Ajit Singh Bains & ANR v. Central Bureau Of Investigation & ORS

 



       

!"#$#%&'&()
* +&",&(-.!&('!($!(".#/ #"&"&(#/'

0#/'1'

#("/!21/#!1(3#'"&-!"&(4#5#2.&4!($!(".#/  #'6($#("'

)  78  , 9 8, /#'#("):

/ ,!&('4$3%!"#4/".#6#"&"&(#/' /,1;.$##6,,!($.14,#(&/,"!($&(-%1('#2 / :/#'6($#(" /!3##(,.!/<!4$3%!"#4 /#'6($#("'
"
  =.#".#/".# #6/"#/'2%!2(#5'6!6#/<!>?#!225#$" '##".#+1$-<#("@
 ?#/##//#$"".# #6/"#//("  =.#".#/".#+1$-<#("'.12$?#/#6/"#$&(".#$&-#'"@ ::

::

8,

8 .!22#(-#$&(".#6/#'#("/#3&'&(&'".#+1$-<#("$!"#$
A
4  6!''#$  ?>  ".#  2#!/(#$  ,6#%&!2  1$-#  4  1(+!?4 !"&!2!  $$&"&(!2  ,#''&('  1$-#4  !"&!2! 4  5.#/#?>  ".# !%%1'#$ 6/&3!"#/#'6($#("'5#/#!%B1&""#$".#%.!/-#'/!<#$ !-!&('"".#<1($#/,#%"&('A*!($A* /#!$5&".,#%"&(  

:
:

.#'./"!%"'45.&%.!/#/#B1&/#$"?#("&%#$/".# 61/6'#$&'6'!2".#6/#'#("/#3&'&(4!/#".!"!%<62!&("5!' <!$#?>/1'"&%#,!&('

#"$ 4 .!&/<!(41(+!?1<!(

&-."'  /-!(&C!"&(4  !-!&('"  ".#  6/#'#("  !%%1'#$ 6/&3!"# /#'6($#("'(".#!22#-!"&('#D"/"&(/<".# !?2# 6#/!"/'

</&"'!/!($'#D1!2#D62&"!"&(5<#(#<62>##' (&"&!22>4 ".#%!'#5!'&(3#'"&-!"#$?>".#1(+!?2&%#4?1"2!"#/&(3&#5 /$#/6!''#$?>".&' 1/"(
&( =E

4 ".#<!""#/5!'#("/1'"#$"".# #("/!21/#!1(3#'"&-!"&( 1/&(-  ".#  %1/'#    &(3#'"&-!"&(4  "./##  6/'#%1"/&D

(!<#'5&"..#2$ 5#/##D!<&(#$?#/#".#$&#/#("2#!/(#$1$&%&!2 !-&'"/!"#''" 2!''41($#/,#%"&(*  /  /'#%1"/&D:5!'#D!<&(#$?#/#'!'5&($#/9!1/4 ".#2#!/(#$1$&%&!2!-&'"/!"#'" 2!''4</&"'!/4!($.#/'"!"#<#(" 5!'/#%/$#$1($#/,#%"&(*  / (

45.#/#&('.# 2#3#22#$".#!22#-!"&('/!6#?>!%%1'#$,!/!?+&",&(-.!2&!' !+1 &(.&'&%#!($&(##< .!<#2&"#2 ,&<&2!/!22#-!"&('5#/# !2'2#3#22#$!-!&('"!/& <.!(;1!4!(#'.$$!/4!$!(8!2 0&+4,1?.!'. .!($#/,.!/<!4D:!>/!($,//! /'#%1"/&D:  5!'  #D!<&(#$  !($  .#/  '"!"#<#("  5!' /#%/$#$1($#/,#%"&(*  / ?#/#,./&9&'./#91<!/4".# 2#!/(#$$$&"&(!2 .&#1$&%&!2!-&'"/!"#4</&"'!/4(

4 5.#/#&('.#2#3#22#$!22#-!"&('/!6#!-!&('",!/!?+&",&(-.!2&!'

::

!+1&(.&'&%#,.#!2'2#3#22#$!22#-!"&('!-!&('"&<6>!2&!' 1/&($#/!2,&(-.".!"".#>.!$#D62&"#$.#/&(##< .!<#2& "#2,.#!2'2#3#22#$!22#-!"&(''#D1!2#D62&"!"&(?>, //!4,9!"!/&!!2&!',!(+14!2!($B?!2,&(-.4,!(+##391<!/ !2&!'??>!($(#2!5>#/ !+5&($#/,&(-.!2&!' !+! /'#%1"/&D:4&(.#/'"!"#<#("/#%/$#$1($#/,#%"&( *  / ?#/#'!/6/##"9!1/4".#2#!/(#$ .&#1$&%&!2 !-&'"/!"#4</&"'!/4(

42#3#22#$".#!22#-!"&('/!6# !-!&('"!%%1'#$,!/!?+&",&(-.!2&!' !+1&(.&'&%#!($&(!>!

"#24!2!($.!/"#/".#&(3#'"&-!"&(4".#%.!22!(5!'6/#'#("#$ &(".# 1/""!2'%<#'1"".!"".#"/&!2%("&(1#$/<".#>#!/
*">#!/
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

:

:

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

::

!22".#"./##6/'#%1"/&D.!$"1/(#$.'"&2#4".#25#/ 1/"5!'2#" 5&".(6"&(4?1"".2$".!"".#%.!/-#'1($#/,#%"&('A*!($ A*  !/#("6/3#$"?#&(-'4$("&($!(>&22#-!2&">/ &(&/<&">&(".#&<61-(#$+1$-<#("%%/$&(-2>4".#6/#'#("/#3&'&( &'$&'<&''#$ 

8,   
* '+;'