High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2339/2006allowed

Subash Chander v. General Manager Hryroadways Depot & ORS

2024-11-18Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma12 pages

"#

!$%&%"'( ")!*+!, - ./+&0 0'1!,

22222233!44'

5&2 !'!,4 '6!,7 ,82 "198& '1 " 0!,&

222222!&3"'1!' & ( :; .2 . . .

!"

# !!!!

$%&&'"() 2

; '

* +,

, "

#

-./ 01 -+. / # "

#

# 2

3

2 "

# 2

#

0 "

# 2 ,

**,

# *

4 5 * #

,

!"

#

6

!,5 *2

"

# !

7 "

2 -./ 01 -+. / "

# ,

**, #

- '

, *

2 8-7

-++ 9 -8..,

# ',

, : ;

',

;<

*

=

.

. ',

++-88/

! , # 2 * *, (

,, ( )2 , * * ()!7!./> ,

*?,,

45

2 (*2@2 5, ** '!-4 , !(

, * ,

* *

5*

, 2

2

*

! , # * * ,

*

'

,

2

( @2 022 # ( ( 2

-4/-88/'

2

,

(

) 87=!

++-88/ +.-88/'

, * * *

,5 * * '

2 , '0") 7 ++-88/

/844/ 44. "#2 * @2

, 3 4 $

= 0

* 6',

2 *

!

" #

$

" #

#

"

" #

!

" %&' '% 7 5 *

*

',

2

) =!

*2

A/BC

(

=

2, ',

....

;

.;.

.

+ '

!

2, ',

2 (

6',

*

*)

,

(

7C , 4C

*

(

< '

2 *

* * '

,

2

, 2 /

!"

# 2

* 2 *

,

, ',

*

,

*

'

. "

2 8 2

, * , 5.. ,# * ( , 2 D

7C * , , ?

( , 5 5.8

,

<

* D

4C0

2 *

- 6 2

4 E 4 ,2 * *

6 2

D-,G ,2 42

*G * * 2

*G * - 2 2

2 44 *44

2 ,25 * #

, @ 5"

# #

, 2 ,) 4

(2

, 6 ',

' ) -7=!

2 2* ,

5

25 ( 0 6',

*

* * .;

;= . -- ( H,

#

2* **

2 , ' D# > ?/*, 5&2 >8 ?/*, '1 '" 0!,

./3,!*!

"/, &!&

() *+

, -../0, 01 # " #$ "

#

2

#

) $ "

# #

" #

#

) # $

2 #

# $ "

,

$ "

$) #

$ # #

"

"

$

$

# /3453 #

!)5 ,!%-673#468 %9 :

4 /!

1; --(/1344((

< -67,4'861 8 )

"

"

$ "

= / 1 >2

# ?

#

# 2

/

1;

/

1"

$ "

#

$

#

= / 1;

# @ /1 ;

#

/

1A#

2 &

# /B 9 # 1 / 19 #

#

$ /1; #

/

C # 1 / 1;2 /

# 1

$ "

"

/ /

1/ 1

/ 1!

$ "

#

# "

/

1/1 /

/1

/ 1

#

#

2 #

/

C # 1

2

! / 1,

$ /#

#

$ 1

/

1) #

"

"

#

)

# #

/2

" ")

# #

1

@

/

1) "

$ & # "2 #

# 2 #

2 #

)

#

"

) "

/ 1 ) # #

#

$

"#$

%

%%

&

%

% '

()(=)

$

"#

" 7

%777C&# #

, 9 0

#

#

$ " 87D

#

" 7D)

" ) (D

#

##

" 4 "

"= 1,

#

=%8 777C& 1;

# /(D

#1= %('77C&

1*

"

=6

1;

=/('77261= %- .77C& '

(*(=)

$ " 7

%777C&# :

#

#

87D:" #

# $ :

## "

$ " ))

6(D4 "

"= 1,

#

=%8 777C& 1;

# /6(D

#1 =% 6777C&

1*

"

=6

1;

=/ 6777261=%'

(- 777C& '

(+( =)

$ " (

>

,

"

# "#

" #

" )#

# " 67D,

$ "

" 67D) "

"= 1*

##

#" # >

=%87 777C&

-

1;

# /67D2

#1 =%' 777C&

1*

/ ( 1 =.

1;

=/' 7772.1 =%6 (8 777C& E = )

/,1

/<1

)

! /41"

#

,

5# * / 1F - ( H,

# , ' +- .

/0 A @

.

- B

2

-++-+4! -+. 9 -8..

2 *

:< % *D

F :@<

* * F :#< * ,

*

F :%< ) , *

D 2 :&<

*

* 2

,F !

D '

*

I ) "

# 2 #! #

# #

2 %( %'7 777

%( )

< &

#&

"

# "

# 7D

"

G -4 ( H,

# 1 .

1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34

H6) "

2 #

=

% %(5(

%(6(@ )

#

$ #

!

4# ;

# 3

76 ,4I 677 /341 !

'8

$ # 4 < # # #

#

3 +# /3#1

9 ) 4

, 77-,4I -./341!

(& ( # 0.0 "

2

)

3 4

" # #

0.0

060 -

%

%

%78

#

"

I

* J 7.,4I7/341

3

5 $ ,9

J, 76,4I-6-/3412 "

I

/ 1

.= K. !

#

,

#" # #

" ) " # # "

= /

#

#

@ /

;

#

#@ /

)

# # "

#

@ / 1 *

2

##

@

/1 ;2 K E# F )

# ?

$ # 3

5 $ / 1

# # "

"

# #

"2 #

" # C ? .

# L #, 7I 7)

$

= K, % = /

#

# /

# /

#

# / 1

'J(#

/1

# / # /

2 "

3 4 #"

< # #

$ " 2 A

5 $ / 1 "

# #

#

" #

"

#

#

D)

# $ #

!

4; / 1 #

8/

" (7D

$

"8

"

"

-D

" $

#

I

M / 1

"

#"

-D

"

4 +0,+-9'0, .)

( "

"= :

) ;

" /%'

8'.2 2C77 %- . -6.C& A /(7

%'

-7 -.-C& *

2

# %.

'8 .8'C& ; # #

%( 777C& ; # #

# % (7 777C&

% 777C&

) %' 8- .C& ) "

%' 8- .C& # "

#

-D

##

# ; - "

2 2 2 , ( H,

# , *

2 2 8-7 * '

!

!

.,2 "2 !1& "*3!'& %"'

9,1!1 - "

) -7=!

6

:C< ) +=!:C-7<

"

) 7=!:-E-< 6

*

:.C< ) -+=!

:-+< ) 47+=!

+ * ) -7=!

/

) =!

.

D ) .= '

* ) =!

-

#* ) 4=!

-- 6 ) -7=!

- " 4 "*3!'& %"'

) /87+=!

*"/'

9,1!1 +8 0!

,%+/'4 &27 7 C '0'$!1 *"/'

) 787+=!

-7

, ( H,

#

; *.

.

@ <. 0

.$ , $

+

< ./3,!*!

"/, &!& @7

A8C

*

J -+ ' "

#

*2

2 ',

2 2

*

'',

,

!

, 5

'

, 5

',

-/ @ * 2 *

# D

, #

'"

# , ,

2

*

-. % * -8 *

. .

")!*+!, -7

> 5 *= 5 * 5 * > , K =