Harbir Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab

 

        
  

 !"#$# %&'((

)



 

        



  &  *+, ( - ,-,, + ****  

    

!"

   

  #  $

% 



 - %./ 0.1#23(    
 
  ' (       )**++)*, - . /0  $ 1   !   23     ""  1  1    25 67,  8))9+)*:      8+:;8+8;:)7;89 5#  1  <1  = 23- .*0

2541 $ "1  >1'

 !   

11  4    ""     %  '11 ' >  +?)9+)*:)78)

4     "1$   & #" $ ' >   $ 4 1    '   6!@*8% @?)?* 4  4   

    "1$  -0 A'

4  

 " 4   <  -0

  

 " 4   =

    -0  

 B >    !

"4 8*:11 4 8;9    "4  ' " 

B>   1   1      ' 4  4      4

- 2 - "1   "

  "4 8*: 1  "1  ""1$4 &   "     1 4 11      41   "1  &   

 '14 "    

 1 4 A'

4 

144 < 

 

 "   4        $  

   

  

 > 4 4   ""  1    &  11  4 4$"      1  4    1      " 4 ""    &  "1  4"#11 23 "  =      "1   >1' 

  1" $ "    8))9+)*:           "      4  

 1  "        4     $  "   -0  

    ! 

-0< 

 6  

 -0 

  >1 

   4                  1   ' 1 1 11  1$   A'

4 

   

4  6*9  "1$ 

 

< 

  

4  11  4'  1"  6+          *,8  ##    1$     A'

4 

   

4" +7)/+)*:    1   8+:

8+8 :)74   89 5#&  @       "1     

- 3 -    1   8),5#4 ""      @  "   41 ""1 1  4  @     *8)/+)*:  $ ! 5# 23  "1   >1' 

 -C*0 11$   11  "  25411 " D.* 1" $ "  D.+   

 4 1$ "     25  "4 8*:1 4  4 &     "1$  

 <  

     

   1$ "       1" $ "  D.+  411   $    " $   "1         C*     1         " A   1           4$  "1    "    25 ( 1$  " $      "        1        4   "1    "1      4            11$      1  "      "1  41   1$ 1  "       68    11      ""    $    "1   &     1        11$"1 .

- 4 -           2   1 "  1     

     A   1      "   1 

4 1$ 1   11    $  C*     ""     1    1 4    "1$A'

4 

    

  4 1$114 1     8*?##

      1    1 "   1           14    "1   "1       4  1           "  "1   1   

   

1$""  1 5  1   1     

  1."   " 41    4         


 

  4   #  >  "#4 111"     8*?## 14  @

 




 

     

 
  ! ""

  
#"
 

!$
"  !

""""!"
  



"
 

 
 " 
%

%
""
! ""
      "  # %  ! %
"


- 5 -

%&  #%
! %
' $$$$  $$$$  $$$$

(  #"
 


"

 " $"
 #)
!$
"
  " 
 #
%#)
 !$
"!*

+"


   

  %   %   ! 
   %%

 , # " 
"   
   %  
" " !     # " ! $
" " 
   " 
% (- #"  
%

! !
"%
""! 
  "
.$%

 

%  
"%!!

 
%

   ! 
"
  #

 %  
% 
   $
"   
%  %
      !   

   $   
" 
  !"  #""

)!

   " 
 % $

  # " 
 



 ) 
  

    
"
 

 %
" !
 " %%
" '
%#" #
 "!
" #
"'#" " #
"!
"'
         
  " 
 



% 

 
"' 5 


-0 "#1( 1$ 1  4E F   8*?## 1$   "14  " #    ($    -0    $# "" " 

- 6 - 1G-0. 4   8*?##G -01   4  " 4   1"  +    5 !

"

#   $   

 % ,   " #   1$ .1    4 4    #   8*?## 1 @

 / 
 "

 

%  #!#" 

   

 
   
     !"   
"""!  

  
"
 "# !
 
"! %%
"  ""!$""
 
 


%"
!%%""
"  #
"#
 ! %%
" !    %%"  ""

 "'  #   >     1  4

"   "1144 1.  4   8*?##   1 @ 0
1
%
"
"


" 
   

"  "
 
%  
%%

 !"
" ""   

'!
 "
  

 "  " "
"  

 " 


  2 0

1
 "
"%%""


   %%
 "!"!"
   #
  

  %
  " ""
     #
"
" 
  


- 7 - %
"#%%""
! 
" #
" 2" 0


1
  # " 
    
 
 "  $
"
%




"


.  #!
 "$
" 

 
"     

   
%   ""

 "  ! %%"
  
 0!
" 
1

 1$3 "
 #  >  
 

-0 !

"

#  -0 "# & 

# ' ( ) *  ( 11$ 1 3.

 )
  %
"%4
"
 
" "

#%%
 "
   
   ! $
" 
  "  $
  %   
% 
 
 
    %%  ""

 "5% ""#

#  %
  #  %% ""

 " " 
    "
%
 #
!
"
 4"

 "
%"! " "! "

 %%
  " 
 %  ! "
 " "  
  %   
"  
      ! %%" "  "4"

#%

 %  % #
 "!

" 
# " 
 
)! "
!
"  #"
    !
 "'  5   "  4  ""       8*?## .   "   . "  
%
 
""   1   4   4      (  "  4  ""   1

- 8 -     1$  #  1    1 " ""    $  1 1  "1 "14

    @H@   "1        4   1$   15    $ 1  4    8*?## 

  '

1 25 14 1" $"  $  "1    1   "1         

 B >  4 " 4  8*:  1 4 "   "1  &   @ ; 4

 @ @ 1 4
%
  1    $  1   &        1        11 1    4  1$     4 1""   >   $ @     "1  1$  1 4   1  1 4   1"          " "1  # 1".  $   " 2     "     #      $

     4    $   1  ""    1 25- .*0

 1$   " '((

) 66
 4- %./ 0.1#25 0.1

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No