← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17331/2010disposed of

Vijay v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2019-05-27Mr. Justice Arun Monga16 pages

   



!" "#$%$&' (

) 





 

 

    '* +, - 

 

   

 



 !

" #



 $

 

 "%  !

  

 &"  !

 ' ( 

   





"  

   )*+  . , , ' - 

(

   

     - "   . 

 

  #  

$ 

 

 

( " 

(

%$ "  +

  "



( $  ( 

 "   

(

'

 $

(

 -

 

$$ $

  

$ 

 

 - -  $



-





/  

  "

0    

 (  

  123  

"   (  -  

   45    

- %  " $



  - 

(

   

 $   /, /226 '



-     

 

  7   

    4  #$          

 

(

   (   

+

 

   ( 

   "

 

 



/, /2219  0

,:

) +

   ,;  

 $ 

 -  

        

$  

 

 '

 "

    !

 (  # "" 

 $      

<0 =

  #  

$ 



2/ 2) /2,2  0

/2:

$ " "  

 (

/> 2;

/22>  0

,6:     

$ 



(

 ( 

'

-







2> 2;

/2,29  0

 /,:

$  

      ?

 $$$



$ "

   

$ 

,, 2> /2,29  0

//:    #  

$

%$ "    "  ( 



 

'

-

;



 

  ,;

,, /2,,   # 

  

   , 222@ 

" " $



 + 

- 

$ 

# 

  7

 ),> /2,/ - -" #  .

(

" " - + $



(  -(7A-

 $  

> ! $  $ -

# 

 



( 

"

-

 $  $  







,6 /2,6  

" 

( 

   (

     "$

  

 !

- 

 " #  # 

$ $  

 



21 /2,6-

-

 

  #  

$- =   $

( 



$

" 

  7

 



/) 2, /2,1 # 

  -

  $ - 

- 

 

"

 

  

 ' ( * + "

#$ 

 

   

  -

 

  (   

 



"



 



/) 2, /2,1

 ((-( ( -"

  #      9 $

 

 # 

   

(  "    # "  "  "

 %:(  -

 "

+ ( -

 -

  #   #     

  B

    " -



 - 

 

(%



(

( " -



-(  - 

 ' ( (-(  

/, 2;

/2,1

     (    

   "

  (  "    

 +      "  

- 

   

2> ,16> "

' (  =-



(#

(  - ,16> 4 

    

 

  

 

 @

@    % "

 

( 

  

   

  

  0

?@, * + "

#$ 

 





 

 ( $$ 

"

,2

$    " 



  "

(

$    (     $   

   ,)

+ (



   (

 $

("      $

 



    C 

,,  



$"

!

'$# 



     

 

  !! " #$%& ' ( 

   ) *  +'  ,#$, 

" #  -

#  .

&  *  '  ./     '

. 0 

1  '2!,$# ,/ 4    

$  - 

  (

" # # 

    # 

  !

  '

. 0 * 

,  !!  -$"

"    ($

 "    



   "

  (  " $  

 - 



%

 "

 

("    +

 

$"



-  



  

   

   

 

  

 



 





  

 







       

 

 !  "  

 #      

   $%&

  

  '(

 

   

 



 

)            

    

     

!    

   

  



        *

    +

 , -







 ,          

   -      

       

      

     

      



.

,) 4



   

   )@ 

#   $

" 





"   -

  $   $  A

(A

 "

(

4 

   

%

- (

(



 

+

  (   

$ 4 

"   

"





  ( ,?



  





  

-"   + !! - -

 ,> ,2 /226-



(   /;(

   

 /, /226  

. -"

(

 !!

$ 

(

 $$ 

     (



 "

- 

$  /2,2- -

 -

4 

 $ -

 

"- -



$



"$ "   " !

"

+   -

 

  $

4 

"

 



 "

 



(



.

("



# # 

 

$ $"  ( 

$ 



(  $ 



%$ "    

% ,;

   

      #   @ 

     $

( $ "

   $ 

( 

 $  A 

A

 .   (

( 

"$ 

  ,> '$ 

   

$ 

 $ 

$"

 



 





"  #

4"     $"

 

 

 " #

 

 

 - 

   



 

 - "  

    "

@       -    -  

  ( - 

 

$

 



- 

( 

 .  "

@  - 



  "

 C    =

 #

' 

   

4

      #$ 

  

(($ -

$

   % -

$

   "

 -    

  @     #  

$ 

"

 

,6 +

 

( -  -"

 #  ' 

 $      

       

 

" 

9  0

/:

   -     -

'$

#

 $ 8)2 +

-



% " ' 

 -



" "

 4

 #

* -

   ( !

"

/226 4    "

 

+B+#  "(-         " " -  " ' 

  /, /226 +

-    

"

 

$ !! ,>

,> ,2 /226

- 

 (



   0

) ,8 -       "

 

 

 

-



-   "

!! 

  $

    

" 

  %  

-   " " 

 



(

$!

  "

(-

- ( 

- 

(

 D 

 E ,1 + -  

   "

 (

 -    " " '   - %    

4

     #$ 

 

 @  

-$ - 

" "



#   ?>???-  

"  26 ,/ /226   ,2 ,/ /226     

   "   0

 ?

(:



 " 

$      

4

      #$

- 

% #     #

7 -

   



=!-  

",/ ,/ /226 /) ,/ /226



#  #6,,8,2?

 .

 



 

 0

; ,?

/2 +

#     #

7

"%

" 

   ( 

% !



  

(    

4

   

  #$ -  

"/1 2, /228 2, 2/ /228  $

 ""

 

9  0

,;

(:

-

 

 

A    -    -     (- (

 

     

 4

        

#$

$     $

"









   (

' 

7

"

 

   0

,>9#

(:

/, + $



 

 (

.



 

"

( - 

" ( 

 ( 123- 





 -

"- % 

(-   (  

( -45   



    !

    

4

   

  #$   (

 



/, /2219  0

,:

 //  (  

     C 

/,  #    4 +

    "   



 

( -    9 $

 

# 

 

( " :(  -/22>   

"

    

/;

2?

/22>9  0

,6:

 -    /  #  1

 



- D/:  

    

  

 

    

  

  

/ 

*

0 )  "#

    

  



    

     

   1    



 



   

  

   

 

  

-.

 #  / #  1 

 "

  



( ( 

  

@ 

#   @#



(" 

  C  " $ (

(" /) 4"     - -

  " 

" %

(" A 

  (

 





-   

- 

  .  $  ("

   "  =    $  

   , )

   (&"   (

(

+ (



( "  

"

/?

 -   .       -  

$     " "   (

$    -    

  "

    $  ( -

   (&"   (

(

4"(   "

 $ "(   $ " 



 



/;

  -   

   9/, /226:

( &" -$   ?;(   ( 

($ 

"

  /2,/ $  (&" - ;2( /> 

 $ 

 

"

/2,2 "    ,;  

(



  (&"



  

(







// ,2 /226 " ' 

  -



-$       /) 222@    "     , 1?

)/1@-     ( 

 

 (&"  26 ,/ /226 +





"   

   4<  #$  ##  ' 

7     

$    - 

  123  

    

  

*

"





   "

"

/2,/ $  ( 

/6 







(9/, /226:

(&" 

- %$   

%

$ "

  / ;  

"

4 "

0



  ( /22;2>9 "

( /22>26:F  0

,1G -



 

-/1 2?

,1>,

0

 "

(

- / ?1 ,,/@

$  "

$ -  ;,( "

    

"

/2,/ /8 +  

 " - 

 ' A

0# 

  -    

   $"

       "

   

  

      

    $  0   

    "



        "   "   "    "  

0      

  (   ' H

 

 # 

   4     $"

 

   +              * *    3

# !!      3   "* 52' 5 3

 6 !!

 

$  

 

 



 7     8 * * 

 9:

 2%*

   

  

  



    "3# 

"   

    +         !    ! # 

  



  %4"

 

 %5 2& 2% 25

#      





  6%7 28 &

 6%8 % 5

 6%5 8 3&

 6%3 3% 35

  6% 38 5&

       





  6%% 5% 55

 6' 58 8& 

 67 8% 85

  65 88 7&

   4  "* 52' 5 89:

8%  

 

 

      96 1111 "#*



         5&(

     

   

  

   

- 

    3& 

 

      

&(   





3& 5& 

  





  5& 8& 

    

%5(/

 







1 " #  

 

    1 

    3&(

    

 

 



   3&

 /     25( 





 

3& 5&

 %&( 





  5& 8&

 

      

    

   

     

   

1

 1111 #   

 

    



 

 #$



  





 

 

    

1  

$%5&&&6  $3&&&&6    $%5&&&6   

  

    

 

 %&(

 



.

/1 +%$

   "    

 

 " 



 



" 

"  (

    0  



"

(   (&"   

 :  4 "

    

      ( /22;2>  / ;2 222@ : )23  "



 (

 

"

 -    "/22;2>

/2,/  6;

222@ :+  "

 )  /;

222@  

 "  (   /6 222@

"  :  !

  ,@) 0      - "

  (&"

 222@

:!

 (  -

  $

 ,8 222@  

 "    (  / ,> 222@

"

:



  

$ ;, ,/ $:7    ( "

/ ,> 2220,/I/;

1/ 222@ : " 0  

  $   , 1?

)/1@  ( "  ' 



 (&" 

,/ /226  ) 22 222@ :7  

 /2 222@ :B

0   /2 222@ %:+ # "  /1 )/ 222@ )2

$

   , )



 

(

((

"  /1 )/ 222@9 +- (

7%+

(+- +   (:- 

J>3 2, /2,/

("

+ "    "   $- 

 







 :"

-  (&" ;23 :   $  (&" /;3 : %%!$

 (&" /;3

   (

  -   "   " 

  

  (  

),



$ 

.



/) 2, /2,1 

# 



 ' ( 



 .

( 

"

 *+ "

#$  

 

  (      (  

  

 

 

( 7- 

   9 $

 

 

 

( " :( 7-

/22>         C

       

  /;

2?

/22> 

  $ "

)/ "

(     

   ' (  ' (   

=-



(#

(  - ,16>      

2> ,16>

$"

  *+ "

 

 -(  (  -  



  ' (

 

(  (

  (  - -  "

( 

#$ ))

  $ 

  "   #    %$  



  $$  $ ("   $ -

""  "

  

-$

 (



       -

   

   ' (  

    

9 $

 

# 

 

( " :( 7- /22> ' (     =-

    

(  #

 ( 7-  ,16>





:    

 (  A C    A

(  

(

( !



 7 



"

 





@*+- 

C ("

   $-( (  

-  

 

(" 

 -

%   -

  "  "

  

0   

   7  

"



:  4 

  C         7 



"



 

"   C     -

   



  -

"

 



-



 -

" 

 C  

(-(     "( 

   "

- 

  6(

 

:

("  " $

@ @( -    " (( 



@ " K



   

 $ 

  C            (   7 



"

   " $   "    

 @ 

0     ( 7 



"

 :+ 7  

"





( -   "      

    @ 

  

" $

("   

 @





   (-

   $  

"  



@"   

: 

(

  ( 

 ' (

!



   7   

"

       *+

"

   

   

 (  

    

!

 (  # "" 

@  # "" 

  @  (    <0  =

@  

       #  @

 #    @  # ""

     

    @  *+

"

    

 

  @  

  -  "  " :=

   "

$ $

  $

   9 %  : ("

(

-

( "    $ " (

 $

  

 (   C   

7  

"

""



(

 " 





    "

-  "

"(    



 (   

  

  "

 ,?( )?

 *+ "

  

 -   %  

-  $ 

(  ( ( 7-  

   "

 

("  -   

 # 

$

 

$  " 4   (   



@

@     "

(@ *+ "



 0

 "$ ( 7-@   *+

"

   

    "%      "

 



      

 ' ( );

K   

  

  -

      )> 4 

$  "(      



 7  

"







"



0

"

    -  "

 

(" %

$ "

"



  "

("



%  

 

    

- 

 $ 

-

 

%$ " B   



  

(" 

 %

 

 %  

 

 % % 

 

(

)   @L

, K

 %$@

  M @  / K





M @