Ved Parkash And ORS. v. Rajesh Kumar And ORS.
-1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH . FAO32342007 (O&M) Date of Decision : 25.07.2024
CORAM : HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUDEEPTI SHARMA
!"# $
!"# $ %& ''
SUDEEPTI SHARMA, J. (Oral) ( ) *$*+ ,
- ./.(&..0 *+ ## ) *!- 1$ !2 ) *23!- *+
#
(/4'$
# # !(5661$ !7 # 83$ *+ # , - -
# UNDISPUTED FACTS & ) * $$# $ #
" $&../&..&!9+%1# 3 $:
!$
: 1 3- # %;'4<':'40<( - "
= > - "
? !
# $ -': !
;- ;
:
+ -
- ;
!
? !- &/./&..& @A1 3 %(5 - # #
9 ? # #
-2- (0B$ $ #- ## A $
# - >1
3*+$ - 44..,' ) +$ $#
$ - $ $$ "
#%;'4<':'40<( 4
# $ #
! %(
#
!-
-
## %&$ +-
$# $#
B @ $
! ) *$ $-
'
( > 9+% $ :
## ""
# *
%;'4<'
:'40<( C & A$ %( " $$
"! -
# +#
! $ $ - - 4 >
*C '& B >
"# $#
$
C '& < > # - " $$#
" "
## $## C '& / $ < $ #
"
# #! ) * #
$ # , ;# , $
-3SUBMISSIONS OF THE COUNSELS / D# $ *
$ *+ '# #
(/4'$ #
- $ - - - -1 3 ) # $ $
- $ " # 9+% ## -
*+ $# %;'4<':'40<( 0 # $ 'A # + $ - 6 A " # $
#$
# ANALYSIS 5 $ #* $ -
'
* -$ $$ #
-
- -$ # E
% ;'4<':'40<( -
# $ ## ;$
#
!-
-
##
$$ "
F>(,$# !- $ $ 9+1# 3 #
-
$- ## # &../&..& * 64.'5.. : '- $ $ $ *! -
#
- - ) ##+
-4-
# 'F
)
- $ # - -
- ) * # "
## -
#
#
$ "
-
$DF>'&! -
&../&..& * 5 ..!9+%- $: # #
# "
$ *+ $
) $ 9+ % *# # # + $
$ +* ;-
$ ;
!? -
$ <'/+ $ ## ;$
- ++!-
# $ $ )
##+
# 'F
>'&
"3
$$ "
$ '>'(,! -
F >'(! * (<./&..&!
# 9+%
$ $ *+
E
$$ A
# '
F
! ##+-
# # $# "3 $F'7AE #
(0B - * $ *&/./&..& (& 4.
# $ - G
-5- # $ +# ## "
F':! -
-
#$ *+ #$ G "
$ - ) * # A %& $- '
! "
"
# $% &'(
) * + " ,&-.
&/ 0 " 11'2 3"# # # ) "
" 11'2 & )
# ) " ) $# " )
4'2 & 4'2 5 ) !'1
. !6'2 ( "
"
" 1 (
!6 1 7 '2/ !68!8!60 . ! ' % .
-6- * + 1 !7 '23"# +! #
" )
.
(. ;2* # $ Ram Murti and others Vs.
Punjab State Electricity Board [2022(4) TAC 738]
* *$
$*$ "
# *+ ((!$-
#
(/B$ # "
$+ $ #
# $ $ < # $ " $ &< (( )
FAO1952006
Mamta and Others Vs.
Happy and Others!# &5.<&.&B! #
#
*$
! ? # #
$ "
!-
#
"* +
! +
-
# *#A ** "*+ ;2* #
#
"
$ * # * #
"+$$ *+F#
#
#+ @ ! ?
# # + * - * " *+ #
$ -
#!#!##
*+
- +) #
* # + #$ #$* #
+ +
-7CONCLUSION (& A"
-$ - -*+ ;8* *"$ ! -## +! - ./.(&..0 ) , *
#
$ < !-
*
* E+
(4 $ ##! *+;8* 2019 ACJ 3176
(2022) 5 Supreme Court Cases 107, '# H5I # $ $$ $#
$
J
(B ) A # + #
$ #
-
-
) *-
$ -
$ + ) ) * $ # * $ #
-
E+ ## $ # , ) , # $
* ## ) * (/ #
! $+! $ ?+&<!&.&B (SUDEEPTI SHARMA) JUDGE > ,' > * K