← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3398/2007allowed

M K Chandruka And ORS. v. Geeta Tanwar And ANR.

2025-01-28Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

     

    

 !

"#

!$%&%"'( ')*+ ,  -  

 

   

 

 

( .

/ 01 0 0  0

 



 ! 

"# $% # & 

 

 # $% # &

'(

%  )))) 0  0

1

*            !  & +     



,-,.-,,/   %   &

% *00& %%#*122!" %%    !

#3

 & #  4  !

4  &  

%    &  %   +

    



5%

#  !"    %

'



    

-#/,#,,,5' %%

& &! 

  $%

%% #  %  %%    +   $ +  !  -2,2-,,.    ! *-5*-*. -  &  

    % & 

&%   !" !

#  

 & & %&%   

& &!$" 0 000  /

0/0   0 7  %

&%

'



% 

 

  !" !

  

$!

&# "    ! 

% 

 !

   8

%  # %

&

'(

%  

"# $#$  " +     +"!  



&%  #   !" !

 +"! +

  &# "&   &   . ( $  %

& 

   % &%  0  &    %   -/" & +  & %% 

 +"6 &

   %    + 9%     % % % +"(  &:

% % +#3

;$# !

 +"   % &  %  <  !

     " +  &. 

&*/!

 &    

% + -57  

: !

    

"

&& %#& 

&%  $#

 &&

 :   

$!

 &#  6 

+ %&   0/

/2  0 / ; =!             %   & Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 3   0)5*!6!

")* &!& 7#

     &% 

$

 &

 

'

>30 

           

        

       

   

       

     

 

 

 

    

  

            

    



   !"#$     

%#  !"&$     

&'   !"($     



 31)

       

                    *              (+,                  











  

  

-  

   

 

      

      

 $         .  /





          

                *  

 



           



                32 

         

        (+,        

   (+,           

      





 

         

                         



 

        

   * * * * * * 42. )     



    &$          0

 1   $       !2    !(%+ %!%(

 $ 

    

  3!4%' #+

 3!'#!#(

 3!(#'&+

 3!& &!&(

  3!#&'(+

   

  

 

  3!!(!((

 35(''+

 34'!'(

  3(''4+

  2 ; =!     % &National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 3   4 0 4 7  % &  

 % *00#*07'

*02&%%#*122# & +

%'



?

%  &  

 

 $ +  :      

%

@

% &  

+ +& %  @ +& %   !

& " + @

?

 

!  &+     % $

  

# 

"#    &  #&% 

&

 : #% @

-

< %& % +& 

& &&

+

B!@&' " &:  " $

 &B

+  



'

>52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 7/

8*

    7 %(+++       

  7  !+++++  

   7 !+++++ 



  

        

       

   7/

 

0   9 

 





       



   

 

 



 

   :    

       6                    

     



 

    

   

  

  

   

  ; 

       

       

  

     

     





   

  

            

   

*

   



        





 



        

    7 !(+++

&++++     7 !(+++  

                

   <

    

   

 )                         

   

 

  



   

    !+,    

 )   

 



  

 



   = = = = = 59.3)   

  (+,   



 





 / 

  &+

        #+,  

  

&+(+

  * 

  

 (+'+

 

   !(,6      

 

 59.4* 







 $ 

   &+,

 



  

    &+

  6  %(,

  

  &+(+

  !+,

  

 (+'+

    



       

   

 

    

59.5.              

          #+#%0> ?  



     59.6. 

        

  0> @ &%/

 59.7  

       59.87   

        





 

     

 7

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++

  

    

  !+,  

 A 1 ; =!             %   & 96 !'!*:

'&)*'$!

"65'+ /%6% !;

<&1 ') 6 :%& =)=*) 6

 =!*& 3   0  7

&%   + 0*:

<!*6 &)5*

*'+ 0! =%

0)5*   + +%  $

&  



'

B216  <

  C  0 8         

  

         

  ;

   

      

 

 *  

D  D  

   



 D     D  D 

 D D  D  

                 





 

 

  



     )  

      

       

  



 %!! Spousal consortium   

        

         

    



D  

   

     

 /  D %!% Parental consortium      



              

   D    

 

  

 

   D %!# Filial consortium             

  

 

   6

      

           

 

   

    

      

              22  



 

     

       3 /     

 

  

E     

 

       

   

  3 /                

   

           

 

   

       

 23 3> 

6  

    

      

  

 

   

* 

       

             

                

 C       

    

    6 6     

    

      

  

   

           

   

  24  

    

    

 

   D

  D   C  0 8* 







      

   7 &++++ 

   /0 *, ( $&   !"; =!     

!$& B

+  #      



,-,.-,,/   & %% +" 

'%

    

%  & 

'(

%  

" "&  %# % % 

'

'

Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded *  "( %  *7,,,5'

- < %C.,D 0.,,5' *7,,,E.,D

?

%     

:

 *5- 1/.,5' *1.,,E*5-

8  ( %  1/., *1.,,'1/.,

.

  */ 

?

%" *1#21#,,, 1/.,E*-E*/

/ 9&A  *2#,,,5'

<

 A:  *2#,,,5'

9&  

*#88#,,,5'

< 82#,,,5':7 " :

"65!'& %"'

&1,4, >

!;)$ %"'

 

 !"!

&1, , > '='$!;

6")'

&1,, >

4  ** &    % % #  !"; =!    Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma    

R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation

  - 0)5*!6!

")* &!& ,  

'%

   +

     C1D

 

& 

&& +&%  



& F  *- (

%  

"'

G7 %  

&%   + !



 &  & 

"!

&  %  !



&%   +   %%

& %

5 

           !"    !

         

 %

5 

    %    &     !

  %%

        !

 *7 <   (

%   

"    %    !

    %  %

&

 # $% # 

 

 *2,/-,-8   <HG*02-&-,,/#  & "

"& 

& %&%& %"&B

+   *8 ? & %% +" *.

+ % #&

"# 

 &

0  0 

 

')*+ ,  - 

$   I  +5 '  +  +   I ! J