Subhash Chand Mangla v. State Of Haryana Etc.
!"#$ % & '( (( ! )*$ ! + & ,!" (!$ -
! !-/* 0$&!1+2 ( !34*&
)(( **$1+
! &(!
5"*$115,!"
!" 6"(
. $(. (** )(!!
1
7 !8
)( 9 6!
!((. !2 ..
2!
!) *!'
% 2 .!9(. /
) ,
! 9 % ::
!)!
)( (** -9$ $
+ ! *
!*0&
)( ('
!)
! ** ;!8 $()
9 #
! !*( (** -9 **
)9 %'"0.
) 2" !9! 2!!)
! 9
3(!2!(!(!) * **)
$ <=-2 *))
( 9 .!***($(!)
(2 *
'( (
!" 2** !
= (
!".!
(2 *" 9. (.
..)
!9 2 ( 9 * +
!
*.!
* *9
'"4 )9
.
'"(!
* ! ,
*
..*' !(*2!..** !2( (2 *
'"
4 )9 %
# !
(
* (
!
..*$(2
!9
)( 9((
.!+(((' ) *"
+*+
)9!* !.
$
) ( 9 (2 2(" (
' !9
,
*!
*!+
'!
)--
#
!)
(
* (
!
*..* .!"(
( *'0 (2 ,2+!$
(!2 " $(2 * 9*"
'"(
9. ) !!39.*( !! 2 ** '
!" 9 (! ( (
!
* !+
2 *
'"(
!'"4 )9
;!
!
* !) (( . ! (+
) *!" ' .
(
.!9 *
$(
*!! *" ('
(
( '"(!
'*4.!"3(
!) 9 ( ' *"
'!43(.! 1! * (
= ( *"!
*.! !( 9
=( (*'"(-4 ( , )( !
!
;*+& -4 ( $
:&;-% $2(!
2 (* 8 > ;0
)('+ ! 9
( $(? !!9
.
(2(!.!
2(( .
( !* !
.!9 * ?
!" !- *: 1- * *! $ 9(!)$
(
'"(!
* ! (
!
* $
!! !9+*
( ' .
)
( .!
$ 2((! ( !! !9+*
**)*!2 ( 4 !
!( '"(.!
.* '*4.!"
) !1! * (
! =9"' (!(* $
.!+
1! * (
!! * $
- * (1- * - * (1- * !
@- *88&. *! != !
8 2 (
) "(
)
- *
:$% 8 2(!. *"
9. 2( (( *(
!
(!)A!
2(!(
!"1 (!
"
#
!!
'!!
)(
! '*" .! '* **2 ( .! !.! !
'
! * A!
2(!(5+!
!
(
! !
" (&$
7. **2 (.! ! 3(
!"1 (!
"9"
! ( ! 9 ( .
(!!
9
!+ ( ( 99
(** '
* ' ! .
) ( !!
"
2( ( (
*
!"@ =9"' (!(
2( ( ** !
- * ( 1 - * 2( ( !! 1! * $(..!
" (!
)(
'*
(*)(!
('+(!
= ( 9!
2( .!9 * ?
!"
(! !
*
* (!$(!
) !**"9
.
!$2( (! 3(
( 2( !
(!)$.!
?
$
(
$(! 2 .!( !
.!9 *
)
(.!
<!((*
(, B'*& .!9 !
&!!"$
!" ,91
1 !+3( !1* /(
3")
&3%&9"'! !! 3(
(+
!
.! ( 99
))
".!
$
!".!
)
! . 2( ( !9 ( '4 9! (!)
(!
* !
!'
' 99 3(! !$ 2 .!***
!".!
(!
!
*.!
'( !
)(! 3(( !
( '+
(( .!
$2(( .!9 *.!
.!9 *.!
$(2 .
( $ (! !$
(2
(!
* $ 2((! ('
.
!
$ .
' 9. .
( .!
! =
. $(
! + * "
(! (? 2( (2 . '+( '
2! 3(*!
* )( ( (*. !9 * 1! *
= 2( ( .0 ( .!
(**'.! .
( !( 9
9!( * 1! * (
) ! ( .!
'.! .
( !( 9
9!( B1 B
(!
(!
!" +
, $ 1! * '!
.! *"2(! ( ( '(.! .
(
!( 9
.!+ *"' (
*
'! !
*
(
)!
(.!+ ( !
!
# 3(
!"
! ..* '
* "
* 1! * (
= ! 3(!9 (+' .!+ .!
' ! ! *2!4 *!
* 9. 4 !
'3(.!
9 (+' B.! B
.!+ .!
) 3( ! ?
*
( .!+
9 '
!( 9 !
*A 3(B
B2( (
'489!
.!
)9 '( 9 (
$ ! 2( ( ( 2 B.! .
(B 3(B
B9 '
& (5 !** 1$(
"$B !9
9.
('*'" "*2
! ( 9 '
)
!B = ( ( .! 9 '+* ** + !
: '! + 3( .!
) 9 ' ! (
)2(!(
!( 9$ )( 'B.! .
(B !( 9
, $ ( * ( ..* 2(! (
.!
)
9!
.!+ .!
$)
( ..* )
?
*$!)
! '!
!!
*$ ..*$2 ( ! ! !9( (!) $.!+ (!!
*
( 9
!
!2( (((' !
( !
*!
* (!2! $ .
!( 9
!(.! (*
*
.
2!
! (
) 3(2! B.! .
(B
( '((.!
! !!'"(* 9 '
' ! ! *2 ! 4 !
* : B! B
(
7$ ( $ 9
! !
) .!
!
!*' ! ! *2!4 *!
*
! 2 ( ( .!
.! !
'
2( (! (
!) * .
% B
B
(
* 9
4 . *"$ 2! '" !
* !$
( !9 !" (!
" 2 *
* (!. * (
!"
( . '* !+ !
)( !
!) 9 .
?
2 . '((*!
*2((!(!
" (!
+ .! 9 ( , B'* & .!9 !! "(!, )( ! (.
? $ ' '( *!
* !.* ( ?
) + $(! !$*2'0 2!
!( = (+ 9 !
* !.!
&1C 0!9 +D
=
% !1=- #& % $ (! *
) (, B'* & .!9 !
2!
( .! 9.*7 ? !9 '+ = ( $ ( , B'* & .!9 !(* @3(* ) ) 1! * (2! **"
1! *
!*!
((
2 ((.! .
.!
9 '
! !
*.!
)$' ! ! *2!4 !
*$ ' !!
*2( ( !
.!9 * ! 9
! + ?
!" +
( )( .'" $' 2( (
!?
! '" *2 !" 9! 4 **" *)* + @ =9
! . *)!9 2 (('+4 )9 3(9! '+ 2 !9 (! )*3( ! .! !?
!
.!9 * .!
9! 0
( !?
!9 * .!. ! .!''
* "$2( *( !?
!
!
*
'" ! '* ' ( . !2 ) *"
.!9 *.!
2 *"
('
.!. ! .!''
* "' (2 ( 2 .(* .(
! '9
*$(!2
(! '!)!
)(
9.* " ( *4
'*"
.!
( 9.*"! 9 ( *
( ( !+
* ;!
!
* !* .
!
6*2 &
)( + & ,!"
&3:% " +& ,!"
&3% = '( (
$(. !
2!!
+!
2(( ( '"
)* ) !
)3("(' .
(
.!9 *.!
*!$ ! $2!
1 .!( *!
*$
( (
!
(
*!!
1.! !9 ( (! )! $
*! (
!&
%!2 (&
#81 (=
"
+*+9!* !.
$(! !$'(( !
!
('*
)! (* " ! 9 $=
!
!
! ((
9. ) !!
*
*"
. 2 ( !! &
(9
( $(.
)
"$*
# $ %&
'("')*+ ,-- .
/.
01
-!%23
04% 5 034 .
/.
14 / 034