High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12052/2023disposed of

Ram Kishan v. Dhbvn And ORS

2024-07-18Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri13 pages

"# $!%&'&"() *+*,

- .&'/( ***! & &"(!0 122

3'/&( 04(

&56& 1& 0( &7- 8&-& !$ ($ " /!0'

***!'9"($!( '

) :

8 * 2 2 2

2 2

;

06 !

"#$$%&$$' (#)*+# #,,# +

" +#,,# + " # -( ./0#$1 % "-2 34 5 67 #, # # #8# +, #+19 1:

$1$ .;# :/ " ""*, <#=+.<=/ >,.> /

?61- +" !

+# , $ ## @*, !

, 4 $:

??:

A '

1% ??' # , >

@ +> 3+,

, # > #+ !

, <#=+ '

1% $1$1;#

B , "#",+

;# $$$ 1% $1$1 -, '

, ## 1C 1$ $1$ +# #" >

8#8# <#=+ ! # ;# 9$9 1$ $1$ #", 9

+ # ,, > <= * +# #"# , , , <= )8#" #",

;# :19 1:

$1$

" +=+-0+ ,

<=> ,, !

+ +# #:

$1$ + ;# C1 $1$ + #"B 0# 1D $-( ./0#$1 % " 3+, 6 $1 ' + + & (3

&=8#&#&3(+ , ,

$1$ +=+,# + ;# %1$ $1$$ "# %, " ,+ , ,<= +, + # + ,+,# 3+, " *+ , " #

+ + , ++ #+ # 3+, # , " ,

" ++ *+#

+" #", >8# + ;# : .;# %/ # , "

#",+ 8# 1 9 , # , , ,

<=#"8# ,"* %

+#", 8# + ;# :

,+ 8# +;# %

","" (# '

@ + #.;# 9/ , <= #", " " #"# , ," , ,

@ + ,+ #", , ,+ , ,#* ;+ ,"# ; # @ + ,+ #", " #+ , $1$1 +=+ * + ++#8# &, $$#,">

, <= !

=;#=+A-2 3

+ 1?

1% $1$1 , + =+A(-2 33# #8#<=

# ", # " # "* !

"# # +# E=3 4##", ,+ " , # " E=3

+=+ #+ " #+ ##

";8# "# +#++

, #

#", # ,+# ##" "## ## " E=3 +=+ +

# #",

# ,+# + &, + " # "# % , ,"# , ,"#

#", , ,

"* ;

#", #+ , #"B0# 1D $-( ./ 0#$1 %"# , ";+ , #

@ + , + #", +=+,# ",*+,+

+ " +# +# + =+ , # # , , # ,# "+# ,+;"#" =8# A#"#; "#

,, +#

#", , " "

,"# 3+, " ?

A #

+" #", # +

, + 3+,"# 3+, -( 0# "#0# $ $ "# ,, * #

+ #

, # " # # #

#", #+ # ,+ " " #+ " , ",###

) #

A# , # + ;# : + , !

(## ,+

+ .;# %/ # %, , +"+

2 +# ,+ ;# % #,,+ ## F

!"! # $

" # $

#!& '(# " $$ # $ " ) # (* !

)+ ! &

##& $, "!

( $$$,! #& #! $ #-! " (* "

# .

" !,

# #$ /01+101234051664 "! & $)+ &!

" $ *3030

! /317/'2 8'888 13023030 , # #!

$$ # " !! !"! " &# 9& $ # ! #

! #$33 )+ $! !! $-

!"! / '0106073030 / !#

& &# 9& $ # $

! #& ( :

! # ! #& !

( & *! $ ! #(,$ $$ # :- ! (

&& ! "

&!$ & & *$ ! " $! "! $ 8

* ! &9& $ # $!! )+ ! #

1+!! " ! " $! "!&! * 3+!" "! (*

4+!#&

"$ #

"(*, "!

! " $! 5+! "

" #* ! $$ # & 2+! $

!&# $ " -(# $

!$ & "! # &# !! ! # #

!* # "

& ! "& '; $

* <&

%) ="&

'3016 '

)

&!*+)>>?)-88)?)8- ) 8)

!"! # $

" # $

#!& '(# " $$ # $ "

$!! " ! " $! "!&! * $!" "! (*

! ! $!#&

"$ #

"(* , "! ! " $! " $! "

" #* ! $$ # & # $! $

!&# $ " -(# $

!$ & "! # &# !!

! # #

!*# "

& !"& ';$

* <&

%) ="&

'3016 '

)

$ % %% &

$1$ #"B

0# 1D $-( ./0#$1 %

" 3+, ) " " # 3+,

, 3+,# ,"# +# + , , 3 #

0#0+# 3+, +, # - ( 0# $ $ # @13 " $ " &! * ! !

<1= <3=<=-! !# "

!$!! &('!& <1= $

& ?!

* ! # !

($! ! ! !&!

" !' *

$! $ ! ! $?!

*(( !# "

& ! !&

(# & # & (* &! * (* # * ! # #

! $?!

! # & ! #A <(= - ! !# "

& ?!

* ! # ! ($!

! ! !&!

" !' * B < =

(

& # $?!

< =

( ! #$ * #, #!

$&!*!

($! &#

& < =

(# &#(* &#&! * &# # ?!

* !# ##! # !#&! #( ! !# "

# !! $

$! ! ##& ( ! ?!

*&!

" ! #C

# # 3+,# ,#"B (## +, #

- (## ; " +=+# , ,, # ,+ #,, + # + #+

+=+ , # , " +# +# #,,+ , " " +# # # +=+ , # # ,," + " +# A# # # 8# #

,, 8#, +# , =8# A G 8#

#"+ "," , # # ) "# # ,, +=+ # ) '(%

) *'

++ ,,- *. /+ #

" (# # * # , , " + 8# +# "" 8# 0 # B#+,-H" ,(# , )0 1 +#2,,-3 ,4 # !

B#+, ## @338$# &! * !! ($! #!" !!! #& !&

& ( &"!

! # #!

$ # &! *$! "

" !

* &(D#'!$#!"! *!

!"! &

!$! # #

!&# (*& !

$& !

# $D&!

!& #D& #&

* ( (&& ( ( C %

, # , + #"# # " "#" 8#

, " =;# =+ +=+ #

"# "* )+ + #"# " , " ," E=3 , = " > ;# :

+=+ # + %, , , $ ,

,, , + " " -# 3+, , "#+

) #,

, #+ .;# %/ " 8# "+# ,, ) ,+ " "

, " "

" "5%7 #,., / !

# ,+ " , , , ) ,#

, , " ##5?7 #,., /

(+ #, " +=+.,/ 3+, # .;# %/ E$# ,," + +# 0 C1111& "

, , !

" " 3+, "+ 3+, ; " , , ./" +

*+*,

2 2 5 @ *+& I&3 @ " I&3