High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4675/2015dismissed

Subhash And ANR v. Shivani

2015-12-03Mr. Justice Krishna Murari6 pages

!"##$%&%'(#$#)*#+,- ./*0!&0!'1!'"0#+ 2 #"%"%'#+& 3& .0%4!'% 2 #&5'1#'" ( 67 .. 88

+#&#'"(8 +.0!'19-14$!"# +"0#5#"%"%'#+& 88 ' !55:%$!"%' %:#1 *; .0%4!'% + ! +#&%1#'$# +1#+ !'1 )!%'"#'!'$# 0!& *##' !::<#1 *; /1%$%!: !=%&"+!"#- !'&% 0# &!%1 +1#+0!&*##'/50#:1*;"0#55#::!"#/+" 5#+/&!:"0#+1#+5!&&#1*;"0#!=%&"+!"#%'1%$!"#&"0!" "0#$:!%)+#&5'1#'"<%#"0!4#+#&%1#'$#%'"0#&0!+#10/&#0:1%'

!"#0!*!10!&*##'!::<#1""0##>"#'"'#+)-'#"%:#"-*!"0+) !'1 9%"$0#' &5#$%;%'= "0!" "%:#"- *!"0+) !'1 9%"$0#' $/:1 *# ?%'" &/*?#$"""0#!4!%:!*%:%";

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

#"%"%'#+ 0!1!++%4#1!"/+=!'!'1"!9#'"0#+#&5'1#'"<%"00%)"

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

&"!;#1 %' "0# &0!+#1 0/&#0:1 !& 5#+ 1#%'%"%' .#$"%' & "0#

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

"<%"0&"!'1%'= !';"0%'= $'"!%'#1 %'!';"0#+:!<+"0#"%)#*#%'=%'+$#-#4#+;<)!' %'!1)#&"%$+#:!"%'&0%5&0!::0!4#"0#+%=0""+#&%1#%' "0#&0!+#10/&#0:1-<0#"0#++'"&0#0!&!';+%=0"- "%":#+*#'#%$%!:%'"#+#&"%'"0#&!)#

0#!==+%#4#15#+&'&0!::'"*##4%$"#1+#>$:/1#1 +) "0# &0!+#1 0/&#0:1 + !'; 5!+" %" *; "0# +#&5'1#'" &!4# %' !$$+1!'$# <%"0 "0# 5+$#1/+# #&"!*:%&0#1*;:!<E 0# /+"& *#:< !"#+ =%'= "0+/=0 "0# 5:#!1%'=& !'1 "0# )!"#+%!: !4!%:!*:# ' "0# +#$+1 0!4# 5!&&#1 %'"#+%) +1#+& =+!'"%'= +#&%1#'$#+1#+!'1)!%'"#'!'$#""0#+#&5'1#'" 0!4# 0#!+1 :#!+'#1 $/'&#: + "0# 5#"%"%'#+ <0 5:!$#& +#:%!'$# ' "0# ?/1=)#'"

!" !#$ %& ' ( )!

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

*; #%"0#+ "0#) %' +#&5#$" <0%$0 #%"0#+ "0# !==+%#4#1 5#+&' + "0# +#&5'1#'" %':!<& +*"0?%'":;+&%'=:;0!4#!';+%=0"-"%":#-%'"#+#&"+ #A/%";0#+#&5'1#'"<%#!"#+)!++%!=#0!1&"!;#1%'"0#0/&#!'10!1 !$A/%+#1!'%'"#+#&"!'1+%=0""&"!;%'"0#&0!+#10/&#0:10#?/1=)#'"

*& $!&# &/5+! 1#& '" 1#!: <%"0 ! &%"/!"%' <0#+# "0# 0/&*!'1 +#&5'1#'" %&*#'"/5'!)%&$0%#*;$!)/:!=%'=!&%"/!"%'*; "!9%'= 1%#+#'" +#&%1#'$# !'1 <!'"& " <!&0 0%& 0!'1& 0%& :%!*%:%"; "<!+1&0%&<%#*;$:!%)%'="0!"0#%&'</'#)5:;#1!'1'"0!4%'=!'; +#&%1#'$#4#'"0#0/&*!'10!&'"$)#+<!+1<%"0!';5:#!%'+1#+" #'!*:#0%&<%#"#'+$#0#+:#=!:+%=0"&/'1#+.#$"%'

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

"%&#>5#$"#1"0!""0#&!%1#+<%::*#"!9#'%'"$'&%1#+!"%'%'+1#+" &"+%9#!*!:!'$#*#"<##'"0#+%=0"&"0#!==+%#4#15#+&'!'10#+%'8:!<& "#'?;"0#%+%'1#5#'1#'$#!'1:%*#+"; #$#)*#+,- . &!'?!;