

0* '&* 238-&/ "$9* &* 235+ & '""

8* &$# & !1 "$

0$* &"$$ . $ "*9"

!!"$ 324334489 "

"&&*$ "$"?!("&

0"&?"$*&" 0*'$"

'" +*+("9 '&("* "+"!!((" 2* $"$ "(*%0&"

"!!(*&"* * *( ""

!& "'

"*$0"&?. $ ''"& "( "*D"$ $*

*&$* * ! .$ $.

# "% "$("$& ('

!"*

"$ "%! & $ &"

"$ & ( "!!"*. '

"!!((" % (1 ". $ " &("* "!!(*&"* &" 0 $* ( $.$ 0"

1!& *&"(. $ "$ * $* $.

9 "

("$

(! *. $+"*(9"1 !!

$ A $.

"1*. "*$ "$ "0(*

$9"

" !"

."$ "&&*$9 ($&

9* * "

0* $'*** 9"$*&*$"

%* ".$ $ ! %* "*$*&* 238 -&/ &

& *$"* '*%"(& * # '*$ '

"* $ 0 "(' '("$& ('

"!!((" '

(( 9*.

+ %"*"*

9* *.*"($ "$" ("$ $ #"

$$ 901 *0 "(** ! .$ $.

#9 ($ 0 ' %"( *"

*$*1 $ 0

9*$ 9 0E $01"10 $1 '""

"%! $ &$""0("$ ".01 "!!(*&" "& &$#

"$ % "*(9"1 (*&"$*' *0 "(9"

!** "*9"

! $ &$"%1(" ". * "$9 !* F* #* "?

$ & $"$'

*$*

& $(1#*'* "? $ & $ *& ($ "%."$

*1 *$ 0 * "A *

9 0 "$ 01 *0 "(* ."$*. $""$* "&&*$ ! !

#$" "&&*$9"

<24 424234489 "

"&& $*.

"*(9"1 # "&&*$

?!("&* %*.""0 6GG 82233443 9%# *0 "(&

!((1'

*$ !& " "* "!!(*&"* # &"

"&&*$

?!("& 82233443* %*. !!

*. "1*

$ 0*.9 .#*9 ($0 ' E &9 "*(9"1

"%"$ *$ "&&*$ "%"?!("&""0 6GG %*.

!((1 "& 9* &"

%*9 ' "$ *$!

** # 9"

E * ""(( + * "'

"*$. $ & $ *

9 0 "* $ 01 "*(9"1 "$ *$$ 01 *0 "( * ."$*. $&"

$ 0*. " !"

. % (10". $"$ "(

0& $$* ! .$ $.

%*$& $! & A 1 *&?"$' " *&?9"

$* #*# "& !

$01 *0 "( $* &"$$ $

! $ &$01 0("$(1"(

. $

'&"*$* &!"&* 01 "1*."$** E $"

$+ : '

#& *$*. "0 %+ * $$*

"* *. '!"! ! %*$$01 "!!(*&"" * ".

#** !

*0( ("

E !

!"! %* +"+%* 9* $ %*$& *$*&"*.*&*$"

"?!("& 82233443;

9 E 9 ($0#*%*9 '"'

"*$ "$"?#

*0 "(#"' "1*.

"19 $ # !("&$(*"& !

$ 01 9 9"

! $ &$0("$(1C ""!"# "!!(*&"* $* &(

$! & $ & $&("

*&? 0 %*$& & ($ 0 ! $ &$ 01 0&"

$1 9"

"&&

!"1*. $" "*(9"1 "* ! "* "

* #*

& $ "*9"

$"*(1 *

*.""$* *"""$ $0"&?* %*.

" * "* #&"*0!

""!

%1$"10 "$*.

"*'

*. *"""$.

*.0"&?'

*"" "*$"#9"

"%((*.9*

! & *.*&?"$ % " *.( &&"

E $ '

$9*

*&?01 "*(9"1!

& $E * *&?& ($ "%0(

$ *. "&&*$C

#** "$* !

(*&!

9 $"$*&?9"

$#'

"*$'"&#* &" 0*'$ " "*&?+(

* ( . "

0& *$$ 01 0( ! ** 9((&(0"$ $.

$$* /'%' '*%!0&%'!#1%2

34 .

0"!!&*"* # (%"!"

".'

"*$ $&* #*#!""."!

265* D"&$"$E $"

$+ :265B

($ " ! & '"0 $1

"*(9"1! 9*(( 0& &( *%

($ "*A $ $&"

$ 9"

" !"

9 &("* '

& ($0

"*"*$ 9%# "0 & ' *&? 9* *A $ $&"

$9*(( ."*% " " !"

. **"(0 $9*((0 "9 &"0$* ".$01'*(*.

" "''*$"%* ' (%"'"& "$ 0 $9*((

"$ *

&"0$&*$$ '"&

9 "$*.

&*&

"& 9*(( "% 0$"(9* '

''"& '

$ (."(!

** * ."$9*(( "$D!("*$ "&& $*.(1; 1 !** # ***"(0 $9"

$* ".$01 "!!(("

01 "1*. "''*$"%* ""*&?9"

! & $"$ . ("(1#"

*# "%(%1$"1'

"*$" *"""$0"&?'

*"" "*$"#0 *.*0 "( !" "*(9"1 "% "$D&! "$ " *&?9"

0 $1 $ ""!"# 0*.. ("& "9 "*$ *&$01 *0 "(* "1*E *19"

($01

*1*

'&* 22G &#2=>=C " 9 0."*% * "$" *(1E *$*

'&* 22G &

($*E *1 "((1

*E ** "0*.$ 0 #*

3 ! &"

# *. 0$ '

"*(9"1 #9*

*E *1#&" &

"$"?" "$ "&&*$9"

9"$ *&*$"$ $9"

" !"

.%*'

"*(9"1$*%"$. "$* "?* *$"* # $*% &("(1

"$ ""&& $*. % . "$# !"

.9"

1*.

"$"

%*."*9 9"

%*.""( 9 !$ '6+>?

' "$ " !$# &""

*(10 "$"$$+0 "$ "* "

"9 1*. 0 "$ "* "1"*# "* "$

%*."$ (*!!$'

"*"$ &"

$ 9 ( "**& *E *1 0$ 01 "*(9"1 #*&""(

0& *$$"$ ($ "*(9"1 %

"$D *% "& "$A **.""9 "&&*$ && $

'*$ 0( .*.

$ (1 !

$9"

"& $01 E 9 9*(("* * &"

"$9 0 "* $01 ("$& ('

"!!(("* "*(9"1. "$ "*$ $9"

*. 9"$ "*"

*' 9"$

*&*$ 9 E 9 ($09 "&"0(*$ !

01"

'("9C *E *1 *% *."* 9* ."$ "* 01 (*& 01 "*(9"1

** *. & $9 "1

.. 9&"*"

* *&*$ (1 " !&!* !

"( *$" $* &(

$ 01 9*

&" 0 *$$ 0& &"$"?"

"!*& '%*$& " 9*

9* ."$ '"& "&&*$ *&*$$* &(

'"&

."$*. " "&&*$ *&*$&"0& *$$01" ("90 *$"D!

$01 !

"( !** ."$*.!"*& ("

) *.&"0"&&!$"

%*$& ""!"#!("*"$*. '&* 235+ &#2=>=%"( &

"&& ' 9"$ *&*$* ."$* !&*% '"&9 0"1 9 .' ("&#.(& $'" ( !" "*(9"1$ ** "*

! %* $* &(

* 0."$ '" ( 1

!& "(

0& *$$01 0(!D *%'!#1%&56,! 0"!!&*"* # (%"!"

". '

"*$ $.

"D"&$"$E $"

$+ :#(%%667%$!"%' ,%'$%67# 4",%$"8%!9%77%":;'$#6"

4#7 '

7%$"#*'<5,:

2<2F

A $.

&*$" "9$ "1& '(*& "!!(*&"0*(*1 !*&*!( ' *&(*"0*(*1&* 235"$ &* 235! %*$ "&

* !"1"0(9

0 9 .' ( "&# .(& '" ( !" ' "*(9"1 "$ ** "* * &"

'""&&*$ * &"

'"H 9"$ *&*$I (1D&!* "

! %*$$ $! %*

&* 235 ,!9+!=!,!'0%<!:!>5?!,- !"/*9"

($ "&* 235("1 $ 9 *&(*"0*(*1 '" ((*"0*(*1*&"

'"*(9"1 "&&*$ B !*&*!( ' *&(*"0*(*1"!!(* #!

' '.(*.& E *$ !*&*!( 0*"$* !?##7!- !"/ 2<3

*. ! %*

&* 235 ''& "

* !"1"0(*'!"

.$* '' *A 1$

* "* * $ *# $*''*& (1"

."$ *&*$ " !$ *&*$ * 9 &"

"1 0 !"1"0( '(*& ' !** **.

"* $ "$*. D!

H ('*'(*&$*A 1I* ! %*

$&* *

0 ($ "*A 1 $" 0&"

'.(*.& %*&* 9"

" !"9* ('*'(*&$*A 1B "1' $&* '*.

')"("* &#6+ - !"/#

0"1* 5&+6!- !"/"$

( **4+!:!?!,!:!'- !"/ !

* 2<8 &#6+ - !"/# %*&* &*%$*A * * & *.""*9 "$

%*.J 9"

&("*

" "$ ''$*A * *"H 9"$*&*$I"

$'*$ $ &* 238-&/& ($0 !

($ 9 %$01! %*

&* 235&("

-0/ *.

($ "9 *(* &"

*&*$ " !

* *&*$#** "("&*

*"(*& &! 'H ('*'(*&$*A 1I* $* *&'

"" !$ *&*$#

** * E *$"$%9*

** *'"!

"& .(*.(1#*A * ''$* ""&&*$9*(("

H ('

*'(*&$*A 1I (%" %"* " : '

# 9 (* %*

($0 $ "%9 $*'' 0A&*% 0"& *%$B&" $ "$ "*. K ('+*'(*&$*A 1K (1 '

& ! %*$$01 $*&* "* #0 "(

D*9 ** $* " K ('+*'(*&$ *A 1K $* " &"0$$ &$"

9 "!

'' "&& ' 9"&* #9

"""

.(*."& *

"(( 0"** "("& " !$ *&*$ B *( "1 0 &"

9 *

** *'(*& ('9* *A 1"

*. ('+*'(*&$ *A 1#9 '"((

'"" !

* *&*$# &" "(

0&"

#* !&*% '** #"!

"1"& 9* "(&?(

#* "# "1 9"((

'&" * 9*$"$."$(

".#&*&

"& #&"&

$* F"& &"

9 "!!(("" !$

"$"

%*."*'

'' *$ *$' ( ' "."$ ' ((1 "9" ' !

** "( $* "$%"".

"$ $". "$*.""*'

"(%(( 9 " '

0 "$ "* *

? 9($. '

0 "$"$ "$"*( " $

!" "$ *.$ * & %*& !"

. '

0 "$*.'

"$"(*.

*. !("'

$" * #9 "!

* 1*. 0 "$ "* '

!("'

*$# 9*((0 "$*. "! 00( ?!0" "&?"$

*"( 9(%(F

# 9*(( "% &

(' &"& "$"*( "$

..( &(* 0 ! .

0 "$ ".*.0" .* ! 0"0*(*1 ' $". * *&"

$ * "*

*& ! .

9 "**

%*. * "(* *."(( *.

* *$#*&" (10 ($ "& "!!(("9"

' &"(

# * ! $& "$ '

( "$*

*$* ! "0( ! !

'&* 235 &*

! %*$ " !$1 $1 " *A $ !"

. $!$" ' " $&"

$ !"

. *% (%$ * " 9"$ *&*$&* 235 &! %*$ '

. $!$"

'' *A 1 $" #"

"10#*" 9"$*&*$%9 9"$ *&*$* & E & '"19 .' ("&#.(& $'" ( !" "*(9"1$ ** "* D#* &"0 "*$ 0" +'" ((*"0*(*1%

! %*

("*. !"1 '&

* &&"0 "*$ 0"

!*& '0'*&*"((.* ("* #*&" 0 &

9"$" !

"& &"((

(1# 9* (1 * ! $(1 ! %* '("90 .

*&! **. !"

. "*'

+!("'

*$ "*(9"1 "&? 9%# & ('

$$*$

9"1 ! %* '("9!

*0**. E 9 ""& 01 9 " !"

"* *A 1 9 *( 0 "$*. " "* .

'' *$#* " ('*'(*&$*A 1 $!$

'"& '"& &"

(10&"

''$*A 1* ! &

'.*.* "* .

'' *$#* "1 0

''*&* *"

" ('*'(*&$*A 1# (

'"& "$ &*&

9 " "&9"

"((1* ! $#*"* "(# &"((

"$ *$' ( ' & E & (( '"& "$ &*&

"& "0(*

$* &"

9 ($

9 "& "!!(("9"

9* ' ((? 9($. *

*0*(*1

'$".*. (*' (* 0"$ '

#* E "(1&

9* * K ('+*'(*&$*A 1K$'*$*&* 235 %*

-0/ &;

2<5 5&+6!- !"/" "9?$*$* & '0 "$*.""* 9"

($ " *($

*9"

"&"

'H ('

*'(*&$*A 1I (%" %"* " : & "" !01" "9? 0%*9$01 *"( "

*."

*. &* *"(.(*.&

!""$"(

"''

*'(*&*A *

(' *"( "

$ "*' $&"

$ "$ (( .

$ 01 "$*.""*#

($ "% $ $

(19 *9"

E * "''

. "* 9* & ($ "% "% *$$&"& *. "*"$9"*$'

" "*

*$ 9"

( (1

! ( 1'

$* ! &"

"?"" !

9 0 "$ "*9 *(*9"

." *. !$;

2<G4+:!?!,!:!'- !"/# %*99"

"? '

(( :<-**/&" ".9* ".

.$ 0 "(' "!!((" 7"!!(*&" * '"& ! &"

0&"

"$*''&09" 9"$*&*$"$" "& '&* *"(.(*.&B "

.(*.&9*(( $* *( ." '&

$ &#

9%# & .(*.&0&

"&* *"(.(*.&"$ ('+*'(*&$*A 1 &

&" 0."$ !&*'*&"((1! %*$$ * '* ! %*

&* 235+ &9

! %*$ "&

9*(( 0!"1"0(*&"

"? !("& "&& ' *&*$ " !$ *&*$# ('

*'(*&$*A 1#0 "'*$!"

. 9&* *"("& ""&

*$01 $* " '* D*&"* * "*1;

2<<B" "0( !

($ "0 %%*9"

& &! 'H ('

*'(*&$*A 1I9 ($E *** *'(*& *A 1"$

.(*.& '"1!"*& ("$.

($"

*% ?*. !*&*!( '& *0 1.(*.&9 &" 0$ * &"

' (*"0*(*10"

$ H '" ( 1I B "1 *

&* ' A $.

*'%"#*'*%!'&5,!'$# 8"*1#,&5&45'%7>5?!, ("1*.$ 9 "!(" '.(*.& %*&* &" 0"(( 9$*&("* 0"

$ H '" ( 1I $ &* 2<8 *&( &#2=>>&& $*.(1#9

($ " $" *A 1* & '0 "$*. $+0 "$*.""*9*((0"

H 9"$*&*$I*(*."%*&* &

"$9*(( '"(( $ ! %*

&* 235 (1 !(" '.(*.&

%*&* "& *0 *.'"& ;

9 ($0%*$'

"*$ & &! '

E * ** *'(*& *A 1"$ .(*.&

'"1!"*& ("$."

$ *.

($"

*% ?*. !*&*!( *0 1.(*.&9 &" 0$ * &"

'(*"0*(*10"

! &"

* 0 "$01 $*%"

*$" $9"

*. 9"$ "*"

*' 1*.

* *&*$0 $ ("&? '"1 "*"( & $ *$*&"*.

** $& !($9* ' '"& "*'

0 $19 ($1

* *&*$# 9*(( "$&

*' "*(9"1.*"$ 09 "*(9"1& "& #*&" 0 ($ "*9"

('+*'(*&$*A 1 "%*.$*

$"$ ($"

"0 %#$ "%"1 *"* *

($*. $9"

" !"

."$ "%*&* '" 9"$*&*$*

'&* 238-&/"$9* &* 235+

&#2=>= '"

8* &$# *0 "( ($

" (1 $!$ ' $&"

$ J * " &("* + "!!((" "%$&("$

(% 0 (1$!$ "$*'

"% "* $

!&*'*&"((1** 9* " " * ("$*.%*$& ** $ "$"0(9 1 *0 "(9*((& *$* * "'

"*$ ""$ "? " *$&"

9 *. & $

9 " $!$ '$&"

$"(

"(*% $"C 1 !** # 9"

''*&* "*"(

($ " &("* "$!$ $ 9"

*.9 .

*& *$*. "* &"$#%*'!!"$"' "&&*$#'

(%"! !

# &("* 9 ($ 0 *($ '

*E "(

& $ (""&

! "#$ %

&'(()#9 *%*9

D* *. $ (9 ($&

5#44#4447+ 9%# "(

$ *"!! !*"* * 'A *& "9"$* L=M! " 0&"(& ("$'

$" ''*(*. &("* "!!(*&"* *(( $" '!"1 "9"$$"

(# "!!"( "$ "(( 9$ "$ * ! .$ $.

* E "

$"$ "

*$ 9%# !"* 9*((0" * 9

0 2848342= A"( @+#"+#,&6#!=%'AB,#!&'#*C #&B @+#"+#,,#6,"!97#C #&B